Mferrel @ KentDisplays....
When I installed our network and set up Internet Access, I used a Proxy Server called GateKeeper. I use a dialup ISDN connection and let the GateKeeper Proxy Server allow multi-user access through a common connection.Since your access is already running efficiently, GateKeeper will still run daily logs of where each IP address is "surfing". You can see who has been assigned a particular IP address thru NT or GateKeeper also has a feature to determine who 1.2.3.4 is. You can choose to log WWW traffic; POP3, IMAP & SMTP (Email) traffic, SOCKS, FTP, DNS, etc etc. Any traffic occuring over the connection can be logged in any combination. The administrator box has real time reporting where you can sit and watch an IP address surf. I like calling users on their phone when I notice someone downloading a huge file named something like boomboom.mpg. The best thing about GateKeeper is that you can purchase a couple different packages. 2 years ago, the 5 concurrent user license was only $100 and I purchased with a credit card over the internet. This package may be a good start for you, then, you can go to a larger user license. The 5 user license would log the first 5 users it notices.
You can find GateKeeper here....
http://www.infopulse.net/gatekeeper/
Happy Hunting!!
Scott