Discussion Locked

Is it worth switching browsers from IE to secure a network?

0 helpful
149 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

149 replies

by dogzilla

There are skins available for Mozilla and maybe also for Firefox that makes it look so similar to IE that some just think they got an "upgrade". And, well, it is an upgrade from IE!

by danthebestman

What will that fix? Know what your IT department is gonna do when this "fix" starts breaking applications? They are going to set those system settings right back where they were so those apps will start working again. IT departments just don't have the time or manpower to keep fixing things that MS breaks.

by dogzilla

Yes there are "known issues" with Firefox and the Mozilla browser and that is good. We can all read about them and read about what developers are doing about them.

It's the unknown issues with IE and m$ apps and the exploits that come along one after the other that more people should be concerned with. When it comes to "known issues" with IE first there's denial, then when it can't be ignored there's "We'll fix it soon, er, when we get a round-tuit." When it comes to a sense of safety that is scarey.

It is worth switching browsers for security alone.

by dogzilla

Many companies do not work with the same rape, pillage, and blunder philosophy as m$ so are generally ahead of the curve. Yes as more users switch to different browsers those may become bigger targets. But why are exploits so far and few between with open source software where a person can see the source code along with everyone else? Is that too easy or is the software harder to exploit because more eyes are on it ferreting out potential problems before they are go into releases.

by dogzilla

I've been using Mozilla now for a few years and have watched and it has steadily improved. Although it isn't perfect yet, it is not as imperfect as IE. It gives you real control over things like popups, cookies, etc. without the risk of using bunches of other programs that can cause even more problems as I understand happens when trying to "make do" with IE.

I haven't tried it yet but I also understand Firefox is even faster.

With Mozilla and my favorite firewall, when I'm not busy just getting work done, I can sit back and watch as the masses scramble around trying to get away from the latest security exploit of IE and other m$ apps. It's sometimes more entertaining than playing Tetris.

by richman316

I have tried both recently and although they are decent products, I don't think it's worth the trouble of switching over. As for popups I have no problems since I have a utility to handle them and they hardly ever appear. As for updates they are so simple to apply that I lose no sleep over that issue. Unfortunately all programs have their weaknesses and as more people switch to these other browsers those security problems will become apparent.

by thechas

The core code of Netscape 7 is Mozilla.

I think it is version 1.4 or before.

Mozilla is now at version 1.7.1 and 1.8 Beta testing.

Chas

by xenon333

It's good enough for now. After all no answer to security is forever. It's only as good as your diligence and the will and skill of the next bored hacker. But with significantly fewer holes to crawl through, or hook on to, it's good for the foreseeable future. Just having no popups for the users to accidentally or ignorantly click on, installing who knows what is 90% of the battle for me.

by oz_ollie

I have no problems accessing OWA 2003 using Firefox 0.8 and I'm using Firefox on SUSE Linux.

I'm not sure about the "look" being consistent with an "IE look" as I don't use IE to access it.

by oz_ollie

You state that Firefox/Mozilla don't render JavaScript "properly" - sorry it is actually Microsoft Internet Explorer that doesn't render JavaScript "properly".

Microsoft use their own Document Object Model (DOM) not the DOM standard from the W3C. The two DOMs are available online.

The IE DOM is at:
http://msdn.microsoft.com/workshop/author/om/doc_object.asp

The Mozilla/Firefox/Gecko DOM is at:

http://www.mozilla.org/docs/dom/domref.pdf

If Microsoft was standards compliant by default (which it isn't - http://msdn.microsoft.com/library/default.asp?url=/nhp/default.asp?contentid=28000441 => Technical Articles => CSS Enhancements in ...) we wouldn't have many of these issues.

by jm22

that is exactly what I am doing.

I am going with FireFox as the primary browser.

But I have 2 mission critical apps that require IE; so I have to educate users when to use IE and when not. its a pain but I think IE is too huge a vulnerability to tolerate it.

by cdl0002

Firefox suffers from certificate spoofing vulnerability

Today, in a post on the Full-Disclosure mailing list, Emmanouel Kellinis described a new SSL certificate spoofing vulnerability that affects Mozilla Firefox 0.9.1 and 0.9.2. By spoofing the SSL certificate of a site you trust, a malicious Web administrator could exploit this flaw to trick you into believing that his hostile Web site is one you trust.

Attackers and Internet scamsters commonly use flaws like these in their phishing attempts. Phishing is when network hackers use all the tricks of their trade to convince you that their Web site belongs to an entity you trust. For instance, an attacker might try to copy the look and feel of Citibank or PayPal's Web site so that you'll enter your sensitive account details. The more closely the attacker's site mimics the one you expect, the more likely you are to unintentionally give him your sensitive information.

Usually, paying careful attention to URLs and SSL certificates can help you authenticate the sites you visit and avoid phishing attacks. Unfortunately, flaws like this one in Mozilla make it a lot easier for hackers to trick you.

Kellinis released this vulnerability before Mozilla could release a patch. Furthermore, he released Proof-of-Concept code, so net criminals can implement it in their next phishing attempts. To protect yourself, I recommend you follow the advice given by the Anti-Phishing Working Group. --Corey Nachreiner

by mrpjb

We have both IE 6 (of course) and Mozilla 1.7 installed on our lab computers. Some machines even have Opera, Firefox and Netscape 7 on them. I educate ALL users (students) that complain about IE in some manner to use Mozilla or its Firefox version, even for a test run. Most look at me somewhat puzzled because IE is their "staple" to get on the web and they can't fathom double-clicking on another icon. Once they use Mozilla (or another browser) once or twice though, several have chosen to stick with Mozilla, especially for its pop-up blocker.
Microsoft needs to pay attention to the way the Mozilla dev team rolls out updates. They're excellent and I thank them for well-crafted browsers. Make sure to send them a donation through your Paypal. :-)

by ummmmbeer

98 is not more secure. I find it play doh! It is true there are fewer ways for people to access them remotely as it was designed as a workstation only (few server functions).Passwords are stored in an easy to find/delete *.pwl files(blanking them out) and without NTFS security you can browse any file on the drive(s)! While it is true XP Home is poor as it leaves raw ports available to the user Pro does not. No matter what OS installed you have to take action to secure these systems. Without continued support from the vendor, patches and updates, you have no way to plug holes.

sidenote: what tech uses AOL???

by blarman

Do you like tabbed browsing?
Do you like being able to block pop-ups?
Do you like not having to worry about having your PC hijacked by visiting websites?

If so, then all you have to do is switch to Opera, Firefox, Mozilla, or any number of alternative browsers. Caution: some sites don't work well in alternate browsers, and some plug-ins aren't flawless in execution.

Succinctly, you sacrifice some extended useability for better security and basic useability.

by psk

Even presumming you don't get tagged by a virus, hacker, trojan, or whatever else slips in the doorway that IE leaves wide open, there is the matter of administration overhead to apply a never-ending stream of patches, reading never-ending supplies of security warning documents, and watching breathlessly to see if this latest patch will break your web app. Too much fun, and if you're short of job security, perhaps IE offers some of that.

Personally, I wash my hands of it. Done. No more. I've switched the network over to Netscape/Mozilla (and will give Firefox a go when the 1.0 release hits next month). And now, when I read about the latest IE nightmare, my blood pressure stays nice and low, and I don't go scrambling for data, patches, and testbed setups.

This dog ain't salivating any more when the bell rings.

-psk

by timbo zimbabwe

Just make your alternative browser the default, then remove the IE icon from the desktop. Now, if you need to go to Windows Update, IE will automatically fire up, otherwise you will default to the alternative....

by tbbrickster

Very true. The thing is, only use IEV on "safe" sites, like a brand-name store. If it's someone's personal site and s/he insists I use IE, it's like, "You're kidding me, right???"

by mokeloc

I just checked out Firefox as well as DeepNet Explorer. I find that Firefox is pretty good but it doesn't have the tabed feature and in my line of work. I have to keep about 12 different windows open and having more windows open doesn't help. DeepNet on the other hand is pretty sweet and simple. But I have have one problem with Deepet Explorer, it eats away at your memory with all the caching. That's a minor problem but other then that I would go with DeepNet Explorer.

by ccoach

Tabbed browsing has been a basic feature of Moz/Firefox for years. Use a control/click (or enter) when loading another address or link. That will induce another tab.

In Firefox, adjust this to have the tabbar show even with only 1 site open:
tools | options | advanced | (in the "Browsing" section - UNcheck the "Hide the tab bar when only one site is open".

Trust millions of us: Firefox has tabbed browsing ...

CCoach

by gometrics

Well so much for using Firefox and Netscape. Two out of three clients where I replaced explorer for better security wanted their old browser put back.

They both found explorer easier and simpler to use.
You can make explorer secure by blocking all ActiveX
but they inevitably complain about loss functionality. I'm convinced the only reason other browsers are more secure is because the offer less functionality and it is not as lucrative for varments to find their flaws...yet.

by todrescher

Users hate to learn new things. They will adamantly fight against it.
Non-IE browsers are "new things."
They don't offer less functionality; that would be the fault of web developers who don't know how to create a website that is W3C compliant, instead concentrating on making it work in IE.
But then we could go off on the Dreamweaver/FrontPage tangent, where WYSIWYG editors create web developers.

That's the great thing about internet standards...there are so many to choose from!

Until all the web guys out there start making websites by the rules, you'll never be able to completely get away from IE.

by too old for it

I've often wondered, with all the spare cash MicroSoft has, why it can't employ a corps of "white hat" hackers, moles, private investigators, machete weilding enforcers and so forth to take care of the "busy hands" in the hack community?

by usaatca2001

About 5 years ago, I bought 98Lite for my PC at work (I was the Network Mgr.). I used it to uninstall IE, but had to reverse the install because hyper-linking stopped working in every application. Apparently, hyper-linking in W98 is controlled by IE. I don't know if uninstalling IE in the current OS's will produce the same effect. If you need hyper-linking (& who doesn't), be sure you can reverse the IE uninstall.

BTW, I use Firefox for everything other than web sites that bow down to Redmond & have been using it since version 0.4 (I also use Mozilla).

by nicknielsen

It's probably the same reason that my XP Pro laptop takes up to 5 minutes to log on to my school's Novell network and my old Win98SE desktop can log on in under 30 seconds.

by marence

The problem here is not so much that it's "troublesome" to switch, but that IE is inherently an insecure browser, and responsible users shouldn't use a browser that basically begs to be exploited.
I don't understand why it would be "trouble" to switch over. The program is easy to install, will automatically load all your preferences and bookmarks during install if you wish.
I have always had multiple versions of Netscape and IE on my PCs, because I write web pages and like to test them in alternate browsers. I did lean towards using IE when version 6 came out, but only until Mozilla came out with their new version.
I still don't understand the whole "trouble" idea.

by gregeb

I use Outlook Web Access for Exchange 2003 at the company where I work. It has two client modes, Premium, and Basic. The Premium client has the interface that looks like Outlook 2003. If I use plain-vanilla Firefox, I can only access the Basic client. I have tried the user agent extension to have Firefox identify itself as being IE. This lets me select the Premium client, but the Premium client interface has display errors. I have yet to find a way to use Firefox for Premium client access. I have to use IE for Premium client access.

by dalivision

Does Deepnet utilize ActiveX? Do you get Ad/Spyware with Deepnet? My experience with Firefox does not have Ad/Spyware which I think is due to ActiveX, but not sure. Yes some pages require IE and I simple load IE and go to that page then shut it down once completed with that page, then continue with Firefox. If Deepnet can view those pages without the Ad/Spyware it deserves a long look.

by nader058

I have made a switch from IE to Opera and I am very happy I did. Never tried Mozilla but I bet that is a good choice too. Switching away from IE has many security advantages and also makes your browsing much simpler and a LOT faster, if you use Opera at least. But keep in mind that many security threats from IE do not require you to use IE as your browser!! They pose a threat as long as IE is present on your system, even if you never use it as a browser!

by richard.mckinney

Sure....

If you want it really secure try Netware servers and OS/2 clients. When was the last time you saw a virus-writer that could spell OS/2?

Even CERT admits that you really can't get rid of IE without ditching MS altogether - the core functionality is built into EVERYTHING.

by wbailey

I've been using Firefox for a few weeks at work & home. If there are any speed differences, it might be a little faster than IE. I'm guessing that Firefox has less overhead.

Will

by c93213

I find it much easier to write a dummy proxy address in IE as a way of disabling it.

That way when someone wants to browse with IE, it will simply not be allowed.

by unclerob

I guess in the end it comes down to personal choice, firefox is nice and I've used it a little (my 1st experience with it was using it for the euro2004 soccer championship website) but downloading updates and plug-ins still leaves alot to be desired, it's a much easier process in ie (internet explorer). Also if firefox was the most widely used browser and ie was in firefox's position, we'd be having the same discussion, as we'd all be downloading patches for firefox or opera on a regular basis. Most of the planet currently uses ie5,5.5 or 6. Even though adoption of firefox & opera is growing, their total usage numbers compared to ie are relatively small. Hackers & virus writers attack the medium that gets used the most, which in this case is windows & ie. If this was a linux world, same problems would exist for them as well. Jumping ship to another platform doesn't solve the underlying problem which is that there are people out there looking to create security problems by writing viruses, spyware, malware and invent methods of hacking into pc's, servers, website, etc. The platform being attacked isn't the problem, even with winxp sp2 and ie's beefed up security, in a short while, there will be security patches needed again just because someone's found another way to get in and cause problems. I don't mind using firefox because of it's new look but I don't think you're going to get worldwide adoption of this new browser (or any other non-ie browser) and even if that happened, don't look for the security problems to go away - it's foolish to think that these security issues are that easy to solve - security will always be an issue. Instead of continually knocking MS for their products, try to acknowledge that it's difficult to keep pace with every new security threat out there and developing patches to secure a platform is difficult work when you have to support several generations of OS's that use this browsing platform. I'm not a huge fan of Microsoft but at least I'll admit that security isn't easy to tackle and at least they're trying. Just my 0.02 cents, you don't have to agree, opinions are free.

by pricetech

I switched, and I've encouraged ALL my customers to switch as well. I use the following browsers, in order:
Firefox, Mozilla, Opera, Idiot Exploder.

Actually, Opera is my first choice for checking mail at my OperaMail account. I use it for next to nothing beyond that.

IE is used for Windows Update and checking my spam at Hotmail about once a week.

Firefox is the most used browser on all my machines. It's quick, and I like it's features. Mozilla comes in a distant second, being every bit as feature rich as Firefox, if not moreso, but just not as quick and efficient.

Nothing, however can beat Konqueror in my opinion, both as a web browser and a file system browser.

Slightly off topic here, but I can't find an email client under winders that I like. I guess I'm spoiled to K Mail. My favorite feature is the option to "bounce" an email. Keeps me off of most spam lists.

by tke72

The problem is that many companies and Web developers create their sites so they work best with Internet Explorer, and not so well with other browsers that are used by quote minority who do not use IE.

Some site that do not work for me as a Firefox user include Expedia, MSNBC, Yahoo LAUNCH, some bank sites, etc. Most sites such as Yahoo Launch and Shutterfly will warns visitors that it only supports a limited set of browsers.

This posses a real problem as so many novices and even web developers have relied so heavily on Microsoft's front page and multimedia plug-in software that in some cases the true form of HTML language has been lost or pushed by the weigh-side, and thus not complying with the W3C standard. I have to keep IE around for the simple fact when I can not access a sites that cannot be accessed by any other browser I use it, because I am not installing 5 differnt browsers to avoid using one.

by tbbrickster

You may wish to consider using Yahoo as your client. Yahoo stores the email on it's servers, rather than on the local C drive of one specific machine as any PC-based client does. I find it quite handy to be able to access my email from anywhere I can obtain Internet access.

by svandermolen

I've heard so many people say that everyone should switch to Firefox, and that it's so much better, but I'm not convinced. All too often, people point the finger at Internet Explorer and say how it is lacking in standards compliancy in certain areas, and that it has security holes. The truth of the matter is that Firefox is also lacking in standards compliancy, and the only reason it doesn't have as many potential security holes is that it doesn't support certain technologies which are essential on some web sites.

To make IE more secure, you need Windows XP with Service Pack 2. That fixes major security holes such as ActiveX and drive-by downloading. If you want the same level of security as Firefox, you can crank up the security and privacy settings in IE, but be warned that browsing experience can be hindered when, for example, cookies are completely blocked. Spybot S&D and Spywareblaster both have an "immunize" feature which further protects IE from the bad stuff out there, and those are updated on a regular basis.

It's well known that some web pages don't render the same in Firefox as they do in Internet Explorer. This is always blamed on IE, with the excuse that it isn't standards compliant. While IE doesn't support the latest standards, it does support most standards. I validate my code to XHTML 1.1 and it doesn't render properly in Firefox, but renders beautifully in Internet Explorer. Firefox hides the fact that it's rendering engine is flawed by blaming people for writing bad code and saying Internet Explorer isn't standards-compliant, but it's a lie. For example, Firefox still uses the proprietary EMBED tag to display things such as Flash animations.

The real problem with IE and security is user education. The receptionist at my Dad's office has loads of spyware on her computer, and she claims she doesn't know how it got there. The truth of the matter is, she downloaded some freeware app and installed it. I've been using IE since Windows 95 and have never had problems, because I only download from trustworthy sources.

It's only a matter of time before the hackers download the source code for FireFox and start finding vulnerabilities in that. I'm sticking with Internet Explorer, and I don't see any reason to switch. The solution is user education and government legislation.

by apotheon

Malware writers don't attack browsers: they attack vulnerabilities.

They attack the most common vulnerabilities most often, which means that the more commonly used a browser is the more available its vulnerabilities are to attack. That also means that vulnerabilities that exist in multiple browsers will get attacked more often than those that exist in only one browser.

They also attack big, easy vulnerabilities that provide lots of easy access to the system more often that piddly little vulnerabilities that hardly allow anything untoward to happen. Because of the way IE is integrated with the OS and provides multiple direct paths to the most basic functions of Windows (ActiveX is a major culprit there), IE is and (as long as it has that vulnerability and no similar vulnerabilities exist in other browsers) will continue to be the biggest, most favored target for malware writers on the World Wide Web, regardless of whether it's the most popular browser.

So, yeah, popularity of a browser has an effect. If the browser wasn't popular enough, it wouldn't be worth attacking ? but that's where popularity's effects on commonality of attacks ends. Firefox, Mozilla, and Netscape all use the Gecko engine, which makes them tempting targets because they all share certain vulnerabilities (until identified and addressed), and each of them individually is popular enough to warrant being targeted for attacks, and yet they don't receive the same volume of attacks that IE gets.

IE attracts thousands more attacks than it would otherwise because of the prevalence, ease of access, and severity of its security holes. There are truly egregious security holes in the IE style of web browser design that nobody else has any interest in designing into a browser, and if IE disappeared today and was replaced by Firefox there would be a sharp drop-off in browser-targeted attacks on the Web that would never fully recover. The main reason for that is that Firefox is a more difficult target for writers of malware, and there are other vulnerabilities in any Windows system than Firefox that are much more tempting targets than a non-IE browser ? due to ease of access and severity.

by house

The only reason that IE is a security hole is because people have had years of practice researching and exploiting its flaws. Consider this analogy...in the OS world, people praise Linux distributions for their security...wait and see...as it becomes more and more popular, there will be more and more underground effort devoted to hacking, cracking, and infecting these systems.

by house

I'll say it again. I don't like to defend MS, but the reason IE has so many flaws is that there is more effort aimed towards IE in the underground. Wait until your favorite browsers are #1 on the list.

by fredvoit

This browser is IE with all it's holes. So is the "yahoo browser" posted about earlier in this thread. If you don't like IE, why use a garbage browser that is just a faceplate for the one you don't like?

by lata

I use Firefox personally, and I wouldn't go back to IE. I'm interested in the security side.
But IE can be controlled from the Active Directory very easily. Last week I changed the proxy server for IE - just went to the GPO and changed the settings. I'm aware it is possible to do this sort of thing with Firefox, but I haven't the time to work out how to deploy it. Therefore I'm not rolling out Firefox to everyone.

How about an adm for Firefox, someone?

by vetch_101

it's true... Firefox is far better from the point of view of usability, functionality and everything to do with speed.
The only thing it is missing is a methodology of deploying updates and patches, and centralised administration.
As far as I can tell, you cannot set up a "Firefox Update Server" internal to a network, nor can you use group policy to control it.
Apart from the few and far between sites that won't take anything other than IE, this is the main reason not to switch. Currently, updates are not as important as they are with IE, as it isn't being exploited as often, but nevertheless, in the future it will be, and Network Administrators need to be able to automate deployment of updates...

This discussion is closed to new replies.