Discussion Locked

Imagine your ideal PM tool

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Tell us what you would imagine for an ideal PM tool, as featured in this week's Project Management Blueprint e-newsletter. What functionality would your PM tool include that most PM tools don't? What benefits do you think you would reap if your ideal PM tool existed? For the most part, are you satisfied with today's standard PM tools?

9 replies

by lmuthukaruppan

I agree with the view finally its dependent on the data you receive to know whether your project is going correctly. Major problem what i had using MS project was,
1. My team should be able to login the hours correctly against their allocations and
2. i should come to know if a particular task/activity is blowed
3. Link to billing system

by md5005

For our organization we went through an exstensive market and litterature research; we pased from 46 players to the wwiner was long and difficult, but the main think we learned were:
- same pool of resources, different Prj Mgr. as often happens in SW development; you DO need a lot more than MS Project.
- lot of tools are going Web; wise choice indeed BUT at some price (usually graphics and easiness of use) and usually on MS (not easily to find in open / JAVA world);
- you can get very interesting solutions for low prices (as low as 200 US$ per seat, expecially Web solutions);
- ASP solution are promising but still not here;
- beware of reporting structures NOT tied with DataWareHouse products (there is not something like "so many GENERAL REPORTS: you will find the one you need);
- Prj Mgt is, somewhat, I'm not sure, an art or a science, BUT you DO need to get formal education BEFORE implementing the tool for EVERY user (time reporters as well as Prj Managers alike);
- get your house in order FIRST (processed described, procedures defined).

by mfcashmere

RESOURCE MGT: for consulting firms - a margin analysis (rate vs. cost, etc.); roll-off; capacity planning tools; links to off-shore personnel databases/skill/industry/education libraries; historical projects (per company, per person); scenario planning for supporting projected revenues/growth/possible work.

Portal - personalized for each constituent and per access level; quick review of team data (hours, deliverables, status); query capable on a number of areas; scenario planning.

Business indicators (select to track); let's you know per parameters when something isn't quite right or needs evaluation.

Issue Tracking - what has popped up that needs attention or to be scheduled.

Financials - every associated cost, rate and performance item to be tracked and assessed.

by freed-0

The biggest frustration I have with MS Project is resource loading. You have your project template laid out with rough effort estimates for each task.

You know what skills are required to perform each task and you know what skills each of yourteam members possess.

The problem is determining the optimal assignment of resources to tasks. This is particularly true when you have team members that possess several skills and there is some overlap in skills between the various team members.

As an oversimplified example consider Task-1 requires someone with Skill-A, Task-2 requires Skill-B, and Task-3 requires Skill-C. On your team you have Person-1 with Skill-A, Skill-B and Skill-C; Person-2 with Skill-A and Skill-B; and Person-3with Skill-B and Skill-C. Who do you assign to which tasks? Now expand this problem to a project schedule with hundreds of tasks.

I would like to be able to specify the skillset and minimum proficiency level required to perform each task. I should then be able to specify the skillsets and proficiency levels that each resource possesses. Then the resource loading/leveling function should automatically assign the resources to the tasks in the most optimal way. Of course, it would also be nice to be able to specify a set of tasks (highly related or interdependent tasks) that logically should have the same resource assigned.

by todd williams

This topic interests me a lot. To the point that I have been researching this information and producing a free newsletter that may be of interest to others. They are posted on my personal site (http://home.pacifier.com/~toddwill) under the Collaborative Project Management section.

My focus in this newsletter is Collaborative systems and trying to review products in that light.

I hope I am not violating any "guidelines" with this note. I have reviewed them I do not think so. If it is inviolation of the guidelines (either the links or the advertising) I apologize. I feel the newsletter is general in nature and of value to others.

by patrick andrews

My purpose in writing this article was to attempt to get our profession to think 'out of the box' in terms of its tools. Maybe one of the major software organisations should consider implementing many of these excellent ideas....or perhaps the open source community can focus more on the project level and agree to start work on a qualtitatively better set of management tools for projects?

by ronmizrahi

It seems that you could achieve this and other features if you kept the data in an object oriented database with an OLAP front-end. In the case of your resource loading example, if each employee was a type associate with an attribute defining skillset(s) then the application could automatically assign the resource based on availability, priority, etc.

To me it seems like the issues are all in the data and they are accessed.

by johnfili

? Web-based solution
? Collaborative
? General Requirements
o Intuitive, easy-to-use
o Technical support available
o Customizable training
o Knowledge Management
o Link and cross-reference to other corporate systems
o Messagingand Instant Communications
o Logical Flow
o Rich set of APIs for input/output
? Executive front-end (Project Portfolio Management)
? Allow secure access by internal and external users
? Links to corporate project management methodology
? Administration
o Manage users, groups, roles, and permissions
o Hierarchy security and access control
o Customizable and ad-hoc user and group query and reporting
o Project number assigned to be used for all time and expense tracking
oCreate projects from project templates
o Automatic notification to each level for approval
o Access control to document or task level
? Document control/sharing
o Access and Version control
o Editing markups and tracking
o Document check In/Out
o Native document view
o Document notification
o Document content text search
o Folder organization and structure
? Calendaring and Scheduling
o Compatible with common PDAs
? Project Risk Management
o Risk Planning,Assessment, and Management
? Project Schedule/Task management
o Project Schedule Development and communication
o Notification of task status with alerts
o Time and expense tracking by tasks
? Resource management
o Time Reporting
o Skills tracking
o Resource scheduling
o Contractor management
? Project Cost Management
? Project Status
? Issues/Action Item Management
? Change Control
? Project Quality Management
? Process Management (work flow)
? Project Procurement Management
? Project Audit and Examination Management
? Assists or provides information for the Corporate Balanced Scorecard

by arjay

In managing a Project one is concerned with the Efforts, Schedule and Defects. All these basic metrics can be captured with a flexibility to add / change - activities / people assignment etc is my requirement # 1. Be that as it may the same is Post Mortem in nature. The tool should have a way to ask queries and elicit repsonses that can project 'What is probably going to happen', in addtion to 'What Has happened'.
The representation of progress / analysis must be pictorial (For example say a road bwn 2 cities - deflate tyre,out of gas, etc) at a high level of abstraction witha facility to drill down / zoom into details as found necessary would be the icing.

This discussion is closed to new replies.