Discussion Locked

A+ or no A+, that is the question.

0 helpful
35 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I am presently working as a CSR for a software company, and working on my Degree in Computer Science. I dont have any certifications yet and because I dont have the dicipline for self study, I am going to be trained at a IT school in here in town.I had planned to pursue A+, and Network+, but I have about 7 years of helpdesk and onsite support experience, therefore, I am thinking that it may be better to go for Network+, and Security+ rather than spend that much money on my A+. I think that my work experience would validate that I have hardware and software support knowledge so why bother with the A+? My long term career goals are to work in network administration. Any thoughts?

35 replies

by areets

If I may ask, where is 'here in town'? Yes, you are correct. Your experience to now will count for more than an A+. Network and security are vital knowledge packs for troubleshooting skills. Without, you'll not be able to improve those techniques, ESSENTIAL, but not enough is done in many companies towards greater in-house inter-networking analytic training. Good luck!!!

by jim phelps

You need to have some sort of certification, be it A+, CNA, MCP, Network+, or whatever. If you have none, and you came to me looking for a job, I would wonder why you had no certifications.

If you and another candidate appeared to be equally qualified, and he was certified in something but you weren't, I'd probably go with the other candidate.

by areets

The IT sector's recruiters must be able to match environment experiences to certification achievements. Not every employer is prepared to train his or her employees. Those with certifications are neither guaranteed a job.

You can achieve certification without terrain experience. Would you choose the established certified non-experienced or the experienced non-certified job seeker?

Your ROI on overall support can be rapidly achieved over the use of the non-certified job seeker. Industry experiences show that. What plays against the non-certified, is the lack of his immediate leader's ability to manage the team, which requires today a standard of people, business and technical skills.

by willpd13

Having strayed into customer support from network support/administration I am now looking to get back into the hands on side of things again and as such have done 2 certifications Network+ and MCP 2000 Server I am finding in my local area (Manchester UK) that I am not getting interviews because I dont have any recent experience.

So from my point of view the experience you have is more valuble than the certifications however if they are choosing between someone with them or someone without both having the required experience they would pick the one that did have them.

by tomsal

Respectfully, I must say "HOGWASH!!" lol.

But really that's nonsense that you need to have a cert in something even if its just A+. Especially in the case of this thread's author -- who is working on a Computer Science degree (which I am assumingis a 4 year degree) AND he already has 7 years helpdesk experience under his belt PLUS he wants to go to an IT tech school for network training.

That's how I understood his educational background if I'm mistaken, then my post won't hold much water but I think I got the details right.

With his education he is leaps and bounds more qualified than anyone with a piece of paper that says CNA, MCP or A+ on it...oh sorry I mean "Certification". They are a dime a dozen. Today, especially those three certs -- the basic ones. A 100% non-IT person, so long as he/she has good study habits, could earn any one of those certs in a month's time or less.

Very few certs impress me at all. Some exceptions would be the CCIE and some highlevel industry certs by the likes of IBM or RSA.

Being that I *am* an IT manager, college degree holder and someone who earned a few certs himself some years back -- trust me. I'll take a well rounded college educated, hands on experienced applicant any day of the week over someone with 50 certifications and no experience whatsoever.

Bar none.

This guy is doing just fine. Looks to me he knows what he's doing.

by joshua1

I gotta disagree. Technical certs and college are 2 *completely* different animals. [First, let me say I have a 4 year degree in I.S. and I have certs and I'm in Networking/Systems admin]. College is conceptual & theoretical.
Certs are technical& applied.
If the job is to run a network...that's hands on. Knowing how to create a DFD, normalize a table, or perform JCL sorts are irrelevant. Give me the technically skilled candidate over the degree w/ no certs. I've seen the reverse in practice...it's not effective.

You only have to get a degree once, but you have to get certs every few years. So, (in vague generalities): A degree speaks of long-term skills, while certs signal short-term success.

So do you want success now, orlater? Well...probably you want both. That's how Certs & IT Degrees work together. A candidate w/ only 1 of the 2 has weaknesses. Of course, experience trumps.

by voldar

Tom, then what about a job offer for me? I worked a lot as admin (4 years) in Ro, with W2K network of 300 users (any servers you want - you got them), alone, and now when I move to Ca (Mtl), it's not that easy to find a job in IT when u r W2K specialized. I am MCP, MCSA W2K (710,715,716,718), and guess what? I just passed my A+ exams ... LOL

by tjc

Certification can not hurt in getting any job. If anything they look good on the resume to show you are on top of the technology.

by philospher

For an ITmanager you have the wrong attitude about certifcation, It's this attitiude toward certifacation that is the problem. Tyring to devalue someone's education is apalling. It takes both education and experience to handle an IT workshop, not just certifications or just experience.How do you get experience when IT-managers like you won't hire someone with certifications. The IT community has to adopt some sort of professional code of conduct. And that includes not looking down on someone's educational background.

by oz_media

I didn't have ANY certs at all when I was hired as a fulltime Novell admin. The company paid for my CNE and MCNE training while I was with them but it was not needed to find work.

Somepeople RELY on finding certs and then looking for a career.

You can also decide WHERE you want to work and pursue a job just as successfully with enough determination and personal skill brought to the table.

I do agree though that unfortunately SOME people are too blind to see value in a person and simply rely on certs to aid in making important decisions. What makes them so sure that a certified employee will do a better job than a determined and driven employee?

by generalist

You may want to check the job requirements in your geographical area. If they say they want A+ as well as other certifications, then not having it can be a hassle.

One of the biggest problems with work experience is that it may not provide solid'proof' that you have the skills. It is much easier to check a certification than it is to contact an employer and find out the details of a potential employee's prior job.

Then you have to consider whether the employer can release the information you request. I've run into instances where an employer can only verify that the employee worked for them for a given date range. The employer's legal staff advised them that offering more information would put them at risk for lawsuits.

A final problem with work experience is the fact that using your current employer as a reference can put your current job at risk. A lot of job applications take this into consideration when they ask if they can contact your current employer.

by ghstinshll

That's wxactly why you never use your current job as a reference... You use people who you've worked with who you connected with on a personal level and keep in touch with. They should be individual professional references, not your current/previous employer. Don't lie on a resume and come across as a truthful person and you don't have to watch your back in the process...

by ghstinshll

Holy cow!!!! It's time to step it up a notch!

I spent less than two years in a help desk environment and had enough, so I pity the grey hair you have... an A+, Net+ aren't under you, and to get the ball rolling, you DO need to dedicate to self-preservation in the form of books and time to study. If you're so experienced, you should be able to purchase an exam cram book, purchase a transcender and go pass the A+ tests within 3 weeks. Just do it is all I can say... I've been re-cert'ing for a couple years now, and it sucks when y ou already work with it, but you have to do it no matter what. A mentor of mine told me years ago, that if you don't like reading, get out of the tech field, because you're going to be doing it for the rest of your life. 5 years later and a bunch of exams later, I'm 3 wks out from the CCNA and still at it. It's just the way life has to go. With yor experience AND the certs, you WIll get the job on top of any other candidate, provided you're a likable personAND interview well, guaranteed... Unfortunately, you DO have to begin somewhere, so knock out those two first, then go MCP (2k pro shold take you no more than 3-4 weeks as well) and then you're at a fork in the road. MCSA, CCNA, or other ranges of certs? Then you can really direct your career from there.

I'm not sure what experience you have in networking, but there's a barrier you'll have to break through to be able to get the jobs you want.
I'd like to hear a little feedback from you if you want some advice on how to handle that.

Again, 3 months our you Should have an A+, Network+, and MCP. That's only a semi-aggressive schedule, and you can do it with the experience you have! The Exam Cram books are an easy read, so one chapterper night isn't asking too much. Just leave your PC at home off and don't game!

by ghstinshll

As for the degree, you're doing the right thing there too! Keep it up and you'll be where you want to be in a few years. It'll get close in a year, but plan on making a move or two to get the job you want. Always keep your eyes open for jobs, and watch the markets to keep a grasp on what's out there too.

by rob1150

I am curious as to what barriers you have come across in pursuing a career in Networking, I have anticipated the "Can't get into Networking without experience, but cant get experience without a job" I would like to know what your thoughts are though.

by andy_ex-uk

I made the move over from tech support to networking by getting a tech support job with an ISP. Pretty lame and boring support stuff, but I got to mess around with the servers (well, adding, modifying and deleting user and mail accounts, but it was start). I then took a networking class, got my Network+, took a CCNA prep class and that was enough to get me into my present job administering a Windows 2000 domain.

As for the original question of this thread, I would say A+ is worth having. It's easy to get, lasts a lifetime and many companies require it.

by chandrafirestar

I am currently a student, myself working towards a networking career. From everything I have heard and learned you can never have too much certification. And one of the "biggies" is A+. I am getting ready to take the core part within a week. From what I understand most do not accept that you are a tech unless you are A+ certified. If you are wanting to know how ready you would be for this test without study, you can go to passitnow.com and take the practice tests there. My suggestion would be to take it.

by tomsal

Just thought I'd shed my light, considering I've been working IT for about a decade now I think I have some worthwhile input to share on this. :)

First and foremost, I did the cert thing per request of my employer a few years back (btw, it was truly a REQUEST -- I didn't HAVE to get the cert to keep my job). I also have my degree in the IT field - so I've gone through the "college" route as well. (And I'm STILL going through the college route..lol)

I've worked with A+ techs, heck I've been the manager of A+ techs. The cert in and of itself is worthless paper, pure junk.

Its the experience, aka "benchwork", the one going to get the cert that makes the difference.

Someone comes to me and all they can say is "I'm A+ certified" - in an interview, without a stutter in my voice I'll continue, "what kind of hands on experience do you have?" Then that leads into questions about "are you familiar with the installation of RAID controllers? Have you worked on XXXXX model/brand of servers before? " etc. etc.

A+ does not mean you are a real tech. A+ is you READ about the BASICS.

That's all.

Experience is what counts. Drive is what counts. Determination to succeed is what counts.

THAT is what makes a REAL tech.

Your cert is just a piece of processed wood pulp with ink on it. ;)

by ghstinshll

It can't hurt, per my suggestion to just get it over a month of cramming on the specifics that don't matter, then the same on Net+, MCP (2kpro), etc...

This guy needs "something else" apparently, and they might help his resume look stronger thanthe brawny it's printed on... His interview skills and creativity on his resume might need a little work too. These are hidden cards interviewees shuld have in their sleeves so that they come across the right way... Interviewing is an art to master as well.

Go get the certs, they're easy.

by jim phelps

Tom:

Don't you think that you have to start somewhere? To start, A+ is ok, if you actually know some stuff, and if you're willing to start at the bottom and work up. Because once you get your foot in the door, you will begin to get the needed experience. But without any certification or piece of paper to carry with you to the interview, you might not even get in the door.

If you had an entry-level position to fill, wouldn't you be willing to consider an A+ tech, if after questioning him, you felt he had the knowledge and attitude to be successful on the job?

If he had no certifications in anything, I'd wonder why not, since A+ is so easy. (I practically aced it without hardly breaking a sweat.) I mean, if he doesn't even haveA+, when everybody always talks about A+, I'd wonder at least a little about him.

by chris simon

Certifications exist to validate your skill set. You may have worked break fix for 4 years, but it does not mean that you can do other things. I run across people that tell me they know this or that every day, but when they take a class they ALWAYS learn new things. We all get arrogent.

With a cert, your employeer does not have to take your word, or guess at your skill set. You might say on your resume that you maintained the network, when in reality you just swept out the NOC at night.Give them a reason to hire you. Everybody knows what a A+ is, and if you really knew that much, you could just take the test and pass, right?

by joshua1

What struck me is that you said you have no discipline for self study. That's kind of a critical aspect of working (or at least advancing) in IT. I would first recommend that you try to learn this discipline.

If your goal is Network Administration, then a Net+ cert wouldn't hurt, but it's just a start (and I would skip A+). I would recommend a Network Operating System and/or a router platform.

I would look for certs applicable to your existing environment. If you have Windows servers and Vanguard routers, look at learning those and attempt to change your duties w/ your current employer to build experience. A cert w/ no experience doesn't get a lot of second looks.

If you choose MCSE, heavily consider Exchange as an elective.

by bartware

Certifications have there place in the IT industry. They prove that you have the skill set that covers that particular certification. An IT Degree is the same, showing that you have a skill set that is covered by your Degree. The best is a good combination of both the Degree and Certification. My recommendation is get the Net+ as well as finishing your Degree.

by jim phelps

I have both a degree in Computer Science and some certifications. I also have years of experience as a technician in networking, hardware, software, etc, etc.

My degree gets me in the door (and did when I had no experience), because most people don't realize that a degree in Computer Science means that you've been taught to write programs, not to fix computer issues. However, having a programming background gives me a more complete perspective on computer issues, and helps me to figure some things out which I wouldn't have a clue about had I not had a few years of programming.

Certifications don't automatically mean anything. I knew someone once who claimed to be A+ certified, but I would have been surprised if he had ever toucheda PC! He knew NOTHING about computers!

The best thing to have is long-term, meaningful job experience. Not only will you know your technical stuff, but you are seasoned, and you will know about such things as logging calls, locking your computer when you are away from your desk, how to deal with users, etc, etc.

And if, in addition to the job experience, you have certifications or a degree, that would be like icing on the cake.

by jreeter

The basic foundation starts at the computer hardware level. If you can repair and understand the workstation, periphels, addressing, media, then the OSI model makes sense and trouble shooting becomes easy. The A+ cert. is a requirement for all our I.T. staff. It will help with the rest of your career.

by lmon

Remember the more certs you have the bettter.
You might be better off doing N+ Security+. Then reading and studying for the A+ on your own time. It's not the difficult

by w2ktechman

I have looked into the A+ for myself a few times, and even CompTia states that the A+ cert is to give an employer confidence that you can work as an ENTRY LEVEL technician. Even a year on a helpdesk should do the same. I would say No to the A+. But even this advice isnt 100%, as I have been turned down for jobs in the past because I did not have the A+, even though I have years as a deskside Lead over 12 person staff.
As for Network +, it is supposed to be equivelant to MS Networking Essentials. This would show an employer that you understand how networks work and can troubleshoot network related problems. Always a + for Deskside\server\network support.

by avengerm1

I have seen companies that won't let you open up a workstation or PC unless you have an A+. While this is an easy cert to get, it does make a good general starting point. I would also say get the Network+ as well for the same reason. Both the Network+ and A+ can be used as electives for the MCSA. Always be prepared to answer questions to gauge your skill. I like the posting earlier that said an A+ cert prompts questions like, "how to configure a RAID controller". It is questions like that, asked during interviews, that helps weed out the bookworms from the hands-on techies. Never dismiss a cert because it is "easy". If you have the skills and/or knowledge, then it should be easy. Certs like A+ and Network+ are foundational, not the end-all-be-all. If you pass the Network+, then start looking at an MCSA/MCSE, and/or a CCNA, or something more detailed.

by voldar

In a week, it's right, not in month :)) Real experience I think is the most important in A+.

by kmoskey

The A+ certification should be easy to obtain once you have grasped the fundementals of networking. Especially if you have college experience.

by gwanner

With 7 years of experience, I don't see what you would gain with the A+ cert. My thought is most employeer's want either a A+ cert or experience. A certification doesn't always quailify someone for the job. I beleive experience is more helpful and useful. Finish school and get the network certification. Good luck

by michaelbrague

Hello Rob,

My name is Michael. You being in the IT field should know that these cert's look very good to people. They look even better when you prove to them that you do know yer stuff. Personally owning my own little PC repair company, I would look at a person w/ all the cert's before a person w/ half of them. No offence but the cert's would show me a better work ethic, more self-disapline, and make me lean more towards bringing that person into my company. You said you've been in the field a while, if you'r good and know you'r stuff you should have no problem. I hope my coments help you move towards you'r career decision. Good luck.

by itctonguy

My first IT job was entry level, but I was hired at 19 based solely on my A+ certification. I was then able to work my way through college and other certs, and when I graduate this summer will be promoted to IT Mgmt. Certs are useful! Good luck.

by dseeger

I would suggest start from the bottom and work your way to the top, instead of trying to be at the top and not knowing what the problem could be at the bottom. When MCSE hit South Africa, the potential amount of money that could be earned if you had that certification seemed great, so people started learning MCSE not bothering with A+ or N+, but at the end of the day people with A+ and N+ proved to be just as valuable as people that only hold MCSE, in any circumstance as long as you know your system I/O addresses and IRQ's especially for the com ports, and you know how to diagnose and trouble shoot problems, then you should be able to pass your N+, A+ only touches on the Basics of networking. At the moment I'm currently studying Security+ and N+ proves to help a lot with it. The choice is yours, you do not need A+ as a requirement to do N+ or Security+. Just remember that sometimes showing thatyou have certification proves to be more valid than saying that you can do the job.

by oz_media

I made some comments before about how I never had ANY certs when I was hired as a F/T net admin.

One other thing I've noticed is that you say you have no discipline for self study.

You say you are to be TRAINED at an IT school in town, which is all fine and great, but you will soon find out, whereas a dog is trained, IT staff train themselves. Most GOOD schools, will teach you how to learn, give you the tools and let you learn at your own pace with a mix of classroom and hands on instruction. The bottom line though, if you want to keep on top of the market and progress, you will most definitely need to learn how to teach yourself. Too many techs are complaining that they are out of work or certs are out of date, as if paper creates jobs and not opportunities.

You will need to learn how to spend a great deal of your time in self study if it is ever going to work for you.

You should be shown fundamentals and details, in order to get through though and ESPECIALLY before writing certs, you will need a MASSIVE amount of self-discipline and home study that you will eed to drag yourself through.

So i wish you all the luck with your future, but if you're not someone who is willing and disciplined enough to teach yourself and keep yourself on top, even moreso in IT than most other trades, look or something else now and save yourself the disappointment later.

This discussion is closed to new replies.