Question Locked

Home Network with DSL & Cable...

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have DSL(PPPoE) on one PC. I have Cable(DHCP) on another. Both on XP pro. I use a simple 4 port hub and a cross-over cable to connect everything together. Currently I can't connect the PC's while using my Cable(DHCP) connection.

While connected to the hub:

I can connect to the internet with both PC's(one using DSL and the other using Cable).

-OR-

I can connect PC's while connected to the internet using the DSL.

I want to have the local network functioning while having internet for both PC's, one using DSL and the other using Cable. (No ICS / Proxy Servers needed or wanted)

I am using an alternative IP configuration with the DHCP. Basically, if I disconnect the cable modem from the hub, it will automatically use the other IP configuration(192.168.x.x) and I can then connect the PC's while still using the DSL. But with the cable modem connected it uses DHCP and I get "The Network Name Cannot Be Found" when trying to connect to the other computer. Both internets work fine but I cannot ping the other PC locally.

Is it possible to have all three things simultaniously(DSL internet, Cable internet, and Local Network) without buying a router? Can I do it with another NIC installed to the DHCP machine?

Maybe by assingning one NIC DHCP and the cable modem, then the other to 192.168.x.x and connect directly to the other PC?

thanks!

5 replies

by ozi eagle

Hi,

My first guess is that when you use the DHCP link it assigns an IP Address and submask etc that is in a different range to your 192.168XX setup, hence your PCs can't see each other.

Connect to the DHCP and then in the command prompt type IPCONFIG /ALL. This will give you the locally assigned addresses for that connection. My bet is that it is incompatible with the 192.168XX addressing. (possibly in the 10.0.XX range).

If you can get into the management software of the cable modem, you may be able to reassign the DHCP range to be 192.168XX.

Otherwise a second NIC and bridging should do it.

Herb

by nul4guard-4

Thanks for reply. I'll try the second NIC since I have plenty of them.

Thanks again.

by why me worry?

The reason why your setup fails to work is because a hub/switch cannot perform what is knows as NAT (Network Address Translation) to map packets between the public IP address assigned by your ISP and your internal private address, which is a non routable class B address (192.168.0.x or 172.16.x.x). A cheap $50 broadband router (not the wireless kind) will perform both NAT and DHCP for your internal network and be able to share the internet bandwidth among all PCs'.

You can do this without a router with ICS in which one machine acts as the NAT Proxy for the rest, but setting up Windows ICS (Internet Connection Sharing) is more trouble than it's worth, so opt to spend the $50 for a cheap router.

by nul4guard-4

Thanks for your response. But the question was "without buying a router" and "without ICS"

But thanks for your input, I appreciate it.

The second NIC in both pc's solved the problem. No hub, switch or router needed.

This discussion is closed to new replies.