Discussion Locked

[i] Breaking into Your House - Putting Immigration into Perspective X-(

0 helpful
15 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Let's say I break into your house.

[i]A lady wrote the best letter in the editorials in ages!!! It
explains things better than all the baloney you hear on TV.

Her point: [/i]

Recently, large demonstrations have taken place across the country
protesting the fact that Congress is finally addressing the issue of
illegal immigration.

Certain people are angry that the U.S. might protect its own
borders, might make it harder to sneak into this country and, once
here, to stay indefinitely.

Let me see if I correctly understand the thinking behind these
protests.

Let's say I break into your house.

Let's say that when you discover me in your house, you insist that I
leave.

But I say, "I've made all the beds and washed the dishes and did the
laundry and swept the floors. I've done all the things you don't
like to do. I'm hard-working and honest (except for when I broke
into your house)."

According to the protesters:

You are Required to let me stay in your house
You are Required to add me to your family's insurance plan
You are Required to Educate my kids
You are Required to Provide other benefits to me and to my family
(my husband will do all of your yard work because he is also
hard-working and honest, except for that breaking in part).

If you try to call the police or force me out, I will call my
friends who will picket your house carrying signs that proclaim my
RIGHT to be there.

It's only fair, after all, because you have a nicer house than I do,
and I'm just trying to better myself.

I'm a hard-working and honest, person, except for well, you know, I
did break into your house.

And what a deal it is for me!!!

I live in your house, contributing only a fraction of the cost of my
keep, and there is nothing you can do about it without being accused
of cold, uncaring, selfish, prejudiced, and bigoted behavior.

Oh yeah, I DEMAND that you learn MY LANGUAGE!!! so you can
communicate with me.

Why can't people see how ridiculous this is?! Only in America ...if
you agree, pass it on (in English). Share it if you see the value of
it.

If not, blow it off......... along with your future Social Security
funds, and a lot of other things.

[b][i]From time to time you read something like this and your in total agreement with the idea when looked at in a general sense but and this is a big but, we tend to let the focus slip when we view the matter in individual cases. We make exceptions, unaware that in making the exception we have opened the way for hundreds, if not thousands of other "exceptions".

The law is the law and it must be applied across the board without exception and those endeavouring to circumvent the law should be penalized to the fullest extent under those laws, without any exceptions.[/i]

Dawg[/b] ]:)

15 replies

by mylittlemansanidiot

I remember watching a documentary on the squatter co-op in London. They eventually became an "accepted" part of the area. They exclusivley squatted in emtpy office buildings, such as banks and other old financial institute buildings. They proved to be a very positive thing for the area.

by mylittlemansanidiot

Comparing a single household to a country doesn't cut it in my opinion. It's more akin to her illegally moving into the house across the street and then mowing your lawns and doing your housework for $1.50 an hour.

I don't disagree with it's overall sentiment, I just find it leaves a bad taste in my mouth.

Edit: Actually, the squatting analogy isn't really fitting either, unless both houses are part of some compound which the legal tenant belongs to and pays some sort of levy to, and the illegal tenant doesn't.

by sleepin'dawg

You must enjoy paying increased taxes for decreasing services. Being in Australia, sort of puts you off the beaten path for illegal immigrants, not that you don't have any.

Civilized society is based on rules; rules of law and rules of custom. Everytime, or anytime, an exception is made for any of these rules society steps onto the proverbial slippery slope, a slope which only leads downward into the chaos of a disfunctional repressive society lumbered with the taxes and tariffs which are required to support the overload on society's services.

Those in the top tax brackets get tired of being bled to support this and take steps to avoid the worst effects of the increased taxation, and furthermore our incentive for productivity become drastically lowered. Why bust a gut to support and provide services for those who are not paying their fair share into the system?

Being in Australia, you get a few hundred illegals every year and if you want to support them fine and dandy. However, in the northern hemisphere whether it's North America or Europe the illegal immigants number in the tens of thousands. The real danger in this, is that there is every indication of a reactionary backlash forming and if it takes hold and gets establihed, the current abuses of terrorism will be as nothing to the horrors that may be unleashed. Genocide and ethnic cleansing are just the outriders of what may well be in store for civilized society.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by mylittlemansanidiot

Wow, you can tell all that from my post?

All I said was the analogy was flawed. As far as me being a "liberal socialist", I'm not even sure what that is. Sounds like an oxymoron. Anyway, as I said, I don't disagree with the sentiment of the analogy, I just feel it was oversimplified and contained, what I perceived to be, a racist undercurrent (hence the bad taste).

I don't consider myself to fall into any of the current sociopolitical factions people often use to label others who have a different point of view. I'm just a guy who's trying to get by, enjoy life, and die thinking I've lived the best I can. I firmly believe that if someone breaks the law, they should be punished accordingly. I'm also a bit of a cynic, but I certainly don't share your somewhat bleak outlook on the future of society.

by stephencairns

I agree laws are laws. But you kind of loose the moral high ground when the person that broke in says "I did not break in just walked in the back door. I passed you on the stairs last week and you said nothing then. The rest of your family knew I was here, they've been giving me jobs to do and paying me. Didn't they tell you?" and the rest of your family look at their shoes and say nothing.

by sleepin'dawg

once you are aware and put a stop to the situation, the law breakers should not be rewarded for their crime, regardless of who aided and abetted them. In fact those who have done so should be penalized as well.

Immigration isn't the problem, [b][i]ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION[/b][/i] under the guise of being refugees is and the sooner we get a handle on it by enforcing the statutes already on the books and putting an end to the abuses of the appeals process, the better off we will be. Yes there are some legitimate refugees but for every real refugee their are ten or more "economic" refugees who are abusing our system. There are far too many que jumpers with hard luck stories.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by highlander718

"I did not break in just walked in the back door. I passed you on the stairs last week and you said nothing then.

Since when is walking in somebody else's house OK ? And it's not "passed you on the stairs" but sneaked by you eventualy...

That being said, I agree that you cannot treat the illegal immigration problem (involving millions of people) same as a break in of one person. You cannot just throw out or jail millions of people. I think a mixed approach is appropriate, you have to discourage future illegal immigrants but you also have to do something with the existing ones.

by sleepin'dawg

It hasn't worked yet. We grant an amnesty to the ones that are here, giving them legal status. No sooner than the deadline passes for that and a new batch arrives. We are too permissive and lax with these people. They are illegals but we grant them rights - almost the same rights as citizens.

If we are serious about discouraging them we should be curtailing their "rights" - not extending them. Once caught they should be on the next outbound means of transport - none of the appeals process nonsense. These people are social parasites and should be treated as such.

Their are thousands of real indigent people obeying the rules, obeying our laws and waiting patiently for admitance. These people are being denied their rightful place by these illegal immigrants.

We also have our own poor who are in need but are being denied services due to the overload of these illegals on our society. What's the solution??? Damned if I know but I do know it cannot be allowed to continue.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by dadspad

I see where many get confused about this, so maybe it should be a farm.

Now I will not repeat all that you stated for the house, but apply here.

There was a 100 acre farm run by a small family. The couple had two sons that are in their twentys and have proven to be trustworthy in the past.

Now this farm was not making a profit, but though several investors, could keep operating till profitable by a tight budget.

The farm work had increased to the point that more than two sons and the father could handle. So the father gives the two sons a sum of money to get more workers. He tells the sons that he wants them to work the south 40 acres and he will work the rest. He also reminds them that there is a requirement by the investors that they can only hire from qualified work programs available in the city or the farm can face penalties. The sons agree and leave.

The sons start talking and decide that what is needed is more profit so that the farm can expand and pay back the investors. So they hire a few persons from the qualified work programs and fill in the majority with untrained, unqualified but hard working people. And the sons were happy that profits were up and did not tell their father what they had done.

One day an investor, as was his habit, sent an accountant to look at the part of the farm the sons ran. The accountant arrived unannounced and saw that there were more workers than he expected and their living conditions were terrible. Small housing for large families, no sanitary facilities, etc. The accountant confronted the sons and asked to see the employment records so he verifiy all requirements were followed. The accountant asked why there was over twice as many workers than the paperwork showed? The sons said they would investigate the matter and get back with him.

The accountant said he must inform the investor and their father as there were penaties involved. Later the investor and father came to talk with the sons to see if a way could be found to stop the illegal hiring with as little impact a possible.

Instead of a quiet talk with the sons, there was over 10,000 people there and it looked like a circus. There were protestors, media people interviewing everyone, helicopters flying over broadcasting; the investor and father just stood there with there mouths open. The investor gets a cell phone call, and after a time, hangs up and tells the father he has very bad news for him. There had been a ruling that sons could keep the illegal workers and pay only a very small penalty. But the father must pay all support for the workers.

(Insert here most of the last part of Dawgs house post on demands)

And finally, the investor tells the father, you must provide retirement for the workers, as they do not have any. The father says that they would be taking money that he and mother had been saving for over 50 years so they could live comfortably in their elder years. He had always wanted to leave the farm in good financial shape for his sons. The investor said he was sorry, but could do nothing for him, and left.

The father faced his sons, and always having a positive attitude, told them we will work it out somehow. But asked the sons if they had learned their lesson on only hiring qualified workers.

The sons looked at their father and said, you really don't have a clue. Next harvest we will hire all cheap labor, none from the qualified programs. We now know how to keep media pressure on to have no penalties for our hiring practices. They agreed to give the father a portion of their profits so the farm will not bankrupt.

Of course the farm is the U.S., the sons were the business hiring illegal aliens. (note: all business must fill out a form (I9) on each employee confirming that the business has proven the worker has all work permits before hiring.)

The crazyness of this it that it is all true.

Special note: There was no mention of daughters, there was a reason. All the daughters were following the rules, there were,also, other sons doing the same. If not for the daughters, the farm would have been bankrupt long ago. So please no flames :D

by maxwell edison

....equally and aggressively enforced, or they should be repealed. In the case of illegal immigration (illegal being the key), the sentiment especially rings true.

The person who (correctly) pointed out how the law has been ignored for so long should ask him/her self, therefore what? Should they therefore be ignored forever? Should they be repealed? Should the current law-breakers get a free pass? Or should they FINALLY start enforcing the existing immigration laws?

I believe they should FINALLY start enforcing ALL the existing immigration laws AND do whatever is necessary to make the borders as secure as possible. We should have "check-valve" borders -- a free flow to get out; but if you want to get in, you must do all the right things to open the valve; no exceptions should be made.

by dadspad

If all the exiting laws of immagration was enforced there would be no problem. If no work, the flow ceases.

Question: Do you think there is a big powerbase being built that is behind the lack of enforcement on this issue on illegal immigration?

by maxwell edison

As of now, there are scores of ?sanctuary cities? in which local governments have actually passed ordinances prohibiting their police departments from checking the immigration status of anyone. Hundreds more don?t have laws, per se, but rather "don't ask, don't tell" policies. I don?t specifically know of any city or state that has immigration laws on their books (not to say there aren?t some), and most immigration laws we discuss are federal.

San Francisco, Detroit, Denver (and Boulder), Los Angeles, San Diego, Houston, Austin, Seattle, Madison, Portland, and on and on, are all sanctuary cities for illegal immigrants. Is your city on the list?

http://ojjpac.org/sanctuary.asp

These sanctuary cities justify their action (or non-action, in this case), by ?claiming? they don?t have the resources to enforce and prosecute the federal immigration laws. I suspect there might be some degree of justification to that, but not a heck of a lot. I also suspect that the political and social motivations of those cities would turn a blind-eye to it anyway. Moreover, the hypocrisy and inconsistency in several such cities can be illustrated by noticing how many of these cities (and there are indeed many) have actually legalized smoking marijuana, for example, but the local law enforcement agencies and city councils insist on enforcing the federal law against the stuff, and they still make arrests accordingly ? even though the voters made it legal (or not illegal) in their city.

Do I think there?s is a big powerbase being built that is behind the lack of enforcement, you ask? Well, I don?t believe these people have annual conventions and make a concerted effort to ignore the laws, but I do believe the political and social leanings of such people certainly do coincide with each other, and their political and social agendas guide their actions (or lack thereof).

A solution I could go along with? Deny Department of Homeland Security funding (or some other federal funding) to any city or state that passes any type of ?sanctuary? law and/or openly refuses to enforce the existing federal laws. The feds will cut-off highway funds if states don?t pass seat belt laws, they place certain education demands under the threat of lost funding, federal funds for public transportation, and on it goes, so this tactic isn?t exactly unprecedented. (However, I must admit, I disagree with the tactic in all three cases I cited; so it does leave me in a bit of an inconsistent quandary.)

How about a radical idea? Hire an additional 10,000 federal marshals, each with the specific mandate and authority to track down, arrest, prosecute, and deport 1,000 illegal immigrants (10,000 x 1,000 = 10 million), and give them exactly 24 (or so) months to do it. Pay them around $50,000 per year (plus expenses), with potential bonuses that could earn them an additional $50,000 depending on how close they came to meeting their quota. Even if this paid each and every one of them $200,000 over 24 months, that?s only an expenditure of 2 billion dollars, maybe 4 billion with expenses. (Check my math. Did I do that right?) Double, triple, or quadruple that total, it doesn't matter, and it would still be worth the cost. Nonetheless, regardless of what it might cost, it?s a mere drop in the bottomless money bucket of the 3 trillion dollars our government spends annually. (And illustrates just how much 3 trillion dollars in spending really is!)

by av .

This is a perfect representation of whats happening in the US with illegal immigration.

We are supposedly a nation of laws and we have 12 - 20 million illegals living among us and off of us legal taxpayers. The fact that our government wants to give them a path to citizenship after they broke our laws, makes me want to puke. And - they want us taxpayers to foot the bill to do it too. Thats the ultimate kick in the a$$ to the legal residents in this country.

Its time to send the illegals back home. They'll leave on their own if we start enforcing our existing immigration laws. Fine illegal employers and landlords.

Illegal immigration should not ever be a path to citizenship in this country. They need to go home. If they can't respect our laws, we don't want them.

AV

This discussion is closed to new replies.