Discussion Locked

Alternative for EXCHANGE server

0 helpful
12 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hello everyone,

Would love some assitance on recommendations on an alternative to exchange server.

- Our company is fairly small but growning and we are in need of an all in one - email\contacts\shared calander etc software \server soloution. However, the IT director does not like MS products at all... so I need to find an altrenative solution to Exchange server that is easy to administer - setup and all the rest.

Can you give me options such as LOTUS etc and reasons why? Otherwise - tell me why EXCHANGE is better?

I have to convience these people that this is the best solution.

12 replies

by yyi

Would love for all you admins to chime in with your responses.

- THANKS signup@ for your reply

Need to spend the least but give the most.

100 + users for email
need global contact list
shared calanders.
would love some type of web access.

by dumphrey

I use Exchange 2003 (daily =\) and overall its a good product. Many times the linux based commercial systems require you to pay yearly charges, which over time (3 plus years for 50ish users)add up to more then Exchange and licenses. I have played with other mail systems (Open Exchange, Axigen, etc) but over all Exchange is the easiest for me to manage. It allows SMTP, IMAP, POP3, HTTP(S), as well as Echange "Native" connections (Ohh and rpc over http). Very flexible. Other servers may have better mail queue managment, but thats rarely what I need, its message tracking I use most, and Exchange does that better then Open Exchange or Axigen (or one or two minor GNU servers I have tried).

by tsunamikimo

For more information call me
717.267.2018...
PS.. Did I tell you 2 minute diaster recovery... Don't believe it call...

? File and print server
? Web server & web caching
? Email server
? Outlook?-compatible groupware*
? Web-based email, calendar and scheduling
? Remote access server
? Router/gateway
? Firewall & virtual private network server
? Continuous, automated, unattended backup
? Two-minute disaster recovery
? Windows?/Mac?/Linux? Support
? Content-filtering
? AntiSpam* and AntiVirus*
? Directory services
? FTP Server
? MySQL? database server
? LDAP server
? Domain name system (DNS)
? Dynamic host confi guration protocol (DHCP)
? Redundant Internet connectivity

by cmiller5400

Used that for years with much success.

But, curiosity is killing the cat... Why does the IT director not like MS products? His decisions should be based on what is best for the company (unless he own it of course) not his personal preferences. Cost and support are two big issues. If you find a product that you like and start having trouble with it, and it's user base is small, the support may not be there.

by dawgit

or better yet, any of the BSDs as the base OS, and build from there. Simple get what you want, as you want, when you want, and only what you want. -d

edited to add: try the folks at Mozilla.org, they will even help you set up 'your' sys. the way you want.

by pringles86

One of the best options is Google Apps I think. You could easily get by using their free version. It would be 100% web based, simple calendar sharing, decent junk mail filter, and you can't beat the price. You don't have to manage the hardware and you can use your existing domain, you just have to update the MX records.

The only reason I am not going with that is I don't have the time to train the 130 users here that would be using it, and I am the only IT guy here. Eventually though, that is the direction I would like to go.

by yyi

I like the google apps, but we have over 150 users. I dont know if this would be more cost effective for us in the long run.

I like the fact we do not have to host. But we would like a bit more strict administration.

Also - our company being small (we are a restaurant group so chefs\mgrs\accountants etc) with just myself for support + the IT Director, need something we can install quickly and not have to watch over constantly.

Any pros or cons? I kinda have to give a proposal to what I feel would work the best.

by pringles86

The only thing I would see you having a problem with is importing all existing emails. The only way you can do that is by going to Premier which costs $50/user/year. Which is why my organization is not going with it.

The dashboard is easy to get around and you can mass import user accounts.

If you do not need to import all the existing emails you should take a deeper look into it. I stopped researching them after I found that out. I am just looking for budget numbers right now and I will get more in depth evaluations later. So, that is about all of the pros and cons I can give you.

Good luck in your search.

by magic8ball

Where I work we recently implemented an Exchange 2007 server. It was last on our list as I and the other admin are not real big fans of MS products. We looked at serveral open source options including Zimbra, Open Xchange, Gordano and a couple of others that I cannot remember off the top of my head. What it boiled down to for us was the integration with Outlook. We had been using MS (non email server) for the longest time. Our ERP software only runs on MS O/Ses. We had a Linux server running Sendmail. The President and VP of the company wanted the shared calendar/meeting setup. Group collaboration. None of the open source products mentioned above integrated natively with Outlook. You typically needed and add-on module. Exchange integrates seamlessly with Outlook and the 2007 web interface isn't that bad either. Cost wise Exchange wasn't out of line with the open source alternatives when we compared it on a long term basis. Setup had a few quirks but once those were hammered out it runs quite smooth. To be honest I wasn't expecting it to go as smooth as it did. A tip for you though, your active directory structure has to be almost flawless for it to install and work properly.

Edited cause I cant speel sometimes.

by idahoit

As an IT consultant, we've used Kerio Mail Server for several of our clients. It's a great alternative to MS Exchange, and it works well on Windows and Macs. For most of our clients we use a hosted Kerio Mail service from www.keriomailhosting.com
Kerio Mail Server provides contact sharing, calendar sharing, push mail, etc. We find it to be a much more efficient and cost effective way to manage our clients email, and by having it hosted with KerioMailHosting.com we don't have to worry about any of the maintenance on the server, upgrades, etc.

This discussion is closed to new replies.