Question Locked

Are my help desk people insane?

0 helpful
20 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

When a user's AD profile starts acting funny (gets out of sync or drive mappings start dropping off), their advice is the following:

With Windows XP up and running, turn off the power and/or pull the plug.

They swear that fixes flaky profiles every time.

Are they full of it, or does that work for some unknown reason?

20 replies

by robo_dev

Just thought maybe this was some secret method like the hard-drive freezer trick.....

by seanferd

It's an "I'm too lazy to walk someone through a chkdsk or perform it myself" trick.

It's also a very good "corrupt the hard drive trick", particularly if they recommend you have an Office document open.

by ic-it

I think Seanferd has nailed it, a bad sector or two.

by the scummy one

just as well as taking a magnet too close to the HDD. Just as well as tossing the PC across the room, just as well as deleting all of the ntuser.dat files and reg hive

Actually, it does probably work better than those that I mentioned. So it should now be put on the list of FUBAR fixes

by rob miners

It's a really good way to corrupt a profile. Have they just recieved their certificates?

by boxfiddler Hot topic

But I do know that's a crap recommendation. So, yes. Your help desk people are insane!

:^0

by oh smeg

In the PS and on the M'Board so that when they reapply power the system restarts in a fresh [b]Clean[/b] state with no carry over from the previous operation running or loaded into the Memory/Cache.

Personally it's not something I would recommend but on some occasions it does work though it's more than a bit rough on the hardware. ;)

Col

by seanferd

but never thought of it as a clever method for clearing a previous state. :^0

Interesting.

by the scummy one

if the system is hung up, and cannot be shut down, Aside from that, it should be avoided, as it may produce more problems

by the scummy one

but I power the unit off first, before removing the battery and power

by nicknielsen

...with less chance of damage by shutting down normally, unplugging the PC, and waiting a minute or so to plug it back in.

by oh smeg

Shut Down Normally Unplug the mains and press the On Switch for 10 seconds.

That does exactly the same thing but it's much safer for the hardware.

But I wouldn't expect the Help Desk people to know that after dealing with one of the biggest ISP's Help Desks here recently. It seems to be a matter of pride that they didn't pass the inquiry along to higher up and the poor girl that I got knew nothing at all it was a nightmare that lasted 3 hours and completely wrecked all of the settings on a computer. Took 3 hours to mess up and 14 hours to fix after the ISP got their system working again.

All that was wrong is that the user couldn't receive any E-Mails they could send browse the net but not receive any incoming E-Mail. Hopefully this week will not be so frustrating. I did however hang up when the demand that I delete all f the e-mail from the system was made. ;)

Col

by seanferd

"I can't get the system to shut down at all."
(Tried everything.)

"Press the power button for 5-10 seconds."
(Depends on how power button behavior is configured.)

by seanferd

shut down the call centre and unplugged it for 10 years, then rebooted.

by oh smeg

Just imagine what advice a 10 year out of Date Call Center would give out. :^0

At least this one had new equipment even if the staff who worked there only knew enough to read the screen sometimes. And all of the time place you on hold while they asked someone else who probably didn't know anything more. :D

Col 0:-)

by seanferd

Maybe they would admit straight up that they don't know, and escalate the call. :D Ain't nothin' like passing the buck.

by oh smeg

Where the exact Opposite. From the way that they where working I think that they got Penalized for Transferring Calls as this girl simply refused to even consider the possibility that someone else may be better equipped to help me. I'm told that the Ex Army Surgeon who was in charge of a Field Hospital who owned the computer had the same experience on 2 previous occasions and brought it to me out of desperation because when he rang them they where useless but pleasant.

What I found interesting was that this girl refused to even consider that the ISP may have a problem and insisted that it had to be the individual Computer. My call to them started out with a Direct Question [b]Are the ISP Mail Servers experiencing problems or is there any issues that I need to know about/[/b] She then launched directly into checking the Incommoding Mail & Outgoing Servers addresses. Strangely that was the first thing that I had checked as well and they where right.

OH well that's finished now and hopefully will not happen again it wasn't my idea of fun at all. :(

Col

This discussion is closed to new replies.