Discussion Locked

HDD speeds lag behind MB & CPU advances

0 helpful
15 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Looking at the advances in MB, RAM, and CPU speeds. At what point will the manufacturers realize that the HDD is one of the biggest bottlenecks in the modern PC(for general use)? Obviously, you can spend a mint and invest in SCSI( and even SCSI can't keep up with them), but, until its pricing is inline with what the general public is willing to pay, it really is a moot point. You'd think they would realize that IDE/EIDE HD is the mainstream component that needs the most attention.
Granted, that the additional speed of the RAM, and CPU do add to the overall performance of any system, if coupled correctly with other peripherals. But, its useless if the HD can't deliver the goods fast enough for the extra system speed to really shine.
Any thoughts?

15 replies

by admin

heheheehe :)

Oh, and huge amounts of processing and RAM onboard with the GPU.

by guruofdos

My first computer (PC that is) was (and still goes!!) a 386DX33 with a whopping 4MB of RAM and a vast 100Mb of 19.5mS IDE hard drive.

I have sat in front of me, a modest beast with a 20Gb Hard disk and 256Mb of RAM and a 1GHz Duron.

Just for gag value...created a 120Mb 'RAM DISK', copied entire HDD from 386 to ram disk, cranked her up and off she went!!! Running Dos 6.22, W3.11 and Word 1.1, Excel 3.0......like greased weasel shit off a chromed shovel!!!!

Oh yes....bypass the HDD and these 'puter thingys really fly. But what do peeps expect from motor and solenoid technology?!!! We use solid state disks (like ram disks) that fit onto the IDE interface. Yes, they are volatile, but they have the option to dump to flash on shutdown.

Hmmm....PC133 memory is what now, pennies per meg?? Ram controllers are cheap, lithium ion batteries are cheap....

One question though....how fast do we really want our computers to go?? Faster than we can type and look at the screens?!!! All the processing is done in the CPU and the ram anyway....and our beloved software companies give us pretty animations to look at while our drives are spinning.....so who really gives two hoots?!!!

:)

by admin

Yes, it it to be for fun around town, on the highway, or just for the exhilaration at Bonneville for the hardy few :)

Your machine sounded pretty fun!

by djent

Are you concerned about the price or the speed. If the speed is desired it is available via Ultra 160 or 320 SCSI. Try it and you may decide it is worth the price. If you are a Yugo customer forget about high performance and be happy with the economy, this relates to most things in life.

by raymond danner

The new standard for ATA should speed up EIDE to SCSI speeds...according to the industry magazines I've read articles about it in...although how one can speed up an interface by dropping back to serial (vs. parallel for current ATA) is beyond me. Parallel would seem, at least on the surface, eight to ten times faster than any POSSIBLE serial connection. However, your jibe about "If you are a Yugo customer forget about high performance and be happy with the economy" was unwarranted IMHO. The fact is that SCSI drive technology is well overpriced for what you get, and that was proven multiple times.

Want to know my biggest gripe about current drives? The sheer size! I tremble to think what damage will be done by losing a 120Gb HDD (who hasthe capability of running a full backup of such a monster? Nobody!) with most of its data? It would be (to me) much better to have four 30Gb HDDs or three 40's than one 120Gb, yet that is EXACTLY what some "high-end" systems come with...a 7200rpm 120Gb HDD.

by djent

SATA drives havn't hit the market yet. We will have to wait and see how it works in the wild. One of the advantages of high end SCSI drives is dependability and durability. I prefer Seagate Cheetah for the speed and relibilty. Most IDE drives targetthe consumer market, you can't expect a $60 drive to work as well or as long as a $250 drive and although IDE drives are much cheeper I have no desire to replace them as often as they fail. If SATA drives are consumer level products they offer little improvement over current ATA products.

by zeraf

IDE speeds are fast catching up on SCSI. Firewire is the new drive medium but hard drives are slowly making the transition. Operating systems are just too large to make an all in memory system functional. Even Games systems are adding hard drives, the hard drive will never be replaced.

Look at citrix, it mimics a driveless technology but you have to use storage on the server side.
There is no way to get away from drives as they are non-volital. Memory is volital. And what is the actual bottle neck with drives is the motherboards data transfer rate, not the drive.

Ever had 2 high capacity drives on the same chain and sent data across? It flies like no tomorrow. Go to a drive on another chain and it boggs down, as data is not goingh through motherboard to the other controller.

Microsoft thought of a OS that could fit on a 1.44 meg floppy after a year working on it they scrapped the idea as knew wuold not get sufficeint consumer support to make development cost worthy. Disklesscomputer has the same limitation. And how do you get all the software copmpanies to follow suit and develope for this platform and the drived platform till a diskless system is the norm?

They are pissed enough that they have too keep up with microsoft and mac at the rates they are developing operating systems. You think they want another hardware platform and operating system to contecnd with? This is what is holding linux back.

Good idea, but no real world application. Not that is cost effective and feasable and will get consumer support.

by thechas

Hard drives have always been one of the slower components of a PC. The only slower devices are floppy and tape drives.

The root speed problem is the limits of a mechanical system.

Until we have a major advance in solid-state or optical storage, data storage speeds are not apt to make a significant jump in speed. It boils down to simple physics.

Chas

by guruofdos

What planet are you on?!! I've been using one for weeks!! They are not as fast as IDE, for the same reason RS232 is not as fast as parallel for printing. A nice idea, but UDMA 133 or SCSI is still better.

by jbeaule

Buy a solid state HD. Dunno if they make IDE versions of those, but they are basically huge memory chips that one can use as a HD. So the access to data is instant (or near to) and the price, well, last time I checked, it was arond 50000$ US for a3.5GB unit.

by ghstinshll

If you feel so needy for performance, there's only one thing you can do. Buy an IDE RAID card and stripe the drives... This won't double your performance, but will increase it dramatically...

by djent

Whose drive and controller are you using? Seagate has planned release for 3Q or 4Q 2002.

This discussion is closed to new replies.