Discussion Locked

grey listing to fight spam

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Has anyone ever heard of greylisting as a defense to combat spam? I just read an article on this, which I plan on re-reading.... http://www.onlamp.com/pub/a/bsd/2007/01/18/greylisting-with-pf.html
But, from what I understand of it.... You work with 3 lists...
[i]
This makes three lists of clients:

* Whitelist: known good clients.
* Blacklist: known bad clients.
* Greylist: we don't know if they are good or bad yet, but we will soon decide.

The key to grey listing is knowing that good and kind mail servers do not mind being politely asked to come back later. This is part of the STMP protocol. Spammers, however, are cheap and nasty. They don't like this. They probably won't come back later. Why? Queue management is tricky. If you're sending to millions of email addresses, why worry about a few messages that you cannot deliver? Just skip along to the next one. Spammers work on volume. Grey listing exploits that characteristic.[/i]

Now, what I think is the crutz of grey listing is the fact that you are asking any email that you do not know to come back and try again. If it doesn't, it is most likely a spam email and it rolls to the blacklist... Otherwise, it is very possibly a good guy...

I'm going to be starting an online server business, and in that it is small. I definitely think I will implement this along with a few other defense's. It's not a defense in my eyes unless there is at least 3 layers to it, but that's only my opinion. But, in larger organizations. Would grey listing be a valid defense? Because, the way I understand this. There would be a lag in the initial receipt of an email until the address makes it to the white list.

This article was written for BSD/Linux.... But, I would think grey listing could be done on any OS.

Dan

5 replies

by jaqui

with greylisting is the very high chance of false positives.
that being a high chance of mistakenly identifying someone as a spammer.

a person sending an email through their isp or a webmail account may not be in a position to make sure that the email is retried later. not all email service providers support this.

by danlm

The web site I am setting up will be directed at regular people. I was going to use this as part of my protection of mail services, but this could end up being more of a deterrent then asset if false positives would be high.

Hmm, ok.....

Thanks Jaqui.

Dan

by jaqui

I can't say they would be high, but the possibility they could be high is there.

Try getting yahoo or hotmail message through a greylist system, if that works then you have most people covered fairly well.

I would do some serious testing with different webmail services and, if possible, different isp email services before making a yes or no decision. if you find that a lot of them are problems then nope, don't use it.
if most work fine then it is a viable option. :)

by danlm

For the article you sent me. I was doing things with my daughter, so I it took me some time to read it.

Much appreciated it.

Dan

This discussion is closed to new replies.