Discussion Locked

Hey I am liking free O/S more and more

0 helpful
25 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am a MS system builder and partner but with each update I get a little more p*ssed off at them. I have set up four companys with server 2003, and two with data center. All have XP Pro on all workstations. I have set the Amin. guy up to be able to install and update each workstation by SUS and it worked great until the last update.
Now he gets svhost.exe is using 99% of CPU, and some times wuauclt.exe is doing the same. Why dose MS keep doing this? I posted some thing about the WGA doing this.
Is this some thing new that MS is trying out or just a new update bug?

25 replies

by jaqui

it's MS making sure people see a need to get the hardware that will properly support vista when it's released.

gotta get them sales numbers somehow.

by zlitocook

It has the IT teams at alot of companys just saying no to updates. And updating each computer which is a pain and cost them a ton of money.

by jaqui

I never said it was smart of them :)

I like my linux. use a distro and you can have automatic updates, or a single script to run after testing them that updates the entire network.
[ an f.y.i.: since 1998 I have only had one linux update break anything, and that was distro specific. it was fixed within 24 hours of my telling them about the problem. no support contract needed. [ an apache mod_perl update broke apache ] ]

by ed woychowsky

Over the last weekend I created a dual boot on my laptop, Fedora Core 5 and XP. I've noticed something interesting about the speed difference between the two, Linux is faster. The difference is really apparent when accessing a USB flash drive, Fedora Core is about twice as fast as XP.

It appears the Windows burns CPU cycles for no good reason. Or, it could be something along the lines of what was said about IBM, "The purpose of IBM software is to sell IBM hardware." Makes sense, if you have to upgrade you'll need a new license.

by ed woychowsky

I only installed it Saturday and I've only played around with Linux, but it seems solid. Actually, at first glance, it seems more solid than XP. I'm still having some issues with adding software, rpms are relatively easy, but the dependencies are confusing.

Fedora seems to be the easiest to start with, also there are sites with forums where help can be found.

by cmiller5400

Thank you for your reply. I guess I will download it at 3 gigs. (it will take a while on a dsl 3meg line ]:)

by w2ktechman

Hello Ed,
I agree and have been stating several times that installing depenencies and installs in general are a bit of a problem. Mainly this is compared to Windows and installing there.
As well as you, I have recently been turning to Linux. I tried Fedora 5 on 2 systems, which I had a lot of trouble with. On 1 system, just trying to change to dual screen hosed everything and forced a reinstall. After 4 installs on 2 systems I gave up Fedora and tried SUSE 10. Much better in my opinion (although everyone is different). If you are used to installing RPM's, then the switch is easy as well, since SUSE supports RPM installs.
I find YAST easy to use and very useful as well. The problem is that SUSE is fatter than Fedora, and installs/runs a bit slower.
Just my 2 cents on comparison. If you are interested though, I would suggest looking at it.

by apotheon

You shouldn't have to install using the rpm command. Look into a package manager for Fedora and RHEL called YUM instead. It handles dependencies so you don't have to. Fedora also supports the use of APT-RPM, and RPM-based version of Debian's Advanced Package Tool. Because of the difference in the RPM package format from the DEB package format that Debian uses, there are occasional issues with APT-RPM, but it's easier to use than YUM (in my honest opinion) and runs significantly faster. Either way, though, you're likely to have a much easier time of it than by using the rpm utility directly.

If you choose to use APT for software management, keep an eye on TechRepublic: there should be an article about using APT appearing here before too long.

by jaqui

I use lfs, which is not for newbies. :)
it's the hardest to install and configure of all.

fedora, suse, mandriva are about equal.
for install and functionality.
and for their lack of respect for standards they match microshaft.

by stress junkie

SuSE is great. I've used it since v9.0. Novell has done a lot of work to improve on the ideas that were behind the original SuSE project. System administration tools are very good. Software package management is good. Dependencies are generally handled well. Hardware recognition is generally good. Software patches install quickly and easily.

In short, SuSE is a good choice for people who want to try Linux and for people who are more interested in doing work with their Linux system than in learning system administration.

by marketingtutor.

Preferrably CentOS. You can download the ISOs at:

http://www.centos.org/

In my experience that is the best Linux distro to use. I also like Suse but CentOS is a good one. Its essentailly Red Hat Enterprise Linux that has been stripped of all Red Hat branding and any Red Hat copyrighted material, which is near nil.

by ghost

I totally agree with the blog concerning Mandriva, Redhat, Gentoo, and the like. Most of the newbies out there are at the learning curve that we all were at months or years ago. It takes a little planning( planning to win, planning to fail and have a good idea of the back up OS you will try next. I have incorporated the use of apt-get in my linux distro. Sometimes it takes a little work to set up, but I found the mirrors that the Yum and apt-get uses are totally out of date. If you want to use GUI and constantly fix problems or bugs, don't forget the daily updates use Windows. The documentation can be as vague as the manpages in Linux. To make a long story short, keep using Windows OS, until you have the Linux concept down. There are tons of books and articles that make using Linux the better choice for intermediate to Expert users. It is a great environment for the newbie trying to understand the big picture. Lastly, there is another alternative, it is a distro made by Transfusion.org (Mepis). They have server as well as workstation for the end users wanting to experience the Linux distro.( No sells pitch )

by jaqui

lfs is for going from system/network admin to guru levels ;)

it's a tool to take your skills higher, but require both familiarity with building from sources and comfort with the cli to use it.

it's not meant as an enterprise server or workstation, since the build is not a fast process.
it can be used as either, but I really don't see any responsable admin using a 3 day build process to install a few hundred workstations. [ 3 day per workstation if you have different hardware on each and can't image the final build. ]

by jaqui

their non standards compliant use of the /opt partition / folder.
The Standard says it's for addon packages, which means packages you get [b]completely separate from the distro media[/b] not the gui, apache webserver, cvs server... [ with suse, everying but the base system ]

stupid mistake on their part, no-one sets enough space for their config of using /opt the way they do, since even the commercial software companies with linux products use the /usr hierarchy for their software, when it's those commercial apps that should be in /opt

the other, is in using Red Hat's bugware software management tool, yast is the worst tool available.

by w2ktechman

So, for beginners what do you recommend? Personally I do like the YAST control center, a common place to do a lot of things (if root PW is known).
But if there are better sources out there, I am listening.
I keep hearing that most distros are more complex for a beginner, and to start with Fedora or Suse. I have learned enough to get my MS exchange mail, and do about 70% of my job with it (cant quite lose Windows yet -- token authentication card for many of the internal sites will not work in Linux). But, I have no problem with downloading and trying another distro

by jaqui

most distros have the same integrated control center.

none of the "user friendly" distros is better than 50% standards compliant.

though since the FSF's LSB has gone lightyears beyond what a BASE standard should be the standard is becoming a meaningless document.
[ base should not specify anything more than the base system required to get a linux box running and have the ability to add more software, and administer the system. everything else they specify is grounds to tell them to stick the standard.

as far as a specific distro, it's personal choice, if you like the suse/fedora/rhel distros tools, then it's the right one for you.

Mandriva's Drakx tools are far more user friendly, and function far more efficiently.
[ 5 hours to get fedora updates with yast is a common complaint, same number of updates with mandriva is about half an hour... about 750 mb of updates, suse did update faster than fedora, but the tools organisation and the default config settings for fedora, rhel and suse are a complete screwup. ]
I told each one to not start the gui at boot, all of them ignored that.
then they disable root login from a gui.
stupidity to not pay attention to user input during install and try to stop the user from configuring it to function the way they want.
even debian seems to start a gui by default when you install it during the initial install.

none of them but mandriva gives you a config screen during the install to tell you what services are starting by default and allow you to disable those you don't want running by default.

I'm not impressed with any distro for making grub the default bootloader, I like LILO for my bootloader.
[ this includes mandriva ]

most of the distros have actually stopped offering any bootloader but grub.

debian offers lilo, if you fight it for the bootloader, but during a network install it refuses to actually install lilo. I install via network since getting debian's 14 cdrom software repository to read in for local repository has always left me seriously unimpressed with performance of debian for package management, the network install it works better.

[ ubuntu, kubuntu, edubuntu all don't offer any bootloader but grub, and refuse to give you a cli only box. ]

because of my strong opinions on what I want with my boxes, I use a distro that is 100% only what I want above the base system, far more so than even debian, slak or gentoo are.

by apotheon

The first thing you need to do when deciding what distro to use is figure out what you're going to be doing. There really isn't a one-size-fits-all solution, generally speaking, though Debian comes really damned close.

If you just want to pick something to learn that creates a "feature rich" user environment for a desktop system with web browser, GUI email client, word processor, and so on, something like SuSE, Mandriva, or Fedora Core will work just well. On the other hand, you'd be better served with something else if you think you'll eventually want to move beyond the status of ignorant end-user and start learning something about using a free unix system.

For such purposes, you should pick out a distro that is relatively standards-compliant, particularly as the FHS (Filesystem Hierarchy Standard) is concerned (since the LSB is really just a "political" compromise designed to make a bunch of self-important nitwits happy). Such distributions include Debian, Gentoo, and Slackware, among some other less-famous distributions. Because FHS compliance appeals more to the technically minded users than to corporate marketing departments, you'll find that FHS compliance is strongest with distributions that tend to target the needs of those technically minded users, and as such the distributions that are most FHS-compliant are also typically those distributions that have a reputation for being suited for the most-expert users.

This doesn't mean that rank newbies are out of luck, however. For instance:

1. Gentoo uses a very involved, complex installation process, but it is extremely well-documented so that if you're relatively computer-competent and are not largely incapable of picking up new concepts quickly, you shouldn't have much trouble getting started.

2. Debian is actually much easier to install and manage than most people realize. It doesn't have a GUI installer, but the console-based installer is very simple and straightforward. In fact, there should be an article appearing on TR fairly soon that gives a step-by-step guide to installing Debian from scratch, quickly and easily.

3. There are spin-offs from Debian that are geared more toward the GUI-only newbie set that can ease one into use of a distribution that is more standards-compliant, flexible, and customizable than something like Fedora Core, SuSE, or Mandriva. Examples include the famous Knoppix and the very slick MEPIS. Ubuntu was also created by modifying Debian, but it's really for people who want to use something like a cross between Windows and MacOS with a Linux kernel rather than people who want to use Linux. In fact, I'd say that Ubuntu is to MacOS X as Linspire and Xandros are to Windows, pretty much.

Fedora, Mandriva, and SuSE all suffer the same problem when it comes to system administration and management: they are all quite divergent from the Linux norm, and all in different ways from each other. As such, learning system administration on one of these distributions tends to be almost useless in terms of positive transferrence of knowledge when you're using a different distribution. Because of the way they tend to change their administration tools from one release to the next, in fact, there can even be problems with having to relearn system administration from one version of a given distribution to the next. These problems are not as significant as they are for Windows, but compared with distributions such as Debian, Gentoo, and Slackware, they are pretty big issues. Even worse, all three of them tend to be pretty piss-poor at documenting their nonstandard utilities. The DrakX tools for Mandriva, for instance, almost universally lack manpages, which not only makes learning the various tools problematic at times, but also introduces some huge problems in terms of feature discovery, since the only way to find the new tool when they're undocumented is to click around in the GUI and hope you find something useful.

Of the three, Fedora is the best-documented, Mandriva has the slickest GUI system administration tools, and SuSE has the most powerful GUI system administration tools, in my experience. Fedora seems like the win, out of those three, to me: it is the most "standardized" of the three, the best documented, and the best supported by commercial software (which is really the only reason I'd generally consider using any of those three anyway -- for commercial software support, if I needed it, which I don't). In addition to this, the wanton violation of the FHS ensures that finding configuration files and executable binaries when you need to do something "by hand" can be an exercise in frustration. The only real upside is that it is at least orders of magnitude easier to accomplish such with these three distros than with Windows, where you'd have to hunt through the Registry (or worse). The example that always comes to mind for me is the separation of network interface configuration into a series of files that are scattered throughout the subdirectories of a scripts directory on Fedora Core, for some reason whose logic entirely escapes me. I got tired of having to relearn the process of configuring network interfaces by hand every single time I wanted to make some small change, in part because it's such a complex process that it is a pain in the butt to try to remember it all and in part because it tends to change from one OS release to the next, and eventually just started using the console network configuration utility instead. The downside of this, of course, is that you then have to re-enter every single configuration option for the interface every time you want to change just one of them. Meanwhile, Debian, Gentoo, and Slackware use a simple, straightforward configuration file format and location, and learning how to use it not only works well for being able to reuse the knowledge the next time on the same distribution, but transfers positively to the other two distros as well.

I could go on, but I think I've typed enough for now.

by apotheon

As promising as that looks, I won't be adopting it any time soon, I think. I won't trust any package manager but APT with my Debian systems for a while yet -- that thing needs more maturity before I'm willing to entrust my production systems to it. The description of the state of the GTK interface is less than heartening, too: Synaptic (for APT) sounds like the clear winner for GUI interfaces to package management (it kicks ass all over YaST2, which had the best GUI interface for package management I'd ever seen before I encountered Synaptic, for instance).

I'll be keeping an eye on the project, though, to see how it's progressing. Thanks for the link.

by w2ktechman

This looks like it may be a good thing coming soon.
I will try it when it comes out of beta. Since I am pretty new to the Linux world, I do not feel comfortable enough using beta SW. In Win, I use it all the time though.

Thank You

by jack-m

We're all unpaid beta testers for MS and have been since Win 3.0. On my home computers it's not too bad but at the customers premises, after the MS salesperson sold a server it's not so cool.

by ghost

I have been running into a ton of problems with the windows updates, Autoplay stops working, Longer shutdown of system, etc.
I have had really good luck with Redhat, but Redhat has gone so deep they almost act like windows os (Big Bill)
I run SUSE 10, and have never returned, the only reason I have Windows is to teach and repair systems. Check out what they have to offer; http://www.novell.com/linux
SUSE caught a bad reputation, but I think they fixed a lot of the problems and compatiblity issues.

This discussion is closed to new replies.