Question Locked

Best Raid config given # of disks

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Morning...

I am looking to set up a W2K3 server and am looking for opinions on the best RAID solution give the hardware...HP DL380 G5 w/ 6 146gb drives available. Was thinking just to split into two raid5's.. but will admit I need to learn more..

Would appreciate any thoughts..

9 replies

by parrontto3

I'm still not certain of whether two raid 5s are the way to go vs one raid 1 (2 disks) for os & one raid 5 (3 disks) leaving sixth for spare.. I'm probably overanalyzing...

by peconet tietokoneet

It depends on what YOU want to do with this server.
Doing a RAID5, with 5 disks, will only show three drives (together) under "My computer", so two drives are made for redundancy purposes. Meaning you can have TWO DRIVES go down without losing data.
A RAID5 is better for a server if that is what you are looking for. It would be good for your business because you can HOTSWAP (if you have the option) the drive(s) if it/they went down.

by churdoo

Well we can't tell you the best solution without knowing what exactly the server is doing, however, we can give you a little more general guidance.

In very general terms, certain types of data lend themselves to better performance on certain types of RAID arrays, and I'm only comparing 2 redundant array types, i.e. RAID 1 (or 1+0, 0+1, 10 call it what you want) versus RAID 5.

Binaries, and other sequential r/w files, like O/S files, executables, and logfiles including database logfiles, lend themselves to RAID 1/1+0.

Dynamic or random access files, like database data files and other user data files tend to perform better on RAID 5.

For your DL380, and again we don't know what this server role is, but one example may be to RAID 1 the first to disks giving you about 135GB of RAID1 capacity for O/S, Program Files, and any logfiles including database logfiles. You may or may not split this into multiple NTFS volumes in Disk Mangler (I would, like a 30GB System volume and the rest a separate volume for the rest of your RAID1 stuff). A RAID5 volume accross the remaining 4x disks would yield approx 400GB RAID5 capacity for your database data files, user data, and other dynamic data, and again you may split this into multiple NTFS volumes in Disk Mangler or not.

Your O/S swapfile or paging file really doesn't belong on any redundant volume, but rather than leaving a whole disk out of the mix, many choose the lesser of evils and put the O/S swapfile on a RAID1 volume.

In any redundant RAID, you may only only fail 1 disk at a time. Even if you have a hot spare, if a failure were to occur, the subject array would have to rebuild onto the hot spare before you could afford a second failure.

Hope this is helpful.

by cmiller5400

[i]Disk Mangler[/i]

Hahahahahahahaha I needed that laugh. :D

by seanferd

I glossed right over that, so thanks for pointing it out. :D

Thanks also tho Churdoo for typing that (intentionally or not). :)

Anyone ever have enough problems with Disk Manager that it earns this name? :^0

by unhappyuser

Use two drives to mirror the OS and use the rest as a RAID 5 for your data. I would leave one as a spare so you can quickly replace it if there is a failure.

This configuration may not work if you need more storage space. Can you purchase a couple of smaller drives for the OS so you'll have more drive space for storage?

EMD

This discussion is closed to new replies.