Question Locked

Connecting Windows Vista to another router port = no network

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have several computers (Windows XP, and Ubuntu Linux) connected to the ports of a Linksys WRT54G router. I have to play musical chairs with the router port connections when I add a laptop, but I've never had a problem connecting to the Internet. Windows XP could be on router port 1 today, and router port 4 tomorrow and everything works well. Linux could be on router port 3 today and on router port 2 tomorrow, and everything works fine. Of course I have to do a complete shutdown of the operating systems before I switch ports, but that's par for the course. Anyway, along comes a Windows Vista Home Premium machine. It is connected to router port 1 today, and accesses the Internet fine; it is on router port 2 tomorrow and the OS claims a network cable failure and no Internet. I put Vista back on router port 1 and it's happy again.

The router ports are all good because Windows XP and Linux access them flawlessly, the Vista ethernet cable is good because it works well on router port 1.

Does anyone have a clue what's going on?

Thanks,

John

5 replies

by cg it

this question begs the question of

"why are you playing musical chairs with the router LAN ports? "

That old adage " if it aint' broke, don't mess with it" seems appropriate

by j.hom.1

All the router ports are used either by desktop machines or network printers. When we connect our laptops, we have to disconnect something. I would love to get a switch (or even a hub), but money is tight right now.

by cg it

4 ports + uplink port at $25.00 USD
+ shipping and tax would solve the problem.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16833122005

http://shop3.frys.com/category/Outpost/Networkingtab/Wired+Networking+Hardware/Desktop+Switches?accipterAreaString=

spend the lunch $$ on a switch....save the hassle.

on the switch side of things, switches are smart. they remember what host is on what switch port usually by mac address. when you start switching around hosts on ports, the switch must relearn what host is on what port. Though the time that the switch takes in learning and modifying it's tables is really short, sometimes the switch "runs on the mumbo" you'll then see some problems like you have seen where the switch port doesn't work until you put the right host on the right switch port. managed switches are like this. Especially if there is port security enabled. only those hosts assigned to the port can connect. With Cisco port security, usually the port is turned off if the wrong host connects to it.

by j.hom.1

Thanks for the help. Placing a switch between Vista and the router solved the problem.

This discussion is closed to new replies.