Question Locked

AMD Athlon X2 Dual Core 4200+ - Good?

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I'm building a machine and I saw a good deal on the AMD Athlon X2 4200+, is it a good CPU? I've stuck with Intel since before Pentium, (286 days) and I had some extra cash and decided I needed to build a new machine (for use at work). I came across this CPU and wanted to know your thoughts on it.

4 replies

by tig2

They have all been great. I am currently on an AMD Turion 64 X2 Mobile. Love the computer and really appreciate the price point.

Intel makes a good chip, AMD makes a good chip. The difference I can see between them is that AMD isn't as expensive.

by mbmdgi

What about the AMD athlon 64 X2 dual core processor with 2gig of Ram, 1.7GHz, for a laptop. Is this outdated technology? It is for basic stuff such as browsing, e-mail, word processing, watching videos.

by hal 9000

If you are building from scratch make sure that you can change parts that may not work. The most common thing is the Video Card as these quite often have problems with the different M'Board Chip Sets. So if you are unable to change the Video Card make sure that there are no known issues between the M'Board and the Video Card.

The main difference between the 2 makers is that Intel provides a complete package with not only a CPU but a M'Board Chip Set that anyone can buy and build their M'Boards on. AMD Currently doesn't offer this as they only make CPU's and right now there are many different suppliers of M'Board Chip Sets that work in different ways.

Although AMD is currently in the process of addressing this problem and have bought ATI and will be supplying both their own ATI Chip Set M'Boards and Chip Sets to different Makers. Though right at the moment that not here yet.

For business I tend to use Intel CPU & Chip Set M'Boards because they give a better Tax Break to the Business and the home users go for the AMD units as they are initially cheaper to make. But that's entirely your decision and you're the one who is going to have to live with the Tax Breaks that any computer will supply you with. Generally speaking for Office type work I've found that Intel CPU's & M'Boards work better and for gaming the AMD has the edge on the Intel's in this range of CPU.

Just make sure that every part works together and I can tell you from personal experience I've yet to build one set of AMD Computers that I've not had a problem with Hardware incompatibility with. When it's only 1 machine it's a nuisance but when there are a few hundred involved it's a lot more than a bit of a nuisance as the time taken to push the refunds through and claim them against your new purchase can be annoying. 1 Video Card you can live with but a few hundred amount to quite a lot of money that you can not afford to have tied up.

Also never consider an All In One M'Board with on board sound and Video as these are the worst possible things that you can use as they steal System Memory to use as Video Memory which is much slower than Video memory and some of the CPU's Clock Cycles to generate that Video. As the CPU works slower than a GPU you are getting the worst of everything possible and there is nothing that you can do to improve the situation.

Unless it's a Server M'Board that will be run Headless always use a separate Video Card as the system will be totally different and far Superior in performance. Even the better NB M'Boards have their own GPU and RAM built onto the M'Boards and don't require any System RAM or CPU Clock Cycles to work properly. Of course the cheap Sub 1K NB's that are sold off as bottom of the range don't meet these specifications and they react like an All in One M'Board slow and CPU intensive to run for any length of time.

Col

This discussion is closed to new replies.