Question Locked

Internet Sharing between Windows and Linux

0 helpful
31 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have Windows Vista and I'm connected to the internet through DSL but I will like to share my Internet with my son who is Linux(Fedora) crazy. How do I do this? Help!!
Stonebridge

31 replies

by jaqui

router between your computer and the internet modem.
connect all the computers to the router.
done.

by jdclyde

it is insane to connect a Windows box directly to ANY Internet connection without a hardware firewall between you and the the internet.

Get the router, and it will not only allow you to share this with the boy, but protect your system as well.

If you have a laptop or plan to get one, get your router with WIFI.

by Former member

The DSL routers are...routers. It does NAT already.

by sgt_shultz

this is a good question to ask your internet service provider.
windows or linux doesn't matter, you just need to provide the dsl signal to the other pc. By definition, you already have a router, your dsl 'modem' is one. just 'extend' it's capacity with a network switch.
does your current working setup connect to the dsl router with a usb cable or an ethernet cable? if ethernet, get like a linksys 4 workstation switch (< $40 US) plus another ethernet cable. see the linksys website for exact how-to instructions. but basically you'll power up your new switch then unplug the ethernet cable that goes from the working internet pc to the 'uplink' port on the new linksys switch. ensure you have a link light and can still surf from the windows pc. then plug the linux box's ethernet cable into any other port on the switch (except for the one right next to the uplink port). ensure you have a link light there also. if no internet, you have a linux problem, not a wiring problem...

by jdclyde

Cable/DSL router to be exact.

You can NOT take the connection from a DSL MODEM and plug it into a switch/hub. It has to go directly to a PC OR a Router. The router allows you to connect to your DSL provider and then share that connection with as many systems as you wish.

http://tinyurl.com/2ep8xg

If you go with non-wireless, you can knock off another $10.

by sgt_shultz

you just need a switch.
however, i am about to need a fire extinquisher...

by faradhi

it depends on the DSL modem and the ISP.

A Switch will work if:

If the ISP will issue multiple IP addresses for an account AND the DSL modem allow passthrough IP

OR

If the ISP will not issue multiple IPs but the Modem will issue multiple internal IPs then a switch will work.

However, those of us who were formerly Bellsouth customers neither of the above is true.

The DSL Modem will only issue 1 internal IP and if using IP passthrough the ISP will only issue 1 IP. Therefore a Router is required.

by jaqui

for both to be online at the same time, their isp needs to issue multiple ip addresses [ hub ] or they need to have a router. a switch will not allow both online at the same time, without severe performance penalties.

which is why I said router in the first place. with the wireless connection so common now, they can have multiple systems and not need additional hardware.

by jdclyde

How much extra does the DSL provider charge for extra IP addresses?

Remember, the DSL has to be logged into, and the poster wants both systems up at the same time (of course).

Don't worry, just because your wrong doesn't mean I would flame you. :D Everyone has the right to be wrong..... :p

by jaqui

let you buy extra ip numbers? not here.
DSL accounts can only get one ip address from the isp, so going DSL you have to have a router or switch.
the poor functionality of sharing through a switch makes it a non viable option, but it can work for some people.

by jdclyde

They didn't WANT you to put in a router. They wanted you to pay an extra $10 a month for EACH extra PC you wanted to connect to the internet.

They now DO sell a "home network" package, but all they are doing is renting you a router and setting it up for you. Pay the $40 up front to buy the router and be done with it.

I can't help laughing. All I hear is "I know nothing, NOTHING!" :D

by sgt_shultz

again. the dsl is the router. the nat takes place there. sigh. do you need private lessons? or just a sugar snack? (rdl)
jd - just try it. climb down outa that ivory tower and give it a try.

by w2ktechman

come on Sgt. a router is the best route, and with the way cable companies are going, it is the only way to get more than 1 system connected at any given time.

Maybe not in all areas yet, but here in the bay area the cable modem holds the MAC address of the 1st computer connected to it. If you dont buy multiple IPs from the cable company that is.
To switch computers you need to unplug or reset the modem. Then plug it into the one that you want to use and only that one will work.

by jdclyde

But isn't it funny that everyone here but you is wrong?

by deity_chooch

Yes, you are correct. The DSL "modem" is also a router. I would put a router in anyway, simply because with a router that _you_ own, you have further functionality (firewall mostly, but statistical tools as well), although a simple hub or switch would suffice. The DSL router usually serves DHCP private IP addresses to connected users, so you don't need extra public IP addresses. This is the only case that I've worked with and I'm not going to say that just because I've never seen exceptions they don't exist, I've just not run into them.

by w2ktechman

most cable companies new 'modems' will only allow for 1 system to connect. If you want to add an extra, you either pay for an additional IP address for each system, or you have to unplug the modem when you connect onto another system.
this keeps from sharing the connection, I think it holds onto a MAC list in the modem for the first connected computer.

To get by this, and to share seamlessly with multiple systems, put a router in, reset the modem and have the router the first and only computer that the modem sees.

Then the router (not hub or switch) will connect to all other computers on the network. If you have need to further split the connection, more than the router has ports, I suggest putting a switch in after that. But for the original posters request, a router is the best possible route to go.

by deity_chooch

Yes, cable systems _do_ work that way. Most cable modems do not have router functionality built in, although you can buy modem/router combinations. The provider gives the user a public IP address (can be from a DHCP pool or set static) which corresponds to a single device's MAC address; this device can be a router or a computer (technically anything that an IP can be assigned to). And in cable systems I do recommend that this first device be a router, as it makes things easier for the user if he/she wants to make a network.

The DSL router doesn't work that way though (again, I've not worked with any exceptions to this rule) because it isn't authenticated by device MAC address. I still recommend that a router be placed there for additional functionality, but this isn't necessary because the DSL router is a router: it has a public IP address and serves DHCP addresses to connected devices. And perhaps the DSL router was programmed differently by the ISP. You can disable the DHCP functions and set static routes, so it could be possible to set it so users need to buy extra public IP addresses.

by jdclyde

you might get added to "the list" too... :0

I think Sgt needs a mydol and a sense of humor.

I would have to REALLY dislike someone to recommend they EVER plug a Windows box directly into the internet without a hardware firewall to protect them. ;\

by jaqui

why?
any common router will use the 192.168 ip series by dfault, private, but unless you are running servers off the network, you don't need to buy a public / static ip over the one commonly assigned.

I have set up a shared connection through a hub, two computers can get an ip from the isp, after that you are screwed.
what wound up happening, hub to one computer, hub to router, router to three other routers and 11 computers.
[ the isp wouldn't play nice with the router from the dsl modem connection, so the hub had to stay ]

by jdclyde

B-)

I am big enough to accept your sincere apology.

:D

And other than DSL requiring a login, in all of my experiences, it is exactly the same, just different as working with Cable.

This requiring of a login is what would have me questioning the ability for multiple systems to be on-line at the same time using a switch, let alone the security aspects.

Oh yeah, shame on you for even mentioning a hub anymore! ;\

by deity_chooch

You must not have been reading my posts. I am also supporting the Sgt.'s side. The DSL "modem" (we usually just call it a DSL router) is _NOT_ the same as a cable modem. The DSL router has NAT capabilities and therefore a hub or switch _WOULD_ work.

by deity_chooch

That's my point. The DSL router does NAT so you shouldn't need to buy public IP addresses unless your ISP locked it down so you can not administer it, then disabled the DHCP. I've never seen this occur and that is why the DSL router should provide all the functions of a router you need; a hub or switch would therefore be good devices to use in this situation.

by sgt_shultz

i wish somebody who actually has DONE this would post (besides me, i mean) you guys are just being right. not accurate. sheesh

by faradhi

I have DSL with AT&T, formerly bellsouth. My DSL modem will only allow a connect from 1 that ONE Ip address. I tried a Switch before the router.

If the modem only accepts connections from one IP YOU CANNOT USE A SWITCH. This is the way some modems are configured.

But your right, you know every model of every DSL modem, that was distributed by every ISP so you know your right. So keep on belittling people.

by w2ktechman

Sgt. is usually very good, but in some areas there are differences in setup.

I know here, DSL and Cable modems seem to behave very similarly, and they have multi-purpose modems (cable/dsl). So when I responded with cable modem earlier, it was based on my exp. here, but most of the people I have supported are on cable not dsl anyways.

As for belittling, I think she was really just messing with JD for the most part. But that is cause JD started it :^0

by faradhi

There are differences in setup depending on the ISP and the DSL Modem.

Some ISP's will not allow the Modem to be changed by the user. Some modems only allow one to one nats. Some ISPs will lock the modem down with a one to one Nat. This prevents the use of a switch. The modem will only accept requests from that one IP.

This was the case with smellSouth now AT&Pee.

As for the belitting. It was Sgt that started with the lamebrain comment. JD can take care of himself and I was not going to comment until she assumed that I had not tried using Nat and a switch. I don't know if someone peed in her Post Toasties or what.

I would agree however that she is normally very good with her responses.

by Former member

If you use a switch, some ISPs will not allow more than one PC to be connected. They do this by hardcoding an access-list to the MAC address connected to the DSL router. Only a router on the LAN end will allow you more than one. If they don't restrict your network to one PC, then you can use a switch and connect all your machines there.

by w2ktechman

you are right, JD brought up a correction and then got slammed (lightly)(per usual). I guess I just didnt notice it cause it happens all too often... :^0

This discussion is closed to new replies.