Discussion Locked

Is Vista Doomed from the Start?

0 helpful
600 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I was discussing this with a friend the other day, and we noticed a pattern in Microsoft's software. All of it was launched with great hype and fanfare and touted as a 'good' product, but the results have been mixed. Going all the way back to 1986:

DOS 3.3: GOOD
DOS 4.2: BAD
DOS 5.0: GOOD
DOS 6.0: BAD
DOS 6.22: GOOD
Windows 3.0: BAD
Windows 3.1: GOOD
Windows 95: BAD
Windows NT/98: GOOD
Windows ME: BAD
Windows 2000/XP: GOOD
Windows Vista: ?

I have used all these OS's with the exception of Vista, and these are my experiences. Anyone have similar experiences?

600 replies

by kiltie

You missed out quite a few DOS versions, and many Windows versions.

Additionally, what criteria did you use to determine "GOOD" from "BAD" and from what perspective?

One may be good for games, but bad for office environment or vice versa
or one may be good from a user point of view, but bad from a techie angle
and so on....
you get my point?

EDIT: typoswe lure
hehe

by unhappyuser

There were MANY versions of DOS that MS came out with besides what's shown. Having worked with CP/M, Xenix, Unix, Linux, DOS/Windows and Mac I can say, in my humble opinion of course, that MS products still lag behind the others and are porrly designed (except maybe Exchange). MS has copied SO many features from other software vendors it's unbelievable.

Then why has Microsoft done so well you ask? Does anyone remember Beta and VHS? It's all about marketing. If Bill Gates had not been so good at this (and a BSer too) he'd be a second rate programmer at Motorola.

by deadly ernest

with desk top OS's. I did notice he stuffed up a bit Win 2K and Win XP are two seperate issues, and he has the linked. tch, tch.

But Vista is too expensive in the way of hardware, and incorporates too many counter productive items as core parts of the software. Who needs every employee able to watch videos at their desk, really. I think we're about to see cases where people are going to lose corporate Internet access at the desk, and only outside contact will be via the mail server.

by tony hopkinson

Personally based on my experience in software, there are releases that are basically a consolidation of the previous that solve existing shortcomings or there are ones which make extensive changes. The latter always go wrong in some respect. Especially when they are more business directed that technical or quality.
I fully expect Vista to cause problems all over the place, not so much because MS have got it wrong, but because they have no way of satisfying the requirements of all their customer base. A mistake they've been making since their initial success.

Just their pricing and product strategy is going to slap a lot of people in the face.

by ramnet9

Surprised a programmer thinks there is/was a Windows 2003 .. glad you dont cut my code.

Vista will be a dog because Microsoft does not GIVE what the IT community wants. Vista is oh so SLOW - requires a major re-investment in hardware and software for no obvious benefits , merely builds on what Microsoft does do well and that is hype something out of nothing. In fact that is what most Americans are expert at hype and bull very short on actual substance and real improvements .. call me a cynic but I wont be making Microsoft richer till they fix what is broke in XP and give me a fast , foolproof and mujch simpler to operate system. PC's were about doing things easier and faster .. this HAS NOT EVENTUATED.

Ken

by deadly ernest

it was for servers only, and sold as Windows 2003 for Servers, and Win 2003 for Advanced Servers. They released it as the server match for XP, but not at the exact same time.

by beowulf_cam

You can remember Dos 1.0? I have a visual image of old time techies in tweed jackets gathered around a small flickering screen in a darkened room...

by 0b1111

Plenty of us still out there that have been through all of DOS and Windows. And in my case early Apple operating systems..ahh the joys of ProDos and 5 Mb Profile hard disks the size of a loaf of bread.

What I have learned is to do your risk assessment before anything else. 'What ifs?' can save your sanity, and maybe prevent early hair loss in the younger members, and Rogaine for the rest of us relics.

But speaking as one who has been around for a while.... I LOVE IT! The challenge alone and pace of change keep the noodle ticking.

And BTW I NEVER wore a tweed jacket. I much preferred a white dust coat and grimey pocket protector, coke bottle thick glasses, and slide rule in the back pocket. Tweed was for those english techs.

Note also that there were no screens to gather around. Punch card terminals and toggle switches on front panels to load software did however give me a hunch :)

Cheers

by ancientmath

The tweed jackets were the old stoagies that told us that computers would never be mainstream or that "windows is just a fad".

by steve

Hmm, DOS 2.0 - that was the 5 and a quarter disks with the sort of pink, label, wasn't it?

My first experience with DOS was when out lecturers excitedly announced that they've got a new IBM PC for the Computer Studies Dept, but could we please shut ourselves in with to the room with a manual and work out how to format a floppy disc so that they could start to use it.

Ah, after changes, we are more or less the same, as Simon & Garfunkel once observed...

by aditya_mrt

I am fully agree with you. I checked all the MicroSoft OS in different Hardware.

Aditya Kumar
785/2, Shastri Nagar,
Meerut (India)
PATNI COMPUTER LTD.INDIA.

by mgp2

I would just modify (slightly) your description on the Windows ME line (a.k.a. Windows Miserable Edition or Major Embarrassment).

Windows ME: Incredibly, horribly BAD

by researcher75

Your proposal leaves out too many other versions:-

Windows 98: BAD
Windows 908SE: GOOD
Windows NT: GOOD
Windows 2000: GOOD
Wiondows XPSP1:BAD
Windows XPSP2: GOOD
Windows Vista: GOOD?
Windows ?????: GOOD

My experience of VISTA now that I have installed Candidate 1 is quite good, their are certain features I don't like and one hopes that manufactures will be able keep up with the new regime, but with Office 2007 and IE7, VISTA runs sweet.

Really depends on the system one sets it up on, but cheapy stuff and you get a cheapy result!
Roy-the-Boy

by justinsvalois

Just my two cents, feel free to disagree... as much of this was when I was still in elem - mid school I was NOT in the field... but for home use, these are my ratings.

DOS as far as I can remember DOS was great, but then all I did was destroy my computer teaching myself about how HEX editors worked and such worked. Damn kids, break stuff too much. :)

Windows 1 (anybody remember that? No windows, just menus) *this was before my time but I did download it once.
Windows 3.x (ALL SUCKED)
Windows 95 SUCKED
Windows 98 SUCKED
Windows 98se Better, but SUCKED
Windows NT Decent
Windows ME COMPLETELY BLEW
Windows 2000 OK, but not great
Windows XP SUCKED
Windows XP sp1 SUCKED
Windows XP sp2 almost getting better....
Windows Vista ???? can we say prolly SUX!
Windows Vista sp1 ???? See above
Windows Vista sp2 ???? Lets give them the benefit of the doubt... Should be Decent. ??

by kirkdavis666

I go back to to OSs with no name that ran on tape. I've run just about every DOS/Windows, including HDOS. Best of all time was NT. Would run 24/7 forever without crashing. XP SP2 is second, assuming it's properly tuned.

by steve

I don't recall there being a Windows 1 or Windows 2. IIRC, Windows/286 was the first, followed by Windows 386 (when things started to come alive - compared to what we had before then!). Windows 3.0 was the first version of Windows as we know it, and it was numbered 3 because of the previous 286 and 386 versions.

I do disagree with your rating of 98, especially 98SE. Lots of BSODs as I recall, but far, far better than 95. Similarly, I've a slightly softer memory of all XP versions.

I think, thought, we also have to factor in the hardware base we were running these things on. Single floppy 4.77 Mhz PCs, anyone? Even going to a twin floppy was a quantum leap, and what excitement we had when out IT department all got shiny new IBM ATs with a 16MHz chip. It's not really fair to compare operating systems (and early Windows versions weren't really OSs because they ran under DOS) because our machines are a lifetime away from the old steam powered crocks we had in the mid-80s. My PDA has more processing power than the whole college had when I was learning the profession!

Says he, only 42 on Monday and sounding like a dinosaur himself...

Steve

by ancientmath

I mean seriously, if they all sucked so damn bad as you say, why do you even bother? When Vista does release, why don't you just skip it and stay in your probably (not "prolly") stagnated hole and wallow in self pity?

As for the versions themselves and all of this ranting...from who's perspective are we really looking at here? the users? the admins? This "Doomed from the start?" scenario started actually with the service packs (NTSP1 worked, SP2 broke things, SP3 fixed them again, SP4 broke more things, SP5 fixed them again, etc) that went along NT server versions and the OP has lumped several versions together for the sake of convenience to rant some more. No content.

As for one that really did grow up through the Windows versions (and launched Win95), I have at least a little more content and input to my own opinion...and it's just that, an OPINION. I will lump it together as such:

User Perspective --
Dos 1.0 -- we were all going to be rich
Dos 2.0 -- nobody became rich
Dos 3.0 -- now we realized who was going to be rich and it wasn't us
Dos 3.1 -- at least it worked
Dos 4.x -- damn, it used to work
Dos 5.0 -- hey, new features!
Dos 5.1 -- hey, the new features actually work cool now!
Dos 6.0 -- no improvements
Dos 6.1 -- damn, they broke it
Dos 6.22 -- finally!
Windows 1 & 2 (i missed these somehow, so I have no opinion)
Windows 3.0 -- sucked, yes, but it was better than BBS doors
Windows 3.1 -- improvement from the user perspective
Windows 3.11 -- networking? wow!
Windows 95 -- Finally!!!
Windows 95a/b/c/d -- wtf?!
Windows 98 -- win95e?
Windows 98SE -- ok
Windows ME -- yes, I skipped this too; the bounce was so hard it was easy to say "i won't support this version, move up or down"
Windows 2000 Pro -- NTFS, finally some security for the user!
Windows XP -- finally some security for the home user!
Windows XPSP1 -- ok, at least they're trying
Windows XPSP2 -- finally some real security...but alas, thanks to advanced genuinity, the pirates are still infecting the others thru email and Home Edition users are frustrated with home networking
Vista -- the viruses are still in email

From the Admin Perspective --
Windows NT 3.0 -- at least there's a GUI
Windows NT 3.5 -- GUI still sucks but at least it's more stable and secure
Windows NT4 -- wtf?
Windows NT4SP1 -- fixes, good
Windows NT4SP2 -- dammit
Windows NT4SP3 -- fixes
Windows NT4SP4 -- dammit AND wtf?!
Windows NT4SP5 -- whew! finally some functionality and fixes
Windows NT4SP6 -- skipped, we're learning
Windows NT4SP6.1 -- told ya
Windows 2000 Server -- at least I can control the user workstations better
Windows 2000 Server SP1 thru SP4 -- there's a pattern here
Windows 2003 Server -- continue the pattern, SP1 fixes, SP2 breaks
Longhorn (Ultimate) -- well, at least it has everything despite being quirky
Longhorn SP2 -- this is the time to jump in

by beowulf_cam

Remember Microsoft Bob (1995)? Bob was so bad that not only did it totally flop, Microsoft has erased all historical references to it... There are probably still people traumatised by it..

by andyilm

Thanks for the hilarious post.I think Bill's wife is still influencing really helpful things in their OSs. Like the Merlin and Rover characters in XP.
Vista is like Windows Me on steroids.

by pkrdk

Remember 'digital dashboard' from late 90'ies? A place where you could create links to all kinds of information. At he time a homepage (which is was) was very common, and Digital Dashboard was yet another try of re-inventing the wheel.

Not to mantion alle the vapourware annonced with W/2000, XP and Vista. Somebody ready with a list ?

by joy64

I can't speak for all these systems because there were years I would skip due to so much bad news about the "new" OS system. I so clearly remember Windows 3.0 being touted as the new best system, installing it, formatting the disk and going back to DOS 5.0. It took me a while after that to trust Microsoft again.

by johnny bee

The only real improvement I've been able to glean from Vista is the Glass interface - which, quite frankly, I find annoying once I got passed the "isn't that nice" phase. Dressing up Windows XP could have been done using service or plus paks. Unless I've missed something, there really hasn't been much improvement to the security features or stability of the OS. So, unless some earth-shattering revelation comes from the release of Vista - I'll be leaving it alone for a while.

by mgp2

With all the problems they're having with delayed release, along with not allowing the security software vendors access to the kernel (like all of a sudden Microsloth is synonymoun with security), and all the other little problems that won't be fixed (or even addressed) prior to RTM, I'm content to wait until Service Pack 1 comes about. On a brighter note, even with their new "Upgrade from XP to Vista" coupon program for PCs purchased between yesterday and March 15, OEMs are probably going to cut their prices considerably to convince people to buy a PC before Xmas instead of waiting for the release. And I'll be taking advantage of that to pick up a new system on the cheap.

by norehca

Vista is nothing but a beautiful interface and several dozen processes gaurenteed to rape your computer. The interface is beautiful, ill give you that much. I have run several demos on vista, most of which have crashed on me (im running an AMD athlon 64 3700+ 1GB RAM radeon 9600 XT overclocked) and the others with decent framerates...if you want to play long enough for vista to "get used" to the game. it simply starts out almost crashing, and eventually smooths out. Not my idea of a good gaming experience. as far as compatibilty goes, vista x64 still has the same problems as windows XP x64. No drivers for some hardware. Bottom line, performace sucks, looks neat, aweful new networking setup, dont count on it.

by jgmsys9

Interesting line of thought. I'd never thought to look to see if a pattern of behavior was emerging in Windows releases. I have played around with Vista Beta 2 and RC1, and I can tell you that in my experience, Vista is little more than eye candy with annoyances. In Vista, the IP protocol stack has been rewritten, and in my opinion is causing major problems in getting to certain web sites via the browser in RC1. I can trace the route to those sites, but for some reason IE7 has issues with them and will just time out. The worst case of this is that the very site through which to report bugs appears inaccessible for some reason. Conspiracy?

I'm sticking with XP and Linux. In fact, I can hardly wait to download and install Fedora Core 6.

by gsquared

I've used Vista Beta 2, RC1 and RC2, and I like the interface and the OS.

Use-wise, it's not the huge change MS would like it to be. I still use it the same way, still put my most common programs on the Quick Start bar, etc. But it does have some convenience factors I like. The ability to type in the names of control panel apps in the search bar on the start menu is convenient. The built in search is fast and useful. I like the way the new start menu works.

Security-wise, I'm happier with Vista than with prior versions of Windows. IE 7 on Vista is more secure than IE 6/7 on XP. It's still not completely secure, but nothing is. I've tested a few things (gone to pages that download spyware, etc.) and the default settings have worked to secure the computer. So long as I don't do really stupid stuff (like allow pages to install code on the computer by typing in an admin password), it should be okay.

Truly, I see it as an incremental improvement over XP. But I do see it as a worthwhile improvement.

As for the new graphics, they're nice, but I don't buy an OS for the glossy graphics.

by brotherjim019

Having used all those operating systems, I must admit I will not be using Vista immediately, for an absolute certainty! That which is being touted reasons for buying/upgrading to Vista, has mostly to do with "aesthetics," which I am not adverse to per se, for I do love beautiful things, but that is found mostly in nature! I can go out for a weekend with a couple of camera bodies, and THERE find my beauty, not have to pay for beauty in an OS, but rather pay for truly needful changes and additions that make the OS worth all our dollars.

As well, MS has usually done their best testing from those who buy at the start, and I feel few will want to be among those who purchase only to be testers for things missing, to find flaws, being of help in improving those things. If I go to Vista, it will be a few years after I have seen the patching process isn't needed anymore, and the OS is absolutely rock solid.

by michael l hereid sr

I'm using Vista X64 Ultimate RC2-it is working with no problems-highly stable in fact it has not stopped working at all. My computer runs 24/7.
I prefer VISTA over XP.
Michael L Hereid Sr

by rsrusa

What does vista really have that isn't already in xp, outside of alot of overhead?

by bookkeeper

First all I'am not sure if it is doomed from the start or not but that is a pretty good theory about MS,s software. One thing i know for sure it's just a matter of preference more then anything else, as to which one we choose. I say try them all it's fun somtimes. ;)

by zczc23119

We all know that the recommended amount of RAM for VISTA is 1 GB and to appreciate the new graphics we will all need new video card PCIE.

After a company spends big dollars on upgrading their hardware comes the big dollars of paying for the software.

The justification for spending all this money to upgrade to VISTA must come with a big advantage and that comes down to increasing productivity in the work place.

Don't you just love the flood of PC vendors offering PC's at a small cost that wont run VISTA either being short of RAM or now having enough power being not built with PCIE graphics cards.

With every version of O/S M$ has produced there is a total disregard for how much the Hardware will cost to run the new version.

This don't care attitude is reflected in meeting where M$ basically tells Hardware Manufacturers what they need to build to support the new O/S

In my life time I have seen Windows happy to run on 16MB of RAM with a 1MB video card and a hard disk with no more than an outrageous
1 GB of RAM.

Certainly the trade off in upgrading hardware means that we can run products like Windows 2000 with speed and increase efficiency in the workplace.

The question is for most companies of medium to large is

What productivity will the outlay cost increase our business efficiency?

If you are purchasing a O/S just for the eye Kandy rather than functionality, you are probably a home user who can indulge in 1 or 2 PC with a new O/S

If you CEO asks you administrators to cost the new hardware and software cost and justify it against productivity gains - which any IT manager must explore then good luck to you.

Just a few thoughts

1. It there a limit less amount of RAM you are prepared to install in each PC
2. Is there a limit less amount of hard disk you are prepared to install.
3. Is there a limit less amount of PCIE video cards you are prepared to upgrade to and what amount of RAM on those cards are you prepared to install.

I do realise that you don't get new functionality for nothing, however there must come a time where business draws the line.

I would love to see a new O/S released that improves productivity without needing to upgrade all your hardware. A new O/S that is safer, faster and manages memory far better and guarantees Disk writes and reads to the HDD are always verified and are fault tolerant the way a Main Frame and servers guarantee this buy the use of Hotfix, Turbo FAT tables and limited use of the disk for virtual RAM so the HDD is free just to read and write to supply files for the O/S and applications.

by nobby57

zczc2311,

Agree 200% with your last paragraph -- real progress for an OS might better be measured in terms of security, speed, and better use of the hardware. Get the idea, Redmond?

Or is it really a conspiracy to spur hardware sales, after all. . .

Reid

by darksunmoon

Have you tried Linux? LOL

Sure, it's not from Microsoft, but it's a decent OS, not to expensive and it doesn't take an expensive hard core gaming machine to run it...

by .. kash ..

i wouldnt call XP that good.. 2000 was no doubt pretty good but in my opinion, XP could've been better.. so in that case, Vista should be better.. and u've grouped NT n 98 together as well.. keep em seperate n u'r pattern goes out the window :P

by philthee

For a start, how on earth can you put NT and 98 together as "NT/98" - they're based on totally different kernels and one (NT) was infinitely more stable than the other.
As for Windows Me, I actually found it the most stable of the MS "consumer" OS's until XP came along.
If anything, Vista is doomed because of the restrictions (think licensing, DRM, and so on) it's going to place on the end user.
Sorry Microsoft, I'll keep my XP. You haven't given me a good enough reason to upgrade.

by .. kash ..

Microsoft's thinking that its pretty smart by inserting these restrictions into Vista. Most of the people I've talked to dont want to upgrade just because of these licensing issues.
Personally, I'd rather not pay so much for cutting my arms n legs off with Vista. XP is a far better choice.

by brummy21

Windows 2000 and Windows XP are distinct and different versions. Therefore, according to your progression Windows XP (2002) should be considered as BAD, which is of course not correct. That would then make Vista GOOD. By the way, in no way was Windows 95 bad either - it remains one of the most stable versions of Windows if you stop third party software from overwriting its system files with broken updates, and keep away from rubbish third party device drivers and rubbish memory modules.

by iaston

Umm I could have sworn these were 2 completely different Operating Sytems with massively different underlying technologies but then again I may be wrong...

Also, you and your pal can't lump Windows 2000 and XP in together for the sake of your pattern!

Nice idea but come on!!

by cloudohana

DOS 3.3: GOOD
DOS 4.2: BAD
DOS 5.0: GOOD
DOS 6.0: OKAY
DOS 6.22: GOOD
Windows 2.0: AWEFUL (quickly uninstalled)
Windows 3.0: OKAY
Windows 3.1/3.11 for WG: GOOD
Windows NT 3.0/95a: BAD
Windows 95b: GOOD
Windows NT 4.0/98: OKAY
Windows 98SE: GOOD
Windows ME: ABSOLUTELY AWEFUL!! Don't do like this again!!
Windows 2000/XP: GREAT!!
Windows Vista: Hopeful!!

by frank semuju

I think Microsoft has learned a lot from the experience of XP SP2, that I hope Vista should be a much more better OS.

by cs

That was the name my 13 year old (at the time) used to describe Windows ME. There certainly is congruence with my experience as an IT Manager as to the adage of don't buy an even numbered version of Microsoft. My theory is that Microsoft lose their good people through promotion or departure following a successful release. The new people in the MS team then have to develop, endure & fix a poor release before they get it right with the next one.

by w.j.eichler

You may be closer to the truth than anyone else in this post.
In sports, now that there is free agency, championship teams fall apart, when the stars depart.
People write software not companys. In companys there are stars and duds. In companys, coming off of recent success, self promoting duds can convince management they are stars. You can polish up a dud, but it remains a dud. Stars working for duds soon learn the truth and find somewhere else to go.
When the duds make the company go through a bad period, they start to weed out the duds and look for stars.
Problem is that this cyclic bussines pattern starts to let the duds slip through the cracks and after a while you get dud build up, that is when the CEO retires with his fortune and leaves the duds to fend for themselves. Just a thought!!

by necrothug

For this pattern to be true, it would have to look like this:

DOS 3.3: GOOD
DOS 4.2: BAD
DOS 5.0: GOOD
DOS 6.0: BAD
DOS 6.22: GOOD
Windows 3.0: BAD
Windows 3.1: GOOD
Windows 95: BAD
Windows NT: GOOD
Windows 98: BAD
Windows ME: GOOD
Windows 2000: BAD
Windows XP: GOOD
Windows Vista: ?

This is obviously flawed.
You can't lump together totally different technology like you did for the sake of a clever little pattern.

by onclejon

After Windows 98 my experience was:
20000 Good
Me Bad
XPHome Bad
XP Pro Good
XP SP1 Good
XP SP2 Bad
Vista which version to compare?

by mercenaryali9

That stops the trend dead in it's shoes!
VISTA works just fine and I have only the RC1 version as issued to testers directely from Microcost. So far so good.

by tony hopkinson

One happy customer, many billions to go.
I dare say if you go off as home user by vista capable hardware and you only use applications designed for it, it will be OK. Especially after a service pack or two.

A place where I worked, where they still have a large win95 base (1000s) and some very old in house and 3rd applications that work with their ibm and vax kit which are absolutely critical to their business aren't going to greet it with any fervour.

Don't say oh they should have upgraded ages ago etc. What they have runs their business effectively, they see no need for change nor is there much in Vista that offers them any increase in effectiveness compared to the cost of doing an upgrade. So quite rightly they won't.

Personally I think MS have just given them the incentive for a switch to linux, which is something they've been looking at for a while. Training and infrastructure changes have put them off up to press, but they are were starting to look less of a problem against XP never mind Vista.

by deadly ernest

and want a machine primarily for multimedia use. For the average office environment it's expensive rubbish, all eye candy.

You can spend less than half of the money and get a box running XP, or for about a tenth of Vista, you can get Linspire.

by Member 25634966

It's a bit naughty to lump 2000 and XP together just to prove your point. Let's hope that Vista benefits from the rule "never two without three".

2000 - GOOD
XP - GOOD
Vista - will have to be GOOD

by computab

I do not agree with this simplistic analysis. Windows 95 was not that bad, it started quickly, you didn't need much security in those days. Windows 98 had that bad shutdown problem. I hated Windows 2000 - it was too slow. It had too much security built-in. Later experience has proved my point - you can't rely on Windows for security. 2 good points in Win2k were that it had no antivirus or firewall, so you could get something good, like Zonealarm firewall and AVG antivirus. Windows XP has its share of idiotic error messages, eg ' This program could not initialise as this station is trying to shut down'

by ancientmath

imho, you say having no firewall is a "good" thing?! Zonealarm was a good concept, but lets the whole app thru and back in again; not to mention the constant need to click allow for every process. for end users, they claimed dns requests was me "hacking" them and i just simply had to drop them because i spent too much time going thru networking 101 with them that they misunderstood anyway.

by tony hopkinson

How are you doing two ways comms if you block one leg?
I'm sure all of us would prefer a hardware firewall than a software one, but ZoneAlarm, Sygate etc were a much better alternative that XP's when it came out with XP SP2. At least they have the facility to stop applications 'dialing' out.

Configuration is a pain and an integrated firewall set from policies will be an improvement though.

The education issue is a problem every where PC's were not designed as appliances. To make them into one, someone has to lobotomise them. Lucky us eh?

by andy.ross11

Umm, following your logic, as Windows 2000 and Windows XP are different products, it should be:

Windows 2000 Good, Windows XP Bad, Vista Good

by flh70

DEC Tape and paper tape. No option or module swaps. 16 K system were hot.

by ancientmath

I think you're confusing the "firewall" in SP1 with the SP2 version. Sure, two way comms are necessary; but that was just the problem with ZoneAlarm, when two way comms were necessary, you had to open up the whole app; unlike SP2 firewall that allows return traffic. I found ZoneAlarm "configuration" more of a pain and headache. I did like Sygate over the earlier versions of Windows Firewall (pre-SP2), but likewise, opened the whole app, not just the port to listen on...maybe it was just me, maybe I didn't have enough time to answer all of the Yes's and OK's to properly test the product, but I found it to be a hinderance and in each case found it just easier and less expensive (man hours) to go the hardware route.

What I like about XPSP2 Firewall is that at least users aren't left "naked" before they could be educated to see the advantages of a hardware setup and in a blown up situation that called you on the weekends with a wipe and a tutorial to complete when done.

by gruehlin

This is so lame it isn't even worthy of being in this column.

Hopefully, it is supposed to be humorous because it certainly isn't tech-worthy.

by bryonsean

The lamest part of this is that you lumped together NT with 98 and 2000 with XP. If you are going to lump things together, which is lame, then NT would go with 95 and XP would go with 2003 Server. 2000 could only be lumped into Professional, Server, etc.

by claymann39

I have beta tested this product from when it was dubbed 'Longhorn'. Yess, it truly sucks. The product bottomed out halfway thru the process, and was renamed 'Vista'. The early builds were so bad they would not install correctly. Microsoft had to remove many promised features they could not deliver. I will never, ever buy this piece of Ka ka.

by alin.selicean

This "rule" also applies to NT service packs, but viceversa. If anyone remebers, NT SP4 was bad enough (it altered something in the SAM encryption algorithms). Overall, yes, it seems we do have a pattern.

by szobal

In addition to all the versions noted, I am also running VISTA Candidate 2. Except for a couple of applications, the OS is performing well -- so far. Maby because of the 2 version?

by ang2006

....but XP does anything I require of it and I have no need nor desire in trading up anytime soon. As the old saying goes, "if it ain't broke don't fix it." By the time I may need Vista it will probably be perfect.

by ang2006

I will never use Vista if Windows follows through with any kinds of plans to monopolize anti-virus by shutting out any anti-virus vendors. That is like General Motors building cars which only run on a secret formula which you then must get from a GM dealership---I don't think so. There are other OS.

by viveka

Still miss programming flash memories, on z90 and 8086 processors, and for kicks, printing (aka punching holes)on ticker tapes to see what went wrong where... nothing like taking the time to debug one instruction at a time....

by runestar

Hello to all :)

I probably won't get vista until I get a new machine, with it already loaded, but that is about a year and a half away as things stand now. I'll have all the old XP things handy in case the new OS isn't "up to the challenge of running smoothly and correctly", not to mention being user friendly. While I can use a computer well, the majority of ppl out there turn it on, use the app or game they are familiar with, then turn off their computer. If one of those people have problems, and need to trouble shoot, it is likely they will get SO lost in what must be more complex settings, as if windows XP isn't enough in that regard. I do agree about the "every other product is wonderful" and there are folks out there that still use win98se, as it's speed and performance are close to that of XP. It seems bad to me that MicroSoft can't seem to learn from it's own history, and try to keep the best features of each OS in the next OS they release.

Sincerely,
Stephen

by terrypeck

No. Vista will be a success because, despite the naysayers, there is no, absolutely no, competition. Linux is a duck. The Mac is...well, a given... And anything taking us forward will be the next best thing to perfection - regardless. There will be problems: we now come to expect it.

Incidentally, Windows 95 BAD??? Are you serious? The biggest selling product of all time? Oh, you mean "did it work"? Did that really matter? There just wasn't an alternative. And still, there is no viable competitor to Windows Vista for the masses. I think MS knows this. Pity, but there it is.

by info

Admitedly Linux has not got a nice GUI yet..I am still waiting for that. But from a purely server stand point, Linux blows Server 2003 out of the water, it is faster and can do more with the basic setup. I have several linux servers in the field and customers love them, they never need rebooting.

by fxef

What do you mean... "Linux is a duck"? Tux is a penguin, not a duck.

Moving on, Linux is a great OS for the desktop.

I personally don't think Vista is doomed and do see Linux as a workable option to XP or Vista.

by justanopinion

LOL I remember 286 and 386. I still have my manual and floppys for 3.3, and back in my college days, my computer programming classmate gave me his 5.0 disks so I could upgrade to the "rest of the world"! (I think he liked me ;) hehe, and today, they have locked software so we can't do that). It doesn't seem that long ago that I laid to rest, that beautiful black with green letters monitor.
I have two boxes of floppies with information that I need to transfer to the new age and even better, I have programs on the big 5.25's in a box in my closet!
YIKES!
What I'm having a hard time remembering, is when the internet first appeared. I don't know if I got it when it first came out or if I had to wait, but I remember my big, bright blue eyes, excitement and hunger when I first hooked up and saw information I'd never have known existed and real moving pictures on my screen! lol It took forever to get that stuff to load compared to the cable I have now, but I didn't notice that then. lol
So to all you dinosaurs out there, a big wink and a grin!

by j.g.camp

not because of the every other OS thing, it's because of what it really represents.

It requires the consumer to seriously evaluate their entire stockpile of hardware and software that is still perfectly good. Simply buying the OS, will make it's installation require faster processors and more memory at the least for a significant enough of consumers. The tactic is to scare you to buy more hardware that is "Vista Ready", because what you have may work with it, but at reduced levels of performance, causing dis-satisfaction. And don't get me started on "Vista Ready", that implies it's supported for all features, yet virtually all of them aren't Vista ready.

And who wants to buy an OS, only to have to attempt to install the applications you already have and find out they don't install for whatever reason ? There already is a product out there called Linux that can leave this level of frustration when straying from the path of a repository supported 3rd party software application, even drivers. The difference though, the hardware is more universally supported, and if it's not completely supported, it's free anyway, so you don't feel you paid something for getting hoodwinked and nothing that is beneficial enough to have paid anything for.

Why would anyone want to buy something that makes a PC that is perfectly good and adequate, make it obsolete or at the very least need to undergo upgrades. Why would anyone want to buy an OS that after installing it, requires patch after patch to attempt to get expensive software applications to run on it. I just don't see the percentage for the consumer in it ? I do see the percentages for the industry to charge more for newer versions or incurr additional costs to try to fix what they have for Vista ? In the end, the consumer bends over.

This new OS/Vista opens new doors/windows, for Linux that is !

by tweakerxp

I think that once Vista hits the market and people see the restrictions that are built into this OS, they will start to look at Linux a lttle more closely. The only problem that I have run into with Linux were the people's attitude when I first started messing around with Linux. No one wanted to help me solve problems. Most just told to go figure it out on my own because they had to do the same. FINALLY I got a couple guys to show me what I was doing wrong and it turned out to be a pretty nice OS, But that is just me.

by beads

This has been an old running joke starting closer to the dawn of DOS itself. In case you remember DOS 2.x lasted about 3 days or so it seems. These jokes were ongoing back in the early eighties when I was in college.

- beads

by deadly ernest

Pro as a desktop or stand alone machine,

Server for use on a server,

Advanced Server, for use on a server in a major server network.

That's all the versions they need. XP pro was a slightly updated, and eye candied version of W2K Pro.

Vista is an over eye candied multimedia machine, not suitable for an office environment. And very resource heavy.

by hatfira

What makes you say that Vista is not suited for the office? You don't think that 2000 GPO settings, the ability to lock out USB drives, and the "every user is a standard user" secuity model are not office-friendly? And those are three things I thought of just off the top of my head and not including things like bit locker encryption.

As for resources, the needed requirements for Vista are well within today's mainstream computer environment (512MB RAM, 1Ghz processor, and 1024x768 video). I have even been running Vista and Office12 in a VMWare environment that doesn't meet these specs and Vista is still usable. People look at what Vista wants for all the eye candy and and think that's what's needed to even run it, and that simply not true.

I will grant you however that there are just too many versions. It would make more sense to only have a version for home (without the domain), Pro for business, perhaps one that is stripped to sell to third-world countries, and maybe a Media-Center edition-type. That's not counting two versions of the server world (Sandard and Eterprise). That should be plenty to cover all the bases for MS and stil not be TOO confusing to users.

by rivasj01

Windows 2000 Professional and Windows XP Professional are two distinct and separate Operating Systems.

Windows 2000 Professional released about the saome time as Windows ME.

Basically you have to look at the two Microsoft Operating paths: Home user and NT user once you get into Windows.

The NT path has always had better initial releases since that is where the Money if for Microsoft. From the Windows from Workgroup inital release to the upcoming Vista release.

I fell away from the Home Editions begining with Window 2000/ME release. The Professional version was much more robust and stable from the get-go.

The same was the case with the Windows XP Professional vs the Home Edition.

The same will probably be true with Vista. One reason why the NT editions are more stable is because they have a larger set of beta testers. Corporate users and developer typically clamour to be alpha and beta testors for these OS's. I know from personal experience the private betas usually go through five or more versions before they are released for public beta. This is versus the Home Edition which goes through less than that number.

by upmike

Depending on your level of use would determine how "GOOD" or "BAD" an OS is. For a power user, a ?GOOD? rating would be different from a home user. My evolution with these same variations is somewhat different from yours as is my experience and level of use.

Thank you for your information. It is always good to walk in another?s shoes!

by deadly ernest

I won't mention things I never saw released here in Australia, like Windows 1 and 2. But you left out.

DOS 6.2
Windows 3.11
Windows for Workgroups
Win NT 3.51
Win NT 4
Win NT for Workgroups
Win 98SE - seen as a seperate version not a service pack.
Windows 2003 for Servers

Also Windows 2K was totally different to Win XP, and came in server and Pro version

by wperkman

Now that you bring up the the matter as a IT Tech your Right I have used all of these systems and agree with you. lets see what the magic of windows can pull out their hat this time!
Wayne Perkins
wperkman@cox.net

by huskyaddress-techrepublic

Hello,
just looking at the most recent versions, I think throwing Windows 2000 and XP under one heading isn't justified at all. So my count would go:
Windows 2000 GOOD (very!)
Windows XP BAD (but not too bad)
Vista ? a good chance, in that sequence

I agree about the older versions, more or less.
Thomas

by moselakatse

You've fallen into the trap of selecting statistics to suit your argument, rather than deriving your argument from the statistics.

Had you started off from Windows 1.0, you'd have seen the versions just before your selected baseline of 3.0 were not merely bad, they were completely risible.

by mvicente

Of course not a PC OS but is another version or not?
I agree with Windows ME it was really bad.

by andre.renaud

Your experiences are similar to mine except that Windows 2000 and Windows XP are distinct versions,

Therefore the GOOD and BAD seems count seems to stop at 2000.

by atuly

I'd have to say... Windows 2000 was so much better than Good.
correction for the list:
Windows ME: BAD
Windows 2000: GREAT
Windows XP: Ok/Good
Windows Vista: ?
--------------------
and does anyone relize that Vista is using so much off of Apple. the gadget bar and the lay out maches so much with Apple.

And I haven't yet realy downloaded Vista... but does anyone know how stable it would be? becuase Windows has a trend of loosing stablility throughout the OS's

by gm1cusnr

I can dimly remember back in the mid 80's,(I think)when the Winchester Salesman/Technician Installer arrived at our Facility, - which should remain nameless to protect the guilty, -but the initials are:(DOD/USN), everyone was soooo excited... He had brought along a !NEW! 'Winchester' Disk (20- inch metal O.D. ring covered with magnetic 'magic pixie dust'), to install for a 'HardDrive Upgrade' on our old UNix (Fortan - my cheater notes binder weighed a whopping 8 pounds!)originally it used Data Punch Cards, w/ Reel to Reel Magnetic Tape. - "Yessir, THIS babys gonna bring ya'll right up into the SPACE AGE! THIS HERE is called a Winchester Disk,... THAT big enclosure is the Harddrive for it to run in... Why, I GUARANTEE you'll NEVER run out of hard drive space! - Man, THIS thing holds a whole MegaByte of Information! Never fill That up in a whole lifetime!" - our Federal Tax Dollars at work...

by thomas moser

You seem to be clumping very different OSs in order to make your point. How can you clump Windows VMS (oops I mean Windows NT) with Windows 98?

How can you clump Windows 2000 with Windows XP?

My take:

DOS 3.3: GOOD
DOS 4.2: BAD
DOS 5.0: GOOD
DOS 6.0: BAD
DOS 6.22: GOOD
Windows 3.0: BAD
Windows 3.1: GOOD
Windows 95: Fair
Windows NT: Bad
Windows 98: GOOD
Windows ME: Very Very BAD
Windows 2000: Very Good
Windows XP: Fair but tremendously bloated and slow
Windows Vista: I expect it will be so overburdened with "features" and so slow as to be unusable.

Microsoft should go back to Windows 2000 and
ad in the few parts of XP that make it slightly easier to use.

-Tom

by undeadopi

Ok, first of all... the list of OS's is incomplete and slightly whacked. Putting Windows 2000 and XP as one OS? Aren't we forgetting some years in between? And what about Windows 3.11 (For Workgroups, remember?) or Win98 SE? Another thing: Windows 3.0, 3.1 and 3.11 weren't any OS's.

And all this talk about Vista being to hungry for hardware and too bloated...is exaggerated. First, not being able to program efficiently (compared to other OS's in terms of how many lines of code were used for example) never stopped Microsoft from being successful. Only us Geeks look behind the curtain and see things like that. The average user and the average company? They don't care. And remember when XP came out? Same discussions about it being too hungry for powerful hardware. Did it stop XP? No. And PC's that you buy in stores now? They are more than capable of running Vista. AERO and the Ultimate Edition are not meant for the average, everyday users who just check emails and surf the web once a while and otherwise use their computer as a better typewriter. Ultimate is meant for those kind of users that WILL have the apporpiate system to run it on.

And in one year? All the machines on the shelf's of Best Buy will be able to run Vista Ultimate. Why? Think of it: What is a graphics card with 128MB worth today? Or a gig of memory? How many Ghz ist the slowest CPU you can buy? And now think a year in advance. Do you really think anybody who wants Ultimate to run will have problems doing so?

I am sorry folks, but Vista will not give Linux a boost. The average person just wont get Linux. Unless some major Linux distributor makes a huge OEM bundle deal with DELL or some other big PC manufacturer, Linux will not replace Windows. And Apple's MAC? Please... Apple wouldnt be alive today without Microsoft...

I can't really recall a major industrial impact in the computer industry that has been achieved by pure quality of one particular product. But I can remember a lot that had an impact because of marketing and the power of the company (or companies) behind it, DESPITE the quality of a particular product.
Example: Apples IPod is technically inferior to a lot of MP3 Players around the world. It still is a huge success. Why? Marketing, Itunes, the whole bundle. It never is just about the technical specs of a product.

And to make a long story short. Vista is not a bad OS, it's just not a perfect one. But firstly, the world doesnt need a perfect OS. And secondly... there is none. And as long as Microsoft will just produce good or well above average results and products, things won't radically change.

by dwight-watt9

Odd that you combine 98 and NT as a OS and 2000 and XP as a OS when 98 and NT were completely different OSs. Which NT are you referring to: 3.5 or 4 or both? XP and 2003 are upgrades to 2000. And Windows 3.0 and 3.1 and 3.11 (which you never mentioned) were not OS but envoirnments that ran on the DOS you did rate.

by lorenfoster

Is that he stated that those were the ones that he used, not a collection of all the MS released versions..