Question Locked

How to pick an IT Guy

0 helpful
21 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am looking for someone qualified to fix my server issues and set up VPN. I get tons of applicants all with different certifcations and degrees. What are the main things I should look for as far a certifications for setting up server 2003 and VPN for a 10 person network?

Thanks

21 replies

by jdmercha

Since you have a specific need, look at experience first. Eliminate all applicants that do not have 4+ years experience setting up servers and VPNs.

From that list eliminate all those without a BS.

From that list eliminate all those without an MS.

From that list eliminate all those without a degree in engineering.

From that list eliminate all those without a degree from a top 100 university.

by stress junkie

You say to favor experience but then you eliminate anyone without a college degree. Isn't that inconsistent?

by kjell_andorsen

While I would have made it past the first set of pruning thanks to my experience, I would have been wiped out due to lack of degrees. Nevertheless I could definitly set up a Windows Server 2003 VPN and secure it nicely. As could thousands of techs that don't have an MS in engineering from a top 100 University. Your selection criteria are way overkill. You'd end up getting someone who's most likely overqualified who would most likely cost a hell of a lot more than nescessary.

by 3xp3rt

Just 1 point is right: ?4+ years experience setting up servers and VPNs?
All the other points are a big cloud without real content. I know a lot of people who have no meet those requirements, but they are top IT proofs. (It?s right that they have 10+ years of experience)
One question for jdmercha: In your organization the system administrator have the NOBEL Price?

by slappymcnasty

This could possibly be the worst list I have ever seen to weed out resumes.

by cg it

setting up a VPN for a 10 user company isn't all that hard. what you need is someone who can read because the "How To" is available on Microsoft's Help and Support site and on virtually any firewall hardware vendors support site.

VPN has always been a pain for network admins. Users always complain it's to slow, they can't connect, blah blah. When it comes down to it, the problems users see usually are because a user makes changes on their computer which mucks up the configuration set by the network admin.

If one can read and follow step by step instructions, then they can set up a VPN. That is if they can get access to firewalls and proxies that need configuration as well.

by puppybreath

like you need a job and want to get rid of any competition.

I wouldn't waste my company's money on someone with an MS from top 100 university and a degree in engineering to set up a VPN for 10 people. Talk about being overqualified and overkill.........

by notsochiguy

...like he was taking (and rightfully, so) a potshot at 'technical' recruiters whose idea of clicking the mouse on the screen consists of some plastic on LCD violence; and couldn't identify a solid tech candidate if God reached down from the heavens and put the resume on said recruiter's lap.

Surprised there was no requirement for 5 years of Windows 2003 implementation, though!

by dr dij

Now eliminate those who won't work for $30k/year and put in 4 hours a day overtime,

(and be willing to stop by bosses house unpaid after hours and fix the PC his kid cr*ppd up with viruses)

while training someone in India to do the job over remote lines.

by reptechlic

If you follow this recipe, you'll be paying top dollar! Not to mention, this person will NOT be satisfied to just babysit your servers and setup VPN. You'd better have some interesting IT projects in your queue.

How much were you planning on spending?

by georgeou

It took me one week to become proficient in Windows Server VPN and I didn't have any certs or degrees. 3 months later I built many types of VPN servers using single-home and dual-homed Windows Server VPN configurations and know every nook and cranny about Windows Server VPN and every quirk on the server and client end and how to work around them. The qualifications you listed are real nice and that type of person could probably easily figure out how to set up a VPN server, but it isn't essential to building a VPN server.

You can technically have "4 years of experience" on something without actually being a master of it if you only use a limited static design. On the other hand you can be a master of something in months if you actually have to design, build, and troubleshoot multiple sophisticated configurations.

by jmgarvin

Certs may or may not mean the guy knows what he is doing. So on that note:

1) Look for someone that can answer simple questions about networking, Win2k3, and whatever VPN you want

2) Ask for a time table. For what you are asking for (I think you need a network with outside access from the ground up) you are in the 3-6 month range.

3) With only 10 people it should be somewhat trivial to setup and get the internals deployed. The hardest part will be a good strong VPN setup.

4) Make sure you have TONS of documentation. This documentation should cover how YOU can reset the VPN, add users, etc.

by georgeou

"4) Make sure you have TONS of documentation. This documentation should cover how YOU can reset the VPN, add users, etc."

You don't actually "add users" to a Windows 2000/2003 VPN server if it's set up correctly integrated in to an active directory. Users are automatically added when their computer is joined to the domain and the new user account is created in the active directory. Machine certificates are automatically issued to computers that join the domain. You can of course restrict the users to something more granular than "Domain Users" and create a "Remote Access" group and require users to belong to that group in order to use Remote Access VPN.

I've operated many Windows Server 2003 L2TP VPN servers supporting hundreds of remote users and I've never once had to actually restart the VPN server after years of operation. I actually almost forget about it since it almost never gives me hassles. The only types of issues I have is if the machine certificate expires on the server or the client if you're using L2TP and you need to renew the certificates.

by anders_emajl

OK, sounds like.... some issues....
and suggested 3-6 month may do it.

On the other hand, setting up only the 2k3 server with VPN for 10 users shouldn't take more than max a week.
Add time for documentation, and suggest you get a cookbook manual -howto install VPN, -howto add user, - howto ...
Skip the tech stuff and hire when needed.

Had a VPN problem and hired a guy to fix it.

Action was to connect remote plant and PC's inside local network (NAT) to our plant, through routers, switches into the intranet via win2k3 server and to the AS400 server. All was done by an experianced technitian without any degree whatsoever, just hard working and lot of interrest
Took him 1 day to do the basics and additional day for some support. He used a user at the remote site (with some extra IT-knowledge) and guided him by phone to allow remote desctop and open some ports. The rest was performed with remote desktop connections.

by rschmid1

In the downloads tab there is a test called network skill set. Gives you an idea of how the person will work out, how they can handle situations. Also gives you an idea of how well they can trouble shoot.

by puppybreath

would be to contact William Gates at Microsoft and contract him to bring a team of network experts out to design and install the system. If you're going to go overboard, why not go all the way?

by georgeou

There are different ways to set up a Windows 2003 VPN server and the candidate should be able to set up a single-home and a dual-homed configuration. The person should know how to support split tunneling or how to prevent split tunneling. He should understand the fundamentals of TCP/IP, subnets, DNS, WINS (legacy support), DHCP, firewalling and how they tie in to a Windows 2003 VPN server. The candidate should know how to build a Windows 2003 L2TP server since PPTP is worthless for security. http://blogs.techrepublic.com.com/Ou/index.php?p=21

If I were evaluating a person, I'd give him the following real life question.

A user was able to connect to an Exchange server a week ago until he upgraded his personal router. Once the router was upgraded, the user is no longer able to get to the Exchange server. The candidate should know how to ask me the appropriate questions as if I was the helpless user to troubleshoot the issue. After asking the appropriate questions and getting the real world answers, the candidate should be able to figure out the cause of the problem and figure out a workaround. This is a real-life question based on a real-life quirk in Windows Server VPN.

by cg it

Those are great questions George, CCNP and a MCSE certifications plus some real life experience, but this is a small 10 person small business. They can't afford a full time IT person who will want $45 to $55K per year because they are a CCNP and MCSE. There are plenty of SMB consultants who would charge a base fee to setup VPN for them and then try to sell a managed service plan.

My point about being able to read is that Microsoft has a vast how to library for how to. Your link on VPN with Windows Server is just one example. Router mfgs have similar libraries of how to configure their equipment.

One doesn't need a CCNP and MCSE to setup VPN access for a small business. Just know where to look for the how to articles, and spend the time to read em.

by georgeou

Sure, but I would definitely hire someone like that to design and build the system. Then you can have a cheaper guy operate the system. Designing it the wrong way will cost you a lot more money in the long run because it's harder to use/deploy. The cost of a security breach is something that we can't even begin to measure.

By the way, even an MCSE or CCNP if they lack hands-on design and troubleshooting experience can't answer my questions. On the other hand, there are people who don't have MCSEs or CCNPs who can answer my questions. Furthermore, your typical MCSE and CCNP wants a lot more than $55K a year (at least most places I've been to).

This discussion is closed to new replies.