Not sure about actual side by side comparisons but there's lots of info & links here
http://www.firewallguide.com/index.html
They do have a chart that compares security suites
http://www.firewallguide.com/suites.htm
I use Norton NIS 2005 & find it works great, a resource hog that can be tamed with proper setup.
In general all the AV apps available are basically the same, what it boils down to is the users habits & your ability to properly configuring the software.
If you go with a security suite, I'd advise you to spend some time & delve deep into their settings, you'll find many things you won't like. Their default settings are pathetic, your PC is wide open to Microsoft, Verisign & the vendor themselves. All the vendors have contracts with various websites like Yahoo & Doubleclick, as a result their antispam settings have exceptions for those sites by default. I've found this in Norton, McAfee & PC-cillin's security suites, there likely the same way in the others. Guess they have to make money somehow!!