Discussion Locked

How is it that four year college educated people are better technicians?

0 helpful
127 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have spent 16 years working in the computer industry in one year or another and while I agree that college education can be a good thing, typically in the tech support end of things i've personally found that the people have attended classes and done just enough to pass the classes yet do not have enough practical knowledge from the classes to actually know how to do the job.

A prime example of this is I got a temporary job at a Company in knoxville back in 1999 making $9.00 an hour and couldn't go permanent because they hired 2 people directly out of the local university that had associates degrees in computer sciences who walked in, sat down on either side of me and began asking things like "where's the hard drive in these things" "what does the memory look like and where is it". Now at that time i had only been working in computers for about 6 years and this was day one stuff here they were asking me. I was so flabergasted by the fact that these people were asking me these questions that I asked them the following: "you both went to {local un-named college} for two years now right" [response] "yes" [me agian] "and what did you do in those classes that you don't already know the things you are asking me about" [response] " well we played games mostly, Occasionally we would actually work on computer stuff but for the most part just played games" [me again] "and they give you a degree for that?" [no response]. so every since then I have no confidence and am not at all impressed with people that tell me that they have a college degree, Because I have found this to be a common thing with the people that have completed those courses.

I gained all my knowlege the old school way, by trial and error and I messed up my share of operating system loads and lost more than my share of data before I learned how to do things the proper way. The thing is I learned from all that and never again after that had to ask any one such a question as "where is the hard drive" or "what does memory look like".

Working for one of the worlds largest computer companies as a Senior Technical Support Technician I also got to speak with quite a few technicians and "IT or Network administrators" that claimed to know their stuff and had supposedly done all the proper troubleshooting before calling me.

The thing that was a resounding commonality is that a lot of them may have done some of the troubleshooting but neglected to do the simple first year type troubleshooting that any shade tree tech would have known to do, yet these people had degrees and in some cases were fully Microsoft certified yet they were on my phone having missed some of the most simple steps.

This has been a hot topic with other industry professionals that I have dealt with in my tenure as a support technician. It's like the certification means nothing actually, neither does the schooling. all it means is that those people know how to take and pass tests on the subject of computers. But when it comes time to actually have to practice or use the knowlege they are sadly lacking, yet the requirement of the certifications and college training is still a requirement for so many positions being offered these days. I even put off getting even the industry standard certification until I had to have it to keep my job because I didn't want to be someone that was thought to have just taken a test and gotten a piece of paper that says I know what I am doing. I was counting on my 16 years of experience to speak more for my abilities than any piece of paper ever could. It's just sad to me that the actual hands on experience isn't enough for people any more and they go for that false sense of security that they get with someone that has one of those expensive pieces of paper.

That's just my opinion, what's yours?

127 replies

by jdclyde

but it can complement it well.

I have found the best techs (myself! B-) ) have done all three, hands on experience, formal education, AND technical classes. Each one brings another piece of the puzzle together. You not only understand what is going on, but WHY.

There is no one-size-fits-all. People just learn in different ways.

by jason

Major employers must resolve to utilizing formal education and certifications to sort through resumes. A typical HR manager may see over 2500 resumes for a single position, from there that manager needs to sort through the possible 10-20 (if that) applicants he plans to interview. How does the hiring manager go from 2500 to 20 resumes? Filtering. The HR manager establishes benchmarks for the position. Does the candidate have a four year degree? Does the candidate have X,Y,Z certifications? The HR manager is going to utilize every possible filter to sort through the data until they get down to the forty or fifty resumes they are actually going to read. Congratulations, now that the HR manager considers your resume worthy of reading, your experience matters. Certifications generally are a matter of logistics, statistics, and benchmarking.

by tony hopkinson

is to get the best twenty candidates, not to keep adding buzzword matches until there are twenty

After all he could add get the same by sorting them alphabetically and slicing off the top.
Odds are just as good of getting someone acceptable....

by support slug

Maybe they want someone they know has the "sticktoitiveness" to complete an long, arduous task. Maybe they want someone who shows the ability to understand and process complex data. Maybe they want someone who hasn't shown a complete lack of interest in improving himself. Maybe they are looking for someone who can consistently write in proper English sentences with correct grammar and spelling. Maybe they don't want someone who bashes his way through the learning process or risks the network to figure out which actions are failure. I guess we'll never know.

"I didn't want to be someone that was thought to have just taken a test and gotten a piece of paper"

Horseshit.

by ctsmain

There is no need for a personal attack. This wasn't just about me. This is about employers and the importance they place on certifications and education. It's also to show how some educators simply let thier people slip through the cracks and the actual learning is still done on the job instead of in the class.

If you can't express your thoughts without the Profanity, then maybe I am not the one who needs an English class after all.

posted opinions of people that don't agree with me, or that have different views than mine are one thing, that's fine I don't expect some people agree with me. However, being totally ignorant in the way your thoughts are relayed are quite another.

by larryd4

It appears your topic hit a sore point for what we should assume is the appropriately named support slug :)

by support slug

Awww... poor baby. Think I'm too harsh? Welcome to reality. You certainly DO need a personal attack or whatever else will wake you from reverie and motivate you to stop whining and become qualified.

You may not like how I speak to you, but you definitely need to be shaken from your bliss. You obviously don't realize what a stupid question you asked. The answer is obvious to anyone else who has a brain.

by jdclyde

they are all valid reasons why employers look for degrees.

I have not seen (ever) a valid reason for NOT getting a formal education.

by matthew.balthrop

I hadn't read this until just now, but i am quite suprised at the lack of respect or "open-mindeness" this person displayed. Apparently there was something said that puts some people on the defense.

-alias

by info

no direspect, but wake up. managers hire according to their own-knowledge/budget/politcs and blabla of the entry.
same (american)story all over again.
so, did you take action and report your frustration to your boss(esboss)?

by dumphrey

in that a good tech has skills in various areas.

I got a 4 year degree is psychology. Does it help me with computers? Indirectly. My degree taught me how to learn how to think and reason.

I have a 2 year degree from a technical school that gave me SOME hands on training and experience.

I got lucky and got a job out of tech school that is giving me a lot of varied experience. Real world, in production experience.

Am I a good tech? I think so. Am I the best, not by far.
A friend of mine has the same 4 year degree as me (we were in school together), but his 2 year is in programming, not networking. He is 1000x better with hardware, scripting, and *nix then I am. But I beat the crap out of him in Email administration, Windows in general, and router set up. Comparable ( 4 year + 2 year it related) education, different skill sets.
My opinion is experience is superior to training in 99% of all cases. So far, I am noticing that training focuses on "best case" and generalities that rarely appear in the real world.

by ctsmain

I am not saying that all programs just let you slide through and not teach you anything. I also am not totally against having a degree. In fact I am currently enrolled in a 2 year program myself. (can't beat them join them) The whole point of this was simply to ask if anyone knows why employers put more faith in a person's abilities that has a piece of paper that says he knows what he's doing rather than a person that has been doing the job for any number of years and has the actual experience.

"So far, I am noticing that training focuses on "best case" and generalities that rarely appear in the real world."

I agree whloe heatedly with this myself by the way.

by dumphrey

let you slide, but I know to many that did. Its amazing how little you can do and know and still pass many classes/programs.

It really comes down to the person, they will get out what they put in.

To answer your question about why employers look for the degree, I think its social advertising. They THINK that being educated in a school means you have "equivocal experience". And for some people this could be true.
Also there is the perception that College/University trained people are more focused, stay on task better, and are more capable in picking up new skills. And while this may have some grain of truth, its an opinion held by people that have never seen a frat party at its best/worst... Its hard to look at someone doing naked keg stands and picture them a future leader of anything.
Once again, it comes back to you get what you put into the curriculum.
The opinion that a certificate makes you a better tech is a false premise. All it means is that you have the skills to pass a test through real knowledge, cheating, memorization of info without actual understanding, or just blind luck. A certification means that they have a chance of having a specific skill set of knowledge. But knowledge with no experience is useless, and in some cases plain bad.

So, a concise answer is Certification is perceived to be better because people have a flawed understanding of value.

by cupcake

I've read through about 25% of the posts, but now I have to get my opinion in here.

I am in your boat CTS... I don't have a 4 four year degree. When I started out in the professional world, I didn't have a 2 year. I have found over the years, that there are companies/HRs/hiring managers who both think that you HAVE to have a degree (and doesn't matter in what) and those who don't demand it.

You have to just find them. I spent a number of years contracting - I was lucky - many of the contracts were for multiple year periods. This increased my technical skills. At the same time I worked on my education, although after all this time I still don't have it.

At the current company I work for, I am the highest paid person on a 18 person team and am not in any type of management position. I am looked to for mentoring and my opinion and help on a daily basis. And I earn every penny I make.

Companies that would dismiss me out of hand because I don't have a degree are companies that I wouldn't want to work for anyway.

Keep working, networking and you will find you niche.

My sister's manager is my sanity everyday. They hired her over my sister SIMPLY because she had a degree (a bachelors in ZOOLOGY!) rather than someone who had been performing the job and climbing the ladder for over 16 years and they are now faced with the hell it has caused because she is such a MORON!

Hang in there CTS... I think you're on the right track.

Cupcake

by gate keeper

do you mean "How is it that four year college educated people [b] aren't [/b] better technicians?" ?

While I agree that education cannot replace experience .. but that works the other way around as well.

from my experience non-college educated techies will selectively "bone up" on technical subjects and areas that directly affect their work or catch their interest, while his/her college educated coworker will have a solid foundation in all CS areas.

by ctsmain

The title should have read "how is it that four year educated people are considered better techs than experienced people"

unfortunately there was't room for all that and the title doesn't really match the message because of that. Sorry if it mislead you.

the only thing most of the self taught techs I know don't have and what I am going to school for myself now is the network and server administration and network security. those are some things that you can't just pick up on your own without cracking a book or taking a class. I realized my limitaitons when i started working with servers and the Cisco catylist that's why I decided, rather than take out someone's network trying to learn how to do things I would go to school for it all. I wasn't shooting down education with this post either. Not all certified or 2 or 4 year degreed people are lost when they start doing the job. I am convinced if that were the case there would be a lot less importance placed on college educated or certified people in this industry.

by ctsmain

My point is that not all, in fact less than half of the people that are college eduacted techs can perform in the job unless they get actual work experience while they are going to school. Yes most do have the solid Knowlage to do the job and can be more grounded because of that but when it comes time to actually use that knowlege they typically aren't as good at applying it to the task at hand. That is at least the experiences I have had. Don't misunderstand me there are a lot of techs that come out of school fully capable and well skilled in doing the job they were hired for with a great deal of success. The point of this is that it is not always a fact that the college educated person winds up being a much better fit for a job than someone who has years of experience and no school to back it up. Yet that doesn't stop companys from requiring that a person have a 4 year degree in order to get the job in the first place. I like the way the last place i worked did things. They required the A+ certification but they paid for it, and they gave time for me to study for it and paid time off for me to take the test as well. They didn't require it up front but instead they made sure that you got what they required once hired. You had to first have experience to get the job and they took care of the rest. I don't think this should be required up front. If you have it and can do the job well all the better. But if you don't have the education but do have the experience i think it should be that you can get the education part knocked out while you are still working. That is how i am doing now with my current job because my employer didn't just require the college up front. I throughly appreciate the jobs that list thier positions as College degree or equivalent experience. That shows that they are willing to take the right amount of experience over a degree. There is nothing at all wrong with that.

by larryd4

You have to remember its the person who does the hiring that makes the decision. I have seen some really poor examples of hiring.

But why are people hired?

My Opinion, in order of importance.

1. Who they know.
2. Who they think they know.
3. The way they look during the interview.
4. The way they present their knowledge on the interview. (BS)
5. If the hiring person will be their Manager. Then it's if the manager likes them.
6. Education level
7. Certifications
8. Experience.

Most hiring enviornments are trying to hire the right person who will follow the orders of the Manager. In some cases they are looking for someone to promote later. Most hiring companies, Public and Private look at College Education as the Holy Grail. If we can get a college educated person, who can also do the job we are looking for, then we are bringing on a better person who has the potential to help the company/division in the future. But if its someone who didn't go to college but has been fixing PC's for 10 years, you are facing an up hill battle.

Here is the problem with experience in place of Education and this is going to hurt. If you spend 6 to 10 years in the same job doing the same "techical" job, like repairing PC's, it will be a negative when you try to move on.

From my experience if you stay in the same job for that long and you don't move up, then the interviewer will look at the bigger picture. If this person is so good and has all this technical knowledge why haven't they moved up in the current position?

I am one of those people and I learned this early on. Since 1988 on average I have moved on to a new job every 3 to five years. Aside from my consulting work I have been in my current job for 6 years, the longest anywhere. Each new job has given me a hire salary and title and is reflective on my resume.

IT is constantly changing and though you can still do it, its not about working for the same company for 20, 30 years. Its about keeping you skills and knowledge up to par. If you get lucky enought to get in to a position with upper management you then have to start thinking about keeping yourself on the technological leading edge and solidify your value to the company to protect your job.

by Former member

I'm a mix of both Experience and Degree and I find it disappointing that there are 'Paper' Techs that don't live up to employer expectations and depend on more seasoned often self taught Techs to get the jobs done.

by larryd4

Their are many brain drain, exam cram people that know nothing. But thats a direct responsibility of a manager. Every job has a "probationary" period where the Manager should be testing, observing, and documenting but that rarely happens.

Most Managers don't want to do that level of monitoring and would rather work with what they have.
Plus if the person hired ends up being a bad hire, most managers would rather suck it up then admit they hired the wrong person.

by ctsmain

This was the exact point I was trying to make with posting this in the first place.

Thanks for your contribution

by ctsmain

there's nothing wrong with self taught, I myself am self taught having never taken a course on computers until I went to work for Dell. Then the only thing I learned was about how to do things dell's way on thier computers and about thier hardware and how it was assembled. I had run my own business for 8 years quite successfully before moving where I am now and I did make my share of mistakes starting out but they were always on my own machines, never on one of my customer's computers. The point is I learned through trial and error how to do things and the only one it ever cost anything to learn the things I did was me. The employers I have had since I closed my business have spoken with customer's of mine to verify my skills and there are a lot of people I know that took the same path i did quite successfully. Realisticly there are good and bad of both arguements for and against hiring only educated people

by jamesrl

As a hiring manager....

I would pretty much reverse your order.

Experience is number one. Lots of people come out of school with a pretty certificate but aren't productive.

For the record, I've been hired and promoted many times and I don't have a complete degree - and I didn't study anything to do with tech.

James

by larryd4

Granted the appropriate hiring manager will use his or her skill to determine the best candidate. But in the world how many hiring managers are actually that good?

As an example I had applied to an internal posting and was turned down due to not enough experience. Even my IT manager was amazed. When I went and talked to HR and asked why I didn't qualify. I was told my first 8 years of my career was not IT related.

Thats when I had to explain to HR what ICCF, JCL, Cobol, and Mainframe operations were.

I was hired for that postion a month later.

by ctsmain

Actually based on what I and my other self taught friends have experienced Larry has it pretty much nailed unfortunately.

Experience "should" be number one and back when i first started into computers it was but then microsoft and all these other certification companies started coming out with all the different things you could get certified for saying that if you have their paper you know how to do things the way they would expect people to be able to do them. once those came out the whole thing just blew up and now it's expected of everyone that you have your college , the certifications and then the experience. one common trend I am noticing is that the different recruiters and employers don't usually require two or 4 year degrees until the economy gets bad. How bad the economy is too tends to dictate wheather you have to have a 2 year degree or a 4 year. It could be a coinsidence that it works out that way but I lean more toward it being an employment conspiracy than anything else. Something else I have learned being a Veteran doesn't mean what it used to either when it omes to jobs.

by ctsmain

well if that's the case then this reply alone answered a lot of questions for me. More than even the ones I posed in the main post too.

Thanks for your contribution

by matthew.balthrop

I agree with what was stated above, and it's funny to hear these people with such limited knowledge even though they have certs. and College. I am currently going to school for Computer and Information Science, and about to take my A+ cert. Though i know these things will help me down the road, i couldn't imagine applying for any sort of job without having that self-taught knowledge that can only come from hands on work. I have several computers at home, and i am constantly tweaking them and learning what i can. Like it was said above, trial and error are the only real ways to learn IT. I see the certs. and the College as a reinforcement of my knowledge, but not the foundation. Glad to see this holds true, whether the corporations agree or not.

-alias

by ctsmain

your situation (minus the education) is how i got going with this too. As i stated in the main posting I got my A+ but not until my job dictated that I had to have it. I relied solely on my experience and it was enough till now. I am getting into servers now and network administration and there's a certain level you can get to being only self taught but to set up and maintain servers and networks properly there is no replacing the education side of things, I just wondered why that part of it was weighed so much more heavily than the actual hands on experience. I believe Larry nailed it though.

by m_beezy1337

From talking to people that have been in the field for awhile now, they all seem to agree that this day and age the certs./school are taking the place of experience. That has been a big reason for wanting to pick up the certs; A+, Java, Net+, Microsoft ect.
I want to focus on programming mainly, but i want to have a broad scope of IT at the same time. As far as programming/hardware/software goes, i know that hands on experience will be invaluable. When it comes to networking though, i know i will have to pick up those books and dig into it before i stand a chance of knowing what i am doing.
I think as more and more certifications become available/recongized, and IT continues to grow, it will become more like other careers where employers want the paper-proof of knowledge.

-alias

by ctsmain

this is more along the lines of the point i was trying to make. I started out with a Packard Bell which as most know gave every error possible on a system on a regular basis. if there is nothing else they will teach you it's how to correct problems with them and many other pc's therefore I was self taught too the hard way. I too was about to start college for Computer sciences but since I have knowlege and experience already I was going mostly for the networking, server and security training. once I have that I'll complete the MCSE and then the CCNA but servers aren't something you want to self teach unless you have one of your own to mess up and learn to fix.
good luck with your schooling and on the tests when you take them.

by mjd420nova

Having been in the electronics service industry since the mid sixties and began when vacuum tubes were the only technology, I find that a well rounded tech must be able to work on anything that is computer related. This includes printers and all manner of strange peripherals. The often most neglected aspect is the simple power supply and its AC outlets, including UPS units and their functions. All of the techs I work with can handle everything from checking AC supply problems, all the way back to the circuit breaker if neccesary and on up to diagnosing packets switches and frame buffers. Now all this knowledge doesn't come from a book and because each installation is different, only hands on experience will provide a large enough knowledge base for each individual to become proficient or the broad range. The advent of certifications has only served to increase the numbers of "talkers" who can field phone calls and provide a fresh approach to problems but will never replace a "real" tech.

by ctsmain

That was also kind of my point to all of this though I don't have all of the experience you and your techs seem to by what you posted here I am in total agreement with your final assessment of the situation as a whole. I am not a tech "talker" myself. i'd rather be there hands on which is why I was glad to get into IT Administration however cutbacks due to the economy have put me back into technical support over the phone. So I guess I have to settle for being a tech talker once again, at least till another IT Administrator position opens up. I do have the printer support and networking experience you and yourtechs have but honestly i have never had to personally troubleshoot past the UPS. Also I started playing on computers in 84 but didn't start working on them till 1993. I have been facinated with them from the start, which is now why I work on them. It's a mazing how much they have changed and in such a short period of time.

by tony hopkinson

Looking for academic or vocational certification is simply to cut down the list of candidates, you have to then examine to see if they are any good.

It's easy to pick out good and bad examples of those with or without a degree, cert, or experience, or any combination thereof.

I've worked with people who claimed all three, who I wouldn't have employed ever. I've worked with those who started with nothing except potential (many moons ago), who turned out to be damn good.

I never take qualifications as a given in terms of skill and ability, nor can you take a claim of experience. Any candidates who get to me though, almost certainly have some claim to make.

My employer actually thought I had a degree, but that after twenty + years I'd left it off as irrelevant. :D

It's all about perception, and a list of things you should be able to do, helps.

Development is far less certifiable (unlike the people who do it :p ) than other IT disciplines, but if I was struggling for employment, I'd go get the bits of paper for the numpties who are incapable of judging me any other way.

by notsochiguy

...how do hiring people quantify/qualify experience, other than just years served? It is harder and harder to do any form of background check that has any helpful information other than dates of service and salary. Skills assessments are costly and/or time consuming; rendering them as no-go's.

HR is TERRIFIED of making the bad (by that, I mean indefensible) hire. Even they know that there are many a CorpoRoach (people who seem to last indefinitely in large organizations, despite lack of any discernible skillset) out there, so anything they can do to avoid bringing one in, they'll do; since roaches are known for breeding other roaches!

Additionally, HR people do not know IT. They do, however, know "B.S., 3.9 GPA at U. of Chicago". So, given the choice of trying to make heads or tails of a resume heavy on experience, or one that has a great school and impressive wording, they fall back to what they know.

All of this happens, of course, after the keyword sorter application had already pre-screened the resumes. 10 years of MS Server 2008....IN. 12 years of OpenVMS & AS-400, 5 years of Windows 2003, 5 years of Windows 2000 and 4 years of Windows NT (when 8 years of Windows Operating systems experience is required)...OUT.

I'd love to see a comprehensive study on how poor hiring practices have helped add fuel to the fire in terms of the economic collapse. How many of these firms were headed by paper MBAs or other hoity toits that couldn't tell their @$$ from a hole in the ground??!?!?!??

DISCLAIMER: I have degrees, certs and experience...so I understand the value of each. I just feel that current hiring practices seem to be based on many fallacious assertions and beliefs.

by matthew.balthrop

I had not even thought of this from the point that point of view. It makes sense to think that the people hiring will generally not have a lot of IT experience, and those that don't will go off only what they know. Good point.

-alias

by wizard-09

Ok I'm the holder of the above cert, current undertaking CEH and been in the business 5 plus years, let me 1st state that the books learn you how to it but never really tells you what to if things go wrong.

You learn on the job and I would hire someone without a cert that is self taught. Yes the cert does help don't get me wrong but it's only the stepping stone to what's to come.

by ctsmain

This is one of the responses I hoped to see with posting this question. This explains a lot and answers some other questions I had about how Resume's are looked at and scrutinized.

Thank you for your posting.

by notsochiguy

After having worked with HR closely for a number of years, it really opened my eyes on the whole recruitment process.

In the times I've applied to positions since, I've always made it a point to try and get some background info on the company (specifically, key contacts in both IT and HR), and then send my resume directly to them.

Resume sorting applications (or, as they are euphemistically called, 'Applicant Tracking Systems') are pretty hit and miss (I've worked on migrations between several of them). One bad read on an OCR pass, resume gets canned (Heaven forbid you send in a resume that uses an unrecognized font). System not setup to recognize acronym as opposed to full text title for certification (MCSE, for instance), and the resume gets bounced.

You'd probably have more luck playing the state lottery than trying to get the resume past some of the filters in larger companies.

by matthew.balthrop

I'm not disagreeing with that fact, that is apparently the current nature of the buisiness. My remark was at the attutude of the poster bashing the topic. Maybe this is meant to be directed at me, but what do you mean report my frustration to my boss?

-alias

by info

clicked the wrong follow-up link. so you don't need to visit your boss.....

haha

by matthew.balthrop

One of those people that never learned to intelligently get a message across. Obviously you have had it rough,that is the only reasonable explanation i can think of as to why you would act the way you are. What happens when you personally attack someone? They become defensive, they shut you out. What did this accomplish? Absolutely nothing. What happens when people of different opinions have simple discussion about a topic? They either learn something new, or they possibly become more open to the opposing idea. You have failed to do anything reasonable in any of your posts Slug.

-alias

by support slug

Awww, you are all so sensitive. Well too bad. I get sick of the same moronic question over and over. This guy is crybabying over why he is getting passed over and he doesn't need politeness. He needs to wake the hell up. What is accomplished? He will either put up or shut up. And what have you accomplished? You coddled a poor moron into feeling he is adequate. Lame.

by jdclyde

matthew was entirely correct.

What is the purpose of your post?
To show how much better you are than him?
To verbally beat someone up?
To show someone a point of view they hadn't considered?

If the last option, your childish attitude guarantees that will never happen. If you yell at someone and tell them how stupid they are, they tune you, and your attack out. He will not be shocked into reality by it.

If you are looking to help convince or help him, grow up and talk with him, instead of berate him.

You do yourself a dis-service, as well as the cause you are advocating. You are not representative of the average educated tech.

by the scummy one

the answer is obvious to all but you!
Why not look, he stated that has taken courses and studied. So what is the problem, are you offended so much because you are one of the paper cert holders that has nothing to back it up? Do you spend all of your time asking everyone else in different forums to fix all of your problems because you have no technical knowledge?

I think that the OP has a valid point. I have worked with people similar to what he has described before. However many of them had 2-3 years of 'experience', yet barely knew how to boot Windows. The experience was from having jobs and hiding out as long as possible to not be seen. Each job lasted a couple of weeks, therefore +exp..

I knew a guy that claimed 5 yrs exp, that during the first 2 weeks, we never knew where he was. We tried canning the guy, but he was outsourced, so it had to go through his agency, which claimed for almost 4 weeks that they could not reach him to tell him his contract was over. That is 6 weeks for doing nothing.

There are losers out there, and I think that you are showing to be one of them. If anyone needs a reality check, it is you!

by the scummy one

Experience is a big boon, a cert shows knowledge (in some cases at least) and will to study (see remark again), both show a good backing for hiring.

by matthew.balthrop

I can appreciate those point of views, sort of a middle ground reached for this topic. In the early days i could see the higher demand for pure experience, in this day and age i think you need a good portion of both. The certs and schooling shows on paper that you have the will to further your skill/knowledge, while the experience shows an expertise in whatever field you are applying for.

-alias

by tony hopkinson

Can't agree at all. You can do that without formal education/training, in fact to be successful in IT you must do it. How is only relevant in terms of appearances, of course as we know fromm the regular degrees vs certs vs experience 'erm discussions, appearances are important.

Willing to jump through the necessary hoops, is the way I'd describe it.

by j-mart

1. The required intelegence
2. The required knowledge
3. The aptitude
4. The persomnal integrity to put in effort to accomplish all parts of your work to the standard required.

A prospective employer, if they don't personally know you has to make a judgement, on whether or not you are a good hire or not. The tools at their disposal are, your educational/ certificate qualifications, references and work experience which they have to verify. Often in a larger organization more weight will be given to educational / certificate qualifications, in a smaller organization, gut feeling, and references well checked might hold more sway. But the employer, unless he knows you or knows people in organisations you have worked for, is taking the gamble, that one candidate is the best hire for the job they have available and up to it. How they judged their last hire and how they worked out may also effect the choice of their next hire.

From my experience in my own proffession there are no hard and fast rules to what makes the best in my feild. Sometimes its education, not always in same feild as working in, one of the best machine controler techs I've worked with had a degree in geology but couldn't stand working as a geologist. Some good people I've worked only had loads of experience and nothing else, but the one thing in common they all had was an aptitude and the integrity do their best and often put in more effort than they may have been paid for.

by support slug

The truth is tough to take. My purpose is already accomplished. The guy shut up his whining. I know he isn't going to pursue education. He's as far as he's ever going to go. I, for one, won't waste another breath on him.

by ctsmain

you are right entirely, Look at his posts, all he does is get on people's posts and act the part of an ass. my 13 year old is more mature than this. what gets me is he's hiding imaturity behind a decent vocabulary. I had quit posting because this isn't accomplishing anything nor is it addressing the question I posted to begin this whole thing. Infact it more proves the point that the people that have those degrees think they are elite over the rest of society some how. I may not actually do the college thing, not if that's what it turns you into.
I'd rather remain happy go lucky and easy to get along with by most everyone else in society rather than become someone that thinks they can do no wrong and no one else's opinions on things matter. I thnik i'd rather just get my MCSE and take my chances with that then to have to go through all the schooling and turn out like slug has. I owe it to society, my children and other tech's in general to advance but stay the person I am now. All this did is prove to me that while more employers look for the 4 year degree I am not in any hurry to become a total butt to everyone. I have the luxury of knowing that not all techs that go to college turn out that way and most technicians don't have the social disconnect or need for for attention that slug seems to have a need for i'll post no more on this branch of the repies because it's non productive and shows nothing more than a petty ignorance to continue further with the back and forth banter. that is not what this forum is for nor is it anything I care to persue any longer.

by ctsmain

this fully states what I was asking with the title to this post. I was kind of interested too in finding out how many (if any) others have had the same experiences as I have, given the same situations and variables.
Long and short, it is both nice and disturbing to know I am not alone in what I ran into.

by ctsmain

I love that, good that you were able to clarify it and still get the job though.

by ctsmain

I agree with your take on the certifications but I also understand now about the certifications and schooling as well. I believe if I were in charge of hiring I would do the same way you mentioned however I'll never have that ability to make those decisions but if the occasion came up I have enough tech skills and ability that i could make an informed decision based on what I know.

by jdclyde

Yes, he was being an ass for the sake of being as ass, but he was still correct in the basic message.

I have gone BOTH routes, but do not see the need to belittle someone for going only one way or the other.

He belittles for one way, YOU belittle for going the other.

You are both wrong, in that regard.

Which of course, by default, makes ME RIGHT! B-)

by pvbenn

In the 25+ years I've been in the support business I've found the best Junior Techs are the ones who've worked on computers before any formal education and who are always looking at what is on the edge of the mainstream market place.

I've interviewed people for Technician jobs in the past and the ones who admit to having a collection of old beaters they use for play are often more tech savvy. I have run across the occasional person who prides themselves on not having a computer at home, needless to say they are rarer to find but they never make it past the first interview.

There have been other cases where I?ve seen more senior Technicians try to bluff and B.S. there way though a technical interview only to be exposed as a total crock once they've gotten the job. An admission of the lack of knowledge is a better answer than boldface lie, at least I knew I could teach them something and not have to worry about them trying to B.S a customer and embarrass the support organization. I've also seen people who get Technical training and then realize they can't or won't keep up with the technology so they figure management is the place to go. Often they are just as bad managers as they are Techs and again cause more trouble than what they are worth.

by ctsmain

this is another of the many points I was trying to make with posting this.
I have seen many a college educated tech or supposedly techical person that has managed to pass a test and get a certification come in the door at many businesses that I have worked at, sat down next to me making some times more than me doing the same job and they were totally clueless about what to do. Now mind you they all had the same training classes I did before they got to sit down next to me and they managed to pass those tests too. However when it came time to actually do the job they were totally lost.

Realistically I have frozen up on the first few calls that I took after coming out of a training class but still managed to muttle through with a little guidance. that's not what I am talking about at all. I mean people that for months sit there having to be coached and cottled the whole way through every call. Yes it's mostly helpdesk type support that I have seen this on not actual hands on support because usually in a hands on job lack of actual experience would be apparent right off the bat.

It just amazes me that I have experienced that and the common denomonator is that they had college or were intelligent enough to pass a test and get a cert but couldn't apply what they learned for the cert in a real world environment.

by av .

Having certs or a computer science degree may open doors for you and please HR, but neither one can take the place of experience.

I've spent 25 years in IT in many capacities, but mostly as a Network Administrator. I learned everything I know from working in the trenches. It was very tough sometimes. Only experience can teach you how to deal with what happens when the network goes awry. You just can't learn that from taking classes.

In my opinion, even Corporate America will bend the rules on education if they like your experience and attitude. You have to sell yourself.

AV

Edit: added Corporate America and removed Fortune 500 companies.

by wanttocancel

I have a degree in English and I'm working toward to be a novelist but to pay the bills I use my IT skills to repair computers. I've run across many job opportunties where the employer wanted a IT grad and not me because even though I have the experience I don't have that particular degree.

As AV said you have to sell yourself and your experience because employers are only going to see you at face value, and that face value is your resume.

by av .

IF, they can think outside the box and realize that a degree doesn't mean someone can automatically handle the job.

AV

by lazlohollyfeld

been there. it is not a fun thing.

i once had a worker that had listed specific experience working on dell pc hardware even to the point of listing models (optiplex gx1, etc), but yet when it came to it he did not even know how to crack the case open on it.

i called his bluff. he didn't make it past his probation. i got another tech later that knew what he was doing.

first guy had a masters in cis

second guy had a a.s. in info systems and about 5 years experience.

we started looking at job specs and the phrase "...or equivalent experience" very carefully. seems that a degree alone did not make someone qualified to do the work.

of course, i can say the same thing about management too. most of them with mbas are about qualified to run a drive-thru at mcdonalds. lmbo

by ctsmain

seeing you mention the Dell experience brings up another sore point. I worked at Dell as a Senior Technical support and for 2 years since leaving there have worked in Dell only shops i've repaired everything from the smallest of their portables (laptops) all the way up to repairing servers and switches. I still have a current and up to date DCSE but when dealing with HR people and managers on the phones they act like that's just something that is expected or not really significant at all.

It only bothers me because I honestly expected that to be a more significant accomplishment and experience. Some people require that you have Dell experience but will still hire someone who has been to college over even the Dell experience that they require you to have. it's not the interviews I am failing on so I can only assume it's that I don't have college or that something on my resume doesn't properly convey my actual dell experience.

I didn't mean to make this at all about me personally but on this point there's no other way I could convey it properly and still get my point across.

by the 'g-man.'

If I wanted a DELL technician then I would go for you. Other job, well depends on what else you have to offer.

Tech is getting cheaper, it may be more cost effective to use your salary as a fund for broken equipement as it happens. Not all the equipement will break.

by the 'g-man.'

that you use i instead of I when writing, but then what would be the point?

Guess you just lack experience in writing.

We could say you are not qualified enough or perhaps just lack experience in the writing departement.

Which is it, you decide?

by ajohansson

and agree with ctsmain. Too many know-it-alls that know-it-not. Even with an MS, I've missed out because I lack the cert, but have the experience.

by beldar33

Not sure what the point of your commentary is other than to wail on about those with certifications? I appear to be one of those folks you are writing about who...changed careers recently and went back to school. In one year I had "graduated" with an associates degree and multiple certifications.(new Microsoft Certifications use testing based on actually completing the tasks laid out by a scenario...NOT MULTIPLE CHOICE!) Walking in on the first day...yes, I had tons of questions as we were not afforded the opportunity to work with every single companies blade server or tower server and PC type nor did we have the benefit of years of practical knowledge of the companies network and where resources resided and how everything was configured and no I had not used ADPrep /forestprep in a real life situation...nor had I associated a two way transitive trust...nor had I added SQL cals to a licensing server...but I figured it out.(you know all the stuff cause you helped set it up and have supported it for some time!) What I did know was HOW TO FIND answers to my questions which I learned to do IN SCHOOL!!! And most often my queries did NOT include asking folks who've been there for 10 years cause they all seem to have some morbid desire to see anyone NEW fail to complete necessary tasks!(Why is this?...do IT people have an innate distrust of anyone or any new technology that might CHANGE the dynamic?)
Google and support.microsoft.com are invaluable friends of a Windows administrator and will continue to be of much use and guidance. It is very hard to try to ask questions to folks who feel such a sense of self importance that all they do is point out the weaknesses of others instead of working together to resolve problems and LEARN in a TEAM fashion.
What that "piece of paper" you talk about does show hiring managers and executives is the ability to learn(flexibility) and commitment to completing ongoing education that is necessary for US IT folks to continue to do our jobs efficiently and to understanding manufacturers best practices. (those are very rarely learned through actual use!)
Yes, there are many folks that I work with in this industry who have very little deep understanding of things like DNS, DFS, NTFS, RPC over HTTP ect ect ect...but it doesn't help me or the clients I server to spend my energy complaining instead of developing solutions and helping!
My two cents~

by tony hopkinson

They are entirely situational.
Not knocking education, but until you use it, it's merely an interesting datum.

The why of theory, very useful, academia's version of how, generally useless. The real world is nowhere near as tidy as the class room.

The thing I learn about IT everyday, is I don't know as much as I thought I did. I expect to retire knowing nothing. :p

I took correspondance courses and did a lot of self teaching, while working shifts and bringing up a family, I dropped a third of my salary, my shift pay, and all overtime, to take my first IT job, you think I could sell that as commitment?

NB, don't try this at home, the chances of you getting anywhere in Corporate IT nowadays, without the paper, whether you worked for it or not, range from anorexic to none.

The real question isn't is there a diffrence between a 'qualified' person and I, but how you show the difference, between someone who educated themself in IT (Teachers only help), and some tw@t who photoshopped some stuff and then BS'd his way past some poor fool at an interview.

Wordsearch BSc, all you did was find people who put BSc on their resume.

by knighthawk777

I can not only relate to this but I am actually from Knoxville. A few years ago, I had over 20 years IT experience but couldn't get hired because all of it was from the military and I didn't have any degrees. I was a software engineer for the Air Force but after four months of lowering my job search to take anything, I got hired in at a local company as a help desk tech making under $10.00/hr. All because the manager was taking a risk on me. Pah! I could work circles around the grads with no experience. It took me over a year but I finally got an inside promotion to a developer position from the help desk. The fact is most of the techs I worked around had two and four year degrees but some didn't know much of anything. Some were very good at pretending to know a lot too but they were faking it. Amazingly, this worked in most cases because management didn't know, either. They just trusted the people because of their degree and self-confidence. There were some techs with degrees that did have a good experience base, however, and did quite well. The point is; hiring managers always put so much emphasis on degrees as a prerequisite and not enough on experience.

When I was job-hunting, my "headhunter" told me my resume was always being placed at the bottom because I didn't have a degree and sometimes it didn't even make it to the stack. I do have a degree now and that has made my life a lot easier. The degree didn't teach me much that I didn't already know, however. The life lesson that today a degree is very important can't be overstated. Even though I have seven more years to pay on my student loan it is already paying to have the degree.

I believe people tend to take the "easy-way" out and degrees are an easy way to filter out. I think "Hiring Managers" would get much better results if they took time to evaluate experience or better yet waiver the degree in special circumstances like they now seem to waiver the experience at the drop of a dime. I have even heard some say they can "train them right" if they're straight out of school. I have seen so many people get hired straight out of college with no experience when the job states one or two years.

In addition, there are some who can't do the job no matter how much they are taught. They come into IT for the pay but don't have the other skills that one has to have to go with it. For example, creativity is pretty important in a lot of IT skills but there are many who just don't have it and it's not something that is easy to teach.

Also, IT moves very fast and if a person don't have a genuine interest in IT they will fall behind very quickly. You have to "like" to stay up-to-date and you can't "fake-it". That means hanging out with IT friends and staying connected but knowing when someone has misunderstood something.

One last thing, there are those who get hired just to get the experience and training then leave because they find something else that pays better. One manager told me that he hired two guys that basically lied to him about experience but assured him that if he sent them to school they would stay with his company for a long time. He sent them to school but they both left in a matter of months. I would highly suggest verifying experience and not taking the lazy way out.

In summary, I would rather have someone experienced, including "life-experience" such as mess with computers all of the time, rather than take someone who has experience in nothing but school. One caveat, though, some positions have to give people a chance to get started so they can get that experience.

by cupcake

That's why the way to get a job isn't to send a resume to a HR rep. That's where networking comes in.

However, this doesn't help this CTSMain, since he was already doing the work, just didn't get him the transition from contract to FTE.

I have encountered the same situation, been working a long time in QA (15 years, 25 total in IT), but some companies just want to see that diploma. Go figure. I keep threatening to get it (now only about 15 credits away) but I keep wondering what is the real point at this time?

by tony hopkinson

for the satisfaction,
something to keep the academic fanboys happy, should you find yourself unable to get a position.
If you want to go management.

To be able to do the job better, maybe, but's that's down to us, not the qualification.

by jdclyde

no, finishing that degree would probably not change the way she does her job.

Looks good on the resume, though.

And it did feel good to complete both of my degrees.

One other thing to consider. Upper management has most likely spent a lot of time and money on THEIR education. Them putting an emphasis on education helps to validate their own choice as the right one.

I will say from personal experience, the best techs I have known in the meat world got degrees while working in the field. In addition to, not instead of.

by cupcake

I do want to eventually get the diploma, probably just for the satisfaction. I keep getting pulled in different directions, like last semester I took a German language class (want to do software testing in native languages) instead of the last couple of required classes.

I don't discount continued education and am constantly in some kind of class or other. Learning never stops.

However, my final required classes are like Microeconomics and Trig (or something along those lines) so I guarantee you those will never make a difference in how I do my job. I'd rather take a tech class or like I said, the language class. It makes giving up family time much easier to deal with.

As far as management goes, been there - done that. Don't want to go back. I like being 'in the trenches' and on the 'bleeding edge' rather than pushing paper around on a desk.

No thanks.

And I stated in another posting... if a company won't consider me simply because I haven't completed the degree... I don't want to work for them anyway.

by tink!

In the perspective of HR they must use certain factors to sort the good apps from the masses. (as already pointed out) This then, is when the popular beliefs - no matter how unrealistic or unsupported - come in. Degrees mean "educated". "Educated" still holds some degree of respect to elevate an applicant above the rest. Depending on the position being filled, HR may think they need an "educated" person - especially if the position is higher up on the pay scale.

Most of us know, from experience, that "educated" is not synonymous with "capable". It gives that person SOME edge over a non-educated person only in the eyes of HR. We also know that "experienced" is not synonymous with "capable" neither.

Assumptions SHOULD NOT be made based upon the words upon the resume. However, from an HR standpoint, assumptions HAVE to be made. IMHO a smart HR manager would look for both the educated factor as well as experience. The combination of the two increases the chances of picking a competent hire.

by jdclyde

when I got hired in for my last job, one of the people that tried my position before me (y2k re-write of legacy cobol system), was a 4.0 graduate from U of Michigan. Unfortunately, if the programs were not laid out as an assignment, she was lost. If it WAS laid out for her, she could knock it out easy, but everything else was hopeless.

by tink!

My view is that you really should have both - education AND actual hands-on experience to be fully competent for a job.

[i](Myself excluded - I lack the certs and degrees, but my position is more Administrative than it is officially IT.)[/i]

by jdclyde

it depends on the HR manager on how much weight the put in an education or not.

The down side of not having that degree, you acknowledge that you have one more obstacle in your path, and you can choose to remove it, or go around it and find employment elsewhere.

Someone that has BOTH, experience AND a degree, has just doubled their chances.

by jmgarvin

In the workforce now, it's just easier to have a 4 year degree (even if it is in basket weaving), than to not have one. With community colleges and universities offering more flexible scheduling, I see no reason NOT to go get a degree (at least a 2 year). It just makes your life easier.

With that being said, there is a point of diminishing returns. I'd stop after the 4 year degree unless you REALLY feel a need for a graduate degree.

by jdclyde

to get my masters, but that is because I would like to teach again, and that is the standard now to teach at the university level.

by the 'g-man.'

If I invest 5 years and considerable expense (?4000 per year in fees, 1 year work experience, total ?16000) getting my degree I sure as hell want a return on the investement!

by twitchd8

And I'm sad to say that I knew a LOT of stuff the book was just repeating to me, I've been working with computers since I was in 8th grade. For a class project in 8th grade, we took apart an OLD apple computer and switched out the floppy drive, No biggy... the sad part is, I'm a freshman in college now, and in one of my classes, the book is telling me the EXACT same things I already know, only re-wording it and making it sound complex... well, up to actually partitioning the Hard Drive (I've never done that, I've known a method of doing it, but I've never had the time to do it... also, I don't feel like risking my computer to do it). The classes are all online at my college, and I'm seriously thinking about just quitting and going to work where, at least I'll get some hands-on experience. As you say, though, the paper DOES look nice. It's a sad but very true fact. All my college does is gets you a ton of certifications and attaches an associate's degree to it, thus the life of community college... I'm thinking about switching both colleges AND majors. But I still like to work with computers, and would love to do it for a career.

by ksoniat

Hopefully your classes will catch up with you soon and you will actually start to learn something.

Now is not a good time to be entering the job market ESPECIALLY without experience OR a degree OR a certificate.

If the classes are on-line can you get a part-time job to also get some experience.

Right now you need every weapon in your arsenal. Regardless of whether it is "truly" useful, many companies will not even look at you without the degree.

by rushdi.kirsten

I would say that it all depends on the person. You can have a Degree, industry Certs and 5 years experience and still not be as good as someone that learnt the old fashion way. Someone that says they have a degree but spent most of their time playing games, this is a person I would say does not have much of an ambition.

Yes you get a degree so you can get you foot in the door, but in some cases does not guarantee the job. I have worked with engineers that have Degree's, industry certs but still asked a simple thing like what does the /24 notation mean on a network address.... Go figure some mothers do have em?

by the 'g-man.'

you ask them questions that makes them think exactly the same thing about you and a lack of Degree. It is all relative.

by the 'g-man.'

I have said degree however it was included with 1 year industry placement making the total course 5 years. That way I go from Uni to work with 12 months real experience under my belt.

That and I worked for the IT departement (Part-Time) at the Uni on my last year of course. Bummped the 12 up to 24, left Uni, got an Admin Job, years later now an IT Manager.

Oh, and I have that bit of paper.

by notsochiguy

This is a tangent to the actual purpose of the thread, but since I've read a few comments on TR recently about people thinking about dumping college altogether, I think it bears some mention.

Colleges and universities are a great way to gain experience on top of the classroom learning. Either through working within the confines of the school (tech lab, tutoring, projects, etc) or through internships or job placement programs; you have a lot of directions opened to you that you just can't typically get on your own in the real world.

Case in point, there was recently a tech job fair in downtown Chicago. There were about 6 or 7 firms there hosting the event, and literally a few thousand applicants showed up.

A local university is sponsoring a meet and greet with many of the same firms that were at the job fair, on top of a handful more. It is only open to students of select programs. Meaning, the chance to get a 1-on-1 conversation and much needed face time with the potential employers is SIGNIFICANTLY higher through the college event than it is through the 'real world' event. On top of that, several faculty members will be present, so there is the chance to wrangle one of them to get good word-of-mouth, too.

Finally, when you're part of a college or university 'family', you already have quite the network of people with whom you can work with to find a job. My school has a LinkedIn group for alumni, and it is quite active; there have been a fair number of posts discussing alumnus helping alumnus with job placements.

Again, this was not related to the main purpose of the thread, but I just felt it was something that needed to get thrown out for consideration.

by the 'g-man.'

some people who have not attended further education have a blinkered view / resentment to what it actually is or is not.

The same can be said for those who did attend against those who did not.

If you can can prove you can the job you will likely get the job. Anything else is not the fault of those that attended / did not attend further education but the hiring processes of some companies.

Take it up with them.

I chose my path and I'm happy. If some people are unhappy with the situation well then thats their problem. They knew the state of play long before now!

As I said, take it up with the hiring companies and not the people who selected to follow a chosen path, just as they did!

by ksoniat

When I was getting back into the workforce I thought about teaching as I actually have an education degree (music though).

SC actually has a special "fast track" for non traditional teachers for high demand subjects such as math.

I looked at masters programs also as it would be hard to go back to high schools with the environment now - One reason I liked music was the students _chose_ to be there.

by the 'g-man.'

Would you hire somebody who has never been to High School despite the fact they told you they learned all that is needed on their own (but can't prove it)?