26 replies
by guruofdos
Cable broadband is almost non existant as an entity in its own right. You cannot contact a cable company and get a broadband package without having to also subscribe to a TV package as well. DSL on the other hand is available to anyone with a phone line, regardless of whether you want to use the phone or not.
A few years ago Digital TV was introduced here, and like the cable companies and satellite TV companies, you needed to subscribe to a package to get a service. OnDigital and ITV digital eventually went bust through lack of support and slow rolling out of infrastructure, plus the fact that many potential subscribers couldn't actually receive digital transmissions or needed to get an expensive aerial upgrade to pick up the lousy signals.
Recently, the BBC stepped in to take over digital TV and there are now some 39 free to view channels which can be picked up using an inexpensive decoder or digital-ready TV with no monthly charges and no subscriptions. If you want premium channels, subscription is about half of what the cable companies charge. Because of this, the only people who have cable TV are the minority who cannot get FreeView digital or cannot have a Sky/Astra satellite dish on their buildings.
I pay a quarter of the price of a cable package (with 9 basic TV channels and a 1Mb broadband service) for my 2Mb DSL and in two years of having DSL, it has only ever dropped out once for perhaps ten minutes. Friends of mine with cable modems are lucky if they get a week of uninterrupted internet usage and virtually all the systems I have installed in my area (most cable companies povide little or no support for home users) have had problems with service or lack of. I probably get several phone calls a month from users unhappy with cable and wanting me to convert them over to DSL.
I have also found that it's generally easier to set up home/soho networks with internet sharing using DSL than it is to do the same with most cable internet providers as they seem to have so many restrictions on their TCP/IP traffic.
Bottom line - not only do I prefer DSL, but 27 out of 33 of my clients who have tried cable have
asked me to rip it out and hook them up to a more reliable service.
by myndebox
I had cable for several years. I got speeds around 8Mbps Down and 1Mbps up. 45bucks a month. They didnt let you run any servers, not even to play online games. I now have DSL- 1.5Down/ 348up
the dsl rates around here suck and Verizon (my dsl provider) doesnt let you run servers either. they also block port 80 outbound for "security reasons" **LIARS, cough, cough** DSL should provide servers allowed and a static ip for a few bucks more. In short DSL cant provide the necessary bandwidth for Next Generation internet services. Baby bells are sinking and fast, Even with Verizons FTTH, it still is slower than cable. Verizon ISP, Phone, Cell Phone, VoIP = Theives
by dave7072
by greg_scott
by ageranger10
by stelian
I vote for cable because:
1. You don't have to dial an initial connection, like the DSL.
2. From my experience (and I've tried quite a few, as I change my ISP every 3 to 6 months, whenever the promotion expires) cable is usually faster and more reliable. Unless you live in an apartament bulding with too many heavy downloaders.
3. I found 2 routers (of several tens I've tested) that do not work with DSL but work OK with cable.
4. On the same router I've had some VPN issues (a MAPI Outlook profile) with DSL but not with cable.
by djuan.carter
by -bw-
Altell DSL in Nebraska, this is what I utilize:
DSL Tier 1 - 1536kbps / 128kbps
SOHO - 29.95 monthly
NAT** or /29 Subnet (5 addresses)
DNS hosting included
15 GB / mo. transfer ceiling
Support - AWESOME!
by tomsal
Just wanted to make you realize that a question like this will return differing opinions because the quality/price/value of broadband is different in different regions of the country let alone the world.
For instance a friend of mine who lives out in Hawaii, DSL sucks severely, but her cable broadband is good. Another friend who is in Texas loves their DSL and hates cable.
Here, just outside of Philly, PA...I wouldn't get Verizon DSL over my cable unless you paid me well to do so..lol. My cable connection is excellent, and though its "published" at 3 mb, I have seen it burst at times to nearly 6 mb, and I've *never*, repeat *NEVER* had a connection less than 1.8 mb and I've had cable for 2 1/2 years
now.
So my answer is cable. :)
by edwardsdl6
by at computers
by -bw-
...as is beauty, in the eye of the beholder. If your DSL white box was as slow as you say, you either have some old telephone lines in or around your house, or you are at the end of the DSL length spectrum. In any event, cable should be a bit quicker than a Tier 1 DSL connection, however cable is still a shared medium, you are sharing it with all your neighbors, the more neighbors on-line, the slower your connection. Unlike DSL, a dedicated bandwidth at nearly all times, cable security can easily be compromised.
Basically, your test proved one thing, you went to ungodly extremes to show that cable was faster at your specific house at a specific time of the day all while you had absolutely no security!
Good Job in Indiana!
by tomsal
When speaking of pro's and con's of broadband connections...
don't fall into the trap that lots of folks do by outlining DSL as more secure connection than cable. While technically this *is* true, its only minimally more secure than cable.
I can (and have) hacked systems on DSL and Cable a like, NOW BEFORE PEOPLE SPAZ READ THE NEXT LINE...
This was work related security testing of our own systems and our own Internet connections and was not illegal hacking.
Anyway, the security or should I say false sense of security some folks will have you believe DSL provides over cable in reality is like being in a the center of room and there are two cages, each with a hungry grizzly bear inside. One cage is labled "DSL" it is made of wood, another cage is labeled "Cable" it is made of plastic --- the DSL cage will take a little longer to break, but not much.
by jamesrl
So like major kudos for your rad test plan!
But like, chill cause like, as they say, your mileage or throughput may vary.
If you were like, living in a big ole city, with tons of other dudes using the same cable pipe, playing those cool games and downloading all those music files, it would be knarly. And if you lived closer to the place they call the Central Office, your DSL would rock.
And dude, check your keyboard, I think your shift key gets stuck sometimes.
James
by cjwarner1
I, too, was lucky enough to have both services side by side for a real world evaluation, BellSouth aDSL vs. Charter Pipeline.
Even though cable had bursts faster than the DSL service, every evening, my upload capacity decreased so much that I culdn't even reliably send a simple text e-mail message. The period in question was about 6pm to midnight. It was 25% of the day and a period that you might most likely be on after a day's work. I had technicians come out three times to take a look at what they could do to "fix" my setup. Nothing. They added nothing new to my setup that changed a thing. It stayed the same.
So, when the free 30-day evaluation period for the cable service was complete, I took the modem back and cancelled the cable service. I told them that I didn't need a part-time internet service at full-time prices.
Now I've had almost three very steady years of performance and very reliable service from BellSouth, even though I think their pricing is a little on the high side. But it's better than having a sporadic internet service at a cheaper rate.
So, the moral of the story is that, despite the potential of each technology and the perceived capability one looks to have over the other, you need to check out the actual real world performance based on how human beings in your immediate area implement and support that technology. The human factor makes all of the difference.
by -bw-
Since cable is a shared medium, you'd be an idiot to select cable over DSL; unless of course price became a determining factor and cable was less expensive. Another issue regarding cable access is security; you can go to any warez site and download a cable sniffer that will allow you to watch whatever anybody connected to the same neighborhood trunk is doing while connected to their cable modem, not so easy with DSL.
So...if you believe cable is the way to go because it may be a few hundred k faster, think agian!
by ubbens
Here in Alberta, Canada the dsl available is far and away superior to cable, as the shared bandwidth of cable usually means slowdowns. This is a problem when running vpn's for mission critical business applications.
The adsl here is great: consistent throughput,low latency, only a couple of outages per year on average. I always recommend it!
by herrroger
by -bw-
especially due to your profession. Most techies know DSL is by far the more preferred connection by IT professionals, specifically due to security.
Cable is still a shared medium, unlike DSL dedicated and a private connection.
I am an IT Systems Engineer and have had a DSL connection for nearly 8 years; numerous attempts by my local cable company to lure me away have all failed. Cable has absolutely nothing more to offer than DSL, but it does have more to lose - Security and dedicated bandwidth!
by sundancer268
by bolin
The battle of how to connect a customer!
The DSL or any ?first mile? data transferring technique only use the ?first mile? to the customer premise to transport data to an individual. Yes this part of the connection is ?private? but remember all the stuff behind which means all backbone communication. This part is shared with all other users in the backbone network. You have to compare this with a business building network or a home network with the ?first mile? as a TP cable. We will have most the same situation at the customer premises.
What you have to look for is the effectiveness and bandwidth of the switches/routers and server systems, at the backbone level, above the physical connection to the DSL/ADSL/RFI-LAN/TP or whatever one use.
You always have to compare the percentage overuse (overbooking) of bandwidth which every ISP provider use and must use because of the economic facts in this business. The customer care case, with call centers and so on, is a separated and soft approach to the customer. This part is also economical but maybe lacking of educated staff personnel and the setup of goals for the ISP Company.
Bo Lindgren
by rocky530
by dwdino
In these instances we need telco options not supplied by Cable companies:
DNS Control
Static IP (some cable do)
Guaranteed Uptime
I have also found that VPN tunnels are much more stable on most DSL connections I have worked with.
For home users, take whatever you want.
I'm running Charter Communications cable and it's slow. Even though the price isn't bad $35/month they say I should get 3mb downloads when infact I can really only get about 100kb. I've called them on this and they said that the 3mb are burst and durring non peak internet hours so I tried at midnight and still 100k. I would love to have SBC DSL but we are in a small town and they don't offer it. I know people that have the SBC DSL and we have a backup line here at work with SBC DSL and LOVE it!
From reading many many other sites and their postings it looks that SBC is one of the best DSL providers in the US. For cable I heard Comcast is a good one.
by johnboehlke
I've had clients in both states...both in urban areas. I have to say that cable, when available, is the better option. Throughput is much higher, and the very nature of the technology how cable works is much more reliable than DSL. I have found that connectivity is an issue with DSL in that there are more things that can go wrong. In almost every instance of installing DSL on a client site, you not only had to have a technician from the phone company come out for setup but you also had to have the phone company activate the service from their end....a task they all to often flub up on their end and delay installation for a week. No such problems with cable...once the hardware is in place..it's on.
I have used Time Warner Cable in Florida and Comcast in Indiana. Tech support is mediocre with both companies. In South Florida, I used Bellsouth DLS and that is THE WORST TECHNICAL SUPPORT group I have ever had the displeasure of working with.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending IT Employment posts
Sort by Trending