Question Locked

Access Workgroup and Domain data at the same time?

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Why a XP Pro changed its login method from workgroup to domain can see and be seen, access and be access by computers in the old workgroup?

My company is planning to add a domain controller to current 2 physically separated Lan with 10 computers on each, peer to peer using wrokgroup. in order to increase the security of shared files and folders.

So I test it out at my home first by adding a Windows Server 2003 DC at my home currently with 3 XP Pro under workgroup home.

I installed the DC with domain name home.internal or HOMEINTERNAL. and created a test account.

From one of the XP Pro, right click MyComputer -> property and change the login method from workgroup to domain, a windows pop up ask for user name and password, a welcome message appear and ask for a reboot.
After reboot and login the first thing I do is to go to network neighbor to see what is the different, the different is the workgroup is still their and a new domain is added. I can still access the files on workgroup computer. Well I think maybe domain is superior than workgroup so computer on domain can access workgroup files.

So I do the opposite, access the files on that domain computer, a password box pop up. if i use the user name of that computer to log in I can access the file on that computer only. If I use the domain user name to log in I can also access the files on the Server 2003.

I know I still have a lot of setting to do in the AD, GPO and file system, but I never expect that computers inside a domain can exchange data so easily with other computers, do I setup these things correctly? I have not test it under a freshly installed XP that has not join a workgroup before, can it still access workgroup computer's files when it is in the domain?

I did equip my self with a few server 2003 books first, they all looks like old testament to me, emphasize on all aspect of the server and server role and seldom mention the client.

3 replies

by jamesmondtan

i am not good in server but like to play around with it. too bad no money to buy for testing.
You can try this, login to pc's account (not the one in domain )
Go to control panel - user account - add the name that is in the domain. - and choose administrator for account type. Then you should be able to use the domain account as administrator.
Hope can help.

by simonsimoon

Inspired from your suggestion, I log in an account on a workgroup computer as a restricted user. In network neighbour -> Microsoft Windows Network -> homeinternal (the DC)

A password windows pop up, I input the admin user and password of the DC and was granted access and see NETLOGON and SYSVOL on the DC. Although I haven't set any security yet, the default setting seem to be a little weak or should I say too user friendly?

This discussion is closed to new replies.