Discussion Locked

Is this America or China?

0 helpful
38 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

The American Spectator's Prowler column published today has a disturbing report on the plans by the Democratic Chairman of the House Energy and Commerce Committee Henry Waxman to regulate political speech on the Internet.

In addition to details of methods Waxman is considering to rein in conservative talk radio, The Prowler reports on Waxman's desire to use the power of the federal government to investigate amd control political content on the Internet.

The article quotes an unnamed committee staffer as saying of Waxman's power grab:

"Does one heavily trafficked Internet site present one side of an issue and not link to sites that present alternative views? These are some of the questions the chairman is thinking about right now, and we are going to have an FCC that will finally have the people in place to answer them."

"Internet radio is becoming a big deal, and we're seeing that some web sites are able to control traffic and information, while other sites that may be of interest or use to citizens get limited traffic because of the way the people search and look for information. We're at very early stages on this, but the chairman has made it clear that oversight of the Internet is one of his top priorities."

"This isn't just about Limbaugh or a local radio host most of us haven't heard about. The FCC and state and local governments also have oversight over the Internet lines and the cable and telecom companies that operate them. We want to get alternative views on radio and TV, but we also want to makes sure those alternative views are read, heard and seen online, which is becoming increasingly video and audio driven. Thanks to the stimulus package, we've established that broadband networks -- the Internet -- are critical, national infrastructure. We think that gives us an opening to look at what runs over that critical infrastructure."

The article reports that Waxman intends to work with Democratic Party President Barack Hussein Obama's nominee to be chairman of the Federal Communications Commission, Julius Genachowski, who is awaiting confirmation by the Democrat controlled Senate, to investigate and regulate free speech on the Internet.

38 replies

by boxfiddler Hot topic

What difference does it make where it happens?
Why is anyone surprised to see it happen here?

by santeewelding

I would add temporal.

I would also add that, left to itself, featuring a drift of content and consumption that some don't like, those some will, because they think they can: then, now, and in the future.

by maxwell edison

.....The America people have voted to have. The America that takes the fruits of one's labor and gives it to another. The America that gives up all individual rights in exchange for ignoring all personal responsibilities. The America that feels entitled to that which was not earned. The America that is now a mere figment of what it once was and what it was intended to be.

O beautiful for spacious skies,
For what was once a light,
For all to see, for all to want
That was all good and right.
America! America!
God shed his grace on thee
But now is just a memory
Of what was liberty.

by jdclyde

"You cannot legislate the poor into freedom by legislating the wealthy out of freedom.

What one person received without working for, another person must work for without receiving.

The government cannot give to anybody anything that the government does not first take from somebody else.

When half of the people get the idea that they do not have to work because the other half is going to take care of them,

and when the other half gets the idea that it does no good to work because somebody else is going to get what they work for,

that my dear friend, is about the end of any nation.

You cannot multiply wealth by dividing it."

by jck

[i]"You cannot legislate the poor into freedom by legislating the wealthy out of freedom.[/i]

Please name [b]one[/b] wealthy person who has lost out totally on a true freedom in this country.

They didn't lose a freedom. They lost a small portion of their earnings like [b]every other taxpaying American[/b].

By the way you whine for the wealthy, jd...i'd think your last name is Gates or Walton. At least Warren Buffet doesn't whine about paying taxes.

[i]that my dear friend, is about the end of any nation.[/i]

That's funny. If I remember right, it wasn't the state giving money to the poor from the pockets of the wealthy.

But, it's usually been the case in a lot of instances in history...that most great countries/empires fell because off a small, ruling, wealthy class of people hoarded all the wealth while the masses of slaves/peasants/commoners/citizens fell victim to their whims and had little if anything...unless performing ilkish service such as a concubine, assassain, or spy to those who kept them down.

See...this is my view...

as wrong as it is to give someone something for nothing...

it's just as wrong for Americans to think it's their right to have anything they want just because they do a common thing for it.

You work and earn a check, so you have the right to do what you want?

No lack of humility there, is there?

Self-indulgence and entitlement comes in many forms, jd. Take off the rose-colored glasses now.

by jdclyde

This seems to really be out there. I have been hearing a lot from Michigan rep Stabenau supporting the "fairness doctrine" to censor opposing views.

http://www.620wtmj.com/shows/charliesykes/39690267.html
COYLY MOVING TOWARD SPEECH SUPPRESSION.
By Charlie Sykes
Story Created: Feb 16, 2009

http://worldnetdaily.com/index.php?fa=PAGE.view&pageId=89091
MEDIA MATTERS
Litigation strategy prepared to battle 'Fairness Doctrine'

[i]"The report said not only is the plan to regulate radio under consideration, "Waxman is also interested ? in looking at how the Internet is being used for content and free speech purposes." "[/i]

http://newsbusters.org/blogs/kerry-picket/2009/02/17/rep-henry-waxman-wants-apply-censorship-doctrine-internet

by jdclyde

that should have been in the original post.

As for the second, it is reporting on the first.

looking at drudge to see if he has anything on it.

I do know there has been a lot of talk about censoring the radio waves via "fairness doctrine". Amazing that it is Democrats trying to use the power of government to silence political speech?

There would be liberals on the radio if there was a market for it, but every instance has failed and can only make it on a channel like NPR.

by charliespencer

"There would be liberals on the radio if there was a market for it, ..."

I've always figured that was because liberals were too busy enacting their ideas while conservatives sitting around calling radio shows to agreeing with each other. I could be wrong; maybe it's because advertisers found liberals weren't gullible enough to buy everything a radio host recommended.

:D

I am a bit more concerned about the efforts to regulate broadcast content as opposed to Internet content. It's a lot easier to enforce broadcast regulations. No government has yet been able to effectively control all content all the time, not even China.

by fregeus

.. that republicans or conservatives tend to think alike but act independently while democrats or liberals tend to think independently but act commonly.

That's why talk radio does not work for liberals, they don't seem to have the need anyone telling them how or what to think because they like to form their own opinion regardless of others while conservatives find great solace in listening to others who think like they do and agree with them.

But in a strange twist of faith, there are no more independent individuals than a conservative, who works, lives and breathes for himself and his entourage. While there is no more independent thinker like a liberal, who can easily see anything differently than you but who is willing to work, live and breath for his community and fellow man, more than for himself.

TCB

Edited for clarity

by tonythetiger

those morons don't realize that freedom of speech for you does not create a requirement to listen for me.

by tonythetiger

as independent. Media exists for its own profit. They will report (or not report) and shade the analysis of what they report to enhance their potential for profit.

If you THINK a particular report is independent, it's probably because you agree with it :)

by charliespencer

By 'independent', I meant a second source other than the original referenced article. Independent from the original report, not independent from outside influences.

by jdclyde

although the die-hard liberal would probably spontaneously combust if they were to read anything from newsmax.....

;\

by notsochiguy

...Red Google and Blue Google (Green to be introduced at a later date). Pick a color, pick your search slant.

"We also want to make sure alternative views are read"...this is becoming the second most abused phrase in politics, catching up on "we're doing it to protect the children". As soon as a pollster utters the words, I know he/she is full of it.

by jdclyde

the first step is to control the media and indoctrinate the children. They have been working on the kids for quite some time now.

Says something for their desired message if no one is listening to it, so they want to legislate it getting out.

by notsochiguy

...that words like the ones I quoted were probably used by Hitler in extolling the virtues of forcing people to buy/read Mein Kampf.

They were bogus then, they're equally bogus now (more so, actually...since we have historical precedence to demonstrate how ludicrous this really is).

by jdclyde

Not even liberals want to sit around listening to a talkshow host go on for 2/3 hours saying how stupid Bush is.

We HAD liberal talk shows try to make it and I even gave them a shot. Ed Shultz was just a moron and didn't last long.

That, and the liberals are to busy watching American Idol rather than informing themselves on issues. Look at how many still think Obama is going to pay their rent.

Air America was also a miserable failure. Al Franklin? Hardly. The only thing "funny" about Franklin is they way he is trying to get that senate seat. And no, not "haha" funny. As in "do you smell something funny?"

by tonythetiger

"don't seem to have the need", why are they so worried about "fairness"? Or is it that since "they don't seem to have the need", nobody else should either.

Sounds like a guy who got spurned by a woman and kills her, saying, "If I can't have her, nobody else can either."

Scary stuff.

by fregeus

JD.> I don't know if liberals would sit down and talk about Bush for 2 or 3 hours. I don't know any that would, but I can only speak for myself.

As far as the radio host you mentioned, I never heard their program so I cannot comment on them.

Tony> I don't think the liberals are "worried" about fairness, I thing they actually believe they can achieve it. They try and try and try but never come close. Probably because they fail to see that the simple concept of "fairness" is unfair, or different for everyone and as so, unobtainable. While the conservatives seem to have realized that nothing is fair in this world and the golden rule stands.

TCB

by jdclyde

Spinach in the raw form was one of the last major issues.

The problem is allowing our food to come from countries that have no standards of sanitation.

As for the dude in Georgia, I hope he gets charged with all nine of the deaths for him intentionally passing bad product.

Oh, and every employee that "just did their job" and passed known bad products should also be charged with them.

I have already seen first hand several attempts by teachers to spread their BS to my kids and put a stop to it each time.

Yeah, lets intentionally lie to our kids and tell them New York is going to be under 20 FEET of water instead of 20 inches, MAYBE in 100 years. That is education, or indoctrination?

by charliespencer

I meant the advertisements from the cereal and snack food companies, and the fast food industry.

I guess it's just not their material aimed at kids. I'd also like to require automobile ads show cars as they should actually be driven, not by a "professional driver on closed course, do not attempt". It's amazing how many car companies think I want a car that comes skidding across the desert sands. Why would I want to pay for a car that skids? I want one that doesn't skid; show me that professional driver trying his best to make the car spin out while the vehicle insists on continuing in a straight and controllable manner drivable by a non-professional.

End of exceedingly off-topic rant.

by jdclyde

Do you believe the radio stations have a political agenda, or are making business decisions?

If you believe every talk radio station has a political agenda, then you believe they are willing to make decisions that are potentially bad for their business to get that agenda out.

If you believe they are making business decisions, then it shows that there just is not a consumer market of people looking to listen to liberal radio.

AirAmerica, with lots of private funding started their own airwave attack. As the only liberal party on the block (other than PBS) you would think if there was ANY interest in such a product, they would have flourished, right?

Much like Fox news getting the highest ratings in cable news because it is the only non-left channel out there.

Both of these examples shows liberals are NOT intune with the news media as much as conservatives are.

And many surveys have shown that more liberals get their "news" from the daily show than from any other source. What does THAT say about them?

by tonythetiger

[i]But, it's usually been the case in a lot of instances in history...that most great countries/empires fell because off a small, ruling, wealthy class of people hoarded all the wealth while the masses of slaves/peasants/commoners/citizens fell victim to their whims and had little if anything...unless performing ilkish service such as a concubine, assassain, or spy to those who kept them down.[/i]

And that's exactly what our government is trying to do... put more and more of the power (wealth) into fewer and fewer hands. The wealthy (over 3/4ths Democrats or Socialists, by the way) can take a hit on taxes, because they know they'll get it back penny for penny by including it in the cost of their business' goods and services. Meanwhile if you don't have anybody to pass the cost down to, you're screwed.

The poor always pay the taxes of the rich, so logically, the way to reduce the burden on the poor is to reduce the tax on the rich.

by jdclyde

Everyone knows when "The Government" decides to increase the minimum wage, that comes directly out of the pockets of the evil business owners, and serves them right!

They would NEVER increase the price of their goods/services to offset the increase in the cost of doing business, would they?

It is just one more "feel good" thing that people to stupid to understand "cause and effect" eat up like candy.

Punish success is always a great way to run things.

Reward failure is another winner.

"THEY can afford it". Who the hell is "they"?

by jck

Where did you get that logic from? Target? Dollar General?

If a stimulus plan puts $400 into the hands of individual Americans, how does that put "more and mroe of the power (wealth) into fewer and fewer hands"?

That made no sense.

BTW, that last paragraph:

[i]The poor always pay the taxes of the rich, so logically, the way to reduce the burden on the poor is to reduce the tax on the rich.[/i]

That describes [b]exactly[/b] what Bush's last "middle-class" taxcut did.

Go look at the numbers as to who really got the bigger credits/refunds this year.

Wasn't people making $30k-65k.

by jdclyde

A simple concept.

If you, as a liberal weenie, take money out of the pockets of the evil business owner via taxes, he is going to not just take a business loss. His cost of doing business goes up, so the price he charges the end consumer goes up accordingly.

The cost of living is raised, taking more away from "the poor" than they gained from the welfare check they got.

Kind of like the cost of smokes going up after the government sued and made their backroom deal. Get a huge payoff, causing the industry to raise the cost per pack, so the government can now double dip and get higher sales taxes.

Who won and who lost on that one?

by boxfiddler Hot topic

As they run the abysmal edifice that is education, all that needs be done is teach everything [b][i]but[/i][/b] how to think critically. That's been underway for some time now.

edit: emphasize

by notsochiguy

...as it is one of the reasons I didn't go into education as a profession. Teachers are being taught to be Scantron Test Proctors, and not true educators (at least, it was the case when I was going for my undergrad in the mid 90's...even before No Kid Gets Ahead).

by fregeus

I use to believe that the media was a business and the truth was their product. But for the past few years, I must admit that the media is a business with an agenda and that their vision of the truth is their product.

I totally agree that there is no market for Liberal talk radio like Air America. I stand by my view on why that is. Generally speaking, liberals or democrats don't seem to get the same satisfaction from hearing other people agreeing with them. That is because the liberals or Democrats tend to be (in my view) more independent about their opinions than conservatives or republicans.

As for the polls that say that most Liberal get their news from "the daily show", I have a hard time believing that. I mean, how can so many people be that......strange (to be polite). But for those who do get their news from that show, it does say much about their level of commitment to knowing what is going on in the world. But it goes to show that opinions seem to carry more weight than facts, and opinions are full of agendas.

I do believe that the stations have agendas to push. Its obvious that ABC/CBS/NBC is liberal and FOX is conservative. They both present the news as they see it (political agenda) and as their viewers like to receive it (business agenda).

But I also believe that this is unavoidable. To present true unbiased news, you need to present both side of an issue and come to no conclusion (in order not to influence the masses). That's nice, but no one would want to watch it. It would be extremely long and too boring I think.

TCB

This discussion is closed to new replies.