Question Locked

IT manager - DHCP, DNS, printing question

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am new to my organization with 7 different sites and I wanted some feedback.

We have 2 DNS servers, 1 server also acts as the DHCP server, print server and file server. These boxes are towers and around 5 years old. I believe they need replacement but am not sure.

What is the best practice for setting the standard DHCP, DNS, print server and file sharing environement in any network?

Do they each neeed their own server. What is the best topology for a robust environment?

Thanks.

3 replies

by churdoo

Spec'ing a network isn't like ordering a combo meal of fast food, and there isn't a one-size-fits-all network kit, as much as some vendors would like you to believe there is.

There are waaaay too many variables to be that general. How many users? How are the sites connected? What are the production hours and within the main site LAN what is the tolerance to service outage within production hours? What is the tolerance of the satellite sites to the connectivity to HQ failing? Just to name a few.

In a small LAN, one box can do all of those roles, but add users and add the desire for redundancy and you can quickly build a case to spread those roles across 2 servers or even more. Now enter the fact that you're talking about a 7-site WAN, then there can be a strong case for server or servers at some of the other larger sites.

by 45geek

I would concur that there are many variables to consider when configuring a network of any size. But for security and performance a general rule of thumb is that a DNS server should always be the lone fellow out. Because of all the network traffic that is directed to a DNS server and the inherant hacking that is directed at it, it makes good security and network stability to have the DNS server alone and preferably isolated from the POP DNS server.

All the rest depends upon your size and what you are doing. Iternal R&D, serving up web pages, Apps, database, etc..... But remember a Print server demands increase dramatically as you increase the number of users per printer.

Good Luck and remember to plan for growth in any plan.

"No one plans to fail they only fail to plan!!"

This discussion is closed to new replies.