This has been a very interesting discussion with a wide variety of opinions, all of which are based on the dynamics of their individual companies. What may be acceptable at one company may be deemed unacceptable at another, all depending on a numberof factors. So you have to consider the dynamics of your own.
You asked, “If I discuss this with the legal department and it gets around to upper management how would they ever trust the inner workings of my department?”
You have two choices – discuss this with somebody or don’t. You wonder how they can trust “your department” if you do, but you might ask yourself how they can continue to trust you if you don’t.
You said, “This is quitea blow to me since I need to trust this guy”.
Do you now trust him? Will you ever trust him? Could he do anything to gain your trust again? Is he capable of behaving differently? If the answer to any of these questions is no, then it’s a no-brainer. The bottom line is this, you don’t need to trust “this guy”, but you do need a trustworthy person in that position. Do what’s necessary to fulfill that requirement.
You said, “There are no legitimate reasons why he would have profiles on his system”.
Therefore, his reasons are illegitimate, and you also stated that they were “unethical”. Do you have a “zero tolerance” policy for this kind of deception, or are you willing to give a second chance. Whatever you do will set the stage for such future indiscretions.
An interesting way to look at a situation like this is to ask yourself, “What’s the worst thing that can happen if ....?” Can you live with that “worst thing”? If not, you better do something else.
Don’t let your focus get skewed because you “need to trust this guy”. The bottom