Discussion Locked

Discussions are out of control!

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I know this is relatively overdone but a few months ago people were complaining (myself included)about the number of questions dumped into the Discussion forum.
Today I decided to look for something new to talk about other than the Iraq war. The first 20 discussions listed were ALL questions. EVERY SINGLE ONE! (with the exception of course of the Iraqi discussions which seem to always stay on top.)
Misuse of the forums is getting worse than ever!

Do these people not realize that posting a question puts more points in the posters pocket? It matters to some I'm sure, especially new visitors.

I think TR needs one of those big ugly FLASH intros to explain that there are different discussions and how to use the site.

I never found it too difficult to navigate, actually VERY well laid out. I don't think there is TOO much fine print. Are people really dumb? Is the information on HOW to use TR in the wrong place and not easily found? Are these people just in too much of a hurry (maybe why they have these problems to begin with)? Are people just ignorant when it comes to understanding the guidelines?

I understand that not everyone will post in the right forum and sometimes this is due to just a simple oversight or misunderstanding of the structure. When EVERY discussion is a question, does this then let others think that this is the right forum?

I think straight up questions, once again, should be flagged and then deleted by TR staff as they are brought to their attention.

What a pain in the ass sifting through the piles of crap to find a relevant discussion, especially after sorting through the Q&A's for a half hour or so and helping where you can!

6 replies

by oz_media

Perhaps TR needs another step before entering the forums. A simple Forums link, to replace the Discussions and Technical Q&A links, that leads to a page stating click here if you wish to have your question answered, then going to the Q&A section. And click here to discuss a topic, leading to the discussion forum.

These pages are all CSS scripted it would be EASY AS PIE to change the layout to one that works.

by thechas

Oz,

I have seen a few other sites that offer user assistance.

Many use a forum that is similar to TR's discussion center.

Others have a system similar to the Q&A section.

I even came across 1 that sends out an e-mail to all registered users for the questions that they are interested in.

Perhaps the real answer is to move the Technical Q&A link to the top of the list, or make it larger or a different color.

Chas

by oz_media

As a web designer I'm embarrassed to not have thought of link order. I considered navigation ease as well as clarity but not the order of the links.

You have an excellent point that would take a web master a whole 4 or 5 minutes to fix. Move a link in the CSS sheet and all done. Put Discussions at the BOTTOM of the list, we all know it exists, as well as there are topics on the HOME page for those who don't know the forum.

Great idea!

by mitgat

iM HAPPY YOU PUT IT OUT THEIR, i HAVE NOT BEEN BACK FOR A WHILE BUT i STARTED NOTICING SOME strange threads, that just do not belong. here on one of the best tech sites on the WEB, Leave it...
MGL...

by hal 9000

After all what are Tech Points good for? Unlike some people here I don't need to have someone think that I'm great or a hard worker at TR it is nothing more than light relief after a hards days work. So what if there are some questions on the discussion pages at least they break the problrms that you've had that day at work and make you thing along different lines. I even got an e-mail through the peer listing thanking me for a responce to a problem that someone was having it is a pitty that I have no idea what he was thanking me for but it did help him and it made my day getting that E-Mail.

Now that is something that never happened when I was wasting my time on the Q & A section as most times The Chas was first in with the correct answer which is not a problem owing to the time difference over here but I almost always saw questions closed with out awarding points to someone who responded but worse still not know what the resulition was as this may of been of some use to me latter it might not have been as well but at least I would have known if the question was answered and how a problem was solved. I found it frustrating spending time on these pages and I might as well been at work so I just now play on the discussion pages and if I answer the odd so what?

by oz_media

Even with points meaning sweet F-A, it is still a pain in the ass when Discussions are full of questions.

I spent about an hour answering questions in the Q&A section then got bored so I decided to explore NEW discussions.

After viewing the long list of 'NEW' discussions, I found the only topics of discussion were the Iraqi War and American government threads that had been worn out over and over again.

I thought I'd found someone else starting a router discussion only to find out it was yet another question.

Why structure a site and then just let people post wherever? This site is an excellent resource if used properly and if it wasn't for people who can't figure out the layout, it would be perfect.

Now I'm sure there are those who will never figure it out, there will be those who sneak in the odd question but when EVERY new discussion is an improperly posted question, it drives me nuts. Is it REALLY that hard? I'm no rocket scientist, some have called me a complete idiot and a 'MentalCase' but my first visit was clear and I knew how to post a question.

I don't see this problem at other sites. The links are clear but as Chas suggested it may be better to relocate the links into an easier to navigate tier.

This discussion is closed to new replies.