Discussion Locked

Are exclusive contracts for Cable good or bad?

0 helpful
8 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/10/30/AR2007103002042.html?wpisrc=newsletter

[b]FCC Ready to Ban Exclusive Cable Contracts[/b]
The FCC is looking to ban exclusive contracts to subdivisions and apartment buildings, to allow for competition in these areas. They would go in an negate any existing contracts that are in place now.

At first glance, I am inclined to say the competition would be good for all of us. Taking a closer look though and you see HOW the exclusive contracts came about. No one else WOULD incur the expenses to run the cable to these areas, so in exchange for taking on the costs, the cable companies get an exclusive right to that segment for an extended amount of time, and a very few are indefinite.

Does the US Government have the legal ability to interfere with legally binding contracts?

Will this slow NEW networks being set up because of the costs involved, if the providers can not get the exclusive deal?

If the US Government does interfere, should the cable companies be reimbursed for part of their expenses for running the network?

[i]"The commission can change its mind, but it's a bad precedent to let the government undo contracts because of changes in public policy," said Daniel Brenner[/i]

8 replies

by jaqui

You get better service and better rates when there is competition to get your money.

by jaqui

actually gives them incentive to run the cable out to more areas.
with monopolies in place, they are prohibited from doing so.

we have anti monopoly laws here, it is written in such a way that existing service providers MUST make line available for their competition.
[ so the locla telco has to provide infrastructure to those competing against them ]
same applies to cable services, unfortuntely, the two biggest screwed us over in BC, one sold all their BC holdings to the other, leaving us with only one provider. They did make some improvements at first, now service levels are dropping.

by jdclyde

The only down side is a COMPANY will not spend money running a network to a new area if someone else will come along right away and be the ones to benefit from the expenses of the first company. I see it slowing deployment.

by jaqui

but the competition aspect does help keep them working to keep your business.

by faradhi

As you a jaqui has already discussed, there is a trade off. On one hand, if exclusive contracts limit competition and as such service quality suffers. On the other hand, why shouldn't the cable companies be allowed to realize a return on their investment?

However, If the companies want that new market they will figure out a way. One way would be for companies to pool resources for running cable to new developments. Or Why not take an approach used in pharmaceuticals. A cable company who wires an area can retain exclusive rights for a period of years, then they must open their lines to competition. This is a similar approach to where a generic can not be introduced for a certian number of years. OR The developers run the cable to the individual units and then the cable companies only have to run lines to the building / development and then connect to the appropriate front end.

As for the competition argument, I think it is silly. For the most part, Satellite is available for most. Yet even with the satellite competition, cable is still raising prices and customers are getting crappy service.

by ganyssa

A friend of mine used to live in a low-income apartment complex, and the only way they could get a cable company to wire them at all was to offer them an exclusive contract. The rest of the city (with the exception of some other apartment complexes in the same boat) has a different cable company providing service, and they skipped that area of town when they wired because they didn't see any profit in the residents.

FWIW, the service is actually cheaper than the surrounding area for more stations, but they do not offer cable internet and aren't planning on it. I've no idea if the exclusivity expires or not, though.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

unless some ultra-do-gooder is running things exclusive contracts to cable providers screw the consumer big-time over the long haul.

IOW - when they came into the area, customer service was great, channel lineup was great.
Now they've been around awhile and have a captive audience customer service sucks, as does channel lineup.

edit typo - prolly missed a different one...

This discussion is closed to new replies.