Discussion Locked

Importance of tape backups

0 helpful
16 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Tell us what you think about the importance of tape backups, as featured in this week's Disaster Recovery e-newsletter. Share additional pros and cons of this methodology with your IT peers.

16 replies

by ldn1

Windows 2000 Disk Error-Checking (along with Defrag) ruined my 60 G drive
(disk not formatted ???). Neither Maxtor nor Microsoft acknowledged the problem
and gave no help. Make sure your data is safe.
Any help to get back my data is much appreciated (ldn603@yahoo.com)

by f-baer

Hi, try Ontrack disk recovery to rebuild the mbr, or if it dont work use encase to restore deleted data. with disk-probe on the w2k cd you can edit the mbr manually (! difficult), an other way is with linux boot disk and "dd" to copy per sektor.. more under
http://www.heise.de/ct/00/06/106/default.shtml

good luck
cu obe

by litsterc

Without these (tapes) any disaster recovery plan is flawed. As all tools they are useful if used properly. More importantly every DR plan needs testing including the restore procedures. This is what most people forget and are surprised when the dreaded day comes and what they thought where backups are not! Enjoyed your article.

by draco vulgaris

Never underestimate the power of human stupidity. No form of RAID or offsite replication, that I know of, protects you against some fumble fingered idiot deleting the wrong file or dropping the wrong table! The change propagates to all copies in seconds!!

Only a backup protects you. It need not be a backup to tape; disk, or CDROM, will work if the amount of data to be protected is modest but tape is best.

by sgierach

In your recent article, entitled "Backup Data Using a Methodology That's Tried and True", you stated: "Third, tape is an effective addition to a DR plan for systems that store seldom-changing data." It should be pointed out that tape media has a much short life time than disk media and, therefore, lesser used data needs to occasionally be copied to newer tape media in order to preserve the data content. Also, tape media is subject to occasional media creases, bad spots, stretching, and is much more susceptible to temperature and humidity variances. So, for long-term data archival, it may not be the best media to utilize.

by miketalonnyc

I must disagree, as disk is no more stable than tape, regularly backing up these files to tape is perhaps the best idea. Just make sure to back them up on a regular basis.

Mike Talon
miketalonnyc@yahoo.com

by susalt

Additionally, tape media has a higher capacity per tape than most optical media, unless you're using DVD, and linking multiple discs for backup can cause problems. Most backups can be fit on a single DAT tape. I prefer tape.

by draco vulgaris

You are correct in saying that tape is not an ideal archival medium but the thrust of the article was the use of tape as a backup medium.

As I pointed out in an earlier posting, a tape backup provides a degree of protection from the fumble fingered and fumble minded people around you. It's not absolute but when some idiot deletes a valuable file you'll be really glad that you have a backup on tape. If you make regular backups and use a tape rotation scheme, you will most likely have several copies on several different tapes.

by ppsholka

An extended power outage, never anticipated, can prove the importance of tape backup even with off-line legacy systems.

We recently had a server hard downed as a result of a power problem. The tape backup allowed me to make our historical data available again.

by Member 36565256

The article was reasonable, but it did not address many key issues relative to tape backups in a Disaster Recovery (DR) scenario. Oversimplification of issues is undesirable within the context of disaster recovery planning.

First and foremost, tapes need to be validated on another physical tape device. More than once I have seen DR exercises encounter problems due to bad tapes. Sometimes the tape is bad (and was probably bad from the start), and sometimes the problems are incompatibilities between devices. In our white papers we discuss the difference between testing the DR process and simulating a true DR effort ? there is a difference. The quality of the backups is generally what differentiates the two processes.

The other major consideration is the tape technology being used. Is a non-standard RAID tape array being used? Using proprietary or non-standard backup software? What about the drive format (DLT80 (a safe bet), SDLT, LTO, DLT1, AIT). The best, newest technology may not be the best choice for an offsite recovery scenario. The safest bet is to use standard technology that is readily available, or have spare equipment that is readily available at an offsite location.

So, know what needs to be recovered and backup accordingly. Test the ability to read the backups as well as to recover the systems. Keep backup media offsite, environmentally controlled locations. Make sure that your DR site can readily retrieve the backup media. Test and refine the DR plan - frequently. And more than anything, anticipate issues that are bound to arise during a DR effort and develop contingency plans to address them. Leave nothing to chance and chances are that you will be able to recover your site.

Chip Nickolett (mailto: ChipN@Comp-Soln.com)

by roy bennett

Personally as a business & home user I prefer to back up to a swapable second hard disk drive (D:) Your backups can be accomplished in a matter of moments instead of hours in some cases using tape. I bet my 2nd 40 Gig Hard drive and removeable carrier cost less than your back up drive & tapes. My C: holds all my programes and my D: holds all my data, files and backup. I interchange several hard drives relevant to each of my customers ranging from 3Gig to 40Gig. Just set your Bios to 'auto' for detecting ALL hard drives. Life is just a breeze, shabum shabum ........

by ameanie

I'm just a one-computer non-techie user (for personal and sometimes business stuff). I bought my first tape machine (an Everex for about $1000) in 1987 when a power DIP (NOT surge) scrambled everything on my computer (perhaps because Norton's defragging program was running). Although I had stacks of floppies, it took considerable time to put everything back together. When all my computer equipment was failing in 1998, I bought a new computer with HP 3.2GB internal tape drive. I upgraded last year to HP 20GB internal tape drive. I rotate full backup tapes (never partial), verify them, and store them in a safe deposit box. They have saved me more than once! I'm considering second (or partial) backup with CDs, but YAY for tapes!

by nbp backup

Unless your talking $5000.00 or more for a tape system (which even then can have problems), tapes are just not worth the cost and the hassle if you aren't required to use them. e-Vaulting is the preferred method of many larger companies, for obviousreasons, and can be had by smaller companies, the majority of which can not afford a 'reliable' tape system. I can't think of a single area in which e-vaulting is not superior to tape backups.

by isys

At $600.00 per year per gigabyte (or so), how long before you have paid for that primo tape system? If your standard backup is 40 GB per night, that's $2,400 per night. Five nights a week is $12,000.00 per week. Four weeks per month adds another $9,600.00. Doesn't quite fit my budget.

Instead, many companies are now using hard disks. A 60 GB SCSI disk is under $300.00 now. Ten of those (five for the daily, five for weekly) plus one for each monthly archive is the way to go. But tape is still a viable alternative.

by draco vulgaris

A used DLT 7000 and SCSI Host adapter can be had for $3000 or less. Tape cartridges (DLT-IV) that will hold ~80GB can be had, new, for ~$70 each.

Assume a useful life of one year for the drive, host adapter, and tapes. Assume six backups per week with an 8 week retention. Call it 50 tapes at $70 or $3,500. I make that $6,500 for 312 backups of 80GB each. Let's really splurge and pay $200/month or $2400 per year for contract maintenance on the drive. That's $8,900 total outlay for 24.9 terabytes or $2.80 per gigabyte backed up.

So where does your $600 come from?

This discussion is closed to new replies.