Discussion Locked

Defrag on Large HW RAID-5 Volumes

0 helpful
2 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

What benefit would defragging a 100+GB volume that is stored on an external hardware managed RAID-5 disk system that is online 24/7/365?

I understand how defrag would help single physical disks and RAID-1 configurations, but how could it possiblyhelp multiple drive/head configuraitons, since this is invisible to the O/S.

2 replies

by dbesenho

we had a scenario on a raid-5 where it went down, and because the drive was so fragmented, it took several HOURS to come back up. we scheduled some down-time over the weekend, ran defrag (which ran for 9 hours!), and reboot took 15 minutes. that'sthe only reason i can think of.

by greg hayes/raxco software

Regardless of the underlying disk technology being used (IDE, SCSI, RAIDx), the file system sees things in terms of LOGICAL clusters. Each and every partition starts at LOGICAL cluster 0 and goes for nnn clusters. Defragmenters work at the file system level - at the logical cluster level - and ensure that a file is LOGICALLY contiguous. If a file is LOGICALLY contiguous, then only 1 LOGICAL request has to be made to retrieve the file - that is where the performance benefit is achieved. Where that file actually ends up on the hard drive (which platter of which hard drive) is unknown. Even if a file is LOGICALLY contiguous, it may or may not be PHYSICALLY contiguous on the hard drive.

- Greg/Raxco Software

Disclaimer: I work for Raxco Software, the maker of PerfectDisk - a commercial defrag utility, as a systems engineer in the support department.

This discussion is closed to new replies.