Discussion Locked

1GB LAN, is it needed?

0 helpful
1 reply
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I've been propositioned with upgrading to a 1GB lan. I currently use a 100MB with about 50 stations and a single server. Most of my stations are outdated Celerons and P3's. My operations does not run intense programs just basic data sharing, web sharing, print sharing and mail exchange. To add to that most of my users are computer illeterate and probably wouldn't notice a faster lan connections.

What do you think? Is it worth the extra cost of replacing the NICs and switches? Does anyone know what the cost difference is? Would the added transfer rate even be realized with slower (bottlenecked) stations and users?

Thanks

1 reply

by madmark

Although the information here is little to go on, it doesn't sound like you need 1GB at the desktop.

You may want to use 1GB fiber on the switch-to-switch uplinks. The uplinks contain an aggregate of all of your 100Mbs connection on each VLAN,plus maintenance protocols (SpanTree, VLAN Mgmgt, SNMP, etc.).

What problem are you trying to overcome? If your PC's are all outdated and under spec'ed, it is safe to assume that they are not being used for streaming video, or other bandwidth intensive tasks. I would suggest putting one of the ports into SPAN mode on each subnet one at at time and hooking up an analyzer to see 1) if your bandwidth is tapped. 2) Where your bandwidth is being used.

Who is suggesting the upgrade? Ask them why it is necessary, and on what do they base this decision?

This discussion is closed to new replies.