I will get into tape life shortly but first:
Warren,
Light bulbs are ancient as well but we still see their
purpose in life. Note that I say purpose and not
advantage.
For a very small business, CD-RW is fine but a large
network backup operator would spend his life doing a
full backup.
For a Small/medium size, DVD is fine but has serious
draw backs. While they have a long shelf life they are
prone to read/write errors like any optical device. This
may be a device issue or as simple as a scratch. using
DVD to archive data is great because they are burned
and then stored. Rarely handled.
Also for Small /Med: you have the option of DVD or an
inexpensive tape such as a 20/40 Travan. Not a great
tape but it works for a standard rotation of 9 or 18 tapes.
It solves the offsite issue too. And, it is easy to setup for
automated backup when no tech is employed by the
company. Drive and tape cost is within reach of a small
company. Less risk of damaged backup mediawith a
tape compared to DVD is a benifit.
For a server room with 5 or 6 servers, including
Exchange and an SQL server, then DVD is not an
option. Even if they held 9 GB. I doubt they would make
it through a few offsite transfers safely let alone a few
restores. EVERYONE has scratched a CD/DVD on
inserting it to the tray. For this a Tape Loader is the key
regardless of format. DLT etc.
Backups simply provide access to data in a condition
from the past. That is NOT a true Backup Plan for
disaster recovery. In the event of a building burning
down, the clients, billing, books etc. are still available
with offsite storage. Onsite storage I see so often put in
a standard fire safe. Useless too. Even paper will char,
for media you need a media safe.
OK, now the question...sorry about the wait. Most of the
comments here reference a 9 tape rotation. I too use
this as a minimum. With tapes averaging $35 to $45,
with a purchase of 10, that is a whole set for $350 to
$450. I change tapes yearly. Tapes will last 5 years in
my experience based on use, but the drive may stretch
them. heat may damage them. Shelf-life is only part of
it, and then only if they are handled correctly. For less
than $450 a year I can protect the whole company with
tape. I can have it automated and available offsite.
Compared to the cell phone bills now that is very little.
A cost of doing business.
Just an opinion, but this is a great discussion.