Discussion Locked

Are we willing to pay the price of catastrophe to keep our privacy?

0 helpful
30 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/19539748/

It's about how camera's in London helped capture the latest terrorists and if citizens of the United States would accept this type of surveillance.

My feelings.

1). If your on those camera's, your in public. What freaken privacy.

2). Proven track record, don't try.

3). Quote from the article.
[i]There will always be a healthy dynamic tension between freedom and safety, but we would be well [b]advised to recognize that the ultimate loss of freedom is the death of innocents.[/b][/i]

In other words, your cherished freedom cost someone their life which means they lost all their freedoms, Who here has the guts to tell me that their privacy is more important. come on people do tell.. In the context of this specific article, camera's in the public. Is your precious privacy so important that you would have someone lose all their freedoms? Their life? Are you so much more important then they are?

And yes, it is as simple as that.
Dan

30 replies

by nentech

Is this we do not trust them to keep the information they are given safe?

The camera?s may be in public therefore they do nothing more than show what is seen by anyone who is in visual range

But we do not know who or what is looking at us through them

A burglar may use them to see how far from home you are

In many movies camera?s are used to chase the hero or victim

Also what is a public area?
The street in front of our homes are public

Then we have the paparazzi who show how easy it is to get a picture even inside our home?s from a public location

If people with money and power that the celebs have cant stop them or punish them in the courts or public forum what hope is there for the average Joe

Even if they do the paparazzi still come out as the winner by the huge amount of money they receive even after the fines have been deducted

If we want people to accept camera?s in public places

The law, the government and it?s agencies have to show that any use of information other than what is acceptable will have the threat of painful punishment

Then the sh*t bags who use it for enjoyment or blackmail or as a regular income will find the REAL fear of being discovered is just to much to carry on doing what they have in the past

There is also one other thing to think about
Should the camera?s be hidden or plainly visible?

To some up
Many people and I do not trust anyone who may use these cameras

We do not trust them to look after the info they may get from them

We do not trust them to painfully (Make them wish they had never even thought about it) punish the people who steal or misuse that info

By the way don?t pick your nose or scratch yourself (you know where) or have sex in public it may end up on
http://www.youtube.com/

Col

by danlm

The point is, they work.

They are used intensely by the British Government to combat terrorism and to capture people who practice it. We are foolish for not using what has shown to work. Hell, my apartment complex has them all around the buildings. I trust the government a hell of a lot more then some minimum wage secretary that monitors those tapes. And I am sure that this is not the only apartment that utilizes camera surveillance of their grounds.

Dan

by nentech

But my point was that
They can be used for more than that
and there needs to true punishment for those people who misuse them

Then it will be easyer to gane peoples trust

Then maybe we might have less arguments about privacy

by danlm

chuckle, least you didn't put attack children protect this property.

Dan

by danlm

And you don't care who has been hurt by the criminals that these tools can help stop.

So show your youtube, make your little play on rebellion. I'll just keep posting about all the instances where there are more victims because of you and your precious privacy.

I wonder if I can sue pricks like you and your youtube friend if I become a victim when something could have been done and you stopped it. I wonder how much I could make you suffer for the pain you allowed to happen. I think victims of crimes that could have been stopped should place a class action suit against you and others just like you. You deserve it.

It's only fair. The privacy advocates do just that, file suit when they feel invaded. It's time they get a taste of their own medicine.

Dam

by w2ktechman

Ok lets say they put video in, and there is still crime. What's next?
Will they then decide to install microphones everywhere? So now if you are in a public place, everything you say to someone is recorded and scanned for keywords?
Then they decide to add infrared because people are still doing things illegally, so now they can keep track (to a degree) of what everyone is doing in their homes. Boost up the power and sensitivity of the mics, and what privacy will be left?

by danlm

That have captured criminals and terrorists. This is not a pie in the sky idea that has not been tried and does not have a track record.

I look at these videos as something that has been shown to be useful. And have multiple instances where they were critical in the assistance of capturing murders.

Dan

by nentech

Between criminals and terrorists

One of the main problems is the criminals tend to avoid areas where there are camera?s

The criminals always seem to have the same if not better info than those who are trying to catch them

Many of the agencies that would use the info from the cameras have no problem with using that info to put pressure on someone to do what they want

Those agencies also have no problem with breaking the law when it suits them

What people are really sick and tired of are the lies and half-truths that they constantly hear from almost any official
They are also sick and tired of hearing about the true reason for something that was done afterwards
They then find out that it will now take an act of god to get it stopped

I know what you are saying

But before anything like this can happen
There must be laws and controls in place to prevent abuse
There must also be laws in place to punish the criminals on behalf of the victims (You know, the people who were hurt betrayed and violated)

I know the terrorists will still attack and the cameras may help to stop them
But if a camera fails off a pole and kills someone then the terrorist?s may as well have killed him or her anyway

Yes that is simplistic but it shows how a lack of control and regulations can harm the people who it was suppose to protect

I think the cameras are a good idea
But what I want to know is this

Where they are to be placed and how to control the information they provide

Will the agency?s who monitor them be able to respond in time
If not what will be done so they can

Just some of the things to think about

by danlm

I disagreed and ridicule people that won't even consider these. There is the differece.

Dan

by tony hopkinson

It has no inherrent morality
It can be used to catch bad guys.
It can be used to hurt good guys.

They aren't surveilance until you look at them. They aren't spying 'til someone uses their eye.

The volume of information collected by the camera's in London precludes an invasion of privacy, it's similar to cell phone tracking, it can be done, but you need a target first.
Governments could n't afford a real time tracking and recognition system, and based on their IT development record would probably f*** it up anyway.

The deterrent value of the setup is minimal, would n't even start to justify the cost. A lot of the cameras in London are for the congestion charge, that does pay for itself.

by danlm

As a citizen from Great Britain, do you think these tools are being abused by your government as they are suggesting here? Governments are Governments, they have the same pitfalls.

Or does Great Britain have in place controls such as Digital suggests are needed to stop any type of abuse? And again, I agree with Digitals suggestion that controls need to be in place. No argument at all with that.

Dan

by jmgarvin

The point is the guy in the video was ROBBED and the police claimed they could do nothing about it, but the second an alien shows up on the camera, suddenly the cops can see?

If a camera pointing into someones window can't stop a burglar, than how is it going to help stop anything else?

by danlm

your right, total overreaction.

You caught the tail end of a crap day, not your fault but mine. Again, I apologize.

Dan

by danlm

There HAS to be true punishment for those that misuse them. Absolutely.

You know Digital, I have no issue with arguments such as this. It's a recognizing of the use of a tool to safe guard us, but also addressing your concerns. But for those to just say. NO, its an invasion of my privacy is not an argument. At least in this case. They offer nothing to address the problem that caused the requirement for this consideration, just denial that any type of tools be given to government(local, federal) authorities. This is why I am such a flamer and baiter(I admit it). I know what the answer is going to be in most case's, and I feel these people should be shown for what they are. Selfish individuals that would rather see people die, hurt, or victimized then have tools in place to stop it. Their privacy and liberties are more important than anything else. Even the privacy and liberties that are being taken away from fellow citizens by the criminals, what ever type of criminal they may be. They don't care, it is as simple as that. And, it doesn't matter how many people are hurt. They still don't care.

Dan

by tony hopkinson

of it being abused. If they are careful about it, possibly there never will be.

What is going to be abuse, it's not so much abuse of the tech as that of position.

It's side effects, you are monitoring a businessman laundering money and get some inside info in the process, that would make you a packet on the stock market....

You are monitoring a crack house and you see one of your boss' major political opponent's relatives, frequenting it.....

You are monitoring a whorehouse and you see next door but one's missus working out of there and she's damned attactive and her bloke is a bit violent....

All the cameras do is increase the potential number of extras that could be gleaned.
99% of the footage will never be looked at.
Just not worth getting worked up about, unless your government marks you down as an enemy of the state.

by inkling

Cameras never have and never will STOP the loss of life.

They certainly didn't in this case. Only vigilant citizens can do this.

"Is your precious privacy so important that you would have someone lose all their freedoms? Their life?"

Sounds pretty, but it amounts to absolute crap when held up to any real scrutiny. Especially in this case.

Case in point:

They have some great videos of the 9/11 terrorists on video in the airports.

That was sure helpful wasn't it?

by danlm

I give up. Go read my books, watch my cartoons, and buy my gun. Make sure they fall forward. And pile them where people can't see them.

Dan

by inkling

I didn't realize logical arguments weren't allowed here.

I'll have to work myself into a frenzy and post some emotionally charged nonsense similar to yours later.

Cheers.

by danlm

http://www.usnews.com/usnews/news/articles/070715/23cctv.htm

And truthfully, I am not sugesting these camera's be in every city in the nation. Just the major ones. New York City, Washington, Philladelphia, ...

Large area's that are prime targets.

I have also seen articles where camera's have been used to deter crimes. They put up camera's in high crime area's, and crime suddenly goes down. Why? Smile George as you rob that person, your on candid camera.

They have value.

[i]But cameras are not new to New York, nor is using private cameras in police investigations. Long before 9/11, there were hundreds of police security cameras around New York?one New York Civil Liberties Union report counted more than 2,300 visible from street level in 1998. There are now more than 4,200 cameras south of 14th Street, according to the report. In 2003, the NYPD began installing more cameras in high-crime neighborhoods under a pilot program. There are now more than 120 cameras in that system throughout the five boroughs, and hundreds more are planned.

Officials credit that system, combined with increased officer presence, with an 18 percent reduction in major felony crimes and a 22 percent decrease in shooting incidents in the first four months of 2007. Indeed, the very day that the specifics of the new ring-of-steel plans were announced, two NYPD officers were shot by a suspect fleeing a traffic stop in Brooklyn. The incident was caught by three separate, private security cameras in the area, which aided police in the hunt for the suspects.[/i]

dan

by drowningnotwaving

You can't scream for "privacy", in public.

I think your measure is excellent - if a cop can legally be there, and what she or he can see can legally be used in evidence, then it matters not that the cop is a video camera.

by jmgarvin

I was just giving you hell :-)

But really though, the cops didn't do anything until the guy showed up as an alien....wtf? It seems like the cameras are just there to help after the fact.

by nentech

Just a joke to lighten things up

Its difficult to ignore the past actions of the agency?s who would use these cameras
(We all know who they are and whom they answer to)

Many people have been hurt by invasion of privacy so I can understand why they and the people who know them get upset

I don?t like to think about what may happen to some people if the wrong persons find out where they are

The wife hiding from a violent husband who just happens to know the right people
The witness hiding from the underworld
There are many others

The argument you used to start this discussion is a very old and often misused
The value of my life verse?s the life of someone else

Lets see is my life the same value as someone else
Does it depend on who they are?
Does it depend on what they do?
Does it depend on how many people depend on them?
Is my life of less value than 2 or 10 or 1000 people?
So it?s not just about privacy

Just how much of my privacy should I give up to save the life of another?
Will it even make difference can they be saved?
Is there a better way to save their life?
Just some of the questions

Some people think the Internet is used to invade the lives and privacy of others
We all know how easy it is to use it that way
We all know how easy it is to control

I have tried not to make this personal
So I hope this line
?I wonder if I can sue pricks like you and your youtube friend?
From this post by you was not about me

?fine, then let the criminals go free. You don't want them caught.
(And you don't care who has been hurt by the criminals that these tools can help stop.

So show your youtube, make your little play on rebellion. I'll just keep posting about all the instances where there are more victims because of you and your precious privacy.

I wonder if I can sue pricks like you and your youtube friend if I become a victim when something could have been done and you stopped it. I wonder how much I could make you suffer for the pain you allowed to happen. I think victims of crimes that could have been stopped should place a class action suit against you and others just like you. You deserve it.

It's only fair. The privacy advocates do just that, file suit when they feel invaded. It's time they get a taste of their own medicine.?

by danlm

You was absolutely right, just I give up trying to understand why people find this such an invasion of privacy.

Thats all, nothing more. Nothing less. I accept that I don't understand, and I move on.

Ok?

Dan

by w2ktechman

they already have cameras at major intersections to give out tickets. The cameras themselves are not my concern. As it has been pointed out though, there needs to be limits set and rules (laws) in place before doing it, to reduce the abuse.
What I dont want to happen is for the law to widen the arena by doing anything like I suggested. Bringing not only cameras, but other devices to peek into homes and or listen to personal conversations.
In public is one thing. In your home, bought or rented, is out of the question.

by danlm

God, I don't want that either.

I was going to get long winded here and explain my feelings on privacy. But, what's the point. There are too many people that don't agree, and the conversation has become civil(me). Why ruin it.

Dan

by w2ktechman

we must push back on some of the lesser things as well. The powers at be want to do this, and will try whatever means they can to make it 'adopted'.
To make it harder for them to have their way is the only way we can fight back, under the law.

by dadspad

The streets are public, parking lots are public, where you work is not private to you. In fact, with the popularity of full digital cameras and cell phone cameras, almost anywhere is available.

Inside your house is deemed your privacy. No public run cameras should be able to see into it. Although it might be a good idea to close the curtains or do nothing you wish to hide if they are open.

That said, I worked for a company that manufacutured security cameras; they are capable of swiveling 180% in less than 1 second and zoom to an incredible amount, in color and under low lighting conditions. A security person was watching the building, especially outside for any activity. This was on the midnight shift, he noticed a car was parked way in the back of the parking lot, away from any other cars under under a tree. He was able to zoom from the camera high on top of the roof to the inside of the car. There was a people in side having sexual activity. He called the police and they came and arrested a prositute doing business there. So the technical ability is there to do anything the government wants. Funds are the only limiting factor.

We in the US are proud of our privacy. I do not know if there will be a backlash. Unlike Britain, we have never had terrorist attacks before, we will have to see how that affects the populace.

This discussion is closed to new replies.