Discussion Locked

[b]What I like and dislike about the new TR site[/b]

0 helpful
314 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Just started to look around and right off the bat see a few things I like and something I HATE.

First, the active post that you are reading is MUCH easier to find. How many times have you opened a link from your subscription in a 200 pluss discussion and then want to see what that person was replying to? Was a bit of a pain to find, but now it is BOLD and DARK Black.

What do I absolutely HATE? The posts that you have read do not show up differently than the ones you have not, so it is hard to tell which you have read and which you have not. [b]Hatehatehate this BUG.[/b]

A dislike is the "NEW" is too close to the color of the posts, so they don't show up very well.

Both of these changes will make discussions less appealing, as it greatly hinders the ability to follow along and stay up.

General feel seems nice. Wonder about the large font and avitar size in the contact lists thought. Seems like making that a little smaller would allow you to see more at a time.

I also wonder about the pushing of "TAGS" over discussions so much. Why?

The pages SEEM to be loading well, but late on a sunday night, the server probably isn't under a lot of strain, huh?

What does everyone else think so far?

314 replies

by jdclyde

Looking around the site, it seems like the discussion community is being downplayed greatly.

Is this the case, or am I just experiencing "growing pains" to the new layout?

The choice of fonts and colors makes the pages listing the discussions hard to read and harder to follow.

by cbalness

I am having a hard time finding discussions, in that it used to be mapped out under general topics, and conversations thereunder...

eg:
miscellaneous, friday yuk

this doesn't seem to be quite as user friendly.

by techexec2

There is still a breakout of discussions by category on the [b]Browse[/b] tab of the [b]Forums[/b] page. When you drill down into a category (e.g. Windows, Networking, etc), the discussions are listed in reverse chronological order of when the discussion was started.

Note: "Miscellaneous" has been renamed to "Off Topic".

by absolutely

Where are "My Discussions"? It's now less convenient to find discussions in which I have recently posted without subscribing.

Verdict: HATE!

Other dislikes:
1) baby blue color scheme with alternating message titles in white/baby blue, but max message level limitation still not fixed

2) commercials more important than messages?
How about moving the commercials and other page clutter from the right side of this page to the emails that notify us of new posts to our subscribed threads? Then at least the max message level could be a bit greater, and less limiting, if you can't eliminate the limitation. I promise, I'll still follow the links - to the advertisers selling something [b]I want![/b]

by apotheon

I don't think their business model would survive removing the advertisement column from the discussion pages, and that column is also used for stuff I would like to keep handy anyway. For instance, I love the new Recommended/Contacts/Updates block. That's an excellent use of space.

I do agree that additional width, in part to increase the "max depth" level, would be good. I think the best way to get that, though, is to either remove the thin floating "Hot Spot" bar on the right-hand side or somehow integrate it with the width of the rest of the page content. Maybe a narrow horizontal band across the top somewhere, if it absolutely [b]must[/b] be prominent and present. If not, just chuck the damned thing. Getting it out of the width of the page would allow the main content area to be widened and, where it is now, I just ignore the thing anyway.

by jaqui

"TechRepublic requires javascript for most site functionality. If you are seeing this message, please check your browser settings and enable javascript."

bad, very very bad.

by jdclyde

it really is surprising to still see this. :(

Was REAL cool over the weekend! Dell has a comercial for Servers with pre-installed Linux. While the experienced user would wipe and reload, think how this can help get new users pulled in if it is now an off-the-shelf option?

by danlm

We are looking at those servers right now.
And no, that was nock at susie. It's just not what management wants right at the moment.

Dan

by dawgit

HP, IBM, FSC, Thomas Kern, and, and, and....
maybe I just spolied over here...
It's been that way for a while. (and the costs are amazingly lower, w/o all the MS Licencing load)

by shellbot

dunno guys..
ok, i like the cleaner look..but maybe its too clean?

-I don't like browsing by tags..
-I want to see a list of My Discusions..not
a list of each post i've read recently. (maybe i'm clicking on the wrong thing??)
-In the discussions list (hot, new etc) the font is a wee bit large or soemthing..dunno..just looks off..

i suppose it will take a while to get used to..its not all bad guys..but for us creatures of habit its a bit bewildering..(ok, maybe thats just me)

by jdclyde

:p

The discussions really seem to have taken a back seat. Sad. Don't I look at their pretty ads on the pages, providing them lots of hit?

I even buy books now and then!

But it is the discussions that bring me back. Would be a shame if this broke my addiction.

by shellbot

ok..if its just me then :(

ya, if we complain enough, will they sort it out though?

i don't want my addiction broken. most of my days are just not so good lately, and its nice to come on an whine, or share with others..or just feel better because others are having a sh1t day as well..

by jdclyde

did they add another layer before the "max level"?

Haven't seen it yet, but wonder if they fixed having to follow a thread back a level and post a reply to that to add your reply in! How hard is it to just reply and have it throw the reply at the end on the max level?

by dawgit

Yup, I can hear the sound of busy tweeking all the way over here. :0
(good little TR elves, ;) now you keep up the work, ok?) :p

by jdclyde

No fuctionality or changed screen colors and layout mean anything to me if it means giving up the discussions in the manner we have been using them.

Sure, I have been working on getting more and more into the technical discussions (it was a goal of mine, that has been going well), but that was in ADDITION to the personal discussions, not instead of.

Things I need is to be able to find EASILY are:

1) Posts by my contacts.
2) Know which posts I have read and which ones I have not read.
3) "NEW" posts NEED to jump out more.

If I get these three, it is happy dance time! But not until.

by tig2

I have been trying to figure out what I have read and not read.

I think that they lost some of the user experience with the change. *sigh*

by gadgetgirl

jd, I'm in agreement with you for the most part.

This is a lot less intuitive than it used to be; in total honesty, if I'd just found the site now, I don't think I'd have had the time or patience to hang around and "learn" it.

Yes, it's a nice, bright, clean feel, and I understand why TR PTB has gone primarily for blue (W3C accreds) but for those of us with normal-ish site, it's not that easily readable. Font size seems small (and yes, my reading vision is still perfect, it's double decker buses in the distance I have trouble with!) but the prime fault here is the same colour being used for the "NEW" posts in the thread.

Like the idea of knowing which post you're reading on a thread; but agreeing again with jd (make the most of it, babz!) unless I remember the title, I don't know which posts I've read....

Took me a while to find the Water Cooler, too, but I remembered the hint Jay gave last week, so got there within about 10 mins.

Number of posts to a thread is no longer available until you get into the thread; and then you may find one post you haven't read.... some of us leave the thorough reading until it's worthwhile...and use the print button which I'm relieved to see still working.

Now. Sorry in advance, but which BRIGHT SPARK took the help files off the site??

I've been trying to chance my pm address since May, (intermittently, I admit, but when time allows, I was re-trying) and at least prior to the site change, there where some help files that I was working my way through. Now they've gone. Eh? Do I have to plague Jay/Smorty/Doug to change it for me?? (yes, it's the email addy currently in use bit...)

Like the idea of seeing who's online when I'm posting! Love that one! 10/10 from me on that.

I STILL think it's a good idea for SOMEONE from TR to check these auto links that decide the Hot Topics - then you'd stop promoting the spammers....... I understand why it's an automated process, guys, but surely considering the number of times this has happened, or you've had obscenities through it on the home page, I would have thought you'd have put a process of checking into place by now.

Search funtion seems good - even if it doesn't understand my sense of humour!

Oh, and if you're using timed posts, I'd suggest putting somewhere on the site which time you're using You have more than one timezone over there! S'not fair! It's confusing - this is a world wide site! (remember my chronological challenge, please. If I'm at home, I can have my world clock on another tab, but at work we're still IE )

All in all, I think the site is brighter, but you may want to rethink some of the discussion side of things before it's too late for reversion, and you start leaking members like a colander.

I know there were other things, but brain is non-funtional again today (home - sick again, and totally fed up)[oh, that might just explain my presence for the last 2 days all over the new site design like a rash, btw]

Finally - - -and you knew this was coming - - -

WHERE MY SPOOLCHEEKER???

even more importantly - - - - - - - -

[B] WHERE ARE THE EXTRA EMOTICONS???? [/B]

:D

GG

Edit: remembered something - don't we have any way of finding out posts made/threads started stats anymore?

by jdclyde

Number of new posts IS important, because it lets you know if you need to bother loading that page vs going somewhere else.

Hope your feeling better, my dear.

:x

by tig2

JD, that hasn't changed. In order to post a reply you have to go back to the tail.

Oh well.

by jdclyde

The only difference now is the notice to inform someone that they have reached it does not stand out because the black text blends in with everything else.

Good thing this isn't THAT big a deal, and surely not a deal breaker.

by jdclyde

[i]"The Connection has timed out
The server at ad.doubleclick.net is taking too long to respond"
[/i]

Got this message more than once in the blank space to the right were there is suppose to be an ad.

Back when we were getting a lot of timed out errors, I wondered aloud at that point how much it had to do with waiting to load from third party sites.

by tony hopkinson

never arrived !
Perhaps I should have been more complementary!
LOL

Going to reserve judgment on the usability 'til I've got used to it.

A few points though
A lot of real estate for navigation.

A filter for questions and discussions would be nice.

After running around panicing about my blog there it is in all it's glory ! Huh !

Some idea of activity on the item would be nice.

My .. recent etc seem to be listing by post not topic, so repeating. Given the amount of space you've devoted to each item, this is annoying.

I wsn't at all happy with your attempt to glean company name and contact details either, one hopes that sort of thing won't become a habit.

by tig2

Just like "3 Day Walker" isn't a city. I was pretty put off by the REQUIREMENT that I provide a street address. I finally provided the information that I was comfortable with. Good luck to anyone trying to find 000 Main St!

The ability to obscure personal information was one of the good things...

by techexec2

This preoccupation with truthfully answering every question is overrated. We were all taught it as little boys and little girls and it still haunts many of us.

I know EXACTLY what you're talking about Tigger.

There's an old cynical saying that covers this well: [i]Ask me no questions and I'll tell you no lies.[/i] Good advice for adults (but not to be taught to children).

My aging mother is still too timid to just cut off the telesales callers who bug her at her home at her dinner time. I'm WAY over that and don't even break stride anymore. Wasn't always that way.

You did the right thing.

by tony hopkinson

I don't consider the opportunity to recieve better targetted spam a suitable payment.

I'm thinking a TR mug per letter, Great Britain as a location should mean I always have one available and that the dishwasher is fully utilised.

Oh I forget us types from the mother country don't get anything off TR do we ?

More seriously I cannot see any value at all that I accrue from this site by handing out that sort of personal information, not to mention the problems with construing that somehow my opinions on anything were in any way representive of my employer's.

by onbliss

My first impression about the "Forums" tab was that the old user interface was better than the current one.

The "Browse by Tag" box that appears on the right could have been placed below to get more reading real estate.

The whole box with the user name, job role, location, member since with the "recommended", "my updates" tab does not do much for me.

Learning new navigation is fine, by large fonts and graphics seem to have occurpied the screen real estate.

It definitely delayed my posting this weekend . Kind of drove me way :-( .

by nicknielsen

I would prefer to have more horizontal real estate devoted to the thread.

* I know who I am and have seen the recommendations at the Front Door; if I want to check them out, I already have.
* If I'm in a thread, I'm not usually interested in browsing messages by tags; I'll use a separate tab for that from the Forums door
* If there has to be an advert on the thread page, mount it horizontally between the page header and the message.

I do like the lighter appearance and have the same problems everybody else does finding new posts. As for following what I've already read, I almost always Print the thread, so it only takes half a sec to realize that I've already been there.

by lowlands

The general "look" is ok. And maybe I haven't gotten around on the site too much yet to totally understand it. But...

I am not sure why I can't view questions seperately from discussions.

The tags thing, looks to me like TR wants to be a little too much Web v2. Kind of like youtube, metacafe, flickr or any of those post your video/picture sites.

I'll give it a while, but I can see myself drifting away from TR

by tink!

I like the workspace and the new look, but I want to have the old My Discussions page too. I used that screen [b][i]all the time[/b][/i] because the best part was that it showed the number of posts, so you could easily tell which ones had new posts [b]without having to click on it![/b]

Tink

by alangeek

Ok, so I'm the only one that uses it, but it was so nice that you had finally gotten the "Next page" function fixed again so that it didn't go off to a Dice.com ad, and even better yet, set it so that it would work on the photo pages too!

And now, suddenly, no next page function at all. Hopefully, this will just be one of the lower-priority things that will be coming, I just need to be patient.

The other thing I notice is missing is the "path" thingie at the top of the discussion pages that show where you are in the TR structure. Being able to back out to a particular level is much easier than having to go back to the main tab and work your way in again. Hopefully this will also be coming soon.

Otherwise, so far so good. I mostly come in via links in the newsletters, so I don't use the front door or other structures so much, but I do see that articles now display much better in Opera 9 than before, which the Opera community had dismissed as being non-compliant coding on TR's part. Whatever the reason, it looks better now. The highlighting of the current post is WAY better than before.

As far as the "NEW!" stickers, red definitely stood out much better. If that's not going to change, another approach might be to put a flag in a single column either at the left or right side of the thread view so it would be easier to find. Having them just tacked on the end of the posting title makes them harder to find than always having them in a specific place.

Oh, yeah, the time zone thing really ought to be fixed so that everyone sees times relative to their time zone. Listing everything as Pacific is just kinda weird.

-Alan

by alangeek

Quite cute guys, nice joke. "Next page" from any post in this discussion goes to my post about "Next page". But really, will this be changed? If not, I'll live with it, but it would be nice to have. It still works properly on the photo pages, which is very nice.

Thanks,
-Alan

by mickster269

The "My Discussions" page was rather handy- I could pop in, see if there was anything new to the threads I had commented on, and pop out.

Now, I gotta dig around and try and see if there is anything new added.

by tig2

You only have to deal with ID theft one time and it changes you completely. I am VERY careful with my personal information and likely always will be.

Pity about the world we live in that one must be so careful.

The terrible thing is that I was taught to answer truthfully. I have had to add my own caveat- unless the information is going to an online resource. I draw the line there.

*sigh*

by lowlands

For me there seems to be no added value to providing a lot of personal information on this website. Not to me at least, it just feels like one of these things where you end up with having your personal info sold to who knows how many marketeers.

I believe that for this site I was actually pretty honest for a change, hmmm, must have had a lapse in judgement the day I signed up :)

by danlm

I am doing a heck of a lot of research right now for work, and I have been using this place pretty heavily for some of it. I think I'm going to be pounding on their new search to see if I can find hits(white papers, discussions, and q/a) on any given topic.

I like the personal discussions, but the reason I first started coming here was the technical information this site contains. Lol, and right now I need all the reference material I can get my hands on.

Dan

by senior program analyst

It appears some things have changed in this area of your website.
I placed a question out there and have recieved an answer. I did mark one of the answers as being of help (thumbs up). However are you not doing any point awards now?
Also; How do I close the question now that I have an answer - no need to bother others who are looking to help when I have an answer already. I dont mind leaving he question / answers so that others can learn, but it would be good to mark the question as to no further replys needed or simular - especially if I want to take it off my notifications.

by dr dij

Is this because I am a prehistorical relic of the last century? (joined in 1999)

even tried one of the built in pix, no change.

by tig2

This may help:
Go to your profile. Edit it to add content to each subsection- even if that edit is to add the word "test". Clear your cache. Now try adding an avatar.

Let me know if this works. There are others that have struggled with this.

Good Luck!

by dr dij

it worked! Thank you!
(I never would have imagined software that would have a bug like that!)

Just wait till I find that unguessable photo to use as an avatar :)

From the Leopards of Africa, a hearty Thank You! (ok , I get a little too involved when watching those shows)

by debuggist

The workaround is to add text to your biography. It could take as little as one character.

by dawgit

Is there some way to put a location in, when we're not in the US, Somehow? (as in Germany, folks) ?:|

by tink!

blech! Still don't like how we have to read each message one by one (unless you hit print but then you can't tell which one's you've read although it sounds like the new site is not showing that anyway...whew..take deep breath)

Would still love to see expandable threads where you just click expand or collapse (+ or -) to see or not see all the replies to a post. Rather than Next, Next, Next, Next....

Tink

by emar1000

see a different format of the threads myself as well. This isnt really bad but it isnt the most user friendly either. I personally like the format of the php message boards. Lets go by the 3 click rule. It is much easier and faster to scroll through the thread than clicking a dozen times for replies and waiting for it to load. Just my 2 cents worth.

by curlergirl

Maybe I'm just having a negative day, but I just DON'T LIKE IT AT ALL! I feel like I'm lost in a maze of tags. I feel like I'm being boxed in and constrained by the tags that happen to be put on people's posts - how do they get there anyway? Does the poster specify them? Anway, I just DON'T like it. My mind is too linear. I want to find a topic and follow it to the end. When I go to "Off Topic" I want to see only Off Topic things, not something someone posted about SQL that somehow got a tag of "off topic." Off whose topic?

I'm verra dis-appointed.

by mickster269

It's all part of the "Patriot Act".

TR needs to know exactly which thread knows what other thread, and how they interact.

"New World Order" and all that. I blame it on Dick Cheney, Haliburton, and jdclyde.

by techexec2

NOW you've done it!!!

You would have gotten away with it if you had only mentioned "Patriot Act", "New World Order", "Cheney", and "Halliburton" in a single post. Adding "jdclyde" puts you over the limit and the NSA human analysts will be on you now! :0

:^0

by curlergirl

I refuse to use tags, read tags, write tags, or have any functional relationship with tags. To me, tags should be neither seen nor heard. They will not be served at my table nor welcome in my home. Tags are to be banished from my kingdom, as they are godless and blasphemous. :-}

by sgt_shultz

i miss the old q & a and the points. sure the points were good for nothing but it was fun to rack 'em up. i find the new layout confusing and hard to use. none of the old bugs have been fixed and now we have lots of new ones. sheesh. the only think i like that is new layout is that i can edit my posts when i fat finger. too bad. good bye tech republic it was fun for a while there...this new layout just encourages off topic rants imho. i can get those anyday anywhere...

by lowlands

It turns out you can filter by discussion and questions after all. Granted, it is not all to handy or obvious but it works.

In both Hot Threads and New threads, select view all, and all of a sudden a little filter selection pops up. You can only filter either Hot or New threads that way (not all threads), but it's better than nothing.

by tig2

You can also filter when you are in a "tag" or topic. From the door, go to the fourth tab- called "Browse". Select a "Tag". Once the page for that tag opens, over the box with your avatar, you will see the same filter buttons.

It really isn't so bad once you are accustomed to it.

I've also seen posts about questions being more difficult to navigate through because you have to open each post. Use the handy "print" button to lay out all responses. That way you can know if your fix has been suggested or if you have something to add to someone elses post. I keep a tab for discussions in print layout with the live discussion in a seperate tab so that I can post without hitting "next" a hundred times.

by stress junkie

I agree with you. I think the changes are okay. I finally got something that I had lobbied for, a way to distinguish the post that you are reading from the others in the list. I know that the old site had grey titles in the current post but it didn't help me. Now the post that you are reading is bold black and has a pink background. I'm very happy with that. It would be better if it had a crimson background and maybe white letters in the
title, or maybe a purple background with yellow letters, or even ... Oh, forget it. Anyway, the black on pink is much better than the old way.

I like having the steps to enter a post laid out in step by step format. I didn't know that you entered a title before you write the body of the post. I had been doing it wrong at least half of the time. :D

One problem that I'm having is that when I'm typing a post the right side of the window to type into is overlaid by the box that has my name and other information. I'd say that at least 4 characters are covered by this box so I can't see exactly what I'm typing on the right side until I post it and read it.

Now I've noticed that posts have the date and TIME that they were initially posted and the date and time of the last edit. Very nice.

I think that most of the gripes are just because people don't like change. Ever.

by lowlands

That will get you the discussions or question that have the specific tag.

O well, I'll get used to it all.

by gralfus

Once I found what used to be Discussions, I tried to reply to this posting and it made me re-register with TR and demanded a host of information from me, even though my icon and name were already showing.

The layout is non-intuitive, the read discussions are not marked as such, changing the names of the places we are used to going was stupid.

I'm going to wait a month and check back it to see if any of this has been fixed. If not, I'll find another hangout. I guess they figure change for the sake of change was good. They were wrong.

by tig2

Doug mentioned that they have a bug logged for it. When we did the "Pink Ribbon Brigade" it came up often and we discovered the fix through the good work of NickNielsen and lowlands.

Glad to see you in living colour!

by jdclyde

You have Linux servers advertised on TV "over there"? Cool. This was the one and only time I have seen it on the tube.

by av .

But it has a ways to go with usability. When I get to the homepage, I click on forums, but that doesn't show you anything but the new and hot threads. The only way to get to a forum that I can see is to search for it. A list of the actual forums available would be helpful on the page.

If I'm looking for the miscellaneous forum, and search under off-topic, I'm not sure that I'm really seeing all of the miscellaneous/off-topic or only those threads that were tagged off-topic. Personally, I've never tagged, so will it pick up my old posts or not? I don't know.

I think tags are useful as a way to focus in on a certain subject, but the page only shows the most popular tags and doesn't show a way to look at the rest of the tags. Curiously JD, you have a popular tag under off-topic. Hmm. You must have been an obsessive tagger. :D

If I compare the old site to the new, I'd have to say the one thing I miss is the ability to access everything you wanted with one click from the home page. One click and you were there. Yes, the old TR looked somewhat rudimentary from a visual standpoint, but it was intuitive and useful.

I think this interface can be even better if TR will incorporate that easy functionality into it.

by tig2

From the forums "door" you should see a four tabbed box that will show you "new", "hot", "posts from contacts", and "browse". I use "posts from contacts" mostly.

The only time that you ever were asked to tag in the old world was when you started a post. Makes you think that JD needs a life???

The ability to navigate is still there... we still need to find the best way. They promise that tweaks are coming... but they may not do everything that we want.

Still trying to assemble that FAQ- but have a start in Nick's thread about double posts.

by av .

Thanks Tigger! Now I know for sure I've definitely been on the computer too long, but I know for sure JD holds the record. :D

I'm sure they'll do a good job tweaking the site. I know we'll never get rid of the MAX level has been reached though. Oh well.

Looking forward to FAQs. I'll check out Nick's thread.

AV

by delbertpgh

If I look at "my discussions", I see a list of everything I have posted... and if I posted ten times to one discussion, there are ten items in the list. What's that good for? Nothing. If I've been in ten discussions, and have a hundred items posted, there are a hundred entries in the list... which I have to sift through to find my ten discussions. I notice that all the items within a discussion have got the same title. Looks like your programmer didn't think they were useful, either.

by problemsolversolutionseeker

This is not what I asked for.

I paid how much for this.

Oh my, I'll never get anything done using this.

I sho like the old way better.

Nobody told me this was coming.

Oh, it that what all of the meetings were about.

by tig2

It's just change.

All end users hate change.

Next week they will hate something else.

Oh D@mn! Does this mean my career is over???

Wait... Breathe.

It's just change.

All end users HATE change...

by jdclyde

is good.

Bad change is bad.

I do see more people looking FOR bad than good as a rule though.

Two things is all I ask for.

1) fix font on "posts by my contacts"
2) fix showing read vs unread posts.

Anything beyond that is just bonus.

Life? Why would I need a life? I have TR! :D

by apotheon

Two things that have been discarded with the new design that I'd like to see brought back:

1. Please differentiate discussion posts that have already been read from those that have not (I'm guessing this would have something to do with an a:visited CSS property). Without that, it will be far more difficult to keep track of what we have or have not seen in a discussion, which will in turn be a disincentive for those of us who use the dicussion forum to come to TR.

2. I'd like to see the asterisks by the word "NEW" reappear, or something similarly unique on the page. Something I habitually use for discussion navigation here is the search bar in Firefox, with [b]*new*[/b] as the search term, so that I can jump forward and backward through the list of recent posts. Now that there aren't any asterisks around the word "NEW", that doesn't work any longer, which makes keeping up with new material somewhat more of a hassle.

Otherwise, I quite like the new design. If only the max discussion depth had been increased, and the above two introduced problems were fixed, it'd be about perfect.

by regulus

On several occasions I have wanted to directly contact the editor and there was no availalbe link. These were issues concerning lack of printable version, printable version was not available or other issues that did not relate directly to the content of the article.

How about a link to Editor / Administration where we could directly voice such issues?

And, Yes, you're doing a 99% good job. And thank you for that.

Dave

by tig2

If there is something that you need to feedback on, please post a question in the feedback tag and define the problem. The TR PTB seem to watch for feedback there and you WILL get a response.

Other option- go to the bottom of each page and you will find a handy "Send us your feedback" button.

This isn't a new functionality but brings an existing functionality to the surface.

Hope you keep finding good things about the site! If you find a good tip that will help someone else, please post to Nick's thread on Double Posts.

by jdclyde

One thing that is nice that they fixed was the way the page would load. You would get content and then at the last second everything would shift to make room for the ads. Was VERY annoying.

I don't mind the ads, provided they load quickly. Some of the very animated ones always make me go "hmmmmmm".

The "Hot Spot" bar has up to this day never had anything in it I have cared about, so it has always been a complete waste of space to me (but if it generates lots of revenue, it doesn't really bother me).

by jdclyde

Notice that all the wasted grey space around the page is gone! Woo Woo! :D

With that gone, it really has reclaimed a lot of real estate.

by jdclyde

The layout is nice, and it is GREAT that they have the number of posts to a discussion combined.

It still only goes back one day, instead of the 90 daze.

Sure, claim this is due to the reset, but how do you account for Sunday not being listed? B-)

Copy that format to use for the "Posts by my contacts" as it is much more readable than the current layout.

by gadgetgirl

are you putting your titles in bold all by yourself, or are you getting preferential treatment on todays posts??? !!! :p

If it's you, that was a damn good idea, babz! I can follow you wherever you go, now....

:D

GG

by jdclyde

You know I will do anything go get your attention, my love! :x

Besides, as I was intentionally trying to find GOOD things, I figured it should stand apart from the complaining about what I DON'T like.

I am not that hard to satisfy. Just give me everything I want and there won't be any trouble! B-) ]:)

:x

by onbliss

I am willing to bet a dollar that someday, within 1 year, Jd will join TR in the capacity of employee or consultant or Public Relations personnel. :-)

by wayne m.

In general, the new lay out works for me. I have a couple of minor annoyances that might be worth consideration.

After logging in, take me to the Home page not my Profile. This just adds an unnecessary hop. Might also consider adding a user name and password entry on the home page in lieu of a link to a log in screen. This further reduces the number of clicks to get to the active part of the site.

The new items on the top of pages dynamically rotate though you can click on the numbered bubbles to browse through the summaries. It might be better to include them either as a static list in their current location, or add them as the default tab is the section below with Community Recommends and Hot Topics.

Change the log in default for the remember my user name check box. Someone who uses this option never has to see it again, but for those of us who do not, we are forced to uncheck it every time we log in.

I do like the return of the Articles tab and I think the over all navigation of the site has improved.

by faradhi

I do not see a problem with the new layout. I might even like it once I get a chance to use it. I can however understand others frustraton or apprenhension. I have not been using these message boards for as long as some of the others. I imagine that I will have a little easier transition because I could never navigate around the old site very well.

I am sure that this is considered minor. However, as my workload has increased considerably lately, I can no longer actively monitor New Discussions and Posts. My solution in the old site was to use RSS feed on my Google home page. None of the RSS feeds are updating. Has this been eliminated? Is there a new link to the RSS feed?

Oh well.

So far I like the look and feel. I will try to keep up the best I can as time permits.

Oh Yeah, JD, I am pulling for your Tigers. They finished the season rough but look like they are turning it back around again. I hope they kick the snot out of the A's.

-Bryan

by jdclyde

but it has arived. You know how it is always the person on the elevator that SAYS something about a fart is always the one who let it fly?

http://tinyurl.com/pyksl

Vindicated at last! Sweet vengance is MINE! ]:)

B-)

by gsquared

On the blogs tab (and possibly elsewhere, but I've mainly noticed it on the blogs tab), words from the actual blog articles are being crunched together when they span a line-break. I'm seeing a lot of "forthe" and "thenew" and stuff like that.

It's a mild distraction.

My main complaint about TR discussions is, and always has been, that on a long discussion with a lot of replies and threads, it's hard to tell where you are in the discussion without a lot of scrolling up and down.

If all you do is hit "Next", you run into problems with, "is this a reply to the one I just read, or a reply to something earlier in the thread, or a reply to the original post?"

Maybe I'm missing something, but I don't see a way in the post I'm reading to tell what it's a reply to, if where it is in the tree-view is off the bottom of the screen.

I can think of several layouts, common to many discussion forums, that work better and are easier to follow.

If I'm missing something in how TR displays the data, please, someone let me know.

by nicknielsen

It's a little extra work, but the posts are numbered and indented so you can see who is replying to what.

It adds a step or two when you want to reply (return to standard display tab, scroll/search to the desired post), but eliminates all that farging waiting around for pages to load when you click Next.

Edit: After you submit, return to the Print display and refresh the page to view your post in context.

by jdclyde

never make something you enjoy "work", or it takes away a lot of the enjoyment.

Besides, it is one thing for a nutcase member to say and do what I do, quite another for an employee! :0

:D B-)

by onbliss

...what you are saying is....if they offer you will not say an emphatic "No" :-)

by techexec2

This was not a new feature, not a bug, and undesirable.

edit: Removed to avoid encouraging seagulls and trolls.

by jaqui

seems the new layout isn't "friendly" to any screen resolution below 1280x1024

currently viewing at 1024x768 and getting left and right scrolling on every single page.

by cg it

Something needed to be done with Q&A. It was a farce. Discussions on the other hand became literally discussion on everything from World Politics and Religion to why you can't stop eating potato chips. I didn't see many discussions relating to IT Tech except by George or other TechRepublic employees. I don't have time to to get into discussions about lays potato chips or the democrate or republican political parties.

I like the idea of no points with Q&A. There were to many who had to much time on their hands thinking up wild senarios that really had no answer to. Legitimate questions were few and far between.

I like suggesting stuff to people who have legitimate question but don't have time to waste on the what if or lets say questions.

Now if this was an Elder Scrolls forum....

I used TechRepublic like I use all the other boards. To keep abreast of whats going on in the IT world without having to buy a damn subscription to some magazine.

Glad Q&A is gone.