Question Locked

Can the PING command bring down routers

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have been using PING for a very long time and I never heard this before and just want to verify what I am thinking is correct.

At my job I used to use PING however back in November our parent company decided to change from one VPN service to another (Cisco). Here in my office, a Cisco Pix 501 was installed. Ever since it was installed I have not been able to use the PING or Tracert commands. I would get request timed out. When I asked the person in our parent company (who knows nothing about networks or computers)to ask the people who installed the router why I can not PING, he came back to me and asked why do I want to PING, he told me that PING has been linked to bringing down routers and their might be a ICMP filter to block it. I have never heard of PING bringing down routers and would like to verify that what this guy is saying is incorrect. Who is right?

4 replies

by p.j.hutchison

You need masses and masses of pings from multiple computers to bring a router down. Its a DoS (Denial of Service) attack method but for infrequent pings, its should be fine.
The router is most likely configured to ignore ICMP messages (protocol used for PING) and needs turning on.

by luv2bike2

Thank you P.J. I kind of thought that would be the answer however i just wanted to make sure.

I don't believe there is an alternate command out there that could be used to troubleshoot ... parent company at this time will not allow the use of PING and traceroute which is very fustrating.

Thanks,

by jc2it

If you are trying to ping across the Internet then the parent company has a good policy not to allow it. However, if you are only using ping on your intranet then there should not be a security issue (DoS).

We use ping internally across our private WAN, but do not allow incoming pings via our Internet link.

To get this changed is probably not worth your effort though.

You are on the right track to look for alternatives. These will probably depend upon the actual port you need to connect to.

One thing I will use is telnet. You can telnet to ports other than 23. If you are troubleshooting email then telnet to port 25 or 110 to see if you can get a connection. This also works for ftp on port 21 and to some degree on secured versions of these ports. Google it, I am not the first one to use this.

This discussion is closed to new replies.