As SkipperUSN says the answer depends on the situation. I agree with the entire argument presented by him. I will add some points of my own to augment his post.
I would say that in general, most of the time, in most situations, given a typical corporate structure, with ordinary expectations in play, ... etc., the system administrator is NOT a manager. Notice I use the term 'system administrator'. I used to use the term 'system manager', which was popular among the DEC VMS community. However it can lead to a misunderstanding of the role played by the person in that job. The system administrator is a techie. Period. I have always told end users that I don't make policy; I just implement it. I recommend policies to managers but it is their call and their responsibility whether to implement the policy or not. In many situations an IT manager will give rubber stamp approval to any idea that a system administrator makes without prior consultation. This can give the system administrator, and everyone else, the incorrect perception that s/he makes the policy decisions. No. Policy decisions are the responsibility of actual managers, not techies.