My boss got a home computer for her children, a 1.4 GHz Dell that was when purchased, fairly top of the line. It had the usual kid problems, what with Morpheus and Kazaa being installed (but never quite working as advertised, kids never discovered hardware firewalling though they figured out how to remove ZoneAlarm), suffered from the various tool bars, adware and gee I don't know how that got there pornware installs. It became a normal ritual to go strip the stuff out every two months.
I put that Micrsoft acquired Giant Software antispyware package on it which helped some with the kid infection, but still got pretty proficient with running HijackThis, RootKitRevealer and Norton Antivirus. Spyware Blaster did pretty well at keeping all the activeX stuff down, but when you have a computer running all users as administrative accounts, you just cannot avoid all the stuff out there (didn't want to deal with them complaining about it being too hard to log into a separate account to install software, their friends would have told them how to disable that anyway if they had the administrator password).
The system was set up to automatically install Windows updates, antivirus updates and I kept all other programs updated. During all this, the system performance would undulate with it being slower during spyware infestations. They discovered IM which made the problem a little worse, Norton Antivirus almost worked at keeping that attack vector safe, but not quite enought to make me think that it would make using IM at work safe.
During their IM phase, somewhere along the line, the computer took a severe performance hit. I could do the usual things, clean up, defrag, etc. and it would run a little bit better, but never recover back to it's old self. Starting Internet Explorer was an excercise in patience. Then my boss upgraded to Norton Internet Security 2006 and it really went down the tubes. I thought that was a cause of the problem as a few friends had noticed that NIS2006 caused system slowdowns for them. Nothing showed me any problems, started hunting for rootkits with Blacklight, RKR, and even fired up a BartPE disk. Got out JV16 Power Utils and agressively cleaned the registry. Some of the performance seemed to come back. I told my boss we needed to completely reload the system as it probably got rootkitted, though I just could not find any evidence of that. Didn't get around to the system reload. Kids were graduated and moved out of the house, so it wasn't much of a priority. I did increase the system memory up to 512MB at that time, but it had little effect on system performance which was not a normal experience for me. Usually systems going from 256MB to 512MB tend to show a pretty good boost in performance.
A month later it really got slow, now Internet Explorer was taking 5 minutes to load and ran like molasses, the system had got to the point where it was unusable. This was around the last MSN messenger update (this bears extremely high on the problem, didn't know it at the time).
Well, I decided to take advantage of everyone in the house going on vacation. Backed up the data, started stripping out unused software. This was going to be a forensic type operation as I really wanted to find out what the heck was going on with what had been a perfectly nice system. I spent a week hitting it with every diagnostic I could get hands on to detect anything that might be on it. There was absolutely no sign of any rootkit, virus, spyware, nothing.
I gave up, assembled all the disks and formatted the hard drive. I went into diagnostic reload mode. Install programs, check performance. Wow! It was back to being the computer I'd recommended. Slightly slower if you're used to 3GHz machines, but plenty good enough to use. One major thing I notice is that Norton Internet Security 2006 doesn't seem to have that much effect on the performance. Scratch that as a problem. It's really running well! Stomped out that registry corruption, rootkit or whatever the heck was causing the problem, attaboy Dude, you're cooking!
Somewhere toward the end, I'm ticking off the list of software to be reinstalled. Hmm, MSN Instant Messenger, well my boss is using it to keep in touch with her kids at a distance now, so I probably had better install it. It asks during the install of the latest and greatest if I'd like to install the MSN Tool Bar. What the hey, it was on there before. Wham, January hits the Molasses Tank and we're right back where we started with extended load time for Internet Explorer and a slow system response. Hmmmm! Well, which if the last two items can I do without? I unistall MSN Messenger and MSN Toolbar and the computer is just screeming in comparison to what I had experienced. Some headscratching later, I go back through the reinstall and tell it not to install the MSN toolbar. Wow, it is still running just as well as pre MSN Messenger!!!
So, now the system is running quite happily with the Google toolbar and strict instructions to stay away from MSN toolbar. My boss and her jusband aren't adventurous in their internet useage, their other computer, a laptop has stayed infection free for the year and a half they've had it, so unless one of the kids moves back home or gets adventurous on a visit, this desktop computer may just well be cured.
So how many people out there have bought a new computer just because they wanted to IM their friends, didn't pay attention and installed that MSN toolbar and couldn't get their system performance back?