Discussion Locked

Is this licensing practice ethical? I am furious! (Electric Quilt EQ6 )

0 helpful
10 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

EQ, the makers of EQ6, have decided that their users can only reformat their hard drive and reinstall EQ6 a maximum of 4 times. After that users must pay $40 for an additional activation.

EQ justifies this policy by stating that they are being generous compared with other companies since they are allowing for 4 concurrent installations.

I think the company is being unethical by referring to concurrent installations and activations as the same thing. Most companies may not allow concurrent installations but usually do not restrict the number of reinstallations, especially if they are being performed on the same machine.

At the very least I believe EQ should sell their software as "4 activations of EQ6," not "EQ6."

What do you think? Is it ethical for them to market the program as simply "EQ6," and surprise their users when there are no activations remaining?

Also, if you know of other software companies that do such a thing, please let me know the company and software names. I am not referring to companies that require a phone call to reactivate when computers are swapped. I?m talking about companies that may refuse to activate when the user is using the same equipment or charge for an activation when a computer swap occurs.

If you'd like the full story I have a rant here:

http://techfettish.wordpress.com/2007/12/19/hello-world/

You can see the exact details of EQ6's activation policy here:

http://www.electricquilt.com/Shop/EQ6/EQ6activations.asp

-tech

10 replies

by hal 9000

M$ Legal Department on this one.

It's wrong and unacceptable. The only good thing is that when you receive the software it is clearly displayed on the box so I'm assuming you can return it if you find this unacceptable. Which is what everyone needs to do. For Gods Sake it's a Quilting Program not something that needs to be installed on multiple Computers to do 1 thing.

I find this reprehensible but because it's a little know piece of software with low potential sales I see this more as a Experiment on what can be got away with by the software companies rather than something that will be foisted upon us all unless the buying public don't make loud complaints about this.

Of course if you buy it in a shop you have the chance not to pay for something that you find unacceptable and the software should sit on the shelves unsold.

Col

by cg it

or try to get it free.... That's why MS changed their tactics on XP limited use for non genuine software, allow IE7 and allow XP SP2 for non genuine MS software.

by tekfetish

It was displayed on the box, in tiny writing under the heading System Requirements. I have to admit, I was not worried that my PC might not be able to handle running my wife's quilting software.

The note reminds me of infomercials that cram several sentences of barely-legible disclaimers at the bottom of the TV screen for 2 seconds.

It was listed in the same area (System Requirements tab) on their web site and I hadn?t looked for the same reason. I did not catch it before opening but I did catch it on a sheet of paper in the box. The CD was never removed from its sacred packaging.

EQ has agreed to a return but would not provide me with an RMA (small company). I will update after the transaction is complete. They know I didn't activate the software but the fact that they have engaged in this practice has me weary of them following through with a hassle-free, full refund.

The principal here makes me sick.

-tek

by hal 9000

It may pay to Edit the Heading to include the Makers Name so that when they Search the Web for their Company this appears. :^0

Cheers

Col

by tig2

I will make a point of mentioning this to my MIL. And will thoroughly check Quilt-Pro for anything similar.

I have a family member with a knitting program that is just as anal as EQ6. And Naviteq used to be as bad- they've gotten better.

I agree with you completely. I don't like it when I can't use software I have legally purchased the way I want to. Which is why I don't have a Vista machine. While Microsoft is backing off from their deactivation scheme, I still don't like the idea of being confronted with a piracy banner because THEIR WGA server is having a bad day.

by tekfetish

EQ5 is still available from EQ and it does not use the "4 activations" copy-protection method.

I thought to myself "well, that's different," when I saw a previous version for sale but I wrote it off as extra merchandise, a less expensive way to still use EQ's software, or something similar.

Point being EQ5 is still an option. I would rather use inferior software.

by tig2

I am of the thought that if I dislike someone's business practices, I don't purchase their goods or services. I don't care for the way that Japan views Fair Trade, I don't own or drive a Japanese car. I don't like the WGA in Vista, I use a Mac. I don't like the limited activation of EQ6, I won't buy EQ5.

There is other software out there that will do the job. I'll use it. Something tells me that you feel the same way.

by jonathanpdx

We have "Software", "Vaporware", "Malware", "Garbageware", and now you're saying we have "Stupidware"? And you're surprised?

If the reloads of your system are critical to your operation, install everything you normally put on your system, then burn an image of it using Ghost or some other such utility. It will save you time and effort, and no more needing to re-activate such Stupidware as the activation should already be in the registry.

If not, then consider whether you really need to have that software loaded or perhaps you can get your wife a computer of her own.

by tekfetish

I was wondering what the term for this type of licensing scheme might be called. That's perfect.

I've steered away from images in the past due to hardware changes. I've considered stripping everything down (I swap out data acquisition cards often) before each Ghosting and then reinstalling the devices.

Using an automated installation DVD has kept things rather simple and pain free (most of my software installs automatically with silent installs or macros). I spent a considerable amount of time setting that up years ago.

I considered the additional computer (can you really have too many)? I was too furious at the thought of buying one for this reason!

Thank you for the suggestions though. It sounds like there aren't many other products out there like this. I am glad to hear that!

-tek

by tekfetish

Thanks for the suggestion Hal. I can only hope this appears in a Google search!

I'd like to find more places to expose their dirty little practice. If you think of any please send me a message here or at http://techfettish.wordpress.com/.

From a few IRC conversations I was expecting the responses with a "it's their software they can do what they want" type of attitude. I?m glad to find others who see this the same way I do.

-tek

This discussion is closed to new replies.