Question Locked

Client can't ping server intermittently

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hi, All

I have a client running a Windows Server 2003 Enterprise Edition SP2. There are 4 Windows XP Pro SP3 clients.

A new accounting application upgrade now requires ICMP communication between clients and servers. This is how this issue was discovered, although I suspect it has been going on for some time.

We are having some really weird issues where ICMP communication is intermittent. This is causing the accounting application to behave strangely.

If I run a ping command from the client to the server, sometimes the server will reply and other times the request will time out. Note that this behavior applies not only to pinging the FQDN, but also the server's IP address. Mapped drives, network shares, Exchange, Internet, etc works without interruption.

I have tried running ipconfig /release, deleting Host A DNS records and reverse pointers from the DNS server and deleting DHCP leases, then running ipconfig /flushdns on the client and then ipconfig /renew. Most of the time this temporarily fixes the issue, but not always. And eventually, the client is unable to ping the server again. Sometimes the client will be able to ping the server without requiring the steps above to be performed.

When this behavior occurs, it does not usually affect all PCs at the same time.

My client has several small switches in their environment. I have tried bypassing all those switches by connecting one of the clients directly to the main router, but this did not help. I tried replacing that main router, did not help.

I'm really at a lost as to what is causing this. Any suggestions?

7 replies

by skdtech

May be interpreting the application's activity as a DoS attack and blocking access to the port? May need to reconfigure ping intervals of the application or setup an exception for the traffic on the server to prevent future problems.

by waynek

The only security software installed on this server is ClamWin Antivirus.

The Windows Firewall/ICS service is stopped and disabled.

by cmiller5400

How is ICMP involved in this? ICMP is an error messaging protocol, not a transport protocol.

Download a copy of Wireshark (free sniffer) http://www.wireshark.org/ and find out where things are falling off the map.

by waynek

ICMP Ping works by sending ICMP ?echo request? packets to the target host and listening for ICMP ?echo response? replies, right?

I don't fully understand myself exactly why the accounting app requires this, but without it working properly when the application performs a system verification check which it does when it is first launched, that check fails and the program cannot run.

I will try out Wireshark and let you know what results come from that.

by waynek

Can you explain how that works? Do I need to run it from the client or the server?

by waynek

Strangely it seems from the Wireshark results that every ping request has a reply from the server.

Why isn't this true when I ping from the command prompt?

Any further suggestions anyone?

This discussion is closed to new replies.