Discussion Locked

I'm surprised this Terry Childs case hasn't seen a lot more discussion

0 helpful
23 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

In particular the judge, who by his decisions is rewritting the definition between a "user" and an "administrator" in regards to computer networks. This has really huge consequences for network administrators, especially in California.

Here's an article by Paul Venezia of Infoworld:

http://www.infoworld.com/t/insider-threat/how-terry-childs-case-could-harm-password-security-802?page=0,0

that puts into perspective the quandry the prosecution has with Terry Childs. The prosecution wants to convict him of something and the denial of service is about the only thing they can convict him of. If they do that, convict him of denial of service under a California statute, then by refusing to give out passwords to network infrastructure to basically anyone, a network administrator could be found guilty of criminal conduct. So this is going to be a really interesting case for computer networks and the administrators that manage them.

What the prosecution ought to do is drop the charges, he's been in jail for 16 months,

and the City should come up with policies regarding critical network infrastructure access.... if they don't and do convict Terry Childs on the denial of service, we are all in trouble.

23 replies

by seanferd

Venezia's coverage of the Childs incident has been great from the beginning.

The really stupid thing is, I can't see it as denial of service at all. The network Childs was building was not even in production. He acted correctly in not handing over critical passwords to unauthorized persons.

They probably would have screwed him if he had handed over the info, and the new manager-type had caused a failure by messing with or putting into production a network which was not ready.

by charliespencer

"...by refusing to give out passwords to network infrastructure to basically anyone, a network administrator could be found guilty of criminal conduct."

I already regard it as professional incompetence, if not misconduct. I can't imagine any circumstances under which only a single person knows a network password, unless it's a home, personal, or other single user network. What happens when that person gets run over by a truck?

by hal 9000

Really Pally?

I can think of several reasons why this might happen, and while I agree that it's anything but good enough in every instance where it has happened to me it wasn't my doing and I did everything possible to alter the situation. However most people find it unacceptable to walk out on a job because they need the income to eat.

I no longer do any Government work for this very reason, I was far too often placed in the position where I was the only one with the [b]Keys to the Kingdom[/b] and the people in charge wanted things that way. No matter what I tried to change I was fought at every attempt to change this situation.

I did of course refuse to hands out the Passwords to anyone who asked but I always made sure that I had informed those that should know what these Passwords where even if they did throw the Messages straight into the rubbish bin. I also had the Passwords locked up in a safe so that if anything happened to me they could get into the system and do whatever was required.

In the last case I had to buy the safe myself and place it in the Work Environment as the Government Operatives in charge didn't want to waste the money required to do something so pointless like that. :D

Col

by charliespencer

"I also had the Passwords locked up in a safe so that if anything happened to me they could get into the system and do whatever was required."

Safes are a great idea. As you said, the point it that someone could have opened that safe and had the passwords they needed. It's very different from the Childs situation.

by jck

My house.

No one else needs to know my machine passwords or network passwords or router admin passwords.

I think the guy was responsible to give them up to his superiors, whose job it was to find his replacement. They were not his property to keep to himself, and therefore withheld "property" not belonging to him from his employer.

by forum surfer

I stated it in another post and I'll state it again. As a government employee, the rules are different. Being a CCIE working with routing across a MAN or WAN, there are more than likely public safety systems residing on these networks. His actions are quite literally jeopardizing the lives of citizens. In the event of network failure on a day he happens to be in Tahiti with no backup to cover him, he could affect critical response times for EMS, Fire and Police services. These often reside on the same WAN's and LAN's with a guy like this segmenting the traffic to adhere to security protocol. Terrible judgment on his part. He deserved to be fired and jailed.

Now if he had worked for a corporation, simply firing the guy or some administrative punishment would suffice. But as a government employee that has to answer to taxpayers and ensure government operation and the safety of its citizens, his actions were beyond reprehension.

by charliespencer

I'll amend by original statement to read, "unless it's a home, personal, or other single user network." Even then I'd recommend someone have local Admin access to each system on the network in case of emergencies.

by hal 9000

They would have forgot where they hold the key for the Safe and the Combination would never have been committed to memory.

Some of the people that I used to work with would have insisted that the Combination along with the Emergency Key be kept safe inside the safe. ;)

Kind of reminds me of the ISP who you ring because you are unable to recieve any E-Mail so they offer to e-mail you the fix to the problem.

But you are right the Childs Case is different he only had control of th Fiber Optic backbone and didn't actually hold any Data other than the Passwords for the Cisco Routers. So if a Boeing fell out of the sky onto him no one would have been put out except whoever drew the short straw to replace him. Even then knowing Bureaucrats they would have put off employing a replacement till the Backbone fell over and then demand that whoever was brought in to fix it get it running immediately and preferably 20 minutes before getting called. :D

Just can not beat Bureaucrats as the realities don't apply to them they just want it to work without being involved in doing the Mundane Unimportant Things like knowing what it is that they are supposed to be doing. Provided that they can carry a bit of Blank Paper round with them they are busy till the paper rots in their hands and falls to bits.

The last Recombination that I made tot he Federal Governments Committee about 10 or so years ago was rejected and they saved themselves 1 Million $. Now that have to impelment what I told them that they would need all those years ago and it's going to cost them 40 Billion$. But they did save a Million $ back then.

These people are masters of spending a Trillion $ so that they can save the Budget 1 cent. Every Government Department that I have ever been involved in specialize in Wasting Resources. It appears to be all that they can actually do. ;)

Col

by hal 9000

Drugging, Depriving a Co workers Liberty and Tattooing their A$$ is?

:D :^0

Nice idea though but I'm sure that with the Government work that I used to do there would have been a Sexual Harassment Complaint lodged as well as whatever else they could think of. ;)

Col

by forum surfer

Withholding passwords from other admins, management or superiors does deserve jail time in his case. He was responsible for a large fiber MAN for a large city. He was putting the citizens at risk. If he died in a plane crash, who would correct routing problems? Once routes start flapping and the network crashes you would lose network segments. One of those segments could have been 911 communications. Now this guy's arrogance and poor delegation ability is increasing EMS dispatch time. So yeah, his arrogance could have cost someone their life in a not so far fetched situation.

I couldn't imagine a small city, much less the city in question relying on one guy for their fiber backbone. You're looking at a single [b]human[/b] point of failure that could affect socail services, 911 communication, police, fire and lord knows what else is on the city's fiber MAN.

I've worked with MANs before and I have never seen a situation where one person held that much authority. Excuse me, I did once but efforts were being made to correct the issue.

While he may have been an excellent CCIE, he was a poor manager and planner. He should have gotten a team in place capable of backing him up. With proper setup, changes can be tracked by who, what, when and where configurations were changed. I understand building something on that level provides one with a tremendous sense of accomplish. I can also understand not wanting other less knowledgeable admins mucking with your setup. But the fact of the matter is he was providing a service to support the people of that city and he should have had a designated backup person and internal documentation on his creation.

by hal 9000

He didn't withhold Passwords from his Superior's just people who had no right to have those Passwords or Access.

Here it looks to me like a [b]Typical Bureaucratic Screw Up[/b] where the wrong person who didn't have the [b]Authority Asked and was refused the Passwords.[/b] Just like if I worked in a Corporate Bank as a Computer Guy I wouldn't give the Part Time Security Guard the Passwords just because he may ask for them. Just the same as I wouldn't give him the Keys to the Vault because he was short of money.

The person who asks for things in any Business needs to be authorized to have them or it's [b]Immediate Dismissal[/b] and quite rightly so. But you are advocating giving the Mail Boy the Passwords to the system because he may be required to do something that he shouldn't be doing because he was told to.

Just the same as I wouldn't be handing out Access to those who don't know what they are doing as they will stuff it up and from past experience it's not a easy fix after then undo years of work in a few minutes with no idea of what it is that they are doing. After all you designed & Implemented it so you should be able to fix it up faster than I can break it or you are not competent. The Truly Incompetent is the one who gives untrained, unauthorized people access to this level because someone asked them to without proper Authority or Procedures being followed.

Col

by forum surfer

I never said that, sorry if I didn't elaborate well enough. His superiors without a doubt need access. Under any circumstance it is unacceptable for one person and one person alone to possess the keys to the kingdom, especially where public safety is concerned. He should have a trained backup at the minimum. The best solution would be documentation that is kept privy to key personnel and management. This management may very well reside outside of his IT staff, such as city municipal management staff. Obviously the logical choice would have been his own manager or CIO. My point is someone other than just himself should have had the ability to delegate access in the even of his absence due to vacation, dismissal or death.

We run a large, city wide MAN. There is no one person on our network staff that is so privileged that business will not go on without him. Our staff is well trained and we communicate well. No one makes significant route changes or bgp changes without discussion among team members, and more importantly...properly documented changes or modifications. If we make a goof in our bgp tables, the possibility exist to make the route flap and potentially bring down the segment of our ISP that we are on. No one wants to be the guy that broke the internet for our ISP. :) Even without the documentation, we have measures in place so that we know who changed what when and we have the ability to revert config changes.

by jck

I can't think of a single person I'd trust with my network and computers...well, I'd trust my niece...but, she's got no desire to know them.

Besides if you want into my routers, just push the reset button on it. That resets to factory default lol :^0

by hal 9000

I thought that she had to be consenting to make that acceptable.

In every case where I have run into things like this they are [b]Career Bureaucrats[/b] who do as they are told by their superiors because they got there by knowing what needed doing so they are always right. And they are always correct if they have highly skilled Technicians to clean up their messes.

I remember one who didn't want a Key to the Office because she only worked 9-5. After 18 months she had to visit the office one Sunday and couldn't get in the front door. So I had to drive in to let her in wait around till she had finished and set the Alarms and lock up after she left.

She was supposed to be the Computer Manager and all she knew about computers was that they got plugged into a Wall Socket and performed [b]Magic.[/b] That was her definition of the LAN that she supposedly ran. She had enough problems remembering her Password and refused to have it changed at the stated 7 day Policy. She was so [b]Security Conscious[/b] that she used her own name as a Password and even then messed up the Case as she entered it. :D

She was responsible for disposing of several Desktops and refused to replace the HDD as these cost money. At the Government prices they where then about $20.00 each for he HDD and she was trying to get more money for second hand used systems than they cost new. Well she got her way and ran FDisk on all of the drives before they when to Auction.

for the next 18 months I was tied up in the Legal System Providing [b]Expert Testimony[/b] when they chased down and charged the kid who was given two of these computers and he recovered the Data on the HDD's. They came from the Health Department so they had Patient Records of them.

After that Screw Up she was Promoted and within 6 months of the original Auction has sold off 20 systems from a Insecure Position so the HDD where not even looked at. One had the E-Mail Address of the State Primer [i]State Governor[/i] and he started getting E-Mails with requests for Government Grants so there needed to be an Investigation as to how that happened. During that Investigation she got another Promotion.

Then a year or two latter she was responsible for a HP Laser Printer bouncing down the stairs running over two members of the public and destroying her car when it tried to gain entry to her car through the closed drivers door.

Naturally the Budget didn't stretch to buying a new printer so she organized to have this unit repaired at only 300% the cost of a new printer and then it required a new Staff Position to open and close the Front Door when it fell over. That mess resulted in yet another promotion to a position where she could do even more damage. :^0

Then there was the newly installed 2,500 XP workstation LAN without a single server because someone is supposed to have said [i]XP Doesn't require a Server.[/i] The old system was torn out and replaced with the mess over one weekend and she then insisted that the Departments IT Staff [b]Make it Work[/b] in that configuration which of course it couldn't. For 6 months there was no work finished in that building with 2,500 XP Workstations. It then tool another 3 months to fix the mess up so for 9 months that department was shot to pieces with no real productivity. She got another promotion for that as well. :_|

Col

by hal 9000

In this case it was the Management not Child's who setup the situation the way it was. They couldn't be bothered wanting anyone else knowing and then when a person who didn't have the right to have the Passwords asked and he refused that started the mess.

The Management being [b]Tight[/b] wanted to save money so they refused to have any assistance for Child's or a System in Place to keep the Fiber Optic Backbone running in the even of Child's getting run over by a City Buss on the way home. They had one of the best Cisco Developers at a Bargain Basement Price and they then set about saving even more money by Insisting that he run things.

We don't need assistance we have you. Seemed to be their guiding principle. They then made a Bureaucratic Decision to appoint a Clerk as Security Manager who has no idea of what IT Security actually is and this was who asked and was refused the Passwords. To show the complete Incompetence involved here the City listed the User Passwords in the Indictment and they made the entire system Insecure.

While I'm sure there was a element of [b]personalities[/b] here and I would never have gone the way that Child's did I'm not a Bureaucrat either and I do not consider more responsibility a [b]Good Thing.[/b] It may be necessary but I don't want the responsibility to increase my [i]Perceived Power/Importance[/i] and if I was asked to work under those conditions I would have walked out at the very beginning.

The Management here is so bad that it's Unbelievable as they set this up on a shoe string.

However what I'm interested in finding out is the amount of [b]Down Time[/b] that has occurred after Child's was removed and just how much money has been spent fixing the mess that was made here.

It would also be interesting to find out what has been done to those responsible for creating this mess [b]The Managers involved.[/b] If my past experience is anything to go by they will have been promoted to a position where they can do more damage. ;)

Col

by forum surfer

He should have gave up the passwords when ordered. In many public safety sectors (particularly police) the chief will have all the passwords stored just in case.

Whether the guy appointed was qualified or not, Childs should have surrendered the passwords. I would have documented my objections to cover my rear, but I would have complied if it was me.

I agree, the problem did begin with bad management. But Childs made a bad situation worse. I don't believe that bad management justified his actions.

by hal 9000

I wouldn't have taken the path that he did, but I'm not a Bureaucrat either. This entire situation appears to me at least to be a Bureaucratic Shite Fight that Child's lost.

I'm not sure what I would do when confronted by Police about the Passwords but I very much doubt that I would hand them to someone outside the Sector that I worked in. I would insist that they get the Proper Authority into be handed the Passwords and be more than willing to do that most likely though I would expect to get Written Proof of whoever taking them under those conditions. From past experience when you make Individual Police Officers Responsible for what they are requesting they don't want you to answer their questions. But maybe that was just me. :D

I'm not saying that Child's is blameless here but just that he's not the beginning of the mess though he did effectively end it quite badly. Though when it is all said and done I wouldn't be surprised if the Rate Payers of the City are paying off this mess for the rest of their lives. He'll never get another job in that position again and since he is only one of a handful of people who can do what he did I'm wondering just how much and how many are being paid to confirm that what he did with the System was correct.

Here I really thing that it's just a case of the wrong person asking for something and then everything falling to bits after the request was denied. Nothing more than a Bureaucratic In Fight for Power. ;)

Col

by hal 9000

You should have added Unless they are a Bureaucrat with Delusions of Grander and Supportive Superiors.

I've seen that way too many times to even consider that it's not possible. Granted it wouldn't happen outside Government Offices but Government Offices and Bureaucrats are not [b]Real Life.[/b] I've seen cases when some Power Crazed bureaucrat has spend well in excess of a Million $ with the justification that it saved a few cents on a job. ;)

Col

by forum surfer

In some municipal entities the chief of police or town manager are above the IT CIO. So if a newly appointed town manager asks you to do something like that and it is a bad idea, technically you are required to oblige. The only hope you have is to call a meeting with the local board of commissioners and discuss the matter. At least if you are forced to comply, your objection is noted.

This discussion is closed to new replies.