Discussion Locked

How much data fits on a cdr? 3.8 GigaBytes!

0 helpful
23 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

They say 700 MB.

okay, then how in the world is this 687 MB Music cd [ windows says only cda content ] having 3.8 GB of data..
19 wav files, one for each track.
19 ogg files, one for each track.
19 cda files, one for each track.
19 flac files, one for each track.
plus, cddb information
and
1 cda with every track in one file
1 ogg with every track in one file
1 wav with every track in one file
1 flac with every track in one file

So, I figured a few oddities with the Master disk for a new release.

it gets even odder, I put a commercially made cd into the drive, and it also has all this extra data on it.
yet, windows says it's only a 457 MB disk with only cda content.

23 replies

by jaqui

it's the recording studios master cd.
clearly labelled as a 750 MB cdrom.

That's why I put a store bought CD, Mannheim Steamroller's Fresh Aire I, 435 MB of music, yet it also is gigabytes of content under newer GNU-Linux system.

by the scummy one

say that they had lots of data on them, however even though the file sizes showed as MB's, the data was all missing.
Is the data actually there?

If so, then how much data can you copy to the cd?

by tink!

Windows must be told to ignore all that other stuff. Perhaps it's a Windows conspiracy - trying to keep us all in the dark about how much space there REALLY is on these magical discs. :D

by jaqui

it's another instance of me getting more bang than I'm supposed to. ]:)

I have been known for doing far more meals than should be possible with the quantity of ingredients I started with.

food for 100 people, at a buck a person yet, fed 600 people.

food for 250 fed 500

portioning out crab and shrimp, should have gotten 88 portions, got 130.

silly thing is, I never shorted anyone or any thing.

it just grew to be the amount needed.

by sleepin'dawg

J.C. became the most famous and successful Jew of all time. He was also the first bartenderin the world, what with his water into wine gimmick.

Tell me have you tried walking on water yet or do you not want to get your shoes all wet?? :^0

[i][b]Dawg[/i][/b] ]:)

by thechas

Here is the link to the standard optical media technical data site.

http://www.osta.org/specs/index.htm

There is a lot of data and specifications to dig through.

My take is that the 700 MB is the net data capacity after you account for all of the file structure and data recovery that is part of the format.

Chas

by jaqui

and that gives me a clue.

the GNU-Linux system could be reading the cda content, and generating virtual files in other formats on the disk as metadata associated with the disk.

why the devs would add that functionality is beyond me, but it does seem a more likely scenario than 3.8 gigs on a 700 mb cd.

by jaqui

bash,
konqeror,
midnight commander...

every app and tool that reads the audio cds is showing this "extra" data on the disk.

by jaqui

when I copy the data from the cd, I get 3.8 GB of files copied with no problem.

since the disk is fixated, there is no more writing to the cd.

by sleepin'dawg

Maybe the DVD's had empty space and were relabled as CDs in a move to improve the bottom line. There might have been over production of some DVDs so why not try to recoup the loss by reusing them as CDs. Have you tried to access the data to see what it consists of???

[i][b]Dawg[/i][/b] ]:)

by oz_media

I've seen it at a studio too, it seems that the file structure and formatting cues on the CD appear to some hardware as decompressed files by some studio equipment. They automatically estimate the necessary available space/file size after decompression, perhaps linux does that too.

The files are never actually decompressed to be read though, so that estimated needed space to decompress it is irrelevant but makes it APPEAR to have ample storage for such a file to be read, while it never is actualy read in decompressed format.

I wonder what Balthor's views on this would be, probably simpler than my explanation and it would be interesting to read about military trained aliens.

by jaqui

makes sense, with the fancy studio hardware.

It's odd that Linux can do the same thing with consumer hardware, and that the extra stuff CAN be accessed.

by oz_media

Perhaps the raw simlicity of linux is what sees it. Not to say Windows is more advanced but the format on Windows may just recognize the file types and understand they are enrcypted and acknowledge teh CD's actual size. Linux, on the other hand, may simply be reading but not reconizing a large compressed file type and estimating its extracted size, then basing the total file size on it.

by oz_media

I'll check later for an ark in the area.

Perhaps he will part the waters of Beaver Lake (he, he, I said beaver).

by jaqui

leave the house with $20.00 and go to work.
come back from work with $100 to $300 in my pocket.

and nope, never stole a dime of it.

by oz_media

I used to find that too, leave broke and get home loaded, always a nice way to spend a day.

I'd make more money at lunch or right after work than all day AT work, of course just making legal side deals and earning extra bucks for little work or input here and there (that's what I miss about living downtown, easy money). There were so many rich guys running companies who had no idea how to keep up with technology, I'd be popping out PDF's for several hundred a page or even just writing copy on a napkin and getting paid fistfuls for it. "HOw much do you want?" You'd start low and after a while just throw out numbers and they pull out the cash, makes me wonder what the hell I'm doing here these days?!?!? I should get back downtown and start raking it in again.

When that failed there was always darts, made a LOT of money playing darts with brokers and the likes.

by jaqui

you should bring that up.

My estranged wife swears I do walk on water.
myself, I swear there was a tree right below the water level, and I jumped on it to prove it to her. she doesn't believe me.

by hal 9000

When I copied a couple of MP3 Files to a CD to be played.

The machine that burnt the CD claimed that they where 44 KB CDA Files well actually 2 44 K Files but on either a CD Player or different computer they showed up as straight Audio Files of 4 + Minutes duration and ranged from 2.8 to 5 MEG in size.

I think it's something to do with the way that the software stores the data on the CD here but because I was busy I didn't look overly hard at it and that was done on a XP System using Nero 6. ;)

I don't have that CD here any more so I can not look at it again. Though I suppose if I had the time I could make another one to have a play with.

Col

by oz_media

CDA files are basically just an index file (thus only 44kb), it isn't actually the song itself, which is a separate file altogether also included on the disk. All storebought CD's and some burned ones will offer small CDA files.
Your first PC was showing the CDA files which are linked to the related audio tracks on the disk. The second was reading the audio tracks themselves, it usually depends on how you open tham and what with as to what you see.

If you copy the tracks straight to your hard drive they will not play without the accompanying audio tracks from the CD too.

This is another reason that CD ripping software got so popular, people kept screwing up blank disks by trying to just copy the audio data across and were only copying the CDA files without the actual tracks attached. I don't know how many people have tracked me down all frustrated with thier burned CD's in the past. " I just copied everything straight over and it didn't work!"

by hal 9000

The Files where originally MP3 and I used Nero to copy them to a Audio CD where they just showed as 2 X 44 KB CDA Files with nothing else on the CD Blank but played OK on that system.

So I threw that CD at another System made sure that it actually played and then took it to my Sisters place where I tested again on a actual CD player not a Computer.

Now I'm going to have to go down there again and get that Disc back to see what is actually on it. Not my idea of fun I might add. ;)

Col

This discussion is closed to new replies.