Discussion Locked

Does Microsoft force OEM's to support only Vista?

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

After using Vista on a Toshiba laptop for about a week, I had a user request that XP be put on it instead. After trying to back up his data before the conversion, I can understand why! Vista is truly an abomination, but that is not the focus of this blog.

After re-formatting and installing Windows XP I was shocked to learn that Toshiba offered no drivers for XP and that they would never offer any drivers for XP, and that only Vista would ever be supported. This is after going through three levels of support mind you. But after discussing the weather in Manila or Bhopal for a while (actually I think it was Manila) he remembered that last years model supported XP and that those drivers might work.

Luckily they did work, but it took a substantial amount of time and effort to get the laptop fully functional and stable with XP.

The question is: Did Toshiba agree to NOT support XP in an effort to force buyers to use Vista? Upon searching the internet, I was shocked to find so many computer buyers of different brands in exactly the same predicament. They hate Vista and want to install XP or Linux, but the OEM forces them to use Vista by offering no support for anything but Vista.

I'm guessing Microsoft forbids support for anything but Vista in their sales agreements with various OEM's. And if my guess is correct, it's really aggravating!

9 replies

by techexec2

.
Microsoft has said Windows XP is available until January 2008. I don't think they are lying to us while they have secretly withdrawn XP (although I don't trust them at all). That is a lie that would get out in this age of the Internet. I suspect the lack of Windows XP support on new computers is a matter of (1) Financial incentives in PC OEM contracts, and (2) Keeping costs down (cheaper for PC OEMs to support only Vista, especially on laptops). Microsoft is putting the same aggressive full-court press on PC OEMs as the rest of us. If Windows XP is only available for 12 months after Vista was released, why should the OEM support it on new laptop models released during 2007?

[b]Windows XP is being withdrawn faster than previous releases[/b]

Microsoft is putting unprecedented pressure on PC OEMs and Windows customers to upgrade to the new version of Windows (1).

** Windows XP will be available for only 12 months after Vista released.

** Windows 2000 was available for 27 months after XP was released.

** Windows NT4 was available for 27 months after 2000 was released.

** Windows 95 was available for 30 months after 98 was released.

[b]There is a solution to this problem[/b]

Don't be "aggravated". Solve the problem!

The solution is to stop running Windows. I've been running Windows since 1992. Microsoft and Vista so offend me (Vista is expensive, required application upgrades, required hardware upgrades, aggressive upgrade timeline, aggressive WGA de-activations, aggressive, aggressive, aggressive! ), that I'm just saying "no". I'm switching to Linux on the desktop and MacBook notebooks.

Say it with me loudly: MICROSOFT! KISS MY A**! (use your most professional voice)

Do it. You'll feel better.

-----------------------------------------

(1) Windows Life-Cycle Policy
http://www.microsoft.com/windows/lifecycle/default.mspx

by neil higgins

I have Vista installed.I went out and bought Business Edition,for my desktop,having used XP since 2001.In May,I installed linux Ubuntu on a laptop,I'd bought.At home I hardly use Vista,except for a few work files.All my media,and most of my office stuff,is now on Ubuntu.Whilst thanking MS for all the hard earned cash I have spent with them over the years,I now take my leave.I wont reinstall XP on my desktop,as I am about to sell it to a friend,who likes "tech" challenges.For a realistic fee I might add.

by w2ktechman

Personally, at home I am using SUSE 10.2 on a notebook. My desktop system (bought last year) runs XP media center. My older one flips between PCLinuxOS, Win98, and XP.

At work I am using XP (must) on 3 systems. But my recovery system (HDD cloning, data recovery, storage) is running PCLinuxOS 2007, and a notebook there is running PCLinuxOS 2007 as well. This notebook works for many things that do not work right on my XP systems (domain issues, etc.). However there are a lot of things that I cannot use it for.

I also have a Vista desktop and notebook at work. But I rarely boot them, as Vista annoys me too much!

I started moving to Linux about the time I started beta testing Vista.
So, YES to your question. I do feel much better moving away from MS (and saving some cash as well).

by pgm554

Toshiba is actually offering an XP premium with some laptops that are purchased with Vista.
You not only get Vista,but a fully functional XP pro disc to do with as you want.

It seems that a whole lot of folks dislike Vista.

I think it's a piece if sh!t.

by w2ktechman

If it is a business class system, it is likely to have XP as an option. If it is a home/entertainment system it is likely to only have Vista as an option.

In other words -- Vista -- untrusted in business
Home users are all but forced onto it.

by hal 9000

By making the product cheaper to buy than the older XP.

If you look at the name brand systems the same unit with Vista will be about 1 to 2 hundred $ cheaper than the same unit with XP installed. This is M$ way of attempting to force people to move to Vista make it cheaper and people will accept it without comment. Maybe! :D

Anyway here in AU there are legal matters that M$ is having problems with and the main one is that the Product has to be of a Marketable Quality many people are arguing that Vista doesn't meet this minimum requirement and are demanding either to get their new computer loaded with XP or to get the new computer replaced with one running XP.

Which is kind of funny as the same problems existed when XP first hit the streets well all but the deactivations forced on us by WGA anyway. But the real problem is that with Vista there are so many different version available and this confuses the buying public and even some of the sellers who will sell the wrong OS to new buyers and then because we can not buy a new Product Key here to upgrade the OS we have to pay for the entire new OS of the type that we actually need.

This has peeved off more than a few people as I understand things. As I personally mainly support business it's not really an issue for me as I buy Volume Licenses and XP and Office 2003 will be sold to me for quite a while yet so I'm not overly worried one way or the other. Perhaps business will adopt Vista once it's been out long enough to almost work right perhaps they will not currently I don't know which way things will go but currently no one wants a bar of Office 2007 and if push comes to shove they want Open Office installed rather than Office 2007.

I've had a Volume License copy of Vista Enterprise since November 2006 and am yet to permanently load it to a single computer as it's just not ready for a business environment yet. Perhaps I should have one working copy but I find Vista a real problem with common hardware being incompatible so I really can not be bothered at the moment and prefer to run an Open Source Product on my main work station and all my tools. That's any portable computers that I have to carry around with me for work as it works better.

The only down side is that I'm beginning to forget the way to use Windows so I'm now forcing myself to work on a XP unit just so I don't confuse the customers with directions on how to do something. :D

Col

by pgm554

I have had to upgrade 4 Vista business systems to XP Pro because of the issues(bad drivers,no drivers,incredible slowness) on medium powered systems(p4/1gig ram/256mg vid card/7200 rpm disk).

I put XP on them and it flies,put Vista on and it sucks!

Vista takes forever to boot and forever to shutdown.

I have a Technet subscription with enterprise and Vista biz licensing and I have quit installing it anywhere.

Amazing you have the latest and greatest and it slows everybody dowm trying to use it.

Until they fix this piece of crap ,I'm not going to waste anymore of my time on it.

by hal 9000

To see if that have made any improvements to the silly thing. I'm currently wondering why I bought that 5 Site Volume License. :0

I know that there must be a reason but I'm dammed if I know what it was. :D

What I find amazing is that there are still quite a lot of Beta Drivers out there for Vista from the Hardware makers. Seems that M$ is slow to approve these drivers for use with Vista. :p

Col

by webmaster

I am tired of companies selling crap in Mexico. Someone mentioned Toshiba offering an XP CD in case you want to change from VISTA, well, they don't here in Mexico. I bought a Satellite with VISTA on and was too slow, gave me all kinds of problems to interact with other XP based pcs on the net, to install programs, even to turn off and on!!! I hated it so I tried to go back to XP and no support from TOSHIBA, besides, no drivers available. I managed it to find most of them, but Ethernet controller is still missing.
What a hazzle this VISTA is! I will try a Linux based OS now.

This discussion is closed to new replies.