Graphics card theory question
~In theory~
Do nvida graphics cards work better in intel systems?
and, would it be true to say the same about ATI in AMB systems?
or does it matter?
Thanks for the input
Hardware
~In theory~
Do nvida graphics cards work better in intel systems?
and, would it be true to say the same about ATI in AMB systems?
or does it matter?
Thanks for the input
by snuffy09 Accepted solution
by snuffy09 Accepted solution
by older mycroft Accepted solution
Each combination has been exemplary in practice and equally redoubted in theory and vice versa.
Since very few users ever get the chance to carry out clinical soak tests of both possibilities, they tend to either be influenced by industry standards and computer magazine 'lab tests', or to go with their own beliefs and soldier on into the fray.
My only viable comparison was about four years ago when a top of the range laptop got stolen for the second time (Intel/ATI combination) then I replaced it with a laptop powered with an AMD/Nvidia combination.
Only the AMD/Nvidia combo gave my fish to look at in FarCry.
Prior to that laptop, neither of the other two NBs had featured aquatic images within the loaded program.
If anything was drawn from that experience back then, it can't really bear fruit now though since my current tower has an Intel Core2Duo E8500 with an Nvidia 8800GT but this time the fish ARE there.
So there! :)
by ---tk--- Accepted solution
its all about what you prefer... I have gone back and forth between the two well... four... Lab tests and benchmarks really doesn't make a difference to me. I view the technical spec's and other people's opinion, and their personal experience.
The only thing I know at this point, my friend has a AMD quad core, and a 9800GTX. I have a core 2 Quad and a 9800GTX+. And I do not see any difference in performance and gaming.
by jamesrl Accepted solution
When we are talking about a single graphics card in a system, then it doesn't really matter who makes the CPU. More important are things like the bus speed etc, and those are specific to the chipset, the controlling chips which determine the features and functionality of the motherboard itself. Intel, AMD/ATI, nVidia, SiS, Via and others make these chipsets. Moderns chipsets are referred to as Northbridge and Southbridge, but most people focus on the Northbridge set.
But even there, there are no serious differences between two "equal" chipsets/graphics card matchups based on the manufacturer.
But, there are ways to use two or more cards together on a MB to increase your speed, and those are specific to the graphics chipset - SLI for nVidia, Crossfire for ATI. Those protocols are part of the motherboard chipset.
There is also a hybrid ATI crossfire scenario where if your MB supports it, you can use the processing power of the ATI graphics chip on the MB to combine with an ATI graphics card in the PCI Express slot, to speed up the graphics.
Hope that helps.
James
by ---tk--- Accepted solution
by jamesrl Accepted solution
There is an old theory we used to have, that an improvement of less than 10% is considered to be "not perceptable".
One of your systems may be faster than the other on paper, all things being equal.
But since background tasks often take up CPU and memory, and the number and type of those tasks vary widely, its kinda moot unless you build a machine from scratch for comparison sake and don't install other apps or drivers.
I too have gone back and forth between cards, and I often use benchmarking tools like 3DMark and FRAPS to check how I am doing. I prefer ATI cards for visual quality, but I find that ATI drivers are not my favorite.
I currently run a Radeon 4850. Previous to that a nVidia 8800 GT, before that a Radeon X1900....
James
by slayer_ Accepted solution
And too me, requiring .NET is reason enough to not use something. I've been building custom .NET installers and I have seen first hand the damage .NET does to a system.
Example, .NET 1 after a certain hotfix, is cemented into your system, if you try to reinstall your system will die with nonstop BSOD's. Only way to fix is a reinstall of Windows.
by jamesrl Accepted solution
You can install the "Omega" drivers for ATI cards - they use the driver, but not the ATI control software, so no .Net.
Lots of software requires .net, but my problem is in versioning. I've had too early a version and too new a version, and you have to carefully unintsall and reinstall.
James
by older mycroft Accepted solution
What badge do you have on your steam-powered PC then ?
You cannot make a sweeping Anti-Dot-Net statement like that, then depart without justifying your vehemence. ;)
by snuffy09 Accepted solution
by slayer_ Accepted solution
Like Java...
Both at one point, ruined my home system.
Once I installed java and it turned off windows firewall and wouldn't let it reenable. The only way to fix it was thru system restore. My ISP required Java for one of their web help apps, after I told em this they gave me free internet for 3 months for the trouble.
.NET???
I have seen the performance loss on a system by trying it on VM's. Also on my personal computer wrecked my system once, after it was installed, suddenly Explorer kept crashing over and over. I uninstalled .NET and suddenly everything was fine again.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending