If you want to learn a language that would advance your career, then Java is probably the best choice, because it seems like most of the business world is seeking Java programmers now. The demand for Java programmers is high, so this could be the deciding factor.
As a matter of fact, I'm no fan of Java. I can do anything a Java programmer can do -- better, faster, and cheaper in Forth -- but business prefers the replacable programmer over the gurus, hence the advice: to get a job in the field -- choose the language that business is hot for, and not necessarily the language that provides you with the most freedom, the fastest execution speed, or any other technical advantage.
For Smalltalk information, check out the Wiki Wiki Web, as there are many Smalltalk advocates there. (http://c2.com/cgi/wiki)