Discussion Locked

Enterprise Architect - UML

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
HAs anyone used EA seriously in a corporate environment ? I'm looking for a low cost CASE tool - how does EA compare with Rational Rose ? ... and can one even compare MS Visual Modeler ? ... how seriously should one consider tools in the internet development environment ?

5 replies

by leif

I haven't used EA or MSVM, but I've used Rational Rose and Together Control Center (Togethersoft). Rose had more products integrated (defect tracking, project management, and on and on). Together was easier to use, and didn't enforce a particular methodology as strongly.

If you're sticking to the Rational development process, then Rose is a good choice. I found it unpleasant to use, since our company's process wasn't all that close to Rational's.

I enjoyed Together, for the most part.It didn't do everything I wanted (e.g., collections didn't diagram well), but I found that it helped much more than it annoyed. It also worked well with the other tools we were using.

As for your last question, about how seriously should one consider tools, I'd say they're worth investigating. You know your development process, and can make the most informed judgement about how well a tool will fit into that process. You also know whether you're willing to change the process to fit the tool. If the tool makes you more productive, then it's a good one.

This discussion is closed to new replies.