Discussion Locked

Government tries to interfere with Amish tradition

0 helpful
85 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I think this article will be of special interest to Americans, but also to anyone who believes Government should not try to interfere with individual rights.

Note especially the highlighted portion.

The executive director of a New York-based constitutional rights advocacy group says he will be talking with the senator who chairs the state's Labor Committee today during a special session of the State Legislature. At issue is the attempt to resolve a growing problem for some western New York Amish families whom state labor officials say are violating labor laws.

Amish families in Lyndonville have been told the businesses they run in which their minor children, ages 14 to 17, work -- including sawmilling, metalwork, and construction -- have to cease using the children. The Amherst Record newspaper reports labor officials began placing the businesses on notice earlier this summer.

Christian activist and lobbyist Duane Motley of New Yorkers for Constitutional Freedom (NYCF) says it is vital to stop the erosion of the Amish families' constitutional rights before it goes any further. The violation of these families' freedoms by New York State labor officials must be checked, he contends, "because, if they can limit the Amish in just this one area, what's going to prohibit them from expanding it into other areas affecting the Amish?

[b]"And, of course," Motley adds, "if you limit the Amish, you've got to limit everybody else." That includes New York's home schooling families, he notes, as home school students often intern with someone in the world of work instead of going to trade school.[/b]

The Christian lobbyist says any proposals to help the Amish families through labor law changes have to come through the Labor Committee, which is why he is looking to speak with State Senator George Maziarz. Unfortunately, the NYCF spokesman points out, that committee is also lobbied strongly and regularly by labor unions in the state.

Motley believes the New York unions lobbying the Labor Committee may fear unregulated competition from Amish businesses and therefore may have an interest in blocking any changes to state law that would provide an exception for Amish families or others using minor children as apprentices or workers in particular occupations.

Challenges to the old order cultural tradition of the Amish, which starts young people working with their parents after eighth grade, are causing some families to consider moves as drastic as leaving the state if area lawmakers cannot help them work out a legislative solution. State lawmakers have been quoted as saying they will investigate the issue of whether state labor laws can be modified to accommodate the Amish community's traditional religious practices with regard to their family businesses.

Steve Crampton, chief counsel with the American Family Association Center for Law and Policy, believes constitutional law is on the Amish families' side. He notes that a 1972 Supreme Court ruling in Wisconsin v. Yoder, which provided a precedent establishing Amish families right to keep their children out of public schools, would be in the New York families' favor if they end up having to take the labor matter to court.

Also, the pro-family attorney observes, "The fact that they have so faithfully adhered to their principles and their deeply-held beliefs over a period of centuries really puts them in an unusual ... and a strong factual sort of position to challenge the likes of the New York labor laws."

In other words, the Amish community tradition of introducing its young people early to the world of work has a lengthy history, Crampton explains. So, he says, decades of practice on record that this tradition has not proven hazardous to the children should help the families if the matter has to be resolved in court.

85 replies

by maxwell edison

.....and until that bigger issue is both recognized and resolved, such things will continue.

I often have discussions with my teenage son about the jobs I had as a boy, and how they were all positive experiences for me. They would "violate" today's labor laws (something he and I both resent, by the way), although NONE of them were anything close to being a bad thing.

This is far from a religious issue, Julian, but more accurately an individual liberty issue. Until the core issue of government interference in individual lives is recognized as the REAL problem, people's rights will continue to be violated. However, there are simply too many busy-body, goody-two-shoes, know-better-than-everyone-else, zealots who have become "accepted" as legitimate, instead of being publicly tarred-and-feathered and run outta' town (figuratively speaking, of course).

It's not unlike a question I asked in a different thread (which absolutely nobody answered, by the way, probably for fear of admitting the truth and/or being seen as hypocritical). Should a government have the right to force one citizen to serve the needs of another citizen? The answer is an unequivocal no; ALL issues should rest on this premise; and the chips should be left to fall where they may. Anything other than that, and you'll have infringements on individual rights. The people who say "it depends on the circumstances" either fall into the category of people described above; or they let their emotions trump their reason; or they're afraid of what it might mean to them personally, in as much as THEIR desire to force others to capitulate to their will under certain circumstances (other people should be forced to pay for my health care, for example); or they have not thought these types of issues through, at least to the point of using core principles as their guide. (And have you noticed how many people absolutely HATE my constant use of the term "core principles"? Is it because they have none themselves, or is it that they can't advance an argument against mine?)

In this case, the law of unintended consequences is doing more harm than originally intended, and certainly more than anyone will probably admit. In their zeal to put an end to the stereo-typical "child labor sweat shops" of a century ago, they've literally trampled all over individual rights and common sense -- AND diversity of thought and opinion.

To paraphrase a recent political campaign slogan, it's the core issue, stupid!

(And before anyone "reads into" that and suggests I'm calling anyone "stupid", here's a reference: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/It's_the_economy,_stupid )

by onbliss

I will just quote the paragraph I liked the most in your post

"In this case, the law of unintended consequences is doing more harm than originally intended, and certainly more than anyone will probably admit. In their zeal to put an end to the stereo-typical "child labor sweat shops" of a century ago, they've literally trampled all over individual rights and common sense -- AND diversity of thought and opinion"

by drowningnotwaving

We all worked around the house, yard and / or farm from when we were little.

I see kids (12 - 15) helping out in their parent's restaurants, in their newsagencies (magazine / newspaper stores) and heaps of other things and they don't seem to come out as sociopathic misfits.

But there is a need to understand the line so that the "stereo-typical" sweat-shop is not, by de facto standards, allowed to return.

How to measure or guard against that line is difficult, because any guarding can be perceived as impinging upon someone's right.

by hal 9000

CHEAP LABOUR!!!

What other use do they serve if they are not the ones to run to the TV and change channels, volume or whatever? I blame Technology for the erosion of the ability of children to know what is acceptable for them to do now days. With the advent of remotes the children no longer had to race to the TV every time that you needed the channel changed, put in a Video or DVD and worse still stopped making their beds or doing any work around the house that they live in and still expect to receive pocket money for sitting on their A$$es doing nothing and making more work for others.

The average child is going to cost you upward of $100,000.00 to bring up to age 18 if not more so you need to get some of that investment back by making the little buggers work for everything that they are costing you.

I look at it this way if they are old enough to walk they are old enough to work in the family business at some level of involvement. You start them off in the more dangerous places like sharpening saw blades while they are still running and if they survive they have proven their fitness to start to climb the corporate ladder and eventually end up running the show. Just think of allowing some silly person who isn't bright enough not to get killed in the shop being allowed to run the place and place others lives in danger!

Col

by jdclyde

You are absolutely correct Max (Imagine that?).

People who FEEL so much yet don't have a logical thought bouncing around in their liberal wasteland of a brain have worked hard to destroy what they don't "like".

Children have always grown up helping around the farm, or family business to help the family make ends meet and teach them a trade. It had the effect of building self esteem from knowing a job well done and learning a work ethic.

The more responsibilities you give someone, the more responsible they are. Give them less responsibilities and they grow up to be Democrats, expecting people to do everything for them. Pay for my education, pay to feed my family, pay for my medical, and give me free internet access.

We hear all the time about the "shrinking middle class", but everyone forgets to mention that todays lower income people live today with the equal standard of living that the middle class did back when the "war on poverty" was miserably launched.

by jamesrl

I grew up in a farming area, and this would certainly negatively impact both farmers and kids, not to mention driving up the cost of food for no real benefit.

Helping the family business includes doing some work, even for kids under 14. And the kids often get paid for it, learning the value of hard work and money. Those kids I grew up with know the value of a dollar. They know how to save to get the things they want.

This also exists in other businesses - kids stocking shelves at the corner convenience store, is one example.

I buy produce from Mennonites (the Amish are an offshoot of the Mennonites) at a farmers market. Sometimes the kids selling it are young - 12/13. But they are contributing to their family and are better for it.

For all the comments from some about Canada being a socialist haven, no one has thrown out an idea like this.

James

by tony hopkinson

If they are being paid a wage and are officially an employee and they want to do it, then there's no problem.
If some of those aren't true...

If they weren't Amish would it still be acceptable is the only question.

If no other religious group gets the distinction, then neither do they.

You have to be real careful with this sort of culture/religious tradition. Otherwise you could be setting a precedent you don't want to.

There used to be a tradition with mill owners in the UK and kids working.

Question, how on earth do they get insurance against injury?

by maxwell edison

..... if it IS a "religious" issue

The Amish religion dictates that their boys work in the saw mill at fourteen years of age.

The _____ religion dictates that their fourteen year old boys have a glass of wine at their _____ celebration.

The _____ religion dictates that their fourteen year old girls marry and bear children with a church elder.

Why do the first two seem somewhat acceptable, but the last one abhorrent? All of them are moral judgements.

by jamesrl

Bceause if you set that precedent it no doubt will be used against the Korean convenience store owner, whose 13 kid stocks shelves. Slippery slope is what it is.

As for the last one, it wasn't considered abhorrent 150 years ago. A 14 year old girl had completed her schooling, and many were married at that age. But I'd like to think we know better know now. First off, today we don't have many arranged marriages. We expect people to make their own choice instead of parents choosing for them. And given that, we set the bar at various points in being independant - 18 for voting, etc.

There also has to be some consideration for other factors. One presumes that in a family work situation, the parents have the kids best interests at heart and won't over work them or expose them to dangerous situations.

A glass of wine at a religious celebration may be against the letter of the law, but one glass does little harm. But I would have problems enshrining that in law -slippery slope and all. If a 16 year old kid gets drunk at one of these occasions and drives drunk - is the server not responsible as well as the driver?

On the other hand a 14 year old marrying is potentially for life and if it harms the child could do damage for the rest of their life.

James

by tonythetiger

make an exception for a parent serving it to [b]their own child[/b] in [b]their own home[/b]. Some only prohibit the [b]sale[/b] to minors, and do not specifically prohibit consumption.

by drowningnotwaving

In your post, in examing the laws that enable or diable those actions to occur...

In your three examples,

1. Whose liberties are being affected : the parent or the child?

2. Is there a 'barrier' where acceptable becomes unacceptable - e.g. a kid helping in the afternoons in the barn, versus a kid forced to work 8 hours per day, 7 days a week, on the family farm?

{[b]If[/b] there is such a barrier, should it be 'self-policed' or do government agencies have a right / responsibility to be able to intervene?}

3. Are the concepts of age of responsibility / age of consent there to protect children or impinge upon their individual rights?

The reason I'd ask these questions is that your three examples (which I hope and assume were rhetorical) are similar to the examples that I would ask of you to explain the practicality of your 'reason for government'.

by maxwell edison

.....and one that created the need for government in the first place. And contrary to what you might believe, I've never been an advocate of NO government. (Which I should have added to the list in my language and definition discussion -- Less to me equals None to others!)

---------- Side track ----------

But first of all (if I dare), in an attempt to clear-up your misconception from that other thread, a person should have unlimited freedom as long as it does not infringe upon the freedom of another. A person has a right to "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness"; but that person has no such right to force -- either individually OR through government -- another person to provide that happiness. I can't keep you from pursuing it, and you can't force me to provide it. Government should step-in ONLY when one person or the other is being forced to do something against his will. Absolutely EVERY stance I take has a foundation in that very basic premise, and I'm always consistent. I'm amazed that you apparently fail to understand such a simple concept. You may disagree, but it's a simple enough concept to at least grasp. And if you cannot acknowledge my point (although you may disagree), I have no desire to "argue" with you, especially when it spins into the usual direction of misleading charges and disingenuous claims.

My initial question in that other thread: Should government be able to FORCE one person to serve the needs of another? NO, NO, a million times NO. ALL "collectivist-type" thinkers, however, IF they advanced their position with at least an ounce of intellectual honesty, would say YES. Why don't they do it? Perhaps because they would then have to admit that they actually advocate denying a person his/her individual liberty in order to provide personal comfort and/or meet personal needs.

Today, however, government is the vehicle people use to force their will on others. Personally speaking, I have a problem with that -- and there is literally NO escaping it! (The mere fact that I can't get away from it should prove that it's gone too far!)

In a simplistic kind of illustration, I do not, for example, want to pay for your health care -- and I should not be FORCED to do it! I don't care how you justify it. (And no, I don't expect anyone to pay for mine either.) If you "choose" to donate funds to organizations that DO provide health care to those who cannot afford it, that's all fine and dandy. But you should not be able to FORCE others to donate.

Another illustration: Have you ever had that person in the office who goes around collecting money for a baby gift or something for someone else? YOU DON'T HAVE A CHOICE! YOU MUST CONTRIBUTE! Sorry, that bird won't fly in my world. And the function of government, in similar cases, should be no different.

---------- Okay, back on track ----------

In the context of this discussion, that child certainly does have rights -- but not as many as his/her adult parents. A parent's right, for example, to force that child to go to school, trumps that child's right to decide he/she doesn't want to go.

When I was in the thirteen and fourteen range (and fifteen and sixteen), I had a job in a gas station pumping gas, changing oil, and doing other automotive repair chores. But I was doing things then that kids today are prohibited from doing. And not only was it NOT bad for me, but it was actually good for me.

I will admit, however, when it comes to children, the line gets fuzzy. Where does protecting the safety and well-being of the child stop, and protecting the rights of the parent start. One person might think it's perfectly okay to have a fourteen year old work in a saw mill (or in my case, put a car on a lift, raise it into the air, and change the oil), while another person believes it's endangering the child. I don't have an answer as to how we can always see the line clearly and consistently.

An interesting segue is the abortion issue. Whose "rights" should the government protect? The woman's or the child's? (Let's not hijack Julian's thread to argue the abortion issue -- been there, done that. I mention it only because it illustrates how conflicts and/or irreconcilable differences might occur. The pro-abortionist is arguing for the woman's rights, while the anti-abortionist is arguing for the "child's" rights. But in almost all such cases, there's a premise that FIRST needs to be established and/or agreed upon.)

If I had to define it, I would say that as long as the child is not being placed in a life-threatening situation, or that the child's growth was not being severely impeded, and the child's emotional well-being was not threatened, then a parent's opinion and rights trumps anyone else's. And in cases in which it's not blatantly obvious, we should err on the side of the parent's right to choose what may or may not be best for his/her own kids. (Yea, I know, I know. What's "not blatantly obvious" to one person might be "very clear to see" to another. And on it goes.)

by tony hopkinson

While I rarely agree with Max on most issues, small government or more to the point minimum legislation is something we do agree on.

We have different ideas on what the minimum should consist of, of course. :D

As far as a fourteen year old in a saw mill is concerned, what has age got do with anything?
A fourteen year old given they are physically capable is in just as much (or as little) danger as an 18 year old. Whether they are traditionally expected to work, or they feel they should help out, or they like sawing up bits of wood is immaterial.

As long as they have the same rights in the workplace as an eighteen year old, I fail to see the problem.

If you tell Billy he can't work in the saw mill you are infringing his rights, if you tell Billy's dad he can't make Billy work in the saw mill you are enforcing Billy's rights.

It really is that simple, it's just legislators who want to make it into a complex issue, so they can make a buck, infringing ours legally.

by drowningnotwaving

In many countries the law is being changed to the serving of alcohol to minors - period. Irrespective of who or where.

Fact is that it is unenforceable, so the 'glass of beer' at the barbecue in the back yard effectively remains the same.

Unless the kid is served alcohol, gets drunk and wanders the streets at night.

Then the parent is going to have their butt well and truly kicked if not having their kid taken away from them.

by hal 9000

If the family teach their children to consume alcohol from a very early age these children are very unlikely to become alcoholics. Just how many Traditional Jews do you see at AA Meetings?

My own children where allowed alcohol in moderation from as soon as they could ask for it and today they don't drink in excess ever. Both of them will have a Social Drink at Parties and the like but they refuse gifts of Booze from their bosses for Christmas. Neither of them drink in excess and both of them prefer not to drink Alcohol if they can avoid it.

Because there was no big hodo around the consumption of Alcohol for them it's a None Issue to them but all of their friends who where refused to be allowed to have the smallest drink went wild when they got old enough and went wild drunk as skunks at every opportunity and where so impressed with themselves that they could get so drunk that they didn't know what happened.

It's surprising just how many Good Friends of my children where dropped by the kids for this behaviour and I never had to worry about either of them returning [b]As Drunk As A Lord or Stoned Off their Faces[/b] as it never happened.

Even today it's the ones who where not allowed to drink Booze as children who have to have a drink at the end of the work day or run to the pub for some liquid refreshment. Both of my children just return home to drink some Fizzy junk or Fruit Juice.

While I accept that different people have the right to bring up their children as they see fit I do not accept that they have the right to push their beliefs onto me when I'm doing what I think is best for my children. If anyone was to try this they would be told where they could go in no uncertain terms and they could[b]Get Stuffed[/b] if they think that any thing that they attempt will change the way that I chose to raise children.

Col

by maevinn

As I always do when I read of this type of event--how many people really sit down and THINK before trying to enforce a law? How many decide that all laws are equal in application under all circumstances?

by drowningnotwaving

In researching this, the issue is [b]not[/b] the children working whatsoever, but children working in areas / industries deemed to be dangerous.

Working, per se, is [i]not the issue[/i].

And it would seem that both the White House and the Dept of Justice have problems with any exemption (and in days gone by the Senate as well), because of the constitution.

[i]"This is in fact the DOJ's position: that to grant an exemption to the Amish would be to favor a particular religious sect, and therefore violate the First Amendment's Establishment Clause.[/i]

http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1568/is_2_31/ai_54772888

Bloody constitution. And it's a good thing the Amish discovered wood milling before they discovered recycling depleted plutonium rods to generate spare cash, 'cos that [i]would[/i] be a safety conundrum.

Now here's an ethical question - should an independant developer be allowed to spend their money, buy a large chunk of property, and put up the Mall of America V2 in Amish land?

At what point in time do the regulations serve to protect our/a heritage, versus becoming a constraint on the normal process of progress and population growth and expansion?

{My answer? Somewhere at a certain real-estate value there will be a cross-over. The government won't be able to resist the developer's taxation and growth opportunities. Then the Amish become an enclave. Then a museum. Then perhaps a casino).

by jdclyde

It is a law, and it is to be followed every time, or repealed and a new law put in place.

It is the refusal to always follow the letter of the law that undermines ALL laws and the legal system.

Something people don't seem to understand, is congress has been writing and passing laws for two centuries now and keep anding new ones all the time. In most cases, just enforcing existing laws would keep us all safe. They also write laws that contradict older laws, and they both stay on the books.

A major problem when you have lawyers running the country, and yes, most in congress and the senate are lawyers.

An example is the anti-gun lobby. They choose to not rigidly enforce existing gun laws, and then complain about the violence people commit while using guns. The violent people don't get the blame, the guns do. So they write more and more laws. One day when they decide to start enforcing all these laws, just about everything will be illegal.

STOP WRITING LAWS! If there is a new technology, make a new and SEPARATE law to govern that.

by tony hopkinson

If you are 17 years 364 days 23 hours, 59 minutes and 59 seconds at the time you are arrested for doing something you should be adult for, is this an over literal approach or an interesting and lucrative case to both prosecute and defend?

Both in our current world, designed by the lawyers for lawyers.

by drowningnotwaving

Thanks Max that is a very strong and detailed response.

There are few things we differ upon. I do, however, accept that the way those things are manifest in various governments or psyches around the place may lead to very large differences in practise.

I think your basic concept ('l, l & tpoh') is obvious, correct, proven and though has operational flaws is the best thing we have got. I would add that (in my humble opinion) it is the responsbility of government to work in a manner that reflects the ethics and standards that we as a society wish to maintain, including leadership, opportunity, ownership, fairness, efficiency in administration, compassion and the strength to defend those standards internally and externally.

How would that possibly modify my responses to your points (that is, 'modify' to the extent that I think they may be different).

Should a government force a person to serve the needs of another? No, fully agreed. I dare say that my interpretation of 'force' will be different perhaps to yours.

For specific EXAMPLE(as per the other thread) a company should absolutely be proactively forced to act in a way that does not impinge upon another's rights. I feel a government should proactively legislate and companies should be forced to proactively work in that manner. Example? Cigarettes. (Yes, old, overblown, done a million times). But the point being that when a company reasonably becomes aware that their products, services or manner of delivery is deliberately harming people then at least they should proactively have to make people aware of the risks to the extent that they (the company) are also aware of the risks.

Having made people aware, within a reasonable timeframe, can they then be held responsible for an individual's own decision to continue using that product or service ? NO!

Should someone born in the 80's be able to sue a cigarette company? No! Well not for direct smoking illnesses anyway.

But I feel that there is a need to have a proactive requirement on people or companies to think before they do things, to act as new material / information comes to light. Highlighting the issue and pursuing a remedy shouldn't invariably be the responsibility of the consumer AFTER the fact.

Another example? We may or may not have known of all the effects of a whole raft of different chemicals on the environment. Heck, there may even be a lot chemicals with very little effect. But when an individual or a company rolls their truck backwards up towards the river and dumps 30,000 litres of waste in there, I'd be fairly confident that even in the 1920's, your average truck driver knew that they were doing something not correct. If you make it then you dispose of it, at your cost or effort, irrespective of what the content is. And dumping on public or open property, or shoving it into the air, or dumping it into international waters is so fundamentally wrong, irrespective of that the contents are.

So those are a couple of examples where there should be regulation around the performance of companies and individuals. Now does that reduce their ability to seek l,l,&tpoh? I don't think so. It may well add to the effort necessary. But seemingly from the 'papers their (companies') point of view is somewhat different.

On your examples: HEALTH: I beleive there needs to be a safety net, as there exists in the US, for people to have a basic standard of health care. I beleive it is economically viable and correct for us to have that. An example (hopefully not too trivial) is people in remote areas, who have neither the economic power nor physical access to healthy that I do in the city. They need assistance / propping up. If that is in the form of the mobile health care, or in the form of subsidised travel, whatever works in the circumstances. I don't beleive that a completely gratis health system is necessary nor is an efficient method of running a government. But I think the long term economic cost to us of not having a basic safety net far outweighs the taxation costs in the short term. So I'd rather pay a little now on proper health care and health protection for ALL than pay for the hospitals or prisons or leper farms later on.

And should little Billy from the poor family who is at school be allowed to run around with seaping wounds and coughing up bile while he shares the same class as 25 other healthy kids? No. He should be taken out, taken to a clinic, fixed up and put back in school. Does that impact his or his parent's rights? Probably.

Office donations? I have no compunction telling them no. Even the boss's kids. And I only work in an office with 12 people so the impact is very visible. But I do know what you mean and agree that it happens on a regular basis.

And I, just like you, daren't touch trying to define how you control the behaviour of a parent when that is deemed to be inappropriate. I didn't suffer from being employed in part tiome work from 14; I lived on a farm from 12 - 18 so did my fair share of morning milking (and can guarantee I never got paid enough for that); I got slapped on the butt when I was young. I also got detention at school and grounded at home. In my day we also got the cane. But maybe I am a sociopath.

[i]Today, however, government is the vehicle people use to force their will on others.[/i]

To establish a governmental system that has limited or no social agenda is also [i]forcing a will[/i].

That's why we vote. And argue on threads. If every one agreed with me democracy would be so much easier and cheaper all around. :)

by maxwell edison

.....was meant to illustrate a person's right to refuse contributing; however, with such "donations" going through government, a person has no such right. That is wrong, regardless of how you spin it.

As far as your desired "safety net", that's an overused and abused metaphor. Besides, after all these decades of an ever-growing nanny government, your metaphoric safety net has become a sleep-number bed.

by maecuff

We stayed in a hotel last weekend that had sleep number beds in the room. I'm sure the bionic woman is very happy with hers, but I wasn't all that impressed. And I got on my husband's nerves because I kept playing with the controls.

by jamesrl

If we are talking mainstream western society, I'd be safe in saying generations ago.

And if I had to pin it to another culture shift, it changed around the time of urbanization. Often arranged marriages in farming communities had to do with making good economic matches. When people moved to salary jobs in the city, it made less sense. There are of course other factors -the emancipation of women, etc.

However there are some people in western societies who still maintain aspects of their old cultures and do still arrange marriages. The Amish/Mennonites/Dukohbors still arrange marriages. Many people from differing asian communities still arrange marriages, sometimes sending prospects back to Asia.

James

by onbliss

[i]Often arranged marriages in farming communities had to do with making good economic matches. [/i]

Picture me nodding my head to the above sentence. It is quite true in many many rural communities in India.

We are (were) all so same and yet so different.

by deepsand

As one who grew up along side a large number of Old Order Amish and Mennonites, I can tell you that while parents there do, like many parents, try to encourage marriages which they believe are in the best interest of the children, marriages require the consent of those being married.

Bear in mind that Anabaptist children are [b]not[/b] allowed to join their respective churches, and they are not held to the precepts of the church, as they are held to not be able to make an informed decision as to matters of faith without having first attained a minimum age. Upon attainment of such age, young Amish make a concious choice as to whether or not to remain Amish and join the Church. In this respect, Anabaptist children have far greater freedom that most.

And, only members of the Church can be married within the Church. I.e., there are no "under-aged" girls entering into "arranged" marriages.

by jamesrl

I'm pretty aware of Mennonite communities in Canada. While it is true that consent is required of those being married that is also true of the many arranged marriages in the asian communities in Canada. Perhaps we should consider a sliding scale of "arranged" versus a black and white arranged/not arranged. There is in these cases a varying degree of pressure from parents to accept their choice, and potential for penalties. And of course even in the Mennonite commuities it varies from the Old order to the more "progressive" groups.

I've seen the documentary about Amish kids going through their year of decision, and also sene the docs on bundling. AFAIK, doesn't happen here with the Mennonites.

I never intended to give the impression that there were underage marriages happening in the Mennonite/Amish communities. That has happened in the Warren Jeffs case in a breakaway Mormon sect that trives to live communally like the Amish, but there is no relationship at all between the two.

James

by onbliss

...is this lousy "Thank You (EOM)". ha ha :-)

Merry Christmas to you and your family. Keep Smiling.

by onbliss

... situations where the group's pursuit of happiness is more important than an individual's?

by maxwell edison

...I believe that individual should always have the choice to opt out.

Disclaimer: This ALL presupposes that government infrastructure and government social programs are treated differently. And for the most part, all of my comments apply to government social programs -- and we all know what they are.

by onbliss

...so how would we be able to exist as we are if all (or a threshold number) opt out?

Do you think there could be policies or laws that will not fall into those two buckets? Or that there might be some gray area?

by drowningnotwaving

(Note that this is a conglomerate of some points including the stream with onbliss . . )

[i]government infrastructure and government social programs[/i]

-> Police and speeding fines = Fundamental infrastructure.
-> Police stopping parent kidnapping and killing child from disowned spouse = Fundamental infrastructure but jumping in too early is possible social programme;
-> Police determining at what age is a child too young to operate a saw-mill (5yo, 8yo, 10yo, 12yo or 14yo) = possible social programme.

Is there possibly a grey area in the interpretation?

(Please assume a broad definition of 'police' to include whatever appropriate agency as such).

[i]Free Markets may not be perfect, but allowing them to run their natural course with minimal government interference is exponentially better than government control of absolutely every aspect of a person's life.[/i]

In my readings from your posts taken as a whole, I don't understand your "minimal governmental interference" to the extent that it can be reasonably discussed. To the point that I assume that you really do mean that "any" interference is inappopriate, which I am sure you don't really think is the case.

Can you give an example of what is acceptible versus what is unacceptible, in order to put a scope or range on what you are saying?

Please (to the extent that it is possible) make it 'personal' - eg the building the Mall on someone else's property, or the anti-trust laws and their impact on business behaviour and the individual freedom of the company and shareholders.

[i]Re Health care "If you got the insurers, lawyers, and the government out of the health care delivery system, prices would plummet, making it MORE affordable for EVERYBODY."[/i]

AGREED. Yes. Get them out. Then you could completely socialise healthcare and have an affordable and predictable cost. There are countries in the world that do this, where consistently their 'standard of living' is rated higher than the US, Australia or NZ (where healthcare is one factor of many).

Of course that definition is iffy, and of course they have social desires / programmes / governments under which you or I may not wish to live.

But if we get the doctors (continually raising exhorbitant and monopolistic fees), lawyers, insurance companies and what not out of the equation then it can actually work. Screws up the free-market concept of lawyers being able to make a living for themselves but what the heck. That would get votes!

When I say "safety net" you are indeed pretty quick with the broad brush, saying that is 'overused and overabused'. I could also say that your aim of zero intervention is farsical in that it has never existed and will never exist, but I don't think you actually belive in zero intervention. Just trying to put a scope on what it is that you actually beleive in practise...

That's not really a question but if you want / don't want to comment...

[i]Look at the simple question that started this discussion, the one about a teenage boy working in a saw mill[/i]

Let's look at that then.

I absolutely AGREE that there are 12 and 14 y'olds totally capable of performing this task.

But where does it stop (or, more aptly, start)?

There are thousands of studies globally about the development of young people's brains, intelligence, reflexes, lateral vision, hearing development, concentration phases of development. Thousands.

And there are millions of parents for whom their child is by far the brightest little bee in the nest. To de-trivialise, it is fair to say that many parents over-estimate the development of their child beyond what the science and evidence would say.

So the question(s): Is there an 'age' that having a child in a saw mill is just wrong? Is it 12? Is it 10? Or does it not exist - should a child as young as 5 be able to walk around a working saw mill, picking up pieces of off-cuts and clearing up the floor?

And another related question: Are the Amish so disorganised that they couldn't get their children doing the myriad other tasks that go into making a farm work, and leave the saw-milling to the (let's say) 14-y'olds and over?

edited for speiling and grama

by tony hopkinson

for providing a big back garden, some tools and packs of seeds and leaving me with a driving need to plant and grow stuff I can eat.

He never paid me for the labour or the food, he even made me pick it. :(

But for the fact I used to earn my beer money doing other people's gardens, that I used to sell the spares and that my mum could spend money on other things because there was never a shortage of greens and roots, I wouldn't have benefited at all.

Nanny's aren't socialists, they are fascists.

I started gardening at seven years old, one garden fork only three tines, that was taller than I was. Loved it, still do. I like sawing up wood too.
How I became a programmer is a total mystery to me.

by onbliss

I always felt the pendulum swinging in just one plane was an insufficient model to depict our life. It just had a left-center-right; too simplistic.
But, wrecking ball can swing in multiple planes. No longer is the model confined to depicting just left or center or right. It captures better what happens in our life. So many possibilities....

by onbliss

Well I was just probing further the phrase used by James. I just considered it as a marriage that is being arranged by two families.

by jamesrl

http://www.courttv.com/news/polygamy/112106_ctv.html

I've seen interviews with some women involved in other Warren Jeffs cases. This is why we need laws to protect those who as minors cannot protect themselves.

An adult child can refuse an arranged marriage, a minor sometimes cannot.

So yes it does still happen in North America (Jeffs spends time in both the US and Canada).

James

by maxwell edison

And how do YOU believe those "gray areas" should be defined?

How would we be able to exist, you ask? Just fine, is my answer. You apparently believe that without government nannyism, we'd all perish! At least that's how it appears the premise of your question is. (OH NO, How will we exist? We're DOOMED!)

by onbliss

A great person, once, said "Less to me equals None to others" (reference: https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=206301&messageID=2139484)

I think something along the same lines can be said about "optimum" or "more". And any urgings for some kind of control does not automatically translate to nannyism. "Necessary to me equals Nannyism to others" ....well it does not come out that nicely.

So if a country does not have enough people, because they all opted out, to fight for it, enough farmers to produce food, enough teachers to teach, doctors to treat, cops to police etc. would be fine I suppose. Such things do not fall into infrastructure or social programs. Oh well, if you want to squeeze them into two buckets, please do so.

My premise is simple, at times I will have to sacrifice my individualism for the common good. When? What? It is going to depend. Example, I would like to sit and watch the Sunday football, but if my friend wants some kind of assistance in moving; I would assist.

Would I do it all the time? Probably not. If I see a pattern that a friend is just trying to use me all the time without any gratitude or reciprocity; then it is time to rethink about that friendship. I can [b]not[/b] put the common good ALL the time over my individual interests, nor can I put my individual interests ahead of the common good all the time.

As the thought goes "man is a social animal". In order for me to desire a society that I would like to live, if it means that I have to compromise now and then; so be it.

The numbers after your TR id, just goes to prove how many people you have helped here. And your posts in several threads have shown that you are compassionate (I still remember the pledge for $5 per mile). So I am not accusing of anything.

Since I asked you a straight question, you could either answer or choose not to answer. Mocking, is a kind of intimidation tactic. [b]Especially when it is false[/b]. You apparently assume a lot of "apparent" things about me, you could just ask simple questions to get the same answer.

Note: I use the word all to either indicate all (100%) or a threshold figure.

by jdclyde

just that you should not be able to pick and choose who is guilty and who you let slide.

If the law shouldn't be enforced, it should be repealed.

by jamesrl

Would you charge both the man driving his pregnant wife who is labour to the hospital and the young kid who was street racing? Or should there be some discretion. Or should we throw out the law altogether?

James

by jdclyde

An Ambulance does not speed because it puts people at risk, even with the lights and sirens kicking.

Someone recklessly speeding while distracted like that are a threat to everyone around them, would you not agree?

by tonythetiger

[i]a person should have unlimited freedom as long as it does not infringe upon the freedom of another[/i]

Laws are only necessary if and when that infringement actually occurs. My flailing my arms about is perfectly legal until one of them hits someone in the head.

[i]Where does protecting the safety and well-being of the child stop, and protecting the rights of the parent start.[/i]

It would seem simple: All states (and other countries as well I presume) have laws against abuse and neglect of children. As long as you're not doing either, you should be OK.

by maxwell edison

No more "mocking".

However, you did continue with your doomsday scenario when you suggested it would be a free-for-all. No it wouldn't. It never has been in this country, nor would it ever be. Where does that notion come from anyway? Free Markets may not be perfect, but allowing them to run their natural course with minimal government interference is exponentially better than government control of absolutely every aspect of a person's life.

And your "common good" may very well be defined differently than my "common good". For example, every decade from 1800 through 1960, people in America were improving their lot in life, and there were FEWER people living in "poverty" each and every decade. This is especially true for the black families after they were emancipated following the civil war. After the infamous "war on poverty" started in 1964, however, the trend started to reverse. Why do you suppose that is? That didn't get people out of poverty -- it sentenced them to it!

And another example is health care. When do you think it started becoming extremely expensive? When OTHER PEOPLE started paying for it, that's when. Do some research into the growth of the health insurance industry, for example, and you'll see that before lawyers and insurers got into the picture, it was a fairly affordable commodity. And for those who couldn't afford it, there were the scores (or hundreds) of hospitals and clinics supported by religious organizations that NEVER turned away anybody. (Why do you think so many hospitals are Saint Something?) If you got the insurers, lawyers, and the government out of the health care delivery system, prices would plummet, making it MORE affordable for EVERYBODY.

The Social Security system has made it HARDER for people to plan for their own retirement and/or have a comfortable retirement. And the current system is promising upwards of 20 TRILLION dollars in payments that are neither included in current budget projections or stashed away in some magic "lock-box". Talk about a doomsday scenario, Social Security is doomed to fail because there will be more people taking from it than those paying into it.

Why is it that none of these social programs ever "solve" the social problems they presumably target? Not only that, but they ALL only get worse. Why is that? And there are people who want to "solve the problem" with MORE of the same. I believe the way to avoid getting into a deeper hole is to STOP DIGGING. What do you suggest? A bigger shovel and more people digging? (Not mockery, but a real question.) As far as social programs and government interference into individual lives, we were better off in 1950 than we are today. And I believe the myriad social programs we have in place are not only wrong and immoral, but they're extremely damaging.

Your desired outcome can be achieved ONLY with my desired system of free enterprise with emphasis on individual responsibility and individual liberty.

Look at the simple question that started this discussion, the one about a teenage boy working in a saw mill. That's a question that should NEVER come up in the first place. It's as ludicrous as some government busy-body or some goody-two-shoes advocate trying to tell you, for your own good, what you may or may not eat. And that would never happen, would it?

by jdclyde

sounds like the definition of extortion? The government will send big Louie around if you don't "donate" to people that did not prepare themselves to be successful.

If you do not get a high school diploma, you have no one to blame but yourself.

If you did not get additional training either via college, trade schools, or on-the-job training, you have no one to blame but yourself.

If you "can't afford" something because you are living beyond your means, you have no one to blame but yourself.

If you started a family you can't afford, you have no one to blame but yourself.

Not having all the pretty toys does not make you a victim.

by maxwell edison

John doesn't want to "contribute", so he doesn't pay his taxes.

The government will place a lien on John's house.

The government will send the sheriff (Or would it be a Federal Marshall?) to physically throw John out of his house if he doesn't willingly vacate.

John refuses, and he attempts to protect his "private property" by exercising his Second Amendment right to "bear arms".

In the fracas that follows, John is shot dead by the Sheriff.

John was executed by his government because he did not want to "contribute" to someone else's "cause".

Sarcasm? Yes, it is. But the scenario could indeed happen.

by drowningnotwaving

Under which banner does the provision of legal aid fall?

Is it offering basic protection to those that can't afford it?

Or is it a gross mis-direction of funds and people should be able to / made to fend for themselves?

And should a government official or elected representative be able to apply for, and be given, "legal aid" when they are rich enough and have resources enough to pay the initial invoices themselves?

(Note that this is distinct to winning a case and having an award made by the judge for the payment of your fees by the other party).

by maxwell edison

Access to our legal system, or lack thereof, is another abomination in and of itself. But we shouldn't attempt to fix that wrong by implementing another one that only accommodates it.

by jdclyde

This is all my understanding based on the few law classes I had. If wrong, oops.

Legal aid is part of your civil liberty, and is there as more of a check to the power of the judicial.

Check and balance is an important part of any government to avoid corruption and abuse.

A very limited "free" option should be there for people that just can't afford an attorney, but because of the time that they are allotted per case, you clearly will be represented better by a private attorney who will have more resources to devote to your case.

Fair? Life isn't fair, so get over it.

Are you "buying justice"? For the most part, I don't think so. You just are more likely to be better represented by someone that can devote the time to research your case, if it isn't a straight forward case.

anyone that uses the court appointed lawyer for a murder trial is at a big dissadvantage, while if it is over driving violations it is a "good enough".

Did that answer the question? A MINIMAL amount of "free" resources should be available.

Representatives are generally represented by the government bodies lawyer if it is in relation to their position.

by maxwell edison

You said, [i]"Since I asked you a straight question, you could either answer or choose not to answer."[/i]

Actually, I really DID need for "gray area" to be defined before I could answer a question about it. I NEVER "evade" a question. For example, from my perspective we are so far beyond "gray area" that it's ridiculous. (Just like I suggested that the "safety net" has become a sleep-number bed.)

by jamesrl

In my neck of the woods, ambulances speed, but only when they deem it medically necessary. (Never seen "Mother Jugs and Speed?)

Police cars do too. Last night I was in a left hand turning lane of a 4 lane road (4 lanes without turning lanes) at a light that hand just turned red when a police car came up behind me. After a second he hit the lights and blipped the siren. I didn't have anywhere to pull over to, so I ended up pulling into the intersection and turning right - the oncoming traffic on my left had stopped for me and the officer.

I do agree that it might be a problem to drive fast for many drivers. Some might be able to handle it. In most case you'd be better off pulling over and waiting for an ambulance.

But would I allow the officers to have the discretion to report or not report the incident, depending on their judgment - yes.

There are many many examples. We sometimes go the other direction and charge kids as adults when the situation warrants it. In that case we trust the judge to make the call, under criteria the lawmakers set.

I don't believe in laws that will be ignored and never enforced. But some laws require the judgement of an experienced officer to decide.

James

by onbliss

Free-for-all? Can you point to the exact post where anything that I said could have been inferred as "free-for-all"? If necessary, I can clarify.

Yes, I agree my "common good" could be defined differently by you. I guess that is why we have elections, and we vote for the candidate who portrays to be holding similar views. Sometimes your definition wins, sometimes my definition wins. This behavior pulls the society from all directions and sometimes it moves forward; and sometimes sidewards or backwards. And that is why we sit and argue here. Cycle continues!

This is where I would like to quote Tony Hopkinson:

"While I rarely agree with Max on most issues, small government or more to the point minimum legislation is something we do agree on.

We have different ideas on what the minimum should consist of, of course. :D"

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=206301&messageID=2139801

I do not subscribe to the thought of any minority appeasements in any kind of society. I believe every body has to fight their way up. If a lazy person does not get what s/he wants, then I am not going to complain. If the playing field is not level, or if there is discrimination then there is something to discuss and take action.

You citing "War on Poverty", "Healthcare", "Social Security" systems etc. were what I thought you called about social programs. I was talking about the gray areas. In my opinion it is worthwhile for the society to pause, and makes an effort to improve the lives of the people who are lagging. And if a system does not seem to work; then it is time to look for another system or tool. Applying the IT adaptation of law of diminishing returns, putting more resources will not yield the desired result.

I think a family can play a good, if not great, part in providing the best social security to an individual. Social security does not just come from monetary aspects. Money is important; but happiness can not be measured by it alone. Security in terms of physical, emotional and monetary can be provided, in varying degrees, by the family.

I have never argued against individual responsibility or liberty. I just don't argue on things that I agree with other people :-), and I am not sure how any of what I have been saying is against them.

Point being sacrifices - of the right kind and right amount, by the right people - will help the society. We all do this, I do not think there is any individual who does not do it. It is a matter of how many times and how much we do.

by onbliss

Sometimes it is tough to define the gray areas. Do I have the definition or answer. I do not know. But what I am looking for is the attitude that is ready to acknowledge the [b]possibility[/b] of the gray area existing. Because if that exists, then we, as a society, could discuss things on a case by case basis.

by drowningnotwaving

Toi use Tony's quote from another point . .

[i]...an interesting and lucrative case to both prosecute and defend?

Both in our current world, designed by the lawyers for lawyers.[/i]

The unfortunate facts of life include the one that laws are made by lawyers. Clarity, simplicity, applicability and efficacy are not going to be automatic criteria.

That's not too far away from Exxon sponsoring climate change study.

It would seem, in both instances, the lawyers or scientists are very much aware of how their bread is buttered.

If it was a simple as a sledge hammer Max at least we'd know, at any one point in time, where we stood. Might not agree with it, of course, but it would be very clear.

And then where would these threads be? :)

by jamesrl

A couple of points on that.

Yes lawyers are the dominant profession in most elected governments, but that doesn't tell the whole story. Many of the lawyers elected never practised law, or practised in an area that doesn't help them in crafting laws. Its one thing to practise law, its another to write it.

I don't put it down to maliciousness. Sometimes the only way to test something is to have it go to court and be argued out. If it was all cut and dried then we wouldn't need constitutional trials right?

It is in the politicans best interest to write laws well, because if they spend all their time rewriting ro redefining existing stuff, they never get to do anything new and thats how people make careers - with new stuff. You can't really campaign on - voted to modify the existing law because it was unclear. You can campaign on - passed new laws....

James

by deadly ernest

sky rocket in that state. Once in place, such laws would prohibit the use of children doing chores on a farm, or around the house if you do any work at home. All apprenticeship schemes would have to stop.

Much better if the Amish set up a community wide apprenticeship scheme were children in the age group can register, then try out different industries as part of the scheme. That would shut the trouble makers up.

by tonythetiger

[i]Is there an 'age' that having a child in a saw mill is just wrong? Is it 12? Is it 10? Or does it not exist - should a child as young as 5 be able to walk around a working saw mill, picking up pieces of off-cuts and clearing up the floor?[/i]

Each case is different, and should be treated differently. If the government doesn't want to take the time and resources required to analyze every case, then they should remove the restrictions from the law books and turn that task over to someone who does. In this case, that would be the parents. If the government observes and believes the parents are doing this incorrectly, they can prosecute the parent for abuse and/or neglect. That's the way I believe the law is supposed to work.

Laws that regulate activities which do not violate the rights of others except under certain circumstances should only be enforced when those circumstances occur, or when there is a reasonable cause to believe they will occur if that specific activity by that specific individual continues.

by maxwell edison

...are really moot, because they all presuppose the you or I know what's better for others than they know for themselves. Moreover, I want to discuss the "root issue", but the diversion is to go into scores of scenarios involving "gray areas". And to suggest that one MUST consider such "gray areas" is to suggest there is NO underlying foundation upon which to build.

Those are all loser's questions, and they're evasive in their own way, detracting from the underlying premise. Your "gray area" is different than my "gray area", and the REAL QUESTION gets overlooked when people argue over their respective "gray areas".

The basic question: Should one person BE FORCED to serve the needs of another person? That's the ONLY question we should be asking -- and just let ALL the chips fall where they may. I think you answered no to that question, but you then go on to suggest why the answer should be yes.

Moreover, you, and people like you, are just dead wrong when you suggest that hoards of people will perish, or will be delegated to lives on the street, or will go hungry, or would be doomed, etc. Before 1960, when (the American) government wasn't everybody's nanny, we not only got along fine, but we actually got along BETTER.

Any discussion other than to address those two points only diverts from the real issue. There are simply TOO MANY people who try to FORCE others to behave a certain way and/or are too busy-body for their own good. Even as a compromise, if I were willing to accept a "small amount" of collectivism, we'd still need to scale it back about 90 percent.

It's just wrong for you to force others to serve your needs. And when people pay taxes for social programs that you enjoy, that's exactly what you're doing. And to mask what you're really doing, you then advocate the notion that you know better than others what's really good for them. I simply can't imagine seeing one's fellow man in such a way to suggest I'm superior to them.

As an interesting side-note, look at the replies we're getting in the "find a job in IT" thread. Here I am telling people that I'm NOT superior to them, that they CAN succeed, that they DO have the wherewithal to find what they seek, and they tell me I'm wrong.

In other words, they tell me that I'm better than them, even though I disagree, but they then go on to support programs that force me to pay for them. I'll never win any arguments with such people, but I'm damn sure glad I'm not like them.

by drowningnotwaving

The overall point - should I be FORCED to [b]serve[/b] another person?

No, never.

Do I have OBLIGATIONS to other people? Absolutely yes.

Where "I" choose not to follow those obligations, should I be forced to? Absolutely yes.

You don't want to get into the detail whereas I think it is there where the problem lies.

I think an "injustice" is where a person or a company acts in a way that they think is proper, but proves to be otherwise. I think it is the government's responsibility to act on that injustice and ensure it stops and never happens again to the detriment of others.

I think most of the issues come, certainly in my part of the world, on the interpretation of injustice versus the freedom of the first party to do pretty much whatever they think they can.

But if you don't want to get into the detail, it does become moot.

Because I think without the detail you can hide behind a facade of being the tough freedom fighter and not expose yourself to the realities of what actually does happen in the world.

by drowningnotwaving

Give it 25 years at best.

Then they'll be BEGGING for the government to step in about the Amish tradition.

Funny thing that.

by deepsand

Having grown up along side a sizable community of Old Order Amish, in central Pennsylvania, and become intimately familiar with them, I can assure you that they continue to flourish, to the extent that they are continually expanding into areas either ignored or deserted by other farmers, starting new communities as they continue to outgrow the space available to older ones.

They are a strong and self reliant people, who have never, and will never, seek any sort of governmental assistance.

by tonythetiger

the government suddenly decides they know better what's good for them and makes them take assistance.

by maxwell edison

Amazing in the sense that you contradicted yourself in two consecutive sentences.

Should a person be FORCED to serve another person? Your answer is no.

Does a person have an OBLIGATION to other people? Your answer is, absolutely yes.

This sounds like an answer from a guy who wants it both ways.

Okay then, two-faced one, should a person be FORCED to meet that OBLIGATION to other people?

(Obligation defined: The act of binding oneself by a social, legal, or moral tie.)

For the record, here is my take on your word-play.

I DO have an obligation to provide for my family. And I DO have an obligation to provide for myself. But what about other people? Am I the only one with such obligations? Do OTHER people ALSO have an obligation to provide for themselves and their family? Of course they do. I do not, however, have an obligation to provide for person who chooses to not even provide for himself. Moreover, I don't even have an "obligation" to provide for person who cannot provide for himself, especially if it makes it more difficult -- or even impossible -- to provide for myself and my family.

And when half of my income is taken away from me to provide for either of those two groups of people, the government is indeed making it more difficult -- or impossible -- for me to provide for myself and my family. The government, by way of all you double-talk, touchy-feely, busy-body people, is creating a dependent society. It is YOU and people like you who are creating an environment in which fewer and fewer people are able to meet even their own obligations.

Other people might see my views as "mean-spirited", but if you look at the OBVIOUS conflict, it is THEY who are really the mean-spirited lot, because they strip people of their spirit and dignity, and they deny them their God-given right to meet their OWN obligations and not become a burden on others.

You know, it's okay to speak for yourself, and even act accordingly. If you feel "obligated" to meet the needs of every Tom, Dick, and Harry who can't -- or won't -- meet their own obligations, that's your business. But when you presume to force others (by your vote) to do it, you've gone too far. You are taking the moral low-ground here, even though you may see it otherwise.

Would you like to try again? Or are you willing to rest your case on your double-talk?

by drowningnotwaving

Your addition of one word "provide" which I didn't say once whatsoever has enabled you to take a particular path suited to your overall argument.

I didn't say I have an obligation to 'provide' (per se) only that I have an obligation.

Look carefully. In this specific discussion, that is an inherent assumption by you.

Specific examples?

--> Do I have an obligation to pay taxes for my defence forces to be available to come to my / my fellow country-men's defence?

If I "choose" not to, is it okay to either force me to pay my dues or kick me the f'ck out of the country?

Or, are full-on tax dodgers (and you and I know they exist) just living their righteous dream?

Surely there is something fundamentally socialist about a tax dodger.

Is it right to force them to pay up or f'ck off (the lattter including jailing them)?

--> Should the taxes I pay, living in Colorado, also contribute to the defence force in Miami? Yes. Of course. It directly affects me though I don't see it.

--> pick any of a million examples.

Look, you're right okay? YOU'RE RIGHT that the detail will not progress a discussion.

Going into the quagmire of detail can only lead us through centuries of examples on 'either side'. I can find thousands of exmaples that justify my side, as I very well know you can justify yours.

I have freedom and I have responsbilities. I cannot see any clash of definition whatsoever.

Your semantics calls this the distinction between [i]"government infrastructure and government social programs"[/i].

To be VERY specific, what you say is (the necessary evil of) basic government infrastructure, I call my obligation to participate.

Let's (happily?) agree that the extent of that infrastructure is a point of difference.

But to some extent you have agreed it is necessary.

If I want to live in downtown USA using the streets schools and local police, or even alone in the hills in my camp with 6 generations and 13 wives (but knowing someone will stop the commies coming over the horizon), can I do that with no obligation to share in the cost of the infrastructure?

To paraphrase your position, you would aim for the [b]absence of all direct or coercive government as a political ideal[/b] and you propose the [b]cooperative and voluntary association of individuals and groups as the principal mode of organized society[/b].

And if it looks familiar, it is. It is the definition of Anarchy.

On paper and in a discussion it looks brilliant. Too good to be true.

Which is why it has never, ever, ever worked.

edit grama

by drowningnotwaving

To make access free, you either ...

--> make the system 'free' (that is your taxes paying for it, and limit the free-market ability of young entrepreneurial lawyers).

Or

--> you let the system grow into what it is and provide (pay for) access for those who simply can't afford it?

Or

--> you say 'screw them, they're gnats anyway'?

Am I missing an alternative?

by maxwell edison

....you're not obligated to do anything. Like I said in another thread, we apparently don't speak the same language.

You're a strange one indeed.

by maxwell edison

FREE means NOBODY pays. I'm sick of people's defenition of FREE as being somebody else pays for it.

As usual, you fail to address what I really say.

by drowningnotwaving

and, in making broad sweeping statements:

[i]our legal system, or lack thereof, is another abomination in and of itself[/i]

...you deny any discussion.

I put three alternatives to try to define what the heck your response could possibly be talking about, and you again infer that I have told you HOW it should be done!!!

I didn't tell you anything!!

Is it a precondition of republicanism to be totally paranoid??? If your specific responses today are a measure then I'd conclude "quite possibly".

I must be strange. But it's the festive season so that's not unusual.

by tonythetiger

[i]cooperative and voluntary association of individuals and groups as the principal mode of organized society[/i]

The [b]principal[/b] mode, not the only one. Government is still required to act as traffic cop when an individual asserting their rights (LL&PoH) conflicts with or violates the rights of others.

Which rights of others am I violating that it should cost 45% of my earnings to redress?

by jdclyde

But the decision to not endanger the lives of the crew and everyone else on the streets was make. the Ambulance does get right-of-ways, and so can make better time than the average citizen, but they generally do not exceed the recommended limit on the roads (here in Michigan).

The same is true regarding cops and high speed pursuits. If the offense is not great, they are to call off the chase. It is seen as reckless to risk someone getting killed in a high speed pursuit over someone that did a rolling stop or something, so they call off the chase. generally, they have the plates, and maybe even follow from the air, and hope to catch up to them later.

The public safety is not compromised lightly.

by drowningnotwaving

TonytheTiger, NOT for agreeing, but for getting the point ...

Freedom without responsibility is what my little boy had three months ago.

But now, being nine months old, even he is learning there are some limits.

We can and will argue the limits of that responsility / obligation at length, but to suggest it doesn't exist is the stuff of fantasy.

Perhaps Max never learnt the distinction.

by drowningnotwaving

I agree. There is a basic responsibility to make sure people have some access to legal representation / instruction / guidance in criminal cases.

In New Zealand, 'formal' legal aid does not exist for civil cases / lawsuits, with the exception of basic aid

And I do also take Tony's point that people can represent themselves.

I'd suggest that for, if nothing else other than the basic efficiency of the court & prison system, that the legal aid solution is actually cheaper to me the taxpayer in the long term.

by deepsand

do so [i]involuntarily[/i], by virtue of [i]duress[/i], as opposed to coercion.

For example, in the Amish communities, as one must affirm his desire to join the Church, and as the Church cannot neither marry those who are not members nor those who do not consent to such, nor can the Church shun those members who refuse to marry, there is no duress.

by deepsand

You can write all the assistance checks that you like; the Amish will never use them.

Bear in mind that the Anabaptists, whilst in Europe, were persecuted in Europe, during the 15th and 16th centuries, to the point of being literally boiled in oil, and their properties confiscated, by the established churches of the times.

They are a hardy folk, well used to peaceably defending themselves from the "English," as they refer to those of us outside their community.

This discussion is closed to new replies.