Discussion Locked

Bachelor's.. Business Administration or IT Management?

0 helpful
15 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Greetings all. I'm getting my Associates in Network Administration in September, but I've had absolutely no luck finding any jobs, even for entry-level. So I started thinking and it began to hit me that while I don't mind doing the hands-on computer work, I feel more comfortable directing and planning, and coming up with solutions to increase productivity.

Now I'm highly considering getting my Bachelor's, but I can't decide if I should get it in Business Administration (i.e. all business aspects) or IT Management/MIS (i.e. Directly related to IT). One of my instructors suggested the general business degree as it's more well-rounded and the fact that I would have an associates in a computer discipline helps out greatly since I would understand the tech aspects as well as the business ones.

Any thoughts on which path I should take? Many thanks in advance.

- Wayne

15 replies

by oz_media

This may seem hard or rude but please believe me when I say I am speaking out of sheer honesty and nothing personal is implied.

It seems that you have been finding it hard to find work, and you are basing this on you current certification. Have you thought that it may be your aproach, lack of job hunting skills or interview weaknesses. Again, I know nothig about you so I cannot insinuate, but merely mean to bring your atention to some key unemployment issues.

1) Looking in the paper has less than 2% success rate. Phone books are nearly 100%, find a target company, figure our what you can do for them personally and professionally, call them out of the blue, introduce yourself find out who is in charge (don't talk to the secretary in most cases) and state your objectives wnat you are willing to provide and ask for the opportunity to BRING a resume to them NOT MAIL IT DOES NOT WORK. Once again, MAILING RESUMES DOES NOT WORK. (Sorry, I had to get that out of my system)

TAKE your resume in to the employer and try and get in for an interview, ofer to wait in the lobby if the boss is bust etc. be persisitent, too many people give up, not realizing the secretary is mainly a gatekeepeer in most cases and simply wants to protect the boss from who SHE thinks he doesn't want to see. The boss may actually be thinking about hiring someone and the secretary has no idea.

So anyway, get your resume on the desk and personal presentation should be obvious.

NOW, to address your actual question. MANY MANY people post on TR each week saying they have a BA in this or a masters in that or a PHD in whatever, and they STILL can't find work. So if you ae thinking text books and certifications/degrees will get you a job, think again. In MANY cases they help but it is YOU that gets the job.

speaking purely on a personal level, I would really think twice about getting further education if I can't find an entry level position based on my current certifications, it certainly won't be any easier with a bachelors degree as you will then be looking for higher pay and more responsibility, we will see you posting here in four years saying that you have a bachelors degree and can only find entry level IT work!

Again, I apologize perfusely if I sound like I am negative or condescending in anyway, it is really not my intent, I am just saying what I see here ALL the time.

Myself, not to brag, I got my MCNE AFTER I was em[ployed for two years in IT. When I originally took a network admin position I had NOTHING, not even grade 12, well, I was a licenced mechanic but that hardly counts.

I showed an eagerness and was offered a position by letting other people I knew that I was job hunting, someone reccomended me, my skills checked out and they took me on.

It didn't take a cert or a degree to fin work, just putting the word out and presenting myself to the employer properly.

Since then, I have gone on to be self employed, I work as a contracted admin for a couple of companies and pretty much write my own paycheck.

If I had relied on certs and degrees to get me ahead, I'd be on welfare. I created my last position, I created this line of work. It is up to YOU to actively and agreesively find work.

Sending out 30 resumes month? Complete waste of time and energy, not to mention postage.

Looking in newspapers and IT papers? Absolute waste of time.

Monster etc. online, okay START but not very effective.

Recruiters, absolute waste of time.

So what then?

Phone book, scripted and written intro speech (change it depending on how far you get before your are cut off by secretary and you will get to the owner or President in no time).

Convince the boss to see you and accept your resume, not HR if it can be avoided.

DO NOT MAIL IT IN, hand deliver it and se if you can meet the bocc (just to intorduce yourself of course). Prepare an interesting question to ask him/her and while you are dropping off the resume, ask the question directly to spr interest and perhaps have your face become recognized.

There are a million ways to get on the door and preset yourself, but unless you are doing this ALL DAY EVERY DAY until you are employed you will not succeed. Finding a full time job IS a fulltime job.

Sprry for the long winded lecture, it's just that you ae far from the first and certainly not the last who wil ask this same question.

You can spend all the time and money in the world on training but if you aren't looking for work properly, the eager kid from MacDonalds will beat you out even with a bachelors degree.

Best of luck to you and sincerely, no offense.

by obiwaynekenobi

To be honest, I have no idea what the problem is with finding jobs. I apply for jobs I'm perfectly qualified for, format my resume and cover letter appropriately etc. etc.

I've never had luck cold-calling places since 99% of the time they aren't hiring, and the ones that advertise typically only have a fax number or e-mail address (it's highly difficult to even find out who the heck I'm writing to because none of these companies list anything!).

Honestly the reason I'm contemplating the Bachelor's is because I have a knack for the business end of things moreso than the hands-on work. Not to say I can't do that and that I don't enjoy doing it, but the more I think about it the more I'd rather be the one making the decisions (yes, I realize it takes years of experience and success at managing to get to that point).

Thanks for the advice, though. I'll keep it in mind (both for my actual question and the job advice you generously provided).

- Wayne

by oz_media

I honestly meant it in the nicest way.

I am the same way, I can work for someone for MAYBE a year at max before I want to steer the ship and get frustreted with thos who are.

That's why I have always done my own thing and hate to rely on others for employment and a paycheck.

Good luck

OM

by sherlock bones

I agree with you dude ... we ALL need a dose of reality sometimes...even with experience. We can sometimes start feeling sorry for ourselves and start sinking into negative thinking.

Start thinking positvely and maybe if the jobhunting is going nowhere ...then you could probably look at becoming self-employed. It has it's struggles but can be very fulfilling. I'm actually considering it myself. Even with self-employment, the start is seeking employment but from a different angle.

Go for it dude ... I know I am!

by eyoung

Wayne:

I'll start upfront by stating that I'm a Program Director at a College in New England. I spend a good deal of my time advising students at the Bachelor's level about degrees, where to go next and careers.

It seems to me by your post that you are looking to expand your knowledge in business operations, strategy and planning so you can better apply your AS degree in the business space. It also sounds like you are interested in being that "go-between" person who understands the language of IT as well as the language of business.

The advice you received on getting a business degree is sound. However, I'm not clear if you would go back full-time or part-time (I assume part-time)? You'll not want to loose your networking skills and will want to apply them as well so make sure whatever you do you keep those skills solid. You may want to look at a hybrid degree. One of the programs I administer and teach in is in e-Business Management. It's that hybrid mix between business strategy AND techy. We are not the only ones out there with this type of degree.

Do some research on the web under e-Business or e-Commerce or Managing Information Technology and see what you come up with. You may find that this is the degree that calls to you.

Good luck!

Elaine Young
Program Director Marketing
Assistant Program Director e-Business Management
Champlain College

by rawick

Along the lines mentioned by Elaine, you may also consider Business Analyst or Project Management...

I've been in the IT field for 27 years and am currently a PMP certified project manager. I've lead all types and sizes of projects over the years. I recently interviewed with IBM for a high level PM job in the insurance industry. They originally told me they were looking for strong PM skills vs. business knowledge. When they turned me down they told me I did not have enough business experience... I'm now considering going back for a BA. My advice, go back and get the business degree. More and more companies are tired of the rift between IT and the business and their solution is to place IT PMs from their business ranks.

Good Luck! (Wish me luck too)
Bob

by obiwaynekenobi

Thanks for the replies.. I think that's what I'm going to do.. but I'm going to wait a little bit to (hopefully) find some IT work and have a source of income.. then I'm going to get a B.S. in Business Administration, and with luck the school I go to will allow me to take some of its IT-management type courses as electives so I would essentially have a major in business administration and a minor in management info. systems.

by malikimran.ijaz

No one wishes to under rate the IT Certifications and degrees but whenever the word 'Manager' creeps into the discussion, Technical resources are now 'expected' to have a formal business 'understanding' if not business 'grounding'.
More & more clients now wish the technical consultants address their business problems (through technicalk solutions) rather than suggest equipment or software. It would help if you could talk their lingo.

Malik Imran Ijaz
HR & Business Manager, TechAccess

by mlayton

...in the long term, the advice you have regarding the general business degree is sound. If you're more comfortable with planning and the management type roles, the business degree that will give an overall feel for the pain points of an IT Departments "customers" is a sound pursuit. And what you need to do is think about the future. What is the stage of your life you are at? Because take it from me, while not impossible, it is much harder to pursue your degree after taking time off later. So if you have the time, the interests, and the perserverence to finish your BA now, go for it. If you can get one with a minor in technology, providing you internship possibilities in the field of interest, even better. And as always, think about volunteer opportunities in your spare time - the experience builds your resume, and the people you meet may have the very job opening that you are interested in.

by phascnh

All good response's and all dead on. If I may add do the Business Administration with marketing as your major. You'll never look back...

by obiwaynekenobi

Well I'm only 22, so I guess I have my whole life to look forward to :) I've decided to go for the Business Admin degree, but I think I may wait 6 months to a year so I can find some work and, hopefully, get the company to help pay some of the tuition (I don't have the money on my own, and I don't really want to take out $20K+ in loans)

by dc_guy

To answer your question directly, I just saw some newspaper's table of the starting salaries for new graduates. Chemical engineering was tops, over $50K. Several computer disciplines were right up there. Computer science was best, followed by computer engineering, software engineering, and management information systems. I didn't know there were so many different, related degrees. "IT Management" wasn't listed, but it was clear that hands-on technology rules. As for business admin., a couple of specialties rated well, particularly accounting. Marketing was on the list but not the top half.

What they didn't say was what percentage of graduates actually got jobs. If you factor in all the zero salaries of the people who are still looking, you'd get much different numbers. English majors were on there for comparison, with a starting salary somewhere in the thirties, but I know that people with even master's degrees in English are using that skill to practice saying, "Do you want fries with that?"

In terms of the personal value of the education, I'd give you a different answer and go with business. My degree is in accounting and I've never worked in the field since I graduated, yet hardly a day goes by that I don't find life to be made a bit easier by applying the knowledge and wisdom I learned to real life. It sure gives me a different perspective on the upcoming election.

But speaking as your elder with an obligation to let my conscience and my own world view shape my advice to you, I have to repeat what I've said elsewhere on these boards. Do you really want to spend a lot of time and money getting into a field whose jobs are being outsourced offshore at a dramatic rate? I see an uncanny similarity between the American IT industry in this decade and the American auto industry in the 1960s. The industry has matured and now needs disciplined people more than creative ones. We do best when we're breaking ground that others will pave, and now thats genetic engineering and nanotech, which may well prove to be a single discipline. The world's information infrastructure needs standardization and QA, which are anathema to our cowboy culture.

And I'll tell you what I've told a lot of young people. If you want to get into a field that guarantees an income of $100K in ten years and won't be either automated or outsourced any time soon: apprentice yourself to a plumber.

And I am dead serious.

by elexis

It is a tough question because what works for one person doesn't work for another... I would start with recommending that you start asking your teachers, friends, colleagues, family, and anyone else you find who works in a technical field how they got started.

Let me put it this way.. I have a Bachelors Degree (non-technical) and was surprised to learn once I got into the networking industry that not many others even had a 2-year degree. I took the title ?Network Engineer? literally and thought most would have degrees in Engineering, silly me =). So, don't think that your degree is the magic key to the job world. A degree does not HURT you, but it won't in itself get you the job, you have to do that. I would put more focus on getting hands on experience, search for part time jobs or volunteer work that let's you get in an do what you want to do.

Just to give you an example.
During my 4 years in college I kept 2 part time jobs for a total of 20-30 hours per week. Unlike my friends who took the easy jobs working watching dishes or picking up golf balls, I took jobs that I thought would help me after I graduated. I worked as a computer lab consultant and as an intern in a official college office. Among other things, my jobs involved creating web pages; troubleshooting general PC and network issues; and creating/editing/publishing a quarterly newsletter. I got a volunteer opportunity for the Red Cross once to do data entry using Access and several other tools. It was just 1 hour a week for 8 weeks but at the end I was proficient in using Access. Trust me plenty of my friends while I was in school said, wow how useless is that? I said really, so you know how to use the Access program and can type 75 wpm right? Exactly. It?s just one more skill that I have that someone else doesn?t, that?s what gives you the edge.

The skills I gained at these jobs are why I got my first job outside of school, not the degree. What a degree does is, given two people with similar qualifications; it might push your name up to the top because it shows you know how to finish what you start. I hope that helps.

by dc_guy

I never cease to be amazed at the number of people who choose careers that will cause them to spend the rest of their lives huddled over a keyboard -- and they never learned to type. For a couple of decades it was a matter of pride for women who said, "I will NEVER be a secretary," and a matter of machismo for men who said, "I will ALWAYS have a secretary," but nobody saw computers coming back then.

There's no excuse now. Not being able to enter data at a reasonable clip will hold you back. Sure, a few people just have talent and when they're 25 they learn to type 50 wpm with two fingers. That's great for them but very few of you have it; if you think you do then let me ask which musical instrument you play every day? People with talent rarely let it sit idle.

The computer has made life easier with the backspace key, the mouse, and the spell checker. But you still need to be able to type fairly quickly and fairly accurately without looking at the keys. People who can't do that are always turning in late and/or bad work.

This discussion is closed to new replies.