Networks

Ask something
Discussion Locked

Install a second drop or use a hub?

0 helpful
5 replies

by mdimis

Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I'm beginning to run into situations where I have to install a second network device (usually a printer) at a location with one drop. In earlier situations I had a second drop installed (~$100), but lately I've installed small 5-port unmanaged switches instead (~$30) and don't seem to be experiencing any problems. Am I missing something? Should I go back to multiple drops?

5 replies

by hinrgman

It is basically a management and/or a security issue.

you said it " a 5-port unmanaged switch " emphasizing unmanaged.

other devices can be plugged into that 5 port switch without your knowledge.

in my organization we prohibit such devices and remove any that are discovered when we uncover them.

by mdimis

I was thinking more about the technical aspects (LAN diagramming/management, performance), but I appreciate your points about security.

by jschein

Drops on an avg. run from 100-150... a new 8 port hub runs for 40... Now, If you work in CIA like the last commenter then you would need drops. But the average CORPORATE environment where you have laptop users, desktops, and network printers - you would need HUBS.

1) They are cost effective

2) If you're woried about security, you should already have people logging into your domain which defeats that argument of less secure

3) Does a printer need a Full 10/100/1000 MBS drop all for itself? No - share it on

Good luck.

by mdimis

I think hinrgman had some valid points about security--preventing the addition of unauthorized hardware like a packet sniffer or wireless bridge, or a rogue http server or even a gaming server. Most of our users are not that sophisticated, however, and the ones that are are respectful of the integrity of the LAN. Other than having to add a few more hubs to the LAN diagram, I wanted to be sure I wasn't introducing more complications from a traffic or device-management standpoint.

This discussion is closed to new replies.