Question Locked

Domain workgroup dns issues

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have a windows 2003 server and many windows
xp computers. The xp computers belong to the
same workgroup but do not to the 2003 domain.
I set them up this way because they don't need
to access any shared resources on the server.
The xp computers use a tcpip application to connect directly to the 2003 server and sometime experience slow connections and sometimes drop and don't work. Rebooting them sometimes works. My question is should the xp computers be members of the 2003 server domain instead of their own workgroup for tcpip applications and network dns to work correctly? On a corp network with a 2003 server
should xp workstations be added to the server
domain even if there are no shared resources
needed?

3 replies

by p.j.hutchison

No, you do not need to be member of a domain to use TCP/IP and DNS.
I suspect the problems are with the switch or router you are using or a problem with a network card on one of the machines or an application flooding the network. You need to use some Network Diagnostic tools (try Network Monitor on the Win2003 server) to find the problem.

by techrepublicsucks

What you need is WINS resolution to make sure the computers on your LAN find one another since you don't have local DNS zone which would be created when you installed Active Directory. WINS is built in to Windows Server and is much easier to configure than DNS.
Install WINS on the W2K3 server using Add/Remove Programs>Windows Components. Then configure your DHCP server to provide the WINS server IP address to the workstations or configure WINS for each workstation if you don't have DHCP. The WINS server will automatically record the names and IPs of all computers configure to use the WINS server. Your computers will not need to broadcast for name resolution since the WINS server will service their requests. (See: http://www.microsoft.com/technet/prodtechnol/windows2000serv/plan/wins2000.mspx)

This discussion is closed to new replies.