Discussion Locked

IS Manager needs to Trust Network Admin

0 helpful
27 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I'm am the IS/IT Manager and today I looked on the Network Administrator's pc and found he has many email profiles loaded, including mine and the CEO, Legal, HR, senior staff and on and on. Apparently he has been reading everyone's email. This is quite a blow to me since I need to trust this guy. I would like to know how other companies deal with this issue. Of course he needs the network passwords to do his job but how do I keep him from doing more? We are 200 users with 2 IT on staff.
If I discuss this with the legal department and it gets around to upper management how would they ever trust the inner workings of my department?

27 replies

by les69

Ask them about it. There are a number of valid reasons for the profiles to be there. IE a mail recovery or he may have had to remove mail that someone sent accidentally. Be tactful about it. There could be a good reason.

by nettek

I agree with the other posts in that there may be legitimate reasons why other profiles exists on his computer. Additionally, where I work we make it very clear to all staff that E-mail should not be considered a secure form of communications. In fact, it states in our Policies and Procedures that if you do not want someone else other than your intended recipient to know the subject matter, DON'T send it via email.

I also find it ironic that you're concerned with his actions when YOU WERE LOOKING AT HIS E-MAIL! How can he trust you?

by scoury

There are no legitimate reasons why he would have profiles on his system. It is an understanding within the department and stated as such in our email polity. I had to log onto his system as administrator for another reason and only saw profile files loaded there with date etc. So, no, I was not and would not access in his email without valid reason. It is clear what he was doing was unethical. Obvious you are sensitive to him but would you want a system admin who you can?t trust?

by discordian

quite a dilemma indeed, and there is a lot of reasons for people not to trust the department. but, many times this type of behaviour comes from higher up, and sometimes it is simply just a massive abuse of the tools used to do one's job.

my experience has been quite the opposite, i want to respect the privacy of others because i want them to respect my privacy. thus, my dilemma usually comes about when i am ordered to break into email accounts by the cio of my company. this sets dangerous precedents in my mind and makes me wonder if i should monitor the accounts of those who order me to monitor the accounts of others in a purely ethical sense.

to save aggrivation, i would suggest that you work towards making a very detailed policy about email usage, the level of privacy that should be expected while using company resources, the level of monitoring that is "typical", and the procedure of command that must be followed in order to approve the monitoring of an account. also, you must make known the penalties for being caught breaking these rules at any level, especially for those who can monitor things. see, the problem is that i have no policy to follow and thus this leaves the system open to abuse, either by technical staff, or by executives and managers who have purely political motivations.

maybe by stating a policy this will stop the behavior. at the least, when you de confront the person if he or she does not stop, you can rely on stated policy at that time.

good luck

by discordian

the reason i titled my post groupwise is because that's the email system i like to use since it's a rather difficult proposal to monitor the accounts of others and this makes people feel a bit safer. it also allows me to filter out purely political requests to monitor accounts by explaining the cost in man-hours and equipment to do so. this usually makes executives back off unless they are very sure that there is a very good reason that someone's account must be broken into.

it's also resistant to the security and virus issues some other email systems have, but that is another story entirely. good luck again!

by cward

So, if you have an email policy that includes privacy issues, does that justify/legalize monitoring employees' mail? What if you don't have a policy? Does the absence of policy make it illegal to snoop?

Policy or not, my first response to this situation would be to ask the net admin why he/she has the collection of user profiles. I've been administering networks for many years and never had a reason to install multiple user profiles on my machine, even for roubleshooting. Maybe I'm paranoid, but this situation is fishier than a 25-pound trout.

by adrian smith

I am the IT Manager for a similar size firm - and I have needed to have multiple e-mail profiles loaded for a couple of reasons. 1) staff go away and don't turn on any type of forwarding etc or other users need mail from that person account 2) whenmoving or changing profiles on certain mail systems you need to create accounts to bring PST files in or to move accounts.
Besides all of this, as a network administrator I'm sure this staff member could access just about anything anyway - if youdon't trust him you need to sit down with him and perhaps your HR dept and have a frank converstion - otherwise you have bigger problems than just e-mail.

by madroxxx

Some of the other replies seem to try and suggest that there must be some valid explanation. This is obviously not the case since he has your profile in his email.
I would think this is grounds for termination or at the very least a severe reprimand. As far as management not trusting your department if this comes to light, it shouldn't look bad on your department if you take the appropriate disciplinary actions against the admin. In fact it might be argued that it strengthens the affirmation that this is unacceptable.

by lance.gillis

You two should get along great! You both snoop around looking at non-secure company employee communications. You should get togeather and talk about it, have a laugh or two and then decide that maybe its not good for either of your careers to be snooping around. If you are snooping, you are not predisposed to be a "trusting" mgr anyway. Quit trying to make a federal case, handle this with humor and move on.

by james r linn

If am a manager, and I overhear a harassment between one employee and another I have an obligation to report it, because companies expect managers to do the right thing.

Having found the information, you can't just ignore it. You may have to apoligise to the employee for the way you found it, but you can't ignore it. There is also a difference between casual oops I saw something which the manager did, and the systematic gathering of IDs and passwords that the admin did - there is clear intent based on the number of IDs/profiles that the admin had loaded.

James

by maxwell edison

Scenario:

As IS/IT manager you have come up with a thought - a security concern, actually - about the potential that other people in the IT department (or anywhere else in the company, for that matter) could "eaves drop" on the email of others. You wonder how secure the company's email system really is. You ask your network administrator about the possibility of this happening, and what steps might be taken to prevent it - should anyone feel so inclined to intercept other people’s email.

This will do a couple of things. First of all it will certainly make the network administrator "wonder" if you know what he's doing. You can decide for yourself the merits of actually telling him that you know. Moreover, this approach will shield you from accusing him of something if there is indeed a good reason for what he's done. It will certainly open the door to the discussion, and you can just let the chips fall where they may. Of course, you'll want to create your own approach depending on the personalities and circumstances involved.

The second thing it will achieve is it will make him come up with a solution to a problem that he himself has caused. Of course, you'll want to oversee the solution to make sure there are no built-in bugs that could be exploited by him or anyone else. And I might add this, if your skills in this area aren’t as extensive as your network administrator’s in this particular area, you might consider hiring an outside consultant to review the plan and its implementation. (This could be done with or without the network administrator’s knowledge, again, depending on personalities and circumstances involved.)

This could also serve as a gentle method to put him on notice, so to speak, that he's crossed the line. In the very least, it will sure make him think about it.

Maxwell

by discordian

i never had the need to do this either, even for troubleshooting, nor have i ever needed to view another email account for that reason either, in any way.

i also agree that the arguments for viewing email accounts of other employees are often, ifnot always, unjustified, at least by my experience. yet, within the confines of corporate environments today there are few places that you can work were there is not some level of monitoring used and in such cases you are better off establishing a policy that lets everyone know where they stand and what level of privacy to expect.

my mindset is that, given corporate mindsets of the day, to always expect that every email or site you visit or call you make is monitored and to act accordingly. if you have something to send that you don't want management to see, then send it from home.

it's an unfortunate truth today, no matter what your or my feelings about privacy or big brother happens to be. remember what i said, when i'm ordered to break into an account that i disapprove of such requests, but to keep one's job you must do what you are told, at best you can argue against it and explain how it's usually a bad idea to do so in many ways.

by james r linn

The policy where I used to work and the policy where I currently work is that any opening of a user's mail by anyone other than the user requires the approval of both the CIO and the appropriate director from HR.

We do from time to time have to do security investigations, and people are warned that their email is not totally private.

But people rightfully have a reasonable expectation that they are private unless there is cause, and we try to protect that.

In my world, where we have security screenings and where there is an emphasis on need to know, its a pretty cardinal sin to look at someone else's email. It may be innocent curiousity, but it may be corporate espionage, and we cannot afford to make a mistake in judgement here.Unauthorized access to data here is a firing offense and people know it - the policy is presented to new employees and they must sign off that they have read and understand it as a condition of employment.

James

by discordian

see, you have a policy, it's required reading, and it's enforced. everyone knows where they stand and everyone in the info-sys department knows under what conditions that they must break email accounts and that it's not appropriate in any other case. (yes, they should know this anyways, but ethics tends not to be a requirement for employment these days).

the problem is see is when there are not policies and where people do not know where they stand. also, when policies do not exist or policies are not enforced that allow morally weak persons to do what they original poster is worried about.

of course, if you had good management who hired good staff this sort of thing wouldn't have to be written out since there are people who have thesense to know right from wrong out there. of course, if that were true i guess there wouldn't be disclaimers in barbie commercials telling everyone that barbie cannot, indeed, talk.

it's a nutty world.

by tomsal

Regarding the ethical nature of monitoring people's email (particularly the big dogs in the company) is a totally separate issue as to the LEGALITY of doing it.

However the laws vary by state. In my state for instance an employer has the right toread any employee's email, line for line if he/she wants too, REGARDLESS if the employees are warned ahead of time or not.

by goobs

If I read correctly, you stated that the Net Admin needed the network passwords of the users to do his job. This is not a good policy. I have never needed the network passwords to do my job.

The Admin should have the rights to log into any system on the network and if he needs to log in as a user, he has the rights to make a temporary change of their password (after informing them, of course). This not only keeps the users confident that nobody knows their password, but it would be very difficult for the Net Admin to change it without them knowing and therefore, he could not add their email profiles to his client.

Another benefit of not knowing all of the network passwords is if you do let the Net Admin go, you only have to worry about a few accounts and passwords that need to be changed for security reasons rather than everyones.

by maxwell edison

In addition to my previous post, I would also suggest that you don't jump to conclusions or make any judgments before you have all the facts. After reading the other opinions, there could indeed be a legitimate reason for this, but based on my experience and the tone of your original concern, I rather doubt it. But make sure first.

If the email accounts he had were John's, Judy's and Elmo's because they were on vacation that would be one thing. But since he had the accounts of the IS/IT Manager, the CEO, Legal, HR, senior staff and so on, one could certainly surmise that he was attempting to learn more about what was going on behind closed corporate doors. The fact that you yourself were surprised that he had your account suggests that he was doing it on his own and without coordination with the parties involved. He was trying to be the fly on the wall. I don’t think it could be interpreted any other way.

Also, as previously suggested, be prepared to address the issue as to why you were on his computer. Trust, after all, is a two way street. But if that does indeed become an issue, don’t let it hijack and divert the real discussion at hand, which is why he had those “corporate” accounts on his computer.

I can’t imagine any circumstances under which I would have to have the company’s CEO’s email account on my computer without his knowledge. And how would the company CEO feel about this?

Maxwell

by jklein

What e-mail client are you using? I would change my password and that of everyone else asap.

If you are incharge of this department you got to alert top management. If you blow the whistle on this guy management will trust you.

If something sensitive gets out there could be some serious ramifications, the legal type. Image if one of the CEOs e-mails got out regarding the stock price. Your boy could be selling info on the side. You dont know but you will be holding the bag if something does go wrong.

You need to fire this guy ASAP. He is messing with you putting food on the table, and the CEOs big bonus. That aint cool. Men have died for less. He dug his own grave, no need for you to join him.

by schapman

I agree totally. Your staff are the extra arms and legs that you cant grow yourself. No point having an extra arm that has a mind of its own and is quietly stabbing you in the back. As the IT Manager here, the buck stops with me. My staff do something wrong, I wear the consequences just as much as they do. You have an obligation to your employer and their staff (your customers) to undertake the maintenance of the system with the utmost ethical and moral behaviour.

by maxwell edison

This has been a very interesting discussion with a wide variety of opinions, all of which are based on the dynamics of their individual companies. What may be acceptable at one company may be deemed unacceptable at another, all depending on a numberof factors. So you have to consider the dynamics of your own.

You asked, “If I discuss this with the legal department and it gets around to upper management how would they ever trust the inner workings of my department?”

You have two choices – discuss this with somebody or don’t. You wonder how they can trust “your department” if you do, but you might ask yourself how they can continue to trust you if you don’t.

You said, “This is quitea blow to me since I need to trust this guy”.

Do you now trust him? Will you ever trust him? Could he do anything to gain your trust again? Is he capable of behaving differently? If the answer to any of these questions is no, then it’s a no-brainer. The bottom line is this, you don’t need to trust “this guy”, but you do need a trustworthy person in that position. Do what’s necessary to fulfill that requirement.

You said, “There are no legitimate reasons why he would have profiles on his system”.

Therefore, his reasons are illegitimate, and you also stated that they were “unethical”. Do you have a “zero tolerance” policy for this kind of deception, or are you willing to give a second chance. Whatever you do will set the stage for such future indiscretions.

An interesting way to look at a situation like this is to ask yourself, “What’s the worst thing that can happen if ....?” Can you live with that “worst thing”? If not, you better do something else.

Don’t let your focus get skewed because you “need to trust this guy”. The bottom

by nettek

You said you need to trust him, but it is obvious that your discovery leads you to believe that he is unethical. Ask yourself a question: "Can I ever trust him again?" It seems that you are sure that there are no legitimate reasons for those profiles to be on his PC. You're also sure that this guy is reading the E-mail of top executives which is against your company's policy. And if also doubt wether you can trust him again, then what is the issue? You're his boss, and he violated company policy. Go to your boss or the HR department for a recommended course of action and wash you hands of it.

by lance.gillis

To many of you townspeople are gathering firewood. Any good supervisor knows they have a responsibility to the people who work for them. Everyone makes mistakes / does the wrong thing at some point. You need to decide if you are a vindictive, unbending, self rightous, small minded, fault finding boss or the other kind. You know, the one that inspires people to be their best. How do you stack up? Is there forgivness and leadership in your style or are you just looking for an excuse to showwhos in control? People are flawed. Work to improve the guy to be better. People always respond to good leadership.

by james r linn

There is a time to hold to corporate policy and a time to be forgiving.

One should never be vindictive - thats why you can't take any of thses kinds of measures without involving HR.

I am very forgiving of someone who has shown that they accept that they have made a mistake and will work on correction. But the initial email looks like the person made the same mistake over and over - not a one time thing but a habit.

You also have to look at motive - curiousity can be forgiven, but should malicious intent be forgiven?

People do not always repond to good leadership. Sad to say but some people like to push things to see how far they can take it. And keeping those kind of people around can lower the morale and effect the productivity of the rest of the team. You send the group a message when you are afraid to fire for cause.

It should never be a quick or easy decision. I think alot of it comes down to trust. Trust is earned in both directions. If someone abuses your trust over a long period of time, I would wonder long and hard about how long it would take to regain that trust, the impact on productivity and morale, and whether it would be better to sever the relationship.

James

by madmark

This administrator has been entrusted with the 'keys to the kingdom' and has ridden off with the princess on YOUR white pony. Since you already stated that he is in clear breach of policy, his job is already lost.

You are doing him no disserviceby relieving him of his duties. He cashed in when he breached the policies he was to uphold in the interests of the company, the shareholders, the employees and their families.

Do you have another admin somewhere? Time for a site visit. Speak to HR. You have been entrusted to look out for the company's interests, and Mgmt & Legal need to talk OUTSIDE of email. There may be further investigative work needed here. Espionage? Trade Secrets?

Make certain that your next steps are coordinated and well documented. You MUST be sure that he is doing this without authority, hence management awareness. Who knows, your whole organization may be under investigation from the evil CFO, or Uncle Bill...

Have HR visit your office, and an emergency suddenly arise in the server room. The HR rep should observe the employee leaving the desk. Have a peak at the console, with proper authorization of course. Document and corroborate with HR.

Secure accounts and audit for anomalies.You will likely be removing a major security issue from your company's infrastructure. He is the weakest link. Goodbye.

Your customers should feel that things are not all nice and sunny in your IT kingdom. They will also see that you took the correct course of action and dealth with the matter professionally. Kiss the princess for me. YOU did the right thing.

by cscnet

Ask him why he has them. I have seen reasons for it, just see what his is.

Isn't that your dudy. If your the manager he should expect to answer to you. Don't be an a$$ about it to him or anything. Just ask him. Sometimes new administrators like to map allot of drives or check allot of email. Kinda like an authority thing. It doesn't mean anything bad. Think about it, if he wants to see your email he don't have to set up profiles to do it.

On my networks the administrator, or anybody else,doesn't typically know everybody's password. He can change them, but then the user would be aware of that change. I consider it good practice it protects the IT staff if something happens to somebody's documents or pictures of their cat or something.

Good luck

This discussion is closed to new replies.