Discussion Locked

fiber networks

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hello

Can someone give me a reason for not haveing an all fiber network ?

9 replies

by michael kassner

It requires learning whether you are referring to inter-site networks or internal networks. Also the exact details of the network would be helpful as well, since security level, convenience, IT support abilities and as mentioned earlier cost are factors that need to be outlined first.

For instance I just setup several routers at a Norwegian consulate and they required fiber cable runs to each computer and the fiber had to be in conduit. Reasons:

1. Ethernet traffic can be sniffed on CAT6 without physically disrupting cables
2. Fiber optic runs can also be sniffed by creating a tight enough bend and sensing the EM radiation. (cool stuff to read about), hence the conduit.

So it is hard to debate either case until one knows the intimate details of a particular situation.

I have published a link that offers some debate points about both and might also be helpful.

http://svconline.com/mag/avinstall_fiber_vs_copper/

by budmcardle

Hello

I want to first of all thank you for your reply and taking the time to share your valued experience. I'm attending DeVry University and this is a question from my professor, basicly this is all the information to the question " Why not an all fiber Network"

by oh smeg

It's more expensive than any other Networking Technologies to implement.

Homework/Assignment question?

Col

by michael kassner

The question is an interesting one. It almost is an investment and long term RoI decision more than anything. I would be curious to learn what the instructor was looking for in an answer.

by oh smeg

Unfortunately without knowing more it's very hard to even guess at what is the point of this question. I remember once I was asked to give a Very Basic Description of a LED. I just said [b]Light Emitting Diode[/b] which I thought was simple & self explanatory. The guy asking the question though wanted the answer of [b]A Light without a Filament.[/b]

While I'm not sure if that is technically correct that was the answer that was required and something that I would never have thought of ever. The same applies here without more context it's very hard to answer other than the most obvious the costs involved but there are several advantages over Wired or Wireless Networks that could make it a worthwhile and usable alternative under the right conditions.

Col

by michael kassner

I agree totally and in my old age have finally realized that in order to successfully answer a question or debate an issue, I first ask for definitions of the main terms and or topics. Much less confusion.

This discussion is closed to new replies.