Question Locked

External Hardisk Problem

0 helpful
25 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hi,
I recently bought a new external hardisk. It's a 3.5" Maxtor hardisk. At first I thought it was ok to run. But everytime after I turn it off, Windows is unable to detect it again. I have tried pushing the on and off button again and again but to no success (only sometimes it does). I have scan the hardisk and it gives no problem. I have also tried open up the casing and find no problem with the cable. No loose or anything. I have changed the USB cable but still, couldn't detect. Could it be my USB port problem? But I doubt so since my thumbdrive can still be detected. Need help here. Thanks!

25 replies

by oh smeg

And what if any software was installed when you fitted this drive?

Are you using the Safe Removal Option or just switching off every time as well?

Col

by thugss2000

I'm using Windows XP (SP2). I didn't install any software. Just plug and play.

I did both Safe Removal Option as well as just switching off everything. My friend told me this doesn't make a difference unless I'm transferring my file and I just switch off everything. Just a pre-caution as what he told me.

I hope you can help me with this hardisk as I don't want to just throw it away. Thanks.

Law

by sgt_shultz

does the drive have two usb ports on it? if so you need to plug in both of them, the drive may get its power from them

by oh smeg

As that Parks the Heads before allowing you to turn off. If you just turn off while you think that the Read/Write Heads are not actually doing anything you run the risk of having them crash onto the platters as the power is removed.

What you should always do with anything that moves in a USB Port is to Safely Remove the Device and when you are prompted to remove the device switch off the power to the HDD in this case then finish off by clicking on the finish buttons to get rid of the On Screen Display.

The only time that it's even remotely safe to remove something from a USB Port is when there are no moving parts things like Thumb Drives and the like but even doing this can shorten the lives of this equipment so it's always better to use the Safely Remove Option as the few seconds spent are a lot better than the need to buy new hardware.

Col

by thugss2000

I don't think so. This is a 3.5" external hardisk. I have a power supply to it. So don't think it's the power hub problem...

by 1bn0

In some of the reviews I have been reading for both External Case HDDs and USB drive adpaters there have been a number of complaints that the power supplies seem to be underpowered. Replacing the power supply with different make/model of the same power rating fixes the problem.

It seems to be a problem of manufacturing for the cheapest cost possible.

by thugss2000

Oh, is that true? Do you mean I have to change a power adapter or something like that? Cause I'm currently using multiple plugs (i.e. one row of 4).

If that's the power supply problem, how come the hardisk still manage to turn on? (All the LED in the casing light on).

And there's a signal I noticed. The R/W (Read and Write) LED is blinking at constant rate but my laptop still does not detect any hardrive. Any idea?

by 1bn0

Sorry for the late response.

I forget what model I was reading reviews for, but there were a lot of complaints that the external power supply provided for the unit was ub-standard and did not work effectively.

They replaced it with a compatable alternate power supply and everything would work O.K.

I get the blinking light symptom on a 2.5 " external case I use. It's supposed to work off of just the USB, but I haven't had a macine yet that it did. But plug in the "optional" power connector and everything works fine.

by thugss2000

Thanks for the tips. From now on, I should always click the Safely Remove Option.

by tonythetiger

Try powering on the drive without the USB connected, then after the drive comes up, connect it to the computer. We have to do this on our server, else it detects "new hardware" and asks for a driver disk.

Try different usb ports, on our Dell GX270s, the drive will detect on 4 ports but not on the other two.

by thugss2000

I've tried option 2 before but failed.

As for option 1, I haven't tried it but I think it still won't work for me.

by oh smeg

Is that if they connect directly to the M'Board they work but if the USB Sockets are on a fly lead like in the front of the case sometimes they don't work at all well if at all.

I don't know if that's the problem here but it wouldn't hurt to check it out.

Col

by thugss2000

Something strange happened. I tried the external hardisk on about 6 to 7 pc in my uni and same problem occured (sometimes able to detect the hardisk but later on, not anymore). However, when I asked my friend to try to his pc, his pc recognised the external hardisk EVERYTIME he plug the external hardisk into his pc.

Any idea what's wrong? Thanks.

by oh smeg

Isn't sufficient for the External HDD on some computers and is above the minimum limit on others.

If you can connect an external Power Supply I would really suggest that you try this now. Failing that you can try a Powered USB Hub with both of the USB Plugs plugged in and see if that improves the situation.

In every case that I've dealt with involving unpowered external HDD's it's always been a lack of available Power that has caused problems even to such an extent that 7 drives plugged into a PCMCIA Card all died within a week each did what the owner thought was a daily backup and then when he came to use it again the units no longer worked as both the USB Enclosure and HDD had been destroyed.

Col

by thugss2000

But mine is a laptop with 2 USB Sockets. So, I don't think that's the problem.

by thugss2000

So, that's mean I have to get another new power cable to work with my 3.5" external hardisk?

by thugss2000

Is it something like those 2.5" external hardisk where there'll be two USB Plugs that need to be plugged in the ports? And I'm sorry, I don't get what you mean by external power supply? Actually I'm not using external power supply as it's a 3.5" external hardisk.

Oh my God, what should I do to prevent the USB Enclosure and HDD being destroyed?

by oh smeg

As the 3.5 inch drives run on 12 V DC and a USB Port only puts out 5 V DC. A 3.5 inch drive [b]CAN NOT[/b] run just on a USB Lead as there is not enough power available.

You must have some sort of plug pack that plugs into the mains and puts out 12 Volts to drive a 3.5 inch USB Drive.

The only other option is that it has a 2.5 inch drive mounted inside the enclosure which will run off a USB Port but a 3.5 inch drive never will run off any USB port made to date.

If you want to remove the possibility of not having enough power to drive one of these you can either use the supplied or Optional Extra Plug Pack or a Powered USB Hub.

Col

by thugss2000

My 3.5" external hdd is running using the Power Pack. But the weird thing is, it works for my friend's pc but not on my laptop and my uni's pc.

by oh smeg

As a potential problem here.

With NB and new computers they have lower available power at the USB Ports than some of the less new Desktops did. It could be that with the Power Supply being a bit iffy you are running into a problem of not enough power to properly run the unit.

Col

by thugss2000

I tested the external hdd with my friend 1 year old desktop and it works but failed on my 3 year old laptop and also failed on my uni's few year old desktop.

What can I do to improve the power supply to the usb?

by oh smeg

Though you need to watch the set power specifications and not exceed them by much.

The Voltage needs to remain the same though the Amperage can be slightly greater and remember to watch the polarity of the connector.

Col

by thugss2000

So I just need to replace the power cable only? This is actually a new casing I bought 2 weeks earlier. Seems like I have to fork out more money.

How do I see all the specifications and all that? Is it written somewhere? Hope you can give advices. Thanks

by oh smeg

That as you are in AU will say Input Voltage 240 V AC output Voltage 12 V DC and a amperage.

If you can fin an AU Electrical compliance listing on the plug Pack as well it would help but this may not be there in which case th Plug Pack hasn't been tested by the AU Electrical Authorities and it's therefore illegal.

But everything has by Law to be on the Plug Pack.

Col

This discussion is closed to new replies.