Discussion Locked

CNET's 10 facts you should know about outsourcing?

0 helpful
2 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Has anyone seen this article on CNET?

http://news.com.com/Offshoring%3A+An+issue+that+defies+easy+answers/2009-1022_3-5427940.html?part=rss&tag=5427940&subj=news.1022.20

I think it has some valid point regarding outsourcing and America's reinvestment into technology under Bush. Did not see anything that touched Former Pres Clinton's record.

Thoughts?

2 replies

by maxwell edison

.
When time allows, I'll read (and perhaps comment on) the entire article, but there's one interesting fact we never hear discussed. I'll put this "fact" in the form of a question in case anyone wants to take up my challenge and tries to answer it.

For every technology job "outsourced" FROM the USA, how many technology jobs are "insourced" INTO the USA? (Or just jobs in general.)

The USA does indeed carry a deficit when it comes to the trade of goods with other nations, but when it comes to the trade of jobs, does the USA have a deficit or a surplus? And I'm not talking about people from other nations coming to the USA to fill a job, but rather a task, a project, etc. sent to the USA to be worked on by an American worker.

Any reasonable discussion of one can't be complete without looking at the other.

Does anyone know the answer?

by jamesrl

Certainly in the early days of NAFTA when it was just the US and Canada, there were some adjustments. Canadians noticed some jobs were lost to the US due to consolidations, usually in the heavy manufacturing industries. We also lost jobs in areas like steel making, where some of our smaller less efficient operations couldn't compete with the larger US firms. Of course, if we hadn't done NAFTA, they might have gone anyway, as the competition came from the east.

I also know that Canada gained a few jobs in some sectors from the US, particularly in high tech, but also in some areas like the movie industry, call centres and other areas.

I don't know that there are any known answers here. You can compare the job rates in different countries and look at their trade. Everyone in California complains about movie making in Canada, and how it is taking away their livlihood, but if you looked at the profits that US studios make when their movies are shown in Canada, I'm pretty certain you would find that its higher than the business we take away when a studio movies are shot in Canada.

Tom Daschle(Dem Senator) is currently forcefully blocking the importation of Canadian Beef into the US because of 1 Canadian cow with BSE. This despite the fact that the US(and Canada) import Kobe beef from Japan, which has had 3 cases. He thinks he is helping the US cattle industry. In reality, the Canadian and US markets are(were) very integrated and dependant on each other. US farmers are hurting for breeding stock, and Canadians don't have enough meat packing capacity to deal with all the cattle they aren't shipping south.

Its never a simple answer.

James

This discussion is closed to new replies.